Goldfish Growths 2
(ex: issues of
lumps, bumps, tumors and growths)
Related Articles: Goldfish
Systems, Goldfish Disease, Goldfish, Goldfish
Fish Disease, Livestock
Treatment System, Bloaty, Floaty Goldfish,
Disease/Emphysematosis, Pond Parasite Control
with DTHP, Hole in
the Side Disease/Furunculosis,
Related FAQs: Lumps/Bumps/Growths 1, Growths 3, Growths 4, Growths 5, Growths 6, Growths 7, & Goldfish Disease 2, Goldfish Disease 3, Goldfish Disease
4, Goldfish Disease 5, Goldfish Disease 6, Goldfish Disease 7,
8, Goldfish Disease 9,
10, Goldfish Disease
11, Goldfish Disease 12, Goldfish Disease 13, Goldfish Disease 14, Goldfish Disease 15, Goldfish Disease 16,
17, Goldfish Disease 18,
Goldfish Disease 19, Goldfish Disease 20, Goldfish Disease 21, Goldfish
Disease 22, Goldfish Health 23, Goldfish Disease 24,
Goldfish Health 25, Goldfish Disease 26, Goldfish Disease 27, Goldfish Disease 28, Goldfish Disease 29, Goldfish Disease 30,
31, Goldfish Disease 33,
Goldfish Disease 34, Goldfish Disease 35, Goldfish Health 36, Goldfish Health 37, Goldfish Health 38, Goldfish Disease 39
& Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrate, Nitrogen Cycling, Koi/Pondfish
Disease, Goldfish in General, Goldfish
Behavior, Goldfish Compatibility, Goldfish
Systems, Goldfish Feeding, Bloaty, Floaty Goldfish, Goldfish
New Print and
eBook on Amazon
What it takes to keep goldfish healthy long-term
by Robert (Bob) Fenner
Help! Discharge from Oranda's Wen
I have a large Oranda who has been quite lethargic for many
months (I have indeed written to you about this previously).
Physically she appears very healthy and has no blood in her fins
or lesions of any sort. She is alone in a 72 gallon tank which
has 2 Eheim canister filters and a UV sterilizer.
I do a water exchange/gravel vacuum twice a week (or more if
needed) without fail.
Today I noticed that she had white discharge oozing out of her
Wen- this is not the normal cottony growth that I sometimes see.
I very gently palpated the Wen and more white discharge came out,
approximately 1/8 of a teaspoon.
The discharge is oozing from what appears to be a deep
"cut" approximately 3-4 mm along the sulci in the Wen-
the one that runs along the dorsal aspect and essentially divides
it into a left and right hemisphere. It does not look like a
hole- it looks more like the Wen has naturally separated along
this line. There is nothing that the fish could have cut herself
on- I have fish-proofed the tank.
I looked at the discharge under a microscope and it appears to be
free of bacteria- it looks, in fact, like cells.
<Very likely so>
I can't find a single similar situation anywhere on the
internet or in your archives. This does not appear to be HITH (?)
but I am extremely worried that it could be an infection under
the Wen or that the hole could allow bacteria to enter. The Wen
otherwise looks healthy- I have attached a couple photos though I
did not get one of the discharge and do not want to try to
extrude more for the sake of a photograph.
Is this normal?
Does the Wen have a fluid layer between it and the skull or is
this likely a cyst or infection?
<None of the above>
A bit more background- the fish stopped eating about two months
ago: she became extremely lethargic and did not eat for three
full weeks before perking up and acting normally again. She has
been her usual self up until three days ago when she became
lethargic again and refused to eat. Have you ever heard of this?
What can you suggest?
<Yes; and just your usual good care>
There are no aquatic vets in the area but I have located a vet
who is enthusiastic to learn about fish patients. As a
precautionary measure I will add a bit of sea salt to the water
until I hear from you.
smallish light-colored bump on goldfish
Great web site;
I've perused it multiple times over the past month, but
didn't see anything quite like what I have (or if it is
there, I didn't see pics to make it clear). I have 7 fantail
goldfish (1.5" - 3.5" body sizes) in a 75 gallon tank
with a Hagen 110 filter, no new fish in the last year, water
tests seem good. I moved about 7 weeks prior to the onset of the
issue; I brought along some of their old water (7.2pH), and
gradually introduced them to the new (well water, about 7.5pH),
10% at a time, but to do that, they were all in a 29 for 2 weeks.
