
|
| FAQs on
Colisa lalia, C. chuna... "Dwarf" Gouramis of Many Names,
Honey, Flames, Neon Blue, Sunset Fire... Disease/Health 2
Related Articles: Anabantoids/Gouramis & Relatives,
Genera Ctenopoma & Microctenopoma,
Betta splendens/Siamese Fighting Fish,
Related FAQs: Dwarf Gourami Disease
1,
Dwarf Gourami Disease 3,
Dwarf Gourami Disease 4,
& Dwarf Gouramis,
Dwarf Gourami Identification,
Dwarf Gourami Behavior,
Dwarf Gourami Compatibility, Dwarf Gourami
Selection, Dwarf Gourami Systems,
Dwarf Gourami Feeding,
Dwarf Gourami Reproduction, & FAQs on:
Gouramis 1,
Gouramis 2,
Gourami Identification,
Gourami Behavior,
Gourami Compatibility,
Gourami Selection,
Gourami Systems,
Gourami Feeding,
Gourami Disease,
Gourami Reproduction,
Betta splendens/Siamese Fighting Fish, |

|
|
Dwarf Gourami with sore on side
10/16/08
Hi Guys,
Congrats on having such a great site. I have learnt a lot from reading
the Q&A's but still can't find what I'm after.
I have got 3 Dwarf Gouramis which I have had for about 3 months. About 4
weeks ago I noticed one of them had 1 or 2 scales missing from the side
of him. The colour of the flesh didn't change. Everything looked fine.
<It's an ulcer, and will need to be treated with a suitable
antibacterial or antibiotic to prevent secondary infections. With luck,
the fish will heal just fine. I say "with luck" because Colisa lalia is
a very sensitive species, partly because of inbreeding and partly
because commercially bred fish are routinely exposed to viral infections
for which there is no cure. I do not recommend aquarists keep this
species.>
About 7 days ago I got home from work to find it had turned into a patch
that looked like raw flesh that was white in colour but looked red from
inflammation or infection. It was also raised from the body a few mm's.
I put the Gourami into my 40l tank and started treating it with Furan-2.
After 2 days the redness had gone away. I continued treating as
the sore is still an open. Today I have noticed 2 holes in the white
flesh area that are red. The sore is still raised from the surface and
looks worse in real life, than in the photos. The fish is still eating
normally and looks fine, he is sitting down by the heater a fair bit but
I think it is because he is the shy one of the lot and its a good hiding
spot. What else can I try?
<Very, very difficult to say. The problem with ulcers is that they are
not only infected wounds that need healing, but also gateways through
which infections can travel into the body of the fish. Small fish like
yours are particularly at risk because even a relatively small ulcer
will "dig" quite a distance through the body, well into the major blood
vessels, muscles and nerves.>
My tank details are:
190l tank, 26deg, I top up the salt after every few water changes,
Ammonia 0, Nitrites 0, Nitrates 5, PH 7.2, lots of real plants, big bits
of bogwood, Fluval 405 filter, tank has been running for about 5 months
<In theory all sounds fine, though adding the salt shouldn't be
necessary when the fish are healthy, and long term we really have no
idea what harm constant exposure to salt does to freshwater fish. At
least some react very badly, as is the case with Malawi cichlids, so
broadly speaking salt should only be used therapeutically, not as a
routine additive.>
Fish are:
Guppies x 10 (about 14 babies as well), rummy nose x 9, Danios x 3,
bristlenose x 1, Corys x 2, Neons x 7, Gouramis x 3, pretty tetras x 2,
bleeding heart x 2, harlequins x 6
<Should be fine with Colisa lalia.>
The Gourami has been moved to a 40l tank, internal filter, 27 deg, salt
added, ph 7.2, amm 0, nitrites 0, nitrates 5
Thanks for your help,
Tracey
<All you can really do is carry on treating for ulcers and Finrot, and
hoping for the best. To be honest, this species is so weak I can be
especially confident of a positive result, but who knows? Cheers,
Neale.>
|
Bite? RMF |
Fish inquiry... Tetra, small
Characin sel., comp. 7/15/08
Dear Crew,
I'm pretty new to the fish keeping hobby but I have been researching
online. Here is my dilemma. I have a tank with serpae tetras who
keep to themselves (thank god), zebra danios, a rubber lip Pleco,
and platys.
