
|
|
FAQs about Micro-Crustaceans Reproduction/Culture
Related FAQs: Microcrustaceans/"Pods"
1, Microcrustaceans 2,
Pod Identification, Pod Behavior,
Pod Compatibility, Pod Selection,
Pod Systems, Pod Feeding,
Pod Disease, Pod Reproduction,
Amphipods, Copepods,
Mysids, Brine Shrimp, Hermit
Crabs,
Shrimps,
Cleaner Shrimps,
Banded Coral Shrimp,
Mantis Shrimp,
Anemone Eating Shrimp, Refugiums, Crustaceans
1,
Crustacean Identification, Crustacean
Selection, Crustacean Behavior,
Crustacean Compatibility, Crustacean
Systems, Crustacean Feeding,
Crustacean Disease, Crustacean
Reproduction, Related
Articles: Micro-Crustaceans,
Amphipods,
'Pods:
Delicious and Nutritious
By Adelaide Rhodes, PhD, Copepods,
Mysids,
Hermit Crabs,
Shrimps,
Cleaner Shrimps,
Banded Coral Shrimp,
Mantis Shrimp,
Anemone Eating Shrimp, |
"Plankton Culture Manual" by Frank Hoff from Florida Aqua Farms |
Copepods / Light 10/22/09
Howdy Crew!!!! First time for me picking your brains. I always start out
looking for information on your site then find myself reading for hours
on end, very addicting! HA!. I have truly benefited and learned from you
and your inquirers. Thanks for all you do!!!
<Welcome Rand>
I have a simple question that I haven't found an answer to. I have a 75g
reef tank w/sump. Plenty (60-70lbs) of live rock w/ a DSB of 2-3". My
tank is well established and been up and running now for 4 1/2 years
with literally no real major problems. Filtration is a sump w/ bio-balls
and houses my Sea Urchin 2 skimmer (a purchase I recently made after
reading your site, what a wonderful piece of equipment, thanks for the
advice here as well). The sump probably holds around 10-15g of water. I
do not have a light above the sump, it's placed in the cabinet below and
always dark. Do the copepods need light to survive or reproduce??
<Mmm, no, but illuminating macro-algae, live rock et al. there would be
beneficial indirectly to all>
I do see amphipods in the dark sump but no copepods. I also see other
small creatures on the LR within the tank but again no copepods that I
can see. I am being told the age my tank there should be sufficient live
food sources for a Mandarin to survive.
I have recently purchased a small bottle of "Tigger-pods" and have been
slowly adding them at night to the tank every 2-3 days. My hope is they
will get established and reproduce in the main tank enough to support
the recently acquired Mandarin.
<More likely to be eaten there>
The Mandarin seems to be grazing on the rock now but I cannot actually
see what it is eating. The Mandarin has been in the tank now for 2 weeks
and seems to be very active and doesn't show signs of starvation that I
have noticed. I have tried to shine a light on the glass when the lights
go off at night to see if it attracts any copepods in the tank, but I
cannot see anything. I'm just trying to give the Mandarin what it needs
to survive knowing the copepods are it's essential food source but not
sure how to do this.
<Rubble in the sump/refugium, stocking a useful variety (or two) of
algae, lighting (RDP...) is/would be best. Please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/refuglvstkfaqs.htm
and the linked files above re Algae in Refugiums>
I have the following other inhabitants other than the Mandarin.
1-Yellow Eye Tang, 1-Foxface, 2-(mated pair) Yellowstripe Maroon Clowns
w/ 2 BTA's,
<May consume the Mandarin...>
1-Yellow Watchman Goby w/ Pistol shrimp. 1-Fire Shrimp, 1-Bi-Color
angel, 1-Pajama Cardinal, 1-One Spot Blenny. Corals- yellow polyps,
xenia, green star polyps, green striped mushrooms, blue tip Acropora,
and a crocea clam. Would any of these be feeding on the copepods???
<All the above with the exception of the Xeniids, GSPs. Do realize that
"Copepods" are a huge group of crustaceans... size, life-habits,
palatability-wise>
One last question I just thought of while I have your time. My crocea
clam has a green striped mushroom coral very close by. Actually when the
mushroom is fully opened the flesh of the clam touches the mushroom. It
doesn't seem to be bothering either. Should I remove the mushroom and
relocate it???
<Not if inconvenient>
I'm not worried about the mushroom (have too many of them anyway) but
didn't want any problems for the clam?
<If not registering as such...>
Always appreciate the knowledge from your staff.
Thanks Randy
San Antonio, TX
<Welcome. BobF, still in S. Cal.>
Copepod Refugium set-up
5/2/09
Hello Wet Web Media,
<Danny>
I'd like to set up a copepod refugium in my empty 15 gallon tank. This
refugium will not be connected to the main reef, but will serve as a
grow-out tank for a new copepod population (to help feed the fish and
corals in my well established reef).
<Mmm, okay>
Would it be best to include live sand and a piece or two of live rock in
this refugium, or leave it bare-bottomed?
<The sand would be better... to balance water quality issues, aid in
bio-filtration, allow for habitat, grow foodstuffs...>
The only life I'm looking to cultivate in this refugium are the pods
themselves,
<Mmm, I'd be growing some macro-algae as well>
so I'm not sure if the sand and rock are necessary. Would you recommend
adding a relatively powerful light source (I have a 50-50 power compact
system for this tank) or should the tank be kept dark?
<I'd add light... for the algae, and your appreciation>
Finally, other than phytoplankton what else will these guys eat?
<... only copepodites... Please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/marine/maintenance/maintindex.htm
the last tray... "Pods"... and seek out the references mentioned
therein.
Bob Fenner>
I have plenty of macro algae in the main tank that I could easily
transfer to the new refugium.
Thanks very much for your help.
--Danny
Not a question - more a friendly warning 3/31/09
Good Afternoon to all that make this site such a wonderful resource!!!!!
<Good morning, Bill.>
I'm not certain that this is the correct place for this, but I feel it is
my
duty as a long time reader of this site to warn others of a less than
desirable online vendor.
<OK>
DO NOT order from www.precisionaquatech.com !!!
I needed to add some copepods to my happy tank, and also needed to seed a
refugium I recently set up for my larger tank. After shopping around
online, I came upon this site. Looked great, very reasonable prices, and
FREE shipping! Can't go wrong, right???
<Sounds good to me so far.>
The site stresses the importance of overnight shipping to ensure live
arrival. I could not agree more. I went ahead and placed an order for
5000
pods. Nowhere in the checkout process did it even offer any other option
than the "free" shipping. Imagine my dismay when I got a tracking # and
UPS
indicated it was by GROUND! I immediately emailed the website questioning
this. No reply. So I emailed again. And Again. And Again. No reply to
4
emails. So I called. Twice. No return call.
My copepods arrived on the 5th day in an unrefrigerated, poorly packed
box.
After following the acclimation procedure to the letter, the most
optimistic
estimate I could come up with is 90% DOA. In a bottle that was supposed
to
contain 5000 LIVE Copepods, there were so few left alive that I considered
naming them.
I would NEVER order anything from this site again. I would strongly
recommend that none of your readers do either!!!
<I went to their site and I did read "free UPS ground shipping on most
items."
I also saw the "free shipping" on 5000 pods, but I didn't see anywhere
where they stressed overnight shipping on pods.
That should have rang a bell. If I did not have the overnight option at
checkout, I would have called/emailed
them BEFORE I ordered, and if voicemail came up instead of a human, I would
have left a message to return my call.
And if they did not return my call, I'd be back on the computer looking for
another source.
But to be fair, I would think they would have contacted you with a warning
that they could not guarantee live arrival
with UPS ground. You are not very far from Indianapolis, and is where
Premium Aquatics is located. They sell DT's Live
Pods and you might want to think about them should you order again. I've
dealt with these people for the last 10 years and I have nothing but good
to say about them. See here.
http://www.premiumaquatics.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Product_Code=DT-COPHS&Category_Code=livepods>
***********END OF RANT**********
Thanks again for all that you do here. I have lost track of the number of
times I have attempted to correct misinformation on other forums, only to
be
told how wrong I am. Without fail, after referring them to the proper
link
at this site, they come to the conclusion that maybe I was on the right
track. Keep up the GREAT Work!!!
<Thank you, Bill and hopefully a lesson learned with your experience.
James (Salty Dog)>
Bill Smith
Columbus, Ohio
Copepods 01/12/09 G'day crew, I just set up a 20 gal
refugium with live rock and sand and added a "starter" package from a
dealer. (1200 tisbe sp,1/2 lb Chaetomorpha, and 16 oz of microalgae)
This feeds a 72 gal FOWLR with 120 lbs LR and 90 lbs of Live sand/ Fish
include a Mandarin Dragonette, Tangs, Gobies and assorted inverts.