I do have a small amount of salt in the water- about 1 tbsp per 5
<Using salt this way is pretty pointless. It's too low a
concentration to be useful as a medicine, so all you're doing
is wasting money. If you think this is helping your fish -- and
many retailers and salt manufacturers would suggest it is helpful
-- you're wrong. Salt as a weekly addition to freshwater
tanks is usually a waste of money, and potentially a stress
factor for those fish that dislike salt.>
I change out about 6 gallons every week. Five weeks ago, one of
the fish pretty suddenly developed a white spot high on a side,
forward of the dorsal fin. I popped him over into a 10-gal
quarantine tank with a Hagen 50, filled mostly with change-out
water from the big tank. The next day, there was a dark center or
streak in the bump, but then within a few days, it simply became
cream to light tan colored, and hasn't changed in the last 4
weeks. He seems perfectly fine otherwise - fins up, eating well,
but cranky about being in a smaller tank (his body's about
3" long). In hindsight, had I known he'd be in
quarantine for more than a week or so, I would've set up the
29 as a quarantine, but I wanted to get him out fast, and only
had enough change out water for the 10. I'm attaching 3
pictures to show the bump. At this point, I'd like to put him
back in the other tank, since his health otherwise seems fine.
Any ideas what this is, and if it is a problem, what I should do
<Return him to the main aquarium, and keep tabs on water
chemistry and water quality. This is likely a mild swelling or
perhaps even a slight infection following on from some sort of
trauma. In time, it should clear up; I wouldn't medicate with
an antibiotic or antibacterial unless I was sure it wasn't
clearing up itself. Because your tank is somewhat overstocked,
and the filter a relatively modest affair not suited to messy
fish like Goldfish, I'd be surprised if water quality is
quite as good as you think. So check at minimum nitrite (it needs
to be zero) and you should probably beef up water changes to a
good 20-25% per week, i.e., around 15-20 gallons, to keep nitrate
reasonably low (below 20 mg/l is good, but certainly below 40
mg/l). Ensure circulation of the water at all levels is good,
i.e., water at the bottom of the tank is moving briskly upwards
where it can be "recharged" with oxygen. Meanwhile, do
Thanks in advance for your help, and once again, I do appreciate
having this website to browse through to look for advice - kudos
to you all for your efforts!
<You're welcome, Neale.>
Goldfish with expanding tumour 6/14/11
<He's marked "out">
I wrote a while ago about a growth on the muscle along the spine
of my goldfish. It had grown along the site of an old injury and
at the time of writing had burst open.
<I see this>
The surface has since healed but the lump has continued to grow.
I am certain that this is not carp pox. I am wondering if there
is anything at all that I can do to eliminate it- it is quite
large and I fear may be spreading into the muscle tissue.
<Mmm, really, only improving this fish's world externally
and internally, hopefully "boosting its immune system"
It is about 1.5 cm x 1 cm x 1 cm. The fish also has spots of
blood at the bottom of both eyes and has been bleeding into its
tail- I had the fish on Medigold antibiotic food for 35 days
suspecting a persistent case of hemorrhagic septicemia; the meds
did not help and I discontinued treatment fearing the effects of
long term antibiotic use. I am not sure if it is septicemia or if
the tumour could be responsible since it is in close proximity to
I wondered if attempting to aspirate any fluid inside to try to
reduce the size of the tumour might be an option- I certainly
don't want to expose the fish to a bacterial infection but I
don't want to let this continue to grow and then regret NOT
<I would not "aspirate">
There are no aquatics vets anywhere near my area. I don't
know what to do!
I have great sentimental attachment to this fish as it was the
first one I purchased (and the one that launched me on my
goldfish craze). It has grown from a fry into a beautiful 6"
long demekin. I am worried sick- is there anything I can do for
Many thanks: Gina de Almeida
<What you can do... to improve, stabilize water quality,
nutrition. Bob Fenner>
re: Goldfish with expanding tumour
Thank you Bob!
<Welcome Ms. Almeida>
I am moving the fish from its current 36 gallon tank to a 50
gallon (just waiting for the new tank to cycle.
<Mmm, just bring over a good deal of water, substrate if you
can, siphoned mulm if not, and filter media to the new tank from
the olde. Voila(!), instant cycling>
Nutrition shouldn't be a problem as my fish eat much better
than I do (I'm not kidding).
What is your opinion on the septicemia?
<Almost always environmental in origin...>
The tail fins have quite a lot of prominent blood vessels and
blood streaks in them and the eyes have small spots of pooling
blood (and have had these for months). The size of the blood
spots decreased with the medicated food but did not completely
heal. Could this all be tumour related?
<Possibly but doubtful>
Should I try to treat this before moving the fish to its new
I have read that septicemia can be quite difficult to eliminate
and am not sure what the best medication would be (my water has a
pH of 8.2 so that is a consideration).