<A "courageous" combination to say the least. Serpae tetras aren't
my recommendation for the community tank, as you seem to realise.>
I need a somewhat larger fish to be the so-called "attraction" fish
but I don't know which kinds will live peacefully with my other
fish.
<With Serpae tetras, not much! The obvious choices -- Angelfish,
Gouramis, etc. -- will simply be pecked to death.>
I have a 26 gallon tank, its pretty tall and its a bowfront. I've
been deciding between some kind(s) of gouramis, freshwater angels,
or silver dollars.
<No, no and no respectively. The Gouramis and Angels will be nibbled
to pieces, and the Silver Dollars get far too large for a tank this
size.>
Which species is best suited for my tank and well get along with the
tankmates; and if you have any other suggestions about other species
please let me know.
<To be honest, I'd not bother. I'd either up the numbers of the
species you already have, or perhaps add an interesting catfish of
some sort that can keep out of trouble. Serpae tetras for example
look their best in big swarms of dozens of specimens, when their
feeding frenzy behaviour becomes quite something to watch. Of course
any catfish that avoids trouble, like a Synodontis, isn't going to
be showpiece fish you're after.>
Also, ever since I transferred a red wag platy over to the bigger
tank, it has constantly been hiding even though none of the other
fish harass it.
<Almost certainly it has been nipped by the Serpae tetras and is
keeping a low profile. Serpae tetras don't just bite the fins from
other fish but also the scales, and such damage can be difficult to
see.>
Is there any way I can solve this problem?
<Not really, no.> Thank you, Pierre
<Hope this helps, Neale.>
Re: fish inquiry 7/15/08
Thank you for that info. Do you think there are any tetras that
I could replace the Serpaes with that would get along with angels or
gouramis? I might decide to take them back to the pet store.
Pierre
<Angelfish will simply view very small tetras, such as Neons, as
food, so you have to be careful. Certain other tetras, can be just
as nippy as Serpae tetras and will nibble on the Angels and
Gouramis. Black Widows (Gymnocorymbus ternetzi) and some of the
other Hyphessobrycon species fall into this category. My honest
recommendation would be to replace the Serpae tetras with more Zebra
Danios. Here's the thing: if you have one big school of a schooling
fish, it looks so much better than two small schools of different
schooling fish. You would then have one species at the top (the
Danios), one in the middle (perhaps a pair of Angels or a pair of
Lace Gouramis) and then your catfish at the bottom. Instead of a
jumble, you'll have an nice ordered arrangement. Otherwise, consider
X-Ray tetras (Pristella maxillaris), Diamond tetras (Moenkhausia
pittieri), or Lemon tetras (Hyphessobrycon pulchripinnis) are
excellent community tank tetras and the right size for your
aquarium. But as I say, better to have twelve schooling fish of one
type than six of two different types.
Cheers, Neale.>
Re: fish inquiry (Dwarf Gouramis,
Angelfish, selection)
7/15/08
I'm going to exchange my Serpaes this evening. I think I will
most likely go with the large school or danios and either dwarf
gouramis or angelfish. I'll let my little brother pick. Thanks so
much for all your help! Pierre
<My advise to anyone is don't get Dwarf Gouramis (Colisa lalia,
including fancy forms like "neon gouramis", "robin gouramis", and so
on). Unless wild-caught or locally bred, which the ones in shops
most certainly are not, these fish are extremely likely to carry an
incurable viral disease known as Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus. One
estimate by vets puts the incidence at 22% for Dwarf Gouramis
exported from Singapore. Because the virus is extremely contagious,
you only need one infected fish in a batch to ensure all the others
get sick too. The number of Dwarf Gourami e-mails we get would
astonish you, and they really are a complete waste of money. Almost
every retailer I know dislikes stocking them because so many die in
their tanks, but there is sufficient demand among newbie aquarists
who don't know better that they remain profitable. It's a shame,
because twenty years ago they were quite good little fish. Nowadays,
you're better off with the hardier (if slightly bigger) Colisa
fasciata and Colisa labiosus.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWsubwebindex/dwfgdis.htm
If you buy Angelfish, do remember these are territorial cichlids.