Problem: a bulkhead in the refugium broke loose and the contained area
drained into the pump and got distributed to the main tank. The starter
pack had been in the refugium for about 2 days. Question: Do I need to
reseed the refugium or will there be sufficient residuals in the rock
and Chaetomorpha to regenerate? <Yes and no. There will be enough
residuals to regenerate.... eventually. Eventually, being the key
word. It might take a long time for your refugium to repopulate, but it
will repopulate *eventually.*> Copepods are difficult and expensive
to get to Alaska due the very cold weather and the necessity of
overnight shipping. Thanks for your time. Bill Laflen <If you
don't have the time/patience to wait for your refugium to repopulate
(which might take at least a month or two or three), then go ahead and
buy another starter kit. If you do have the patience/time... then
there's no need. Hope this helps, Sara M.>
Re: Another Algae email... substrate, LR change outs/additions, pod
culture, comp. 12/31/09 Hi Bob, Thanks for
the info. It sent me in all the right directions. I would like for you
to clarify for me on your recommendation to change out some of the
substrate (and LR in time), is it (in your estimation) a lack of
biological activity or is it a lack of buffering/tract elements
capacity? <Actually both these are primary reasons> I am thinking
that I will just scoop a few cups off of the top of the LS and scrap the
rest and change out all at once and re-seed the new. <Okay> I have
the opportunity to do so when I drill the overflow, as the tank will be
empty. Or should I have a little more patience and replace in thirds
over several months. <This would be better> Can I re-use any of
the current sand after rinsing. <Mmm, yes... though it will be less
soluble... a "neat" experiment can be done short or longer term... the
short one might involve some "new" sand and your old... of the same
depth/volume and/or weight... mixed in with water, some dilute acid
(perhaps just vinegar)... and having a few days go by... remeasuring
both samples... Longer term, if you had two aquarium settings you could
do the same sort of experiment, measuring before and after... You will
find that the "older" sand dissolves more slowly> Aragonite sand is
expensive and I would like about 5-6" depth. I have 2 kidneys and can
sell... well, never mind :). All joking aside, I want to make the
smartest decision. <Adding a bit more new live rock would be even
superior... biologically> The algae on the sand bed does feel slimy.
Silky may describe more accurate. Descriptions are subjective. I do
wish I had a microscope. <I wish every household did... and the
curiosity to use it... Costs much less than (for many folks monthly)
cable TV...> Also, my bulb on the HQI 150w over the refugium-to-be is
about 16 months old. It is a 10,000K... do I need to replace with a new
bulb for the Chaeto? <How many hours do you run it? Do you have a PAR
meter? Does it seem that the green alga is growing too little with it?>
A semi-related question. I do not see any copepods in my tank. I shine a
flashlight at night and see nothing. I don't think I have ever noticed
these at all. Is it possible to have the population completely
eradicated and not repopulate? <Yes... is very possible... Hence the
"re-inoculation" suggested...> I have literally thousands of
amphipods. Again, no fish in my system for 8 months or so. I have an
Emerald Crab that will eat them (Copepods), but that is all. I have had
shrimp and other Copepod predators before. Could the conditions in my
tank have caused them to completely die out at an earlier point - my
tank did over heat last summer to about 90F for an afternoon? <Mmm,
more likely the former> Do Hermit Crabs dine on Copepods? <Some
do, will for sure if they can catch them... Do know that the Copepoda
are an enormous assemblage... size, feeding mode et al. very diverse...>
I believe I have read on WWM somewhere (I think an outside link from the
FAQ's... Maybe Advanced Aquaria article) that Amphipods will eat
Copepods, true? <Some can/do> I am about to drill the back of my
tank for an overflow and half inch return line to put the fuge into
action. Keep your toes crossed for this. <Go slow...> I must give
a plug for www.glass-holes.com if I may, as they are truly a top shelf
business. <Ahh, thank you for this. ScottV was kind to drive down and
visit this last week here from Fresno. We had a great time visiting fish
stores, the Birch/SIO aquarium, chatting> Awesome service and
products good prices and free shipping. Take Care and thanks in advance.
Stay safe and have fun tonight (New Years Eve). Don't know if one can
stay safe AND have fun at the same time. :). Scott <Mmm, a bit of a
conundrum, but, yes, partly. Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Collecting Copepods In The Sea 8/18/08 Hi, Bob and gang. How
are you guys? <I'm fine... a bit bleary eyed in CT, but rallying,
thanks> I just popped over to my friend's place and saw that he had a
green spotted mandarin fish in his 50 gallon mature tank. Seems he just
bought the fish a week or two ago. The mandarin is still pretty plump
and according to my friend, he's been nipping at stuff on his live rock.
After telling him how difficult it is to maintain a mandarin in a tank
smaller than 100 gallons without supplementing with live copepods, he's
been trying to look for live copepods. I've also been helping him hunt
for any LFS selling live copepods but to no avail. We're both living in
Malaysia and it seems the LFS here aren't that clued up about copepods.
Most don't even know what we're talking about but they're still selling
mandarins and also seahorses! Anyway, to cut a long story short, I
suggested we try to get the live copepods from the sea. <Lots of
folks do... I have> Since he lives literally 200 meters away from the
sea, he can get seawater very easily. However, my question is how can
we catch the copepods? Do we just scoop up 2 liters of seawater and hope
that there are some live copepods in there?!? <Mmm, really need to
sieve much more volume than this> I can see there is small fish fry
swimming in a relatively calm part of the coast. Am I right to assume
that if the fish fry can survive, there's sure to be live copepods (or
something else to eat) about? <All sorts of life... during different
times of day/night, tides...> I just need to know what is the best
way to capture live copepods from the sea. Do they gather at the water
surface, on surface of rocks or simply swim about in the water. Is there
a best time to capture these live copepods? <Yes, but need to
experiment a bit...> Then after capturing them, what steps should he
take to ensure he doesn't introduce any contaminants from the seawater
into his tank? <A tough question... best to keep all the "catch" in
a separate tank (can be simple... all new water, sponge filter, air
powered...) and sub-net some to feed...> I'd basically like to help
him ensure there's a steady supply of live copepods for his mandarin.
Thanks for your help, Bob & gang. Charles Tang <Do see the Net
re... Plankton Nets... you might be able to fashion one yourself... if
you can find suitable netting... need to find/borrow a boat to drag, dip
it along... a jar or two... or a plastic cooler/esky... Bob Fenner>
Culturing Live Food, 7/9/08 I am looking for guidance on
culturing live food. Doing such is driven by interest rather than a hard
requirement from my tank's inhabitants. I have a 24 gallon nano-cube
(which I wish I had never gotten since it provides no flexibility
whatsoever. A little bit bigger system with a sump/refugium would
have definitely been the way to go. but I digressed). <I think many
people find this to be true once they get their tanks going.> The
tank has been running for 2.5 years, and it houses 2 Percula Clown fish,
1 small Pipe Organ coral, 1 small colony polyp, and a couple of dwarf
crabs and snails. The clown fish readily accept flake foods and seem
happily fed. On rare occasion I have fed them newly hatched baby brine
shrimp which they loved. Also, the tank does have copepods that came
in from the live rock. The clown fish hunt the copepods, but the
copepods mostly hide in the live rock and substrate. The copepods are
also very small, being barely visible to the naked eye. Usually it
requires a 30x eye piece to get a good look at them. <Eye strain for
sure.> There seems to be a couple of choices of easily cultured live
foods: brine shrimp, copepods (larger Tiger pods and smaller
Harpacticoids pods), rotifer's, and Mysid shrimp. The live food(s)
would be cultured in a dedicated vessel. My questions are as follows:
1) Is anyone of the cultured foods listed above more useful than the
others given my tank's inhabitants? <The pods and Mysid by far.>
2) Would introducing any of cultured foods 'live' be harmful for the
current tank's population of copepods? It is my understanding the Mysid
shrimp are voracious and would likely not only consume the current
tank's population of copepods but also would likely consume each other.
I want to feed the tank, not establish a new biological order. <More
likely it would strike some sort of balance eventually, but how many
Mysid could survive long term is hard to say.> 3) Culturing brine
shrimp to adulthood would require that they be enriched before feeding
them to the tank. would this be worth the effort? <Not in my opinion,
easier to just feed the fish the food directly, the brine itself adds
almost nothing.> 4) Should brine shrimp eggs be de-capsulated before
hatching them? Asked another way, can adult fish eat them with the
shells still attached or is this just a concern for fish fry?
<Mostly a concern for smaller fish.> 5) Would the soft corals benefit
from the addition of any of the listed cultured live foods? <Probably
marginally.> Thank you much for your guidance. <I highly suggest
checking out the works of Dr. Adelaide Rhodes, she gave a great
presentation at this year's IMAC, and is an expert on what you are
trying to do. http://www.essentiallivefeeds.com> <Chris>
Pod Culture Tank 4/13/08 I have had a mixed reef tank set up
for about 15 months. I have tried several experiments throughout
this time, including a DSB in-line fuge. I took an Eclipse 6
(basically a six gallon tank with hood and filter package) and
drilled a hole in each side and put about 4 inches of aragonite
substrate and a couple pieces of rubble. No need to get to far
involved because there were many things I did not like so I took it
out. <Okay.> When I took it out it had been running for about
four months, needless to say there were all sorts of pods, worms,
snails, Chitons, sponges, and starfish taking up residence.