<My/our water here is about the same pH wise, with very high
dissolved solids... I use it directly from the tap>
I have found another brand of triple medicated food that I could
try if you think this would help otherwise I could increase the
amount of spirulina that I feed the fish.
<Please... stop medicating your livestock. It really won't
help them; and often hurts>
The fish will be alone but I will at some point wish to introduce
one more fish to the tank.
Many thanks: Gina
<As many welcomes. BobF>
Oranda w/split lip, now Wen
Laura here. I'm replying through a previous email u had sent re:
one of my Orandas. I'm having a little trouble navigating through
the web site since it was changed a little. I have another question,
one of my Orandas has got two (UGLY) looking spots on his Wen looks
like holes forming in his head.
Is this a disease that you are familiar with? Please advise of any
treatment that u maybe aware of. All of my water is balanced my two
other Orandas are doing fine. I'm lost. Thank you for any
<These Wen marks are almost never a problem. There are many
variations on a/the theme of this tissue growth. I would not be
concerned here. Bob Fenner>
Thank you Bob for you reply.
They are rather nasty looking spots. Like the skin is deteriorating
around it, kind of reddish like infected. Started out small and have
eaten away a good portion around them. Is that normal?
<Not abnormal. As I just alluded to; these growths period are
variable, whitish to reddish at times, in spots. IF, as you state, your
other GF are fine, I would not be overly worried. B>
Thank you so much I'm very relieved!! It just looked so bad I was
very concerned. Wow, my little Oranda buddies are a handful..lol. Hope
all is well with you, its storming here in Alabama. Have a good evening
and thank you for your help.
<Welcome Laura. BobF>
Goldfish Pimple Question 3/27/11
So here is my story. I have a 75 gallon goldfish tank that has
been set up for about 8 months. I have a Fluval 350 canister
filter and a bubble wand. I use the API test drops
every week and my water tests at 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite
and 5+ nitrate. In this tank I have an Oranda, a Black Moor and 4
<Mmm, the Comets are not really compatible w/ the
"fancies"; less so w/ time, growth>
They all range in size from 2.5 inches to 3.5 not including fins.
I usually feed once a day with 2 days a week being freeze dried
<I would drop these; not feed them to goldfish. I feed my
goldfishes Spectrum pellets exclusively>
and the other 4 were peas with a fast day. Now that my Black Moor
is having floating issues with the peas I am switching to lettuce
a couple times a week to see if that helps.
The problem I'm writing about is concerning one of the
smaller Comets. He has had a pimple for the last 6 weeks or so.
For the first 4 the bump on his side just grew and I could see
the white stuff underneath. One of my other fish had this so I
though he would be fine once it popped. Well when it did pop a
whole bunch of white cotton stuff
came out but he developed another one right next to it. That one
popped as well and for the last couple of weeks that side has
kind of been swollen and draining white cotton stuff. He is
swimming fine and eating fine, he just looks uncomfortable.
Should I be worried that there is still white stuff coming out?
And I did notice some clear poop so I'm worried that he may
be developing a bacterial infection. I did buy him so anti
bacterial food that's still in the mail from
goldfisconnection.com. Am I over reacting or should I get a
breeder net and just keep him in there for the 14 days I need to
feed him the medicated food? Is there anything else I can do?
Thank you for your time,
<I would not confine this fish, nor feed it/them medicated
food. Very likely this sore developed from a physical trauma, a
mechanical injury and will heal itself in good time. Bob
Goldfish - What Disease or Growth?
Your email has been deleted due to too-large graphic size.
Re-size and re-send per our stated requirements.
What Disease or Growth is this? 3/17/11
What is this disease on my partners goldfish. We thought it was a
tumour, but looking at '14a' on your site, could it be
<Either description can/will fit>
The goldfish is over 8 years old and has had this growth for over
a year and we have tried an antifungus and bacteria product with
<Mmm, no; no treatment will work here>
Although it is getting continually getting bigger, and looks like
it is a number of 'sacks' joined together, one
'sack' has broken open and the 'tissue' inside
appears to be breaking up in parts. It does not appear to worry
the goldfish or affect its appetite of flakes and tidbits of
It lost its (healthy) companion a few months ago so is now on its
own in a 6 gallon aquarium.
<Much too small...>
The aquarium has a filter and airstone some live and plastic
plants and one third water changed at 6 weeks.
<Needs about this much changed out every week>
Sorry about first email being rejected for picture size.
Many thanks, Nick.
<Do please read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/GldfshTksF.htm
Re: What Disease or Growth is this?