You cannot sex them. But if you have two males, in a small aquarium
they are very likely to become aggressive towards one another. If
you buy a singleton, then there's an increased chance that Angelfish
will "go rogue" and attack other fish in the tank, so that approach
is not without risks. The standard way to keep Angels is to buy six
specimens, let them pair off as they mature, and remove the four
surplus fish when the time comes. Because Angels are such popular
fish, rehoming adults is not difficult and any half-decent aquarium
shop will take them off your hands. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: fish inquiry (Dwarf Gouramis,
Angelfish, selection) 7/17/2008
Can the dwarf Gourami virus spread to other species of fish or only the ones
in the Gourami family?
<This is a complex question. The short answer is yes, the virus can spread to
other species in other families. But so far as I know, the only scientifically
documented example is where Dwarf Gouramis Iridovirus appears to have infected
Maccullochella peelii, and Australian perch-like fish belonging to the
Percichthyidae family. There are no reports that I am aware of where the virus
has caused problems in other species of Gourami though. Hence my recommendation
that Colisa fasciata and Colisa labiosus are safe, reliable alternatives. Yes,
they aren't quite as colourful, but they are still lovely fish and much, much
more likely to live long and happy lives. If you want a small, non-aggressive
Gourami for the community tank, these are the ones to go for. Cheers, Neale.>
|
Sick dwarf Gourami 7/12/08
Hi
We have 2 dwarf Gouramis. The male died yesterday and the female is now in
our quarantine tank. We have had them one month in a tank along with platys,
neon tetras, silvertip tetras and zebra Danios. We noticed discolouration
around the mouth a week ago. They both also had/have a white patch on the
side. It looks like a wound but there are no signs of aggression from the
other fish. Water quality- NO2 25mg/l NO3 0mg/l ph 7.6 temp 25C.
Can you offer any suggestions before we lose the female too? Thanks. Grace
<Hello Grace. If the fish has patches of fluffy or slimy stuff around the
mouth and on the body, the chances are you're dealing with Finrot, Fungus,
or "Mouth Fungus" (actually a bacterial infection). These can only be
treated using antibacterial or antibiotic medications. In the UK, I
recommend a product called eSHa 2000; in the US the antibiotic Maracyn seems
to be preferred. As with any medication, remember to remove carbon from the
filter if you are using it (and I don't recommend freshwater aquarists
bother with it, to be honest). Now, with this said, there is a major problem
with a viral infection known as Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus. This is
untreatable, 100% fatal, and highly contagious. Because it is so common, I
do not recommend aquarists bother with Colisa lalia, and instead suggest
they go with other, unaffected species like Colisa labiosus and Colisa
fasciata.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWsubwebindex/dwfgdis.htm
The symptoms are very consistent: first the fish becomes shy and loses its
appetite, then it loses its colour, then discoloured patches and sores
develop, and finally the fish swells up with dropsy and dies. It's a shame
aquarium shops still stock Colisa lalia, and I've talked to managers of many
shops over the years. They all say the same thing -- as much as they'd like
to stop trading these fish (which die just as quickly in their tanks!), less
expert fishkeepers just keep buying them, so they keep stocking them! It's a
vicious circle really, and until aquarists stop buying them, the mass
producers in the Far East will keep cranking out low quality, widely
infected, Dwarf Gouramis. Anyway, I do hope you have your "NO2" and "NO3"
readings back to front, by the way -- 25 mg/l nitrite (NO2) would be deadly
to any fish!