<Good.> So I figure why not another pod culturing tank experiment
since there were far more amphipods in there than anything else I
could see. <Sounds good.> I unhooked the small tank from the
system, plugged back in the filter that it came with in the hood,
(the filter is just a small 3 stage unit) and put a filter sponge in
with no carbon, and no bio-wheel running. The system holds roughly 5
gallons of water 3''-4'' of aragonite substrate, not even 2 pounds
of rubble, and a softball size chunk of Caulerpa racemosa (despite
the dangers, it is an experiment anyways). <The dangers of
Caulerpa get overblown. Many use it without issue.> I plan to
light it with the small light in the hood (12'' 8W T5 20K) and a 65W
grow bulb off to the side. My display is a 75 gallon, 100lbs.
live rock, 6'' DSB(80lbs.) with a Toms Aquaria Rapids Pro backpack
filter system. Light on the fish but many corals (SPS and LPS), and
of course all the cleaners, inverts, etc.. I run heavy on the
carbon, I am currently running my 18w UV at 150 GPH, a skimmer and
multiple rotating powerheads located throughout with all the
necessary sponges and floss pads. I do 10 gallon water change every
two weeks, feed sparingly, and have many, many different types of
macro (some nuisance "algae") in my tank that are all kept in check
by one small Lavender Surgeon fish, so I believe my tank would not
be considered a "nutrient rich" tank. <I would, something is
fueling the algae.> Hopefully this is enough info on the tank,
however to answer this question you may need more info as far as
what type of coral, macro, filter feeders in the display tank, but
here it comes. If I started doing five gallon water changes every
week and put the water from my DT into the culture tank, as well as
put a very small amount of live phyto and a shrimp pellet or two
every other day, would that be enough to keep the pods multiplying
and the macro growing? <It should, yes.> Also know that I
really don't care that much about the Caulerpa, I could always just
put a sponge or more rubble in there. Plus the algae in the display
tank could be using up all the available nutrients in the water so
it would not even make it to the culture tank where the Caulerpa is.
Is this possible? <Yes, you will be far better off having this
plumbed in with the display. Let the Caulerpa grow in the refugium
and hopefully not in the main tank.> I realize this is a broad
overview of my tank and it's parameters and may be hard to answer
the main question which is will there be enough nutrient for the
pods to multiply, or too much and the water will foul in between
water changes. Or is this whole thing a silly idea? <No, it is
not a silly idea, sounds like a fun experiment. It will just yield
little if any benefit unless the tanks are plumbed together.> I
know the best thing to do was to leave it plumbed to the DT, but
there was just not enough room to operate and maintain everything
properly, so the fuge is put on hold till after we move. <This
is unfortunate.> Sorry to completely change the subject but I
have a short question. I keep hearing that a reef tank should
produce a lot of dark skimmate. <Relative to the tank and
livestock.> Not really how much, but how thick. In a standard
mixed reef (''standard''...that's funny) <Good point.> it would be
safe to say that a small fish (say a 2'' Tomato Clown ) will produce
more skimmate than say 3 or 4 softball size SPS corals?
<Actually, no. It is surprising how much skimmate SPS corals alone
can and do produce. If you have a LFS with a fishless frag tank, ask
to see the skimmer sometime, you will be shocked!> Basically you
could say size for size/weight for weight a fish produces much more
skimmate than a coral does? <As compared to size and weight,
possibly.> Considering a little give one way or another as far as
different species go. Example a tang may produce more than a
predatory fish that only gets feed once a day or less? <Yes, a
fish that metabolizes more food/energy than another should in turn
produce more waste.> I have a small Tomato Clown, DS Goby,
Six-line Wrasse, and Lavender Surgeon fish, very large LTA , around
15 stony corals, and about 20 mushrooms. My tank is no Tank of the
Month, but it is pretty heavily stocked as some of my corals are of
pretty good size. <Sounds like a nice tank. I have seen a few so
called “Tanks of the Month” in person. While I am sure there are
many nice, if not spectacular, tanks that make it in, Photoshop and
such programs has made many of these submissions questionable. Don’t
feel the need to judge your tank against these.> I have never
produced more than a cup of light skimmate in a weeks time (unless
something died). All of my corals are growing, have always grown.
<A good sign.> Does the amount of skimmate just sound
unacceptable, and no matter if the corals are growing or not?
<The amount would not satisfy me on a system such as this.>
Should I get a better skimmer (again the skimmer is one with the
filter and it is rated to 150 gallon aquariums, even though we all
know what a joke that is) or does that sound fairly normal? The
skimmer works on reverse flow with an airstone and I can watch it
work, so I know it is working. <A better skimmer should be in
the plans in my opinion. You will find it even more valuable to you
as your fish and corals grow larger, producing more waste.> Thank
you for all your help. <Very welcome.> P.S. I have already
had a firm talking-too about Anemones in the reef tank, so no need
mentioning that. Just know that all is well. <So long as they
know to behave! Best regards, Scott V.>
Re: Pod Culture Tank 4/14/08 Thank you for the speedy and
knowledgeable reply. <Very welcome.> I do however have another
question regarding the algae issue and the amount of excess
nutrients in my tank. <OK> Considering I do religious WC,
maintain floss pads and filter sponges regularly, and feed sparingly
(what I would consider sparingly=5ml DT's phyto every 3-5 days dosed
at night when water circulation is at half without turning off the
skimmer, about 1/3-1/2 cube total of many different types of frozen
foods, mostly every day but sometimes every other, and 1-2 times
weekly soaked in Selcon, and the occasional spectrum dry food,
frozen Cyclops , and Calanus plankton. The later coral foods are
given at night alternating one every other week. As far as food,
that is all I put in. <If this all works for you, don’t fix it!>
Sub-question: does the light over my tank in one way or
another/directly/indirectly play any part in the amount of organic
waste produced in my tank? <Indirectly yes.> If so, I have a
total of 476W
(130W-10K-PC/130W420nm-PC/54W-14K-T5HO/54W-460nm-T5HO/108W-10K-T5HO).
Also, does this sound like a good scheme or should I replace the
other 460nmT5 with another 14KT5? <I likely would, you have
plenty of actinic with the PC bulbs.> Any who, I may have been
misleading when I was talking about the algae. If someone took a
quick glance at the tank they would probably not see any algae at
all. I was just thinking since I have Red Turf Algae and others
alike that are considered "nuisance" algae, and seeing as how they
have never, in the long time I have seen all these in my tank, seem
them get even remotely out of control, and thus led me to the
conclusion that a high amount of organic waste was not present.
<A fair assumption. If there are no indication of problems then
there is not a problem (in this case).> So if this is true and
its not the food, what about phosphate? <Phosphate will promote
growth of algae, but you will have some due merely to the regular
biological processes of your livestock. No tank is devoid of algae,
the nice tanks simply control it.> I do WC with RO water and Red
Sea Coral Pro salt, I currently dose limewater as much as my PH will
allow (and that's just a whole different conversation altogether),
<Yes.> and I currently employ a filter sock filled with 250ml of
Seachem Phosguard that says it removes phosphates and silicate. The
bottle says it will treat well over 75gal , and it is changed out
every 2 weeks. The one thing that worries me is when I change it,
the media is brown, proof that it is working(?), proof of phosphate
present in the tank(?) <Likely acting somewhat as a mechanical
filter being in the sock, hence the color. This is probably the same
color your sock becomes?> The water I use is from 5 Star bottling
company (RO but not DI). Is phosphate the main reason for the added
stage from RO to DI? <And nitrate, silicate. Fact of the matter
is good RO water is just fine. Older membranes may produce a lower
quality water.> If so would it help to hook up a PO4 reactor with
said media to a tub of RO water before I do anything with it?
<You could, but what you have sounds like it is working fine.>
Hopefully pulling out all phosphates and silicate before it even
makes it to the tank. <If there is phosphate in the water it
surely pales in comparison with the phosphate that makes it into
your tank with any food. Other life needs phosphate too, not just
algae. You do not want to completely strip your tank of this.>
MY buddy started up a reef tank about 4 months prior to me. We have
done everything the same, but for the last year he has had a
HORRIBLE "hair" algae problem. Best we can come up with is Bryopsis.
However we do not or cannot get a microscope for definite answer,
but it is a problem none the less. We have tried everything
including one of the "reef safe" algae removers only with near
devastating results. For the last year he has had to do manual
removal of every rock at least every two weeks (with a stiff
bristled brush), and just watching this makes me feel sorry for him.