Thanks for your reply.
I must have made a mistake on conversion somewhere. The tank
measures 30" x 12" x 18" so a couple of sites tell
me that's about 29 gallon (not 6 gallon).
<Ahh, much better. I did wonder re the Comet's size in
relation to its apparent age, stated volume. Cheers, BobF>
Cyst on Telescope eye goldfish 2/15/11
I have a lovely telescope-eyed goldfish with what appears to be a
tumour or a fluid-filled cysts on its back, to the left of and
proximal to the dorsal fin.
<I see this in your excellent photographs>
The fish is not in any distress, but the cyst has been growing
over the past couple of months.
It began as a small injury caused (I suspect) by bullying by
another telescope. The fish sustained what I thought was a
superficial injury- a 1 cm abrasion
<On a small animal, this is more than superficial>
that disrupted a few scales- no blood and it did not look very
deep. I moved him to his own tank (mostly to get him away from
the bully) and added salt to be on the safe side. The wound
healed well and the scales grew back- everything was fine until I
noticed that the scales were pushing up along the line of the
injury. They have continued to pop up and now there is an oval
cyst approximately 1 cm x 0.5 cm x 0.5 cm. It is exactly where
the injury occurred.
I am uncertain whether I should leave it, try to treat it with
antibiotics (if it is building up fluid or exudate I fear it may
eventually make the fish ill) or attempt to aspirate with a small
<I would leave as is... I suspect, as it seems you do, that
this area is resultant, a reaction area from the physical trauma
(I currently have one on the side of a hand from smacking the
back end of a pool pump...). Will likely subside w/ time
I am attaching a couple of photos (though the cysts actually
appears larger in "real life" than it does in the
Thank you, once again, for your assistance:
Gina de Almeida
<Thank you for sharing. BobF>
Re: Cyst on
Telescope eye goldfish 2/21/11
I am so sorry to trouble you again- I have been writing to
Neale about a separate issue involving a different fish and
tank and I feel such a pest!
Thanks to you both for putting up with my many
The trouble I am having is immediate- the cyst that I wrote
to you about 6 days ago started to get a white, fungus-y
looking line on it yesterday and today seems to have burst
or opened up.
<Good. I see this in your pic>
I dabbed it with some Bio-bandage, did a water change and
added 2 tablespoons of salt to the water but have not done
I used a Q-tip to gently dry the area before dabbing on the
Bio-bandage and a small amount of pale yellow exudate
showed on the cotton. This fish is alone in a 25 gallon
cycled tank. Water parameters are pH 8.2, ammonia zero,
nitrite zero, nitrate 8, GH 8 degrees, KH 6 degrees.
As you can see in the photo the cyst is open and I am very
concerned about it becoming infected. Should I add a bit
more salt or treat the water with an antibiotic for the
couple of days?
Since the fish is alone I can pull the cycled media and
turn his tank into a hospital tank if need be.
Bob, this may also be related: when I went to take photos
of the cyst to show you I moved a powerful light over to
the tank and noticed that the fish has quite a bit of fluid
built up around one of its eyes-
<Yes, natural. Bred for this trait>
when he swims the fluid actually wobbles a bit so this is
quite disconcerting. Could there be a connection?
<Not likely, no>
Should I be concerned about the fluid build-up and if so
what can I do about it?
<No and nothing>
The fish has always had uneven eyes
<Genetic... would be destroyed by an earnest breeder,
producer... but fine as a pet>
so I think the fluid has been there for a while and I just
Gina de Almeida
<No worries. BobF>
Goldfish disease 2/6/11
Dear WWM Crew,
Our seven year old goldfish, Jojo, has what appears to be a
blister-like growth over one eye. This began two months ago as a
smaller, slightly raised spot and since has grown.
<I see this>
We routinely change 40% of the water in her 16-gallon tank every
week, and tried treating with Maracyn after her symptoms started
to worsen. Her tank-mate, Mojo, is the same age, always lived in
the same tank, and shows none of these symptoms.
<Mmm, well... these goldfish do/will need more room... I'd
be measuring some aspect of metabolite accumulation, perhaps
Nitrate; use/using this as an indicator of pollution... keeping
NO3 in this case, under 20 ppm>
Can you tell from the photo what her condition might be and
whether or not it is treatable?
<I can and it is not. Likely a tumorous growth. Please read
Good nutrition and water quality may well slow the rate of
Thank you so much for your time and consideration,
<Welcome. Bob Fenner>
New Print and
eBook on Amazon
What it takes to keep goldfish healthy long-term
by Robert (Bob) Fenner