Hope this helps, Neale.>
Gourami with a bloated abdomen.
- 7/2/08
Hello there. I have a dwarf Gourami with a bloated abdomen. It looks
pregnant however, it also looks as though it is bruised. The area in front
of the bulging abdomen is dark purple/blue like a skin bruise on a human.
Half of the lower fin is this color too. The only tank mate is a giant
golden snail. I clean the take regularly and change the filter as
recommended. Please help. Thanks.
Sincerely,
Glenda
<Glenda, your Dwarf Gourami almost certainly has Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus;
an untreatable, highly contagious to other Dwarf Gouramis, apparently 100%
fatal viral disease. The symptoms are very consistent: loss of appetite and
shyness; loss of colour; appearance of blisters on the body and fins;
swelling of the abdomen; death. Your mistake was buying this species at all
-- in my opinion the prevalence of the disease amongst mass-produced Dwarf
Gouramis is so high that spending money on them is a waste. My
recommendation is to painlessly destroy this fish and then switch to a
reliable small Gourami species such as Colisa labiosus or Colisa fasciata.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWsubwebindex/dwfgdis.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/euthanasiafaqs.htm
Cheers, Neale.>
Emerald Green Corys and Dwarf
Gourami Disease 5/26/08
I have two Gouramis and two Emerald Green Catfish in a 10 gallon tank. If I
suspect one Gourami has Gourami Disease swollen abdomen, long stringy
elimination and discoloration), I have read in your posts that I should assume
the other one, while healthy looking, has it too (correct?).
<It isn't a certainty, but you should certainly remove in infected fish
immediately. I'd painlessly destroy it. Various methods, but Clove Oil is
perhaps the easiest on you and the fish.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/euthanasiafaqs.htm>
I have done 10% and 50% water changes adding aquarium salt and conditioner. My
question is, if my Gourami's are "doomed" and I let them live out their disease,
or take them back to the store since they are only a week old, will my Corys
stay healthy or be affected?
<The virus doesn't affect catfish, so your Corydoras will be fine. Most other
fish are likely immune, though I'd perhaps avoid Honey and Dwarf Gouramis as
well as their hybrids.>
Thank you for you time!
<Cheers, Neale.>
|
Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen 5/26/08
Hi. I have recently started up a 10 gallon tank.
<Do understand that this tank is too small for Blue Gouramis, and indeed for
virtually all tropical fish. There's no reason to buy a 10 gallon tank unless
you're an expert fishkeeper with a view to a breeding project or some other
specific usage. 20 gallon tanks are the minimum sized ones that work reliably
for casual aquarists and standard community fish species. The price difference
between 10 and 20 gallon tanks is negligible, especially when set against how
much longer your fish will live in the one compared to the other.>
2 weeks ago, I bought a powder blue dwarf Gourami and a red dwarf Gourami.
<Both Colisa lalia varieties. Extremely prone to disease; I simply don't
recommend them to fishkeepers. Scarily high prevalence of viral disease;
inbreeding and casual use of antibiotics means their lifespan once purchased is
not high. A lot of retailers I know would sooner not stock them at all. Best
avoided, in favour of hardy species like Colisa labiosus and Colisa fasciata.>
All seemed fine, but the red Gourami hangs out at the bottom of the tank and
sometimes pushes the blue one around.
<The tank is too small. These fish are territorial, and if they're both males,
as is highly likely if they're brightly coloured (females are greyish green) the
dominant one will eventually kill the weaker one.>
Two days ago, I purchased two emerald green Corys that are very active, racing
around.
<Too many fish in a 10 gallon tank! Corydoras aeneus need to be kept in groups
of six or more (they're schooling fish) and that means a 20 gallon tank, at
least. I'm not saying this stuff to be awkward: if you try to cram fish into
too-small a tank, you're going to have problems with water quality, and that
means disease. Your fish aren't going to be happy either, and if you don't care
about their happiness, then why bother keeping fish at all?>
I noticed a few days ago that the blue Gourami seems maybe swollen just under
the gills. Today, I noticed he has some black dots on his face, like he's dirty.