He feeds very sparingly, under any meaning of the word, has an
inline fuge with a massive amount of Chaeto, High PH (never below
8.4), runs a PO4 reactor with SeaChem's PhosGuard, also tried
multiple livestock options such as snails, crabs, urchin, and a
Tomini Tang. The only small differences we do are he uses KM liquid
sup., and I use Seachem powder and Kalk. Could that make a big
difference? <No, there is something else going on. Although two
people doing the exact same thing will usually yield different
results with a reef, you can bet he is doing something different
then yourself in this case.> And one final question. We both
started our tanks off on tap water. We both switched to RO at the
same time. His tank was 6 months old and mine was about 1-2 months
old. Is it possible that some of the bad things are still in there,
maybe in the sand or unexposed pieces of rock? <No, not in a
capacity to create the algae issue.> The tap water around here is
extremely hard and just plain $&#@^. Could that still be
contributing to his problem? The only thing we are left with is to
take all the sand and rockwork out and switch it with new over a
period of two months or so. Will this just cover up the problem for
a while and we still need to find the root cause. Will it help him
to start dosing Kalk, and filter all RO water through the PO4
reactor in a tub like previously stated? <All of the above it a
treatment and not a cure. All things equal, the algae will return in
time. If you suspect high phosphate in your RO water, by all means
test it! Otherwise look at the usual factors: water flow, water
changes, anywhere detritus accumulates and sits (mechanical
filtration/dead spots/coarse substrate) and most of all feeding.
Sometimes it is not how or how much you feed, but what. The frozen
foods tend to have a lot of juice in them that should be drained off
to avoid polluting the tank. I personally use the Spectrum pellets
as the main diet for my fish. Frozen foods are used occasionally.
Also, be sure what is added actually get eaten. Adding what seems
like a small amount of food serves no purpose of most of it goes
blasting around the tank!> Thank you again. This site IS truly a
necessity for people in this hobby. By the way, how much money does
it take invested in a hobby before it has become a lifestyle?
<You’re welcome. I feel anything less than cashing your paycheck
down at the LFS is just doing it half way ? ! Thank you for the kind
words, a link to refer your friend to below, Scott V.>
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/algaeconMar.htm
Re: Copepod culture 04/15/2008 Hello again Crew, <<Hello,
Andrew here>> After reading more about amphipods, I'm thinking
about culturing copepods instead. At the moment, I have a 17g
Rubbermaid tub that I'd like to use, but I'll try to convince my dad
to let me use one of his 45g breeders. <<Ok, sounds good>>
Anyways, my amphipod plan was to have a layer of sand on the bottom,
along with some Chaeto and LR rubble. Lighting would be provided via
window (sunlight), heating via heater, circulation via a small
submersible pump, and filtration via HOB filter or canister filter.
I would feed the amphipods old fish pellets/flakes as
supplementation. The amphipods would be fed (hopefully at least a
few times weekly) to a pair of maroon clowns, a BTA, a pair of small
gobies (haven't decided which ones yet), my detritivore crew, and
maybe an Acropora coral. How would this plan differ from an
ideal copepod culture? <<Exactly the same>> I bought a turkey
baster to collect amphipods. Would this be a good tool with
copepods? <<A valuable tool>> Are copepods attracted to
light, and if so would this be useful for collecting them? What is
the most successful way to collect them? <<Sunlight is sufficient
as copepods are attracted to light>> With either a 17g or 45g,
would they be able to thrive just with the microalgae growing in the
container or would small doses of phytoplankton be needed or be at
least extremely beneficial? <<Either would be just fine. They
should thrive in the macro algae/sand/rock setup. They will enjoy a
small amount of floating algae>> Would a culture of this size
(17g or 45g) be able to function as a staple of my fishes' diet?
<<Depends on how many copepod eaters your going to be feeding
really. Start off with 2 - 3 thousand as a culture, and hopefully in
a month or so, you will be shooting for around 50,000 pods>> I
have an off-topic question that's bugging me, if you'd be kind
enough to answer it. I'm going to buy my detritivore crew in a
couple weeks, being my first livestock. The crew will consist of
hermits, snails, mini stars, bristle worms, amphipods, spaghetti
worms, and anything else that comes in their live sand. What could I
feed them to supplement their diet? <<Most of the above will feed
off the rock, sand etc etc. Adding a tiny pinch of brine, or
crunched up Nori every 2 - 3 days will be fine.>> Thanks for
reading this. This site has helped me many-a-time in the past, and I
know that this won't be the last time I consult it. TIA, Random
Aquarist <<Thanks for the questions Tia, always good to hear fro
you. Hope this helps. A Nixon>>
Re: copepod culture 04/17/2008 Hello again, <<Hello
again>> Just a few more questions. <<Sure>> 1. I was
thinking of using the canister filter for the amphipods because
amphipods supposedly love living in them. Is there any need for
filtration in the copepod culture at all as long as I do water
changes? <<no, it should be fine filtering itself et cetra>>
2. I'm guessing that Chaeto would be the best macro to use,
considering that it can be easily removed/ swished around in the
display to feed copepods. However, I'm also considering using Ulva.
Which is better, or would a combination of the two be best?
<<Yes, Chaeto is a great macro to use for the culture. Between the
two, i really like them both. Prefer Chaeto for ease of cropping>>
3. What would be the best sand bed depth for copepods? <<Depends
on the size of the filter really. A good depth of 4 inches would be
great>> Well, thanks for your help. BTW, when I say "TIA", I'm
saying "thanks in advance", not "Tia". I'm actually a guy known only
as Random Aquarist as far as online aquarium-related activities go,
but thanks for the very friendly/ heartwarming comment. I just
wanted to remove any misconceptions. <<Ahhhh...thanks for the
clarity>> Again, thanks for the help. I can always rely on The
Crew. Thanks In Advance, Random Aquarist <<Hope the above
helps. A Nixon>> Re:
copepod culture 04/23/2008 Hello again Crew, <<Hello
again>> Again, I have a few more questions about copepod
culturing. <<Ok>> 1. All I find are "Tigger Pods", which come
from California and the West Coast. Because I'm setting up a biotope
and I don't want foreign "Tigger Pods" in my tank, I'd rather have a
species that does come from the Indo-Pacific. Do you have any ideas
for where I could get such pods? If so, what would be the ideal net
hole size to collect adults (1/64", 1/16", etc.)? <<Here is a few
links for you to peruse http://www.oceanpods.com/
http://www.livecopepods.com/ http://www.inlandaquatics.com/
http://www.ipsf.com/ <---------your best bet i think for your type
of pod required.>> 2. I really like The Breeder's Net's culture
style of just having an empty tank filled with phytoplankton and
copepods. It seems a lot more clean and productive. Is it really
more productive, having no sand or breeding substrate, or is the
sand/rock/Chaeto plan more productive? <<I personally feel the
sand/rock/Chaeto is one of the best ways to culture pods, always
been very successful>> 3. The Breeder's Net plan utilizes an air
pump for circulation. Is this as good or better than using a small,
submersible water pump? <<I don't really see that much difference
in using either>> 4. This is another unrelated question, but I'm
trying to find an e-tailer that sells turtle grass and/or oar grass.
Do you know of any such dealers? <<Off the top of my head, i
don't know of suppliers for these. Maybe the use Google or your
preferred net search tools would be good.>> Well, that's it for
now. <<Thanks for the message, hope this helps. A Nixon>>
Thanks in Advance, Random Aquarist |
Ideal Amphipod Breeding Substrate 04/01/2008 Hello again Crew,
<<Hello, Andrew today>> I have a 17g tub that I plan to culture
amphipods in. I've heard that Chaeto, liverock, sand, and sponges are
good breeding substrates. In your experience, which of these are the
best? <<Chaeto, live rock and sand>> Here are the side and top
views of my current plan for the container. I intend to make sections
out of eggcrate and pump water so it flows through the Chaeto (thus
rolling it) and back towards the pump. <<Hope this helps, A Nixon>>
Amphipod Culturing/Boiling Rock – 03/27/08 Hello again Crew,
<<Greetings>> My cousin has lost interest in the aquarium hobby
and is selling his 10g tank. I'm thinking about buying his live rock
and/or live sand and using it to make an amphipod culture.
<<Cool>> I have several questions. <<Okay>> 1. Can Ulva or
Chaetomorpha be grown using only sunlight? <<Sure…if it gets
enough>> I'm thinking about having the culture container near a
window so I don't have to use lighting. <<If the tank will
receive some direct lighting it should work…is worth a try for
sure>> Apparently, after reading about the "copepod farm in a 5L
bottle" on your site, phytoplankton can grow from sunlight alone.
<<Indeed>> 2. Just to clarify, the macroalgae is the food source,
right? <<No, not so much as the epiphytic matter that is on it,
and the other surfaces in the tank. The dense matrix of the
macroalgae (Chaetomorpha excels in this, in my opinion) will
function primarily as a place for the critters to live and breed>>
If so, will the pods eat all of the macro or will it grow quickly
enough to stay ahead? <<I’ve never seen/known this to be the
case…under the right conditions, the macroalgae will likely outgrow
the tank and require pruning. To optimize your “pod” populations I
suggest supplemental feeding. I find the inexpensive shrimp pellets
from Wal-Mart, etc. to work well here and are very easy to feed>>
Also, what would I feed the macroalgae? Skimmate? Plant fertilizer?
<<Mmm, no…this would/will quickly pollute the system. Judicious
feeding of the pods will supply nutrients for the algae as well.
Have you given any thought to filtration/water circulation?
Something as simple as a small air-driven internal sponge filter
will probably suffice…though this “refugium” would work better if
plumbed directly to the display it is intended to support>> I
read that amphipods are omnivorous and that they'll eat anything.
Would it be beneficial to add meat to their diet? <<As in the
fore mentioned shrimp pellets, yes…or even a pinch or two of a
quality flake food>> 3. How would I deal with evaporation in a
smaller setup without having huge salinity fluctuations from
manually topping off the water every day? <<Daily ”topping-off”
is likely your best/most economical solution for this small tank…and
should work fine>> 4. How does live sand and live rock help
amphipods anyway? <<Provides a matrix/structure for shelter,
breeding>> I've heard of people successfully using playground
sand for aquariums/refugiums. <<Yes>> Could I use this in my
'pod culture? <<Certainly>> 5. Let's say I culture the
amphipods and whatever they eat. I'm only feeding a pair of maroon
clowns, a BTA, and whatever else will eat them in my tank. Will this
culture be more or less expensive than buying food? I know that's
hard to answer, but can you ballpark it? <<Look to this culture
as a “supplement” to feeding…not as a replacement. You will still
need to provide some prepared foods to your fishes/inverts>> This
is assuming, of course, that I don't sell any 'pods or 'pod food to
people and make some money off of it. Don't get the wrong idea. This
isn't an attempt to make a profit. <<But no reason it
can’t…though I think it would need to be much larger>> I just
want to do this for the experience, for the natural food source, and
because watching things eat each other is awesome. Now to the part
about boiling the rock. My cousin's rock is completely covered in
Cyanobacteria and Aiptasia anemones. I'd like to kill them. Could I
just boil the rock and kill everything so I can just rinse/soak it
and not have to cure it? Kinda like a dead coral skeleton (which,
technically, it actually is)? <<Sure…though a less smelly/messy
approach may be to let the rock sit out in the sun for a couple
days, then a freshwater soak overnight followed by a good rinse with
the hose>> Well, that's it for now. TIA, Random Aquarist
<<Regards, EricR>>
Re: Amphipod Culturing/Boiling Rock – 03/28/08 Hey, thanks
for the help. <<Quite welcome>> I have a few more questions
for you. <<Okay>> 1. I found a bucket of dry CaribSea
Eco-Complete Planted substrate that my dad had planned on using a
few years ago. All of my dad's fish are dead, so could I use this?
<<Dunno>> My concern is with the coarse nature of it and possibly
any chemicals it could release that aren't ideal for saltwater.
<<This is my concern as well…though you could contact CaribSea and
get their take/advice re>> 2. I've heard that sponges are great
for amphipods. Should I put in a bunch of filter sponges?
<<Course filter sponges like those made for pond filters can indeed
serve as “housing” for amphipods and other critters…but if you are
going to use Chaetomorpha, I don’t see these as necessary>> 3.
I've also heard that pods like a lot of surface area with their live
rock. Should I break the live rock into pieces and make a 'pod pile
instead of just having a few large pieces? <<If you are adding
rock then yes, “rubble” will provide more of the small
cracks/crevices they prefer>> 4. And lastly, I found a lot of
sealed bags of Dainichi cichlid food that my dad also planned on
using back in the day. They're in sealed bags and are only a few
years old. Could I feed this to my amphipods or does this freshwater
food lack the nutrients needed by saltwater fish? <<See if the
“pods” will eat it…it may/should be just fine>> Thanks again,
Random Aquarist <<Cheers, EricR>> |
Quick Question on Copepods, culture/sys., & Mandarin sys.
1/17/08 Hello. <Hello Pam.> My first tank has been set up
for 8 months now. It's a 53 gallon tank with a 7 gallon sump. I have 55
lbs of live rock, and a shallow sand bed. I've never noticed a
copepod population, and have only seen a couple amphipods over the
months (I've even looked with a magnifying glass). I would like to get a
population of copepods going for my Pygmy Possum Wrasse and Red Scooter
Blenny. <I’m sorry to say your tank is too small to support the
Scooter Blenny, especially with any completion for food come from the
wrasse.> I have a small section in the sump (about 4" x 4" x 6") that
I tried to use for pods. I placed a ball of Chaeto in there and a 6400K
spiral compact fluorescent bulb with reflector to light it (12 hour
reverse lighting schedule) , and added a bottle of Tiggerpods, but never
saw a population build in the display or in that section of the sump
after I initially put them in there. I also took some of the Tiggerpods
in a syringe, and put them in a small pile of rubble I put in the
display, where I thought they might hide and multiply. The Chaeto ended
up dying off in a few weeks, so that spot is empty again in the sump.
That's the second time I've tried Chaeto, and both times it died off. My
LFS is having a group buy on Copepods. To get started, do I need a large
amount like the bag of 2000 copepods they will have, or a small bottle
or two of 100-200 copepods? <Neither really. If your tank is setup
to support copepod population growth, then it will grow. If not, adding
them will only create a temporary spike in population.> I don't seem
to be having luck with Chaeto, should I just put rubble down in that
area of the sump, and put the pods in there or in the display or what?
<You may as well start them in the refugium area, but they will find
their way throughout the tank on their own.> The area of the sump
isn't really large enough to have a Deep Sand bed. One interesting
thing....I can't keep Chaeto, but I have one mound of beautiful red
macro algae in the display that grows like crazy and I have to prune it
weekly to keep it from growing too big. The last time I tried Chaeto, it
only lasted for a few weeks, then almost disintegrated. The first time,
I think it lasted for maybe 2 months. Maybe the flow is too slow through
that section of the sump or the section is too small?? The Chaeto
doesn't roll at all. Thank you!! Pam Parameters: Salinity 1.026 PH:
8.3 Alk: 8 dKH Nitrites, Nitrates and Ammonia all zero. Phosphates:
between 0 and .1 Calcium 390 Magnesium 1170 Temp 80f Flow: 25x
display size Display lighting 150w 10k Metal Halide and 4 24w T5s
<There is something going on in your setup that is allowing the red
macro to outcompete the Chaetomorpha in the sump/refugium. You mention a
spiral compact bulb, but what is the wattage? Many setups you read about
online have very small wattage bulbs on the refugium, making the light
the limiting factor. This is one factor you can control, give it plenty
of light. I have two 65 watt 6500K compact fluorescent bulbs lighting my
Chaeto. This makes the nutrients I am trying to export the limiting
factor. The Chaeto has better growing conditions than any algae in the
tank, hence it grows and algae in the tank doesn’t! As far as pod
population/production, you probably won’t see much with fish in a tank
this size that can wipe out the population fairly easily. Included link
regarding these fish below. Welcome, best of luck, Scott V.>
http://wetwebmedia.com/mandarins.htm - Mandarin
Dragonette - Wow...that hurt! <My apologies, that was not my aim.
I do seek to be realistic though, and hopefully it helps in the long
run.> Thanks for the information. You made me change my mind about the
"tang tank". <Ah good.> I have one problem though....I already ordered
the mandarin goby. With the 29G DSB sump/refugium that I have, will I be
able to "promote" the copepod and amphipod propagation to support this
guy? <Perhaps, but likely not quickly enough. They tend to eat and
nibble all day, but you may be able to promote other frozen items like
Mysis shrimp.> The sump/refugium is below the tank. I also have several
10G tanks at my disposal, but they are not used yet. Will 1 tang and the
clowns compete with the mandarin fish for the copepods/amphipods that
are available? <The tang will not, the clowns might, but you can
probably distract them with other food.> Do you have any suggestions on
how I can further promote the copepods and amphipods to multiply?
<Perhaps with a couple of the live sand starter kits.> Thanks for the
help! Jeff McHenry <Cheers, J -- > Micro-Refugium -
02/26/03 Hi: <Hi Chris, Don tonight> I have a 55gal (48")
FOWLR setup with 5" DSB, 25lbs. LR, Bak Pak 2R Skimmer, 800gph
circulation. I am interested in a refugium, but I am currently out of
cash. I was wondering if I can use an in-tank acrylic breeder that I
have laying around and put some crushed coral (again, laying around) in
it and get some sort of copepod, amphipod thing going? I read in the
daily's recently that CC is a good substrate for their
proliferation. Maybe stick a piece of algae in there too? <How big
is the breeder? A gallon or two? You could set this up if you wanted,
but won't have a real big affect. You really want at least 10G and 15G
would be better. Now you could setup the breeder with the intent of
using it to seed a larger refuge later? Hope this helps, Don> Thanks,
Chris. Cuckoo For Copepods? (Sorry, Anthony!> Scott,
thanks for your prompt response. <My pleasure!> Regarding
establishing amphipods and copepods, you do say I am on the right track
with the Live Rock, Crushed Coral, and 260W Coralife Power Compacts
(actinic and Daylight bulbs). Silly question, but where I have the
MAGNUM 350 Canister with the filter sleeve installed, will this filter
out and kill the early development of small copepods and amphipods?