I have done a few partial water changes this past week. Also, last night, I
noticed when he was eliminating it was not releasing and grew to a few inches
long before it even dropped, or came off.
<Difficult to know precisely what this is, but instinctively I'd be guessing
Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus. This is very very common among Colisa lalia, and
currently impossible to treat. It's 100% fatal, and highly contagious. This is
why I tell people not to waste their money on this species. A photo would help
ID the disease more precisely.>
The red Gourami is a big eater, eating most of the food, including the catfish
pellets. The water temperature is between 78 and 80 degrees. I think the red
Gourami may like the bottom of the tank because I have the thickest planting
there (all artificial). I bought some tall "grass" decor, but it is sparse. I
have read it's recommended that I buy some floating plants.
<Yes, floating plants are appreciated by Gouramis.>
Thank you in advance for your time. These fish were purchased for my kids that
just lost a Betta and I would hate to lose my younger son's Gourami.
<I fear you're going to lose the fish anyway.>
Thanks again.
<You're welcome.>
Beth
<Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen 5/26/08
Thank you for your response. I am obviously a beginner and went into the store
not knowing much at all.
<Fair enough.>
I went by the suggestion of the clerk in regard to size of tank and the fish to
put in them.
<Do always remember the guys in the store are there to make sales. In a perfect
world, they'd also hand out expert advice and would stop you from making unwise
purchases. But we live in an imperfect world, and not every store clerk is an
expert fishkeeper. Many are essentially salespeople with little to no personal
experience of keeping fish.>
He informed me that the Dwarf Gouramis are hearty, obviously misinformed.
<Do see here, for example:
http://www.practicalfishkeeping.co.uk/pfk/pages/show_article.php?article_id=428
Something like 22% of the Singaporean fish are infected with the Iridovirus, so
right out the bag over one-fifth are doomed. Couple this with the fact the virus
is extremely contagious, and you have a real problem. It goes without saying
that intensive farming methods to keep the price down and serious inbreeding to
create the all-red and all-blue varieties has done nothing to improve the
hardiness of the species.>
I also went by his suggestion with the catfish that he told me to come back for
after 7 days when purchasing the Dwarf Gouramis.
<In a bigger tank, not a bad idea. But in a 10 gallon tank, overkill.>
I may not know much, but I even mentioned that the two Gouramis and two Catfish
were going to create too many inches per gallon, but he insisted this was fine
and that two catfish were good enough for them socially.
<Ah, I see. So in this instance you should have trusted your instinct. I suspect
that you have the makings of an expert fishkeeper even if you're only just
starting out! Keep reading, keep being critical, and keep raising your game.>
Thank you for your help. I will go back to the store with this knowledge.
<Happy to help, Neale.>
Re: Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen
5/27/2008
Neale,
Thank you so much answering all of my questions. I have attached photos
for you. If you believe this is what it is, I will be bringing both of
the Gouramis back tomorrow since I have had them such a short time.
("<Difficult to know precisely what this is, but instinctively I'd be
guessing Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus. This is very very common among Colisa
lalia, and currently impossible to treat. It's 100% fatal, and highly
contagious. This is why I tell people not to waste their money on this
species. A photo would help ID the disease more precisely.>")
<Photos aren't quite sharp enough to make a good diagnosis. When looking
for Dwarf Gourami Disease, the order of symptoms is typically this:
shyness; loss of appetite; stringy faeces; appearance of discoloured
(usually pale) patches on the body; open bloody sores on the body;
oedema; death. Obviously not every sick Gourami has Dwarf Gourami
Disease, so it's as well to consider the options too, including things
like Finrot and Constipation that can cause at least some of these
symptoms. Do see here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwdistrbshtart.htm
Dark patches can simply be signs of physical damage, specifically to the
nerves that control the colour cells (effectively similar to "stuck"
pixels on an LCD screen. So as I say, don't destroy the fish out of
hand; review the possible alternatives and treat appropriately. In any
case keeping two specimens in the one tank isn't a good idea, so you'll
need to return or rehome one of them.>
Thank you, again. I hope you can see well enough with these pictures.