<Well, good question. It is possible that some will be "sucked in" and
trapped among the filter sleeve. However, I have seen many wet-dry style
filters and mechanical filters that contained hundreds of amphipods and
copepods of various sizes, and at various stages of development...I
wouldn't worry too much> Is it worth my while because of this to
remove the filter sleeve and not put any media in the canister (e.g.
just let it cycle water with no filtration and just leave in place for
the water circulation until I see signs of copepods and amphipods? Or
is this immaterial and I should just leave the sleeve in the filter and
it's a matter of time before I get these bugs - while some on your site
are working to eliminate them I am looking forward to seeing
them! Thanks again for your help - David. <Actually, David- I think
that you can leave the sleeve in place...Just make sure that you clean
this, and any mechanical filtration media, for that matter- on a regular
basis. This is a great way to increase water quality. Ultimately, you
could get rid of the sleeve, but if it's properly maintained, I don't
see any real drawbacks to its continued use. Good luck! Regards, Scott
F> Breeding bugs in my refugium 08/06/03 I have a
large system, 450 gal fowlr in house, draining into a 500 gal predator
tank and a 300 gal refugium in the garage, they in turn drain to the
sump, then back to 450 to complete circuit. I feed both the fowler and
predator tanks heavily and the system has been running as set up for 6
months and is working to perfection. No water or algae problems.
Refugium has deep sand bed,8 inches, live rock. It's only resident is a
small Fimbriated moray that I removed from predator tank and put in the
refugium as I was concerned he would be eaten by the 3 foot tessellated
moray that lives there. After about 6 months as set up, I was hoping
to see a huge population of bugs in the refugium by now, but even with a
flashlight, I only see a few. I am assuming that with the fowlr with
heavy bioload draining directly into the refugium and the messy little
Fimbriated moray, that there should be ample food to sustain a huge
population of bugs. Lots of rubble on bottom. oyster shells etc. along
with the live rock. Was thinking of sinking a plastic milk crate stuffed
with filter pads in the refugium to see if this home may be more to
their liking, plus giving me a way to harvest the little buggers, and
maybe asses their population better. Any ideas? Refugium has NO
residents other than the small eel. Thanks in advance. <Well,
actually, your idea sounds really good. Have you thought about lighting
the refugium and adding macroalgae (I'm very partial to Chaetomorpha
myself)? I'd say try both, and see what you get. You may also want to
try direct feeding the refugium too, something finely ground. Hope that
helps, PF> Refugium, Mysidopsis bahia 10/14/03 Dear
Anthony, Thanks to your guidance, my second refugium continues to
thrive. <to your success/husbandry above all> Even after
re-reading several specific chapters in Reef Invertebrates, I still have
a couple more questions: Can Mysidopsis bahia be mixed with the smaller
copepods and amphipods or will the bigger guys just eat the smaller
ones. (about 30 gallons, net of sand and rock) <hmmm... not a matter
of predation so much as competition for space/resources... fewer groups
will ultimately survive in the end. Best to focus on providing a
specific matrix to encourage your target group rather than trying to "go
for all" and failing> I find that these shrimp are bred worldwide and
are very available as they are used in environmental testing.
<correct> I found that the addition of 6 large Mexican Turbo snails
has pretty much eliminated all sign of Cyanobacteria. Will these animals
affect my "pod" production? <not much or at all, assuming the
copepods find adequate algae to eat (they will)> I am feeding the
refugium crushed freeze dried krill, soaked so that is sinks. Thanks
again, <this will be better for the meat eating amphipods... but not
for your vegetarian copepods/rotis. Do consider a phyto drip for the
latter unless the macroalgae is sufficiently buck-wild.> Howard in
Wisconsin <Anthony in his chair> Promoting Pod Growth -
11/20/03 Thanks for all the help in the past and your continued
dedication to hobbyist. <always welcome.> I recently set up a new
reef tank and want to get all the beneficial critters really thriving in
it b/f I add anything that will prey on them. <a good notion... and
even better to do this I a refugium. Either way do provide a dense
matrix for them to grow in like Chaetomorpha spaghetti algae> Do I
need to be adding something for the pods to eat, or will they find
enough to eat/reproduce in the Fiji live rock. <small amounts of
foods/organics will sustain them... rotting and live algae and a bit of
prepared fish foods will accelerate all> There will not be anything
in there to produce extra detritus and there are only a few very small
pieces of visible macro algae on the rocks. Also, the rock was curing in
another tank for approx 3 weeks after import so not expecting any
cycling, might also help to mention that I am running a ASM G2 skimmer
with little to no skimmate production at this point, and have a 15gal
refugium plumed into the system as well that I put a couple of smaller
less attractive pieces of rock and some rubble in, it's pretty empty at
this point. Thanks for your help, Ryan <an effective
skimmer/brand... just needs tweaked/tuned. Do seek others on the message
boards that own this same model and get perspective on how to adjust it.
Best of luck, Anthony> Egging Me On..? >I just did a
water change and decided to change the carbon. >>Alright. >The
carbon was about 2 mos. old. As I dumped out the old carbon I noticed
many, many, many tiny dark brown eggs in the carbon and inside of the
mesh bags. I would guess there might be several tablespoons per
bag. >>Wow.. anything like caviar? >These eggs are tiny, about
1/2 the size of a pin head, very dark brown and inside of the media
bag. I do have a lot of copepods in my sump, are they
related/desirable? Mike in Hershey, Pa. >>My goodness, honestly,
I wouldn't be able to give you a definitive answer to that. Assuming
they are actually eggs, and those of your "pods", then if you
experienced a subsequent crash in numbers you'd have your best answer
there, without microscopic examination and reference sources
available. Of course, almost all pods are going to be rather desirable,
and if you do experience a crash, then you'll know for next time to find
a way to preserve what you find in the bags of carbon (consider adding
them to a refugium?). Marina Crab in my reef 12/4/03
Hello Anthony! <cheers, my friend> I watched my reef and I
realized (to my relief) that the creature I saw the other day in a dark
hole in the life rock was not a mantis shrimp but a crab! It arrived as
a hitchhiker on the life rock and has been hiding for 3 months! Anyway,
I read all about crabs in your book "Reef Invertebrates" and concluded
that I should trap it and take it out of my reef, as I can not identify
it and there are practically no crabs that are reef-safe. <quite
correct> Next question is about amphipods (or copepods, I am not
sure). <the former look like arched back shrimp/prawn... the latter
look like dots/fleas> There are hundreds of them on the LR and on the
grass of my tank. Some are very small and some have grown bigger, as
there is no fish to eat them (the clown is swimming at one corner near
the surface of the tank and has not yet moved to other places of the
reef). Now I am thinking of culturing the amphipods in my sump, before I
buy my next fish, which might start eating them (a Neon Goby, Gobiosoma
Oceanops). What it the best way of transferring them in my sump?
<just moving a little bit of dense algae or live rock will do the trick>
I am thinking of moving a couple of LR that have Dictyota, Halimeda and
Padina to the sump, so the amphipods on them will be transferred to the
sump, too. Is it a good idea? <yes> I have not a refugium (lack
of space), so I would like to do as much as possible in my sump.
<understood> Moving some LR with macroalgae on it is my first
thought. Second would be a deep sand bed in the second part of the sump,
which would be a problem, because: 1. There is an EHEIM return pump
sitting on the glass of this part of the sump and 2. The DSB would raise
the bottom by 10cm, which will make me a slave to evaporation (will
decrease my autonomy). Right now I have an evaporation of 3 liters per
day and an autonomy of 7 days. If I make a DSB my autonomy will drop to
4 days. Last question for today: when I bought the Clown fish (see
attached picture) I thought is was a juvenile Ocellaris, Now I am not
certain any more, as it has begun to get darker close to the strip on
its head and to the white spots on its back. Can you identify it please?
Thanks a lot, Thanassis <clearly looks like A. ocellaris to me my
friend. Best regards, Anthony> Propelling 'Pods Hey,
<Hey there! Scott F. with you!> Right now, I have a 10 gallon reef (
all zoos) with 80 watts of pc in the coming week or 2, I am getting a
55 gallon tank with once again is going to be for zoanthids only- I'm
going to use cured rock to cycle the tank quicker. <Hopefully!> I
plan on getting a couple of gobies including a Green or Target Mandarin
so I want to get a head start for a couple of weeks at least before
adding the Mandarin. <I'd wait a longer time than that before
introducing this fish. Mandarins historically fare poorly in newly
established tanks with limited microfauna for them to forage> I know
the question I'm going to ask has been answered and you can go ahead and
refer me to another link, but I assure you no matter how much I read I
am still illiterate in the topic. <Cut yourself a little slack! I'm
sure that you know a lot more than you think you do> I'm going to
have no room behind or on top of the 55 at all except for the AQUA C
Remora I'm getting-this also means the fuge will be under the tank.
<Sounds fine so far...> I plan on using my 10 gallon and the 80 watts
of pc. I still don't understand how the piping goes to get the pods etc
from the fuge to the main tank. Telling me to use the return pump etc
means nothing. Can you please explain to me how this works in layman's?
terms. <Well, in many configurations, this is exactly how it
works...The pods and other planktonic life are "sucked up" (or down, if
the refugium is over the display) into the return to the tank. Really
pretty simple. Sure, there are other possible means to accomplish this,
but this is the most common way. As a simple person myself, this is how
I'd explain it!> Thanks a lot. Mike <My pleasure. Regards, Scott
F.> Pod culture 4/13/04 Anthony, Could you recommend me
a book with information regarding the raising of all types of pods as
additional food for my reef tank and where I could purchase it at?
<such a book does not exist. No one that describes all pod cultures. For
a hobby reference, Bob and I give extensive coverage to refugiums,
plankton reactors, microcrustaceans, etc (~ 100 of 400 pages) in our
"Reef Invertebrates" book. Focus on the refugium chapter. For a
scientific reference, do consult the "Plankton Culture Manual" by Hoff
from Florida Aqua Farms> Once I move into a house, I would like to
have an enormous amount of pods in a 40 gallon tank that provides
constant additional food for my tank. I was reading on seahorse.org
that they breed there pods in simple 10 gallon tanks with water taking
from a matured tank but no water flow or filtration? Have you heard of
this? <yes... rather simple. Rotifers especially> It seems a
little easy? Thanks, Keith <best of luck, Anthony> What to
do with a dirty filter?? (I have a few questions) (Sung to the tune of
"What Do You Do With A Drunken Sailor") Hey there oh helpful
ones! <Ahoy Angela> We have a 29 gal reefish tank with mainly
inverts - here's the list - Lights are 2 55w PCs -50lbs of live
rock, 4-6" DSB -Pair of cleaner shrimp (that won't stop producing
eggs). Is it common for the male to carry eggs as well? <Please read
here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/shrimpreprofaqs.htm> Both of ours
carry the eggs and release the larvae regularly. -Tiger pistol
shrimp/yellow watchman goby/firefish goby- These three all share the
pistol shrimp's burrow and seem to get along. It's funny to watch the
big firefish squeeze into the burrow. I didn't think they'd all get
along in that situation. -50 or so zebra and blue hermits and one
little red hermit...I have tons of empty shells for them in the back of
the tank so we don't have too many wars. -Various(30+ I lost count)
Astraea, Nerite, Cerith snails and 3 bumble bee snails. -2 flame
scallops (don't buy these folks, you'll spend all your time feeding
them!!) -3 peppermint shrimp -Scooter blenny - he was my first
fish in there and feeds well on various frozen foods. He loves to hunt
for pods as well. -Neon Dottyback (for amusement purposes) -Pair
of true perc clowns and their anemone (An "African anemone" can't find
info on them) -4 Feather dusters, an x-mas tree worm rock, plate
coral, trumpet coral, green sea mat, and several reddish sponges that
came on the LR that have been doing great. We also have a rock
designated for those little purple and green anemones that split all the
time that a lot of people consider nuisance (came with the LR). They'll
eventually travel I know. <Sounds like a very healthy, full system>
OK now to my real question...I have an Emperor 400 filtering all of this
and have never had a problem with this tank (knock on wood) even though
it has quite a few animals in it. I do small (5-10%)water changes 3
times a week, but I have never rinsed out the filters. This tank is
going on 5 months old, still new. We pulled out one of the filters
tonight and there were literally hundreds of those Gammarus (sp?) shrimp
and other pod like creatures all throughout it. The filters look great
so I figure they're keeping it cleaned...and I don't want to kill
them. So do we need to change these filters eventually or will we be ok
with all those creatures working on it? Thanks for all the help!
~Angela <I would be very careful re changing the filter, or cleaning
it... If there is room, consider placing a filter pad (can buy material,
cut to fit) on top of the existing "old" "dirty" one... and just
periodically removing the new one to rinse, and/or replace. The old one
can likely best serve as a sort of biological filter bed. Bob Fenner>
Will pumps kill pods from the refugium? Thanks Adam! I'll pass on
the dragonet. I still want to set up a refugium at some point though
-it would be nice to have live food so I can leave the tank to take
care of feeding the fish for days at a time when I go on trips.... <<
Yes refugia are wonderful. >> I just hadn't considered under the tank
refugiums. Wouldn't the pump kill the pods first before pumping them
up to the display? << No, they go right through the pump. I'd say 90%
of refugia are under tanks with pumps pushing the water back up. >>
Narayan << Blundell >> Pod culture, carbon
Hello Anthony, Bob et al ! <Hi Roger> Thanks to all of
you, your assistance is Priceless. Read a lot of FAQ's, still
haven't found a sound answer. Just finished building an 22 gal acrylic
sump. Was going to be a wet/dry but I read the section on
bio-balls! Modified it now to a 22 gal refugium. <Ahh, "a stitch in
time, saves your mind!"> My Nitrates have long been 0.2 but I'd
still like to incorporate a 4' sand bed and really would like to make
this a pod factory. I'll start gathering some LR rubble from the LFS
but in the interim, is there anything else I can add to optimize the
space? <Some macroalgae> Would lava rock work as a good habitat
for the pods? <Not really> In essence, what would constitute
"prime" pod habitat ???? <Mounded LR, macrophytes... there are
actually MANY organisms considered "pods" that live in diverse
habitats.> Second question. I have access to commercial grade
anthracite coal used in water purification plants. Particle size is
about 1/16 to 1/8 of an inch long. Can I use this without harming the
tank inhabitants (fish, corals and inverts)? <Likely yes... talk
with the "folks in your lab" re this application, find out how much
"free" phosphate this product is likely to leach... get their input on
preparing it (likely at least soaking for a day ahead of use) and try
just a few ounces (in a Dacron bag) to see what sort of effects...>
I "think" I remember reading that "activated" carbon is actually
anthracite plus some process. Could you explain the process or the
difference? What makes carbon "activated" <Not in a short space...
Again, I encourage you to ask these questions of the "lab"... and the
Net for that matter! Bob Fenner> Thanks a ton ! RJS Redding,
California
Centrifugal pumps damaging plankton? 12/29/04
Dear WWM crew, First off I would like to say that I have literally spent
hours perusing your forums, enough that my wife groans when she sees me
on the computer <glad to hear the former, not the
latter... do take care of family first and foremost :)> Thank you
for offering a great service. I have heard from a few different places
in passing (mostly magazines, and in a couple of places on the WWM
pages) that our common centrifugal pumps are limiting our ability to
maintain significant zoo and phyto plankton populations in our
aquariums, <actually, this is archaic information/belief based on
some silly research with brine shrimp that was extrapolated to be
applied to marine plankton. In truth, marine plankton act nothing like
(salt lake) brine shrimp and suffer very little plankton shear. The
point is also ultimately moot as the plankton come out just as edible on
the other side :) If you were hungry, would you refuse a hamburger
because you wanted a steak instead? <G>> and thinking about it makes
sense that the plankton could be damaged by colliding with the volute of
the pump. <you'd be amazed what commonly passes
through... I have seen small fish make it numerous times> Since I
cannot seem to find anything more than speculation on this subject I was
wondering what y'alls opinion is. <it is only
speculation and bunk at that. No worries on plankton shear> Do you
think there is any benefit in trying a reciprocating or perhaps rotary
pump? I am thinking that the non-uniform output of the reciprocating
pump could have its advantages (more turbulent flow etc.) but more
complicated design would lead to more maintenance. I would love to hear
the WWM opinion on this subject. Thanks very much for your input
Chad Miltenberger <hamburger 'til it hurts, mate. Anthony>
30 gal. system check James, Thanks for your input regarding my
tank's water flow and filtration issues. Should I be concerned
about the apparent loss of copepods and/or Mysis shrimp LR hitchhikers
running amuck on the LS? One other thing I forgot to mention is that
Joe's Juice was used on a couple of occasions to get rid of some larger
Aiptasia specimens. <I wouldn't be concerned about it. I think if you
want to maintain large populations of the pods you would need a
refugium. James (Salty Dog)> Propagatin' 'Pods!
First, let me say I think it's great that you guys take your time to
answer and post these questions. I've learned a lot by reading through
the FAQs. <Glad that you've found it helpful! We really
enjoy bringing WWM to you every day! Scott F. here tonight!> I could
use some guidance with a specific sand cleaner question. Here's a
quick overview of the latest project: It's a small display (24g
NanoCube) that flows to a lighted 16"x16"x7" mud 'fuge. That in turn
flows to an unlighted 16"x18" DSB 'fuge with 5" of sand and 5" of
water. In addition to nutrient export, I'm hoping to generate plankton
of varying sizes, as well as small crustaceans ('pods.. etc.).
Unfortunately, there are corners that don't receive optimal water flow,
and I'm trying to keep from turn the whole contraption from turning
into one large unstable nutrient sink. To that end I believe the key is
to keep detritus from accumulating. The space is pretty tight and
manual stirring / vacuuming would be hard. The questions: What
is the best live stock for eating detritus without damaging (too much)
the population of 'pods, algae, and other beneficials? <I'd utilize
the so-called "Tiger Tail" Sea Cucumbers, which do an excellent job at
this, as well as some serpent stars. These creatures are efficient at
consuming detritus without excessive collateral damage to other, more
desirable life forms> Also, what creature would be good for stirring
the DSB without harm to the beneficial critters? <As above>
Finally, is there a medium I can put in the DSB 'fuge that will
facilitate 'pod growth? ..it's just open water now. <Well,
depending upon what types of 'pods you're trying to grow, you could use
a mixed course/fine substrate, some macroalgae, such as my
favorite-Chaetomorpha, and the protection of the sump. Inoculate the
'fuge with a starter culture, sit back and you'll see an explosion of
life after a few months! There is a lot of good information about
amphipods and copepods (see the article in the latest issue of
"Conscientious Aquarist" by Adelaide Rhodes, right here on WWM) on the
net...Just do a little searching and you'll find more than you could
imagine!> Thanks very much, Jon <My pleasure, John! Regards,
Scott F.> Copepods I have a 29 gallon tank with a sump,
110 watts power compact lighting, 3 inches of crushed coral, and 20lbs
live rock. It has been running for about a year. There were fish in it
at one time but now they're in the 55 gallon tank. I want to turn it
into a copepod farm so I will have food to feed my mandarin that is in
the 55 gallon tank. I just purchased some live copepods from an online
fish store and want to know what I need to do to get it started. Do I
need to get anything else for the tank or can I just pour them in?
<Shawn, here is a link on pods.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_2/cav2i1/Pods/pods.htm
James (Salty Dog)> A Look Into the Culture of Pods and Their Kin
11/21/05 Greetings Bob n crew! <Sam> Bob…I’m really looking
forward to meeting you at the February Puget Sound Aquarium Society
meeting. Will be nice to be able to say thanks in person for envisioning
all that WWM has become (or at least starting something that has become
truly incredible :*) ) <Ah! You add to my anticipation!> Quick
hardware recap…125 gallon tank, 20 gallon refugium, 29 gallon sump,
Aqua-C skimmer, 180# live rock over ½-inch deep fine aragonite sand bed.
Refugium packed with rock, and will be adding Chaeto in the coming month
or so. I’m currently fishless, and planning on remaining so for at least
6 months to allow critters to proliferate. <Wow, good discipline>
No corals yet either, and will likely remain that way for at least
another month or two. There are currently about a dozen hermits and two
dozen snails (total, of 6 varieties, one of which has already produced
baby snails…I take this as a sign of moderately acceptable husbandry)
munching on the progressing algal succession. I’m doing 10-15% water
changes every 7-10 days with aged, aerated, buffered DI turned saltwater
(Instant Ocean). The goal with this tank, aside from corals
(probably LPS) and a couple of other small
nothing-less-peaceful-than-clownfish fishes, is to house a Mandarin, and
for the system to be as self-sustaining as can be reasonably expected.
Getting to the question, I’m curious as to whether investing in a ‘pod
culture at this point would be a prudent move. As I see it, the benefits
would include adding to the number, and possibly diversity of the pods
in the tank, and adding at this point would allow the new additions
several months to continue to proliferate. I’m thinking the possible
ramifications could include; 1) introducing a species capable of out
competing those that hitched in 2) that there is a finite number of
pods that the tank can sustain, and that what I’m already doing may
allow me to get somewhere in the neighborhood of that number or, adding
to the population may exceed that number and cause a pod-stock die-off
3) that the current population would, in the outlined time frame, be
able to grow to the point of being able to sustain a Mandarin on its
own, thus making the addition unnecessary. <I would stick with what
you have... should be fine for all the reasons stated> I’m guessing I
could always wait until after the Mandarin is added, and if the
population dropped too severely, could add at that point. <Yes>
I’m looking at a gift certificate for Ocean Pods. What say you? <I
would save it> Thanks in advance, Sam <Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Culturing Pods for Mandarin Dragonet 7/28/06 Hi
there, I've a question regarding Mandarin Dragonets and
the feeding of this finicky fish. I would like to add one to my 46
gallon bowfront tank. It is a very mature tank. I've currently got
about 75 lbs of live rock in the tank and about 3 inches of live sand.
Right now the tank is loaded with copepods and mysis shrimp. I see
them scurrying around constantly. I do have a small 6 line wrasse in
the thank that will soon be moved to my 29 gallon reef tank.
I'll also be adding a 29 gallon tank as a refugium to the bowfront.
<Ahh, very good> In the refugium, I'll have livesand, rubble rock
and Chaeto. I'd also like to set up a 10 gallon tank
to culture pods in. I've got 2 different plans for doing this. I'd
like your advice on both please. #1 is to line the tank
with quart mason jars that each contain some livesand, a little rubble
rock and some Chaeto. The water level will be kept a few inches above
the top of each jar. I'll then seed the entire tank with copepods and
mysis shrimp. I'll also have a small powerhead going in the tank.
<Mmm, an air-powered sponge filter would be better/best... the splice
and dice action of the powerhead will reduce the small crustacean
population> My thoughts are that as the pods and shrimp grow
and reproduce, I can remove a jar and pour the water off into the
refugium or main tank. I'd then return the jar to the 10 gallon to
repopulate. <Mmm, we'll see... likely the jars will be too much
trouble, and unnecessary> I've heard that I may have a problem with
evaporation and a rise in salinity using this method. I'm not sure how
that would happen faster with the jars than without.
#2 is to just use the 10 gallon with live sand, rubble rock and Chaeto
but without the jars. <This would be my option...>
I'm just not sure how I'd go about removing the pods to feed to the
fuge or main tank though. <"Tie" the ten in with the 29 refugium
somehow...> One thing that's been suggested to me is to take 4 to 6
sponges, get them wet with the tank water, crush some flake food into
them and place them in the tank. Then as they populate with pods,
remove a sponge and put it in the fuge or main tank for a few days and
then replace into the culturing tank for repopulation. With 4 to 6
sponges, I'd think that I could rotate them and keep a good supply
of pods. <Worth trying> Do either of these plans
sound reasonable? <This second much more than the first> Also,
in plan 2, can you suggest any other means of removing pods from the
culture tank for feeding? <Vacuuming, mass water changes...> My
last few questions concern the refugium. My bow tank is not drilled so
I'll have to come up with some way to move water from the display tank
to the refugium and then back to the display tank. Any suggestions?
<Posted:
http://wetwebmedia.com/overfloboxfaqs.htm and the linked files
above> Do I need to section the refugium off into
different compartments or can I just add lots of Chaeto and let it
grow? <Can/could> I'll also have lighting on this tank.
<... good idea:
http://wetwebmedia.com/refugltgfaqs.htm> I would also like to
put my skimmer into the refugium but am I better off leaving it on the
display tank? <Mmm... not necessarily... though would situate in an
anterior/first water arrangement I have a Remora Skimmer with an
overflow/pre-filter box. Any advice you're able to give
would be greatly appreciated!! Thanks. Michael
<Bob Fenner> Amiracle mud filter,
using WWM 7/27/05 Hi I'm new to the site and so far it pretty
informative well here's my questions. To grow various types of pods and
food for my mandarins and fish what would be the best substrate type
size and depth. --Sbatiste <Please keep reading... learn to use
the Google search tool, the indices on WWM. Much/a great deal of
"collateral" benefit/s... Bob Fenner> Amphipods, Copepods, Mysis,
Oh my! 7/28/05 Hi <Good evening. Mike G with you tonight.>
I did some research on your site about pods but didn't really pick up
the answer I was looking for. Well here's my question what kind of pods
would grow in Ecosystems miracle mud with some Caulerpa <<Caulerpa>>
(think it's misspelled) algae? <Well, to be quick, Amphipods and
Copepods. If you want to get more in-depth, any of several hundred
species of extremely similar "pods" may happen to populate a refugium
seeded with the brand mud specified. Here are a few articles/FAQs
related to "pods," hopefully they will assist you in getting an idea of
what will soon inhabit your tank.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_2/cav2i1/Pods/pods.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/pods.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/isopoda.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/copepodfaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/pericaridanfaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/amphipodfaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/mysidfaqs.htm > Thanks in advance
<You're welcome. Good luck with your new tank! Mike G> Amiracle
Mud Filters Substrate 7/28/05, same idiot question/response Hi
Guys. I had a few question Ive <There is no such word> been
browsing this site for a while and could not find a specific answer to
my questions, Well here they are 1) Would you suggest using Miracle
mud to grow copepods and other foods for my aquarium? <Mmm, sure>
2) or would a different type of substrate be better if so what grain
size and how much? Thanks <... please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_2/cav2i1/Pods/pods.htm and the
linked files... at the bottom. Bob Fenner>
|
|