They don't depict the signs as well as I wish:
<Indeed.>
Again, I appreciate your time with this. The information invaluable!
<Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen 5/27/2008
Do you have advice if I
wanted two more fish, after bringing the Gouramis back that might be
smaller and okay in the tank?
<There's an art to stocking 10 gallon tanks. Essentially look for small
(2.5 cm/1") fish that don't move about much and aren't territorial. This
approach will maximise your chances of success. In the "Gourami" field,
you might consider Sparkling Gouramis (Trichopsis pumila), tiny little
fish that work well in groups provided there are lots of plants at the
surface of the tank for them to hide among. They're wonderfully coloured
and make strange little sounds from time to time. If you live in a hard
water area, you might also consider a "shell dweller" from Lake
Tanganyika such as Lamprologus ocellatus. These fish rarely stray far
from their shells (ideally empty apple snail shells or "escargot" shells
from a boutique food store) and aren't aggressive to mid- or upper-level
fish. Livebearers offer some interesting options, like the darling Least
Killifish (Heterandria formosa), one of the smallest vertebrates known
and native to the Southern United States. Gobies offer lots of
potential, but you do need to review issues like feeding and water
chemistry because some species will not last long if not kept correctly.
Bumblebee Gobies for example do best in hard water with a little salt
added (though this isn't essential) and will only eat ((wet) frozen
bloodworms and small live foods like brine shrimp. As for catfish, the
smallest Callichthyidae are perhaps the ideal, including things like
Aspidoras pauciradiatus and Corydoras habrosus. Small Whiptails like
Hemiloricaria parva also work nicely and add a quirky look to the
system. I'm also keeping Cherry Shrimps and snails such as Nerites and
snail-eating snails (Clea helena) in my mini tanks, and they're
thriving, the shrimps in particular breeding like rabbits. So there's
lots of potential with small tanks, provided you research your options
and make good choices. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen 5/27/2008
Follow Up: Thank you for all of your help. I returned the fish today and
they, indeed, said the Powder Blue Dwarf Gourami did not look well at
all. I followed your advice and decided that the fish were all going to
be too big to be happy in the tank and brought the other Gourami and 2
Cory's back.
<Very good.>
I will say that the pet stores do seem more into turn around than into
the happiness of the fish as the Emerald Green Cory tank said that a 10
gallon tank is suitable and some fish that grow to be 3 inches were
labeled for 5 gallon tanks!
<Unfortunately not an uncommon way to keep fish.>
I purchased 4 guppies, figuring that they will grow no more than 1.5-2
inches and should remain happy. I would like to add 1 or 2 catfish after
the Guppies stabilize. I saw online that there are small species that
only grow to be 1.5 to 2 inches. Would these fish all be okay in the
tank as it would equal about 7.5 to 10 inches of fish in a 10 gallon
tank?
<In theory, Guppies can work in a 10 gallon tank. But in practise, the
males often become aggressive towards one another. They also pester the
females. It's not much fun to watch your male Guppies chasing one
another and harassing the females. So while a single male and two or
more females might be viable, I don't personally recommend Guppies in
very small tanks. That said, many people keep Endler Guppies in small
tanks, and their smaller size perhaps makes them a better bet. I've also
found Humpbacked Limia (Limia nigrofasciata) and Wrestling Halfbeaks
(Dermogenys spp.) work well in 10 gallon tanks.>
Thank you, again.
<Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Blue Gourami black spots and
swollen 5/27/2008
Dear Neale,
I'm sorry for all of the emails. I just want to get this right.
<Understandable!>
As it is (background), under advice from a first pet store, we bought a
tank, let it run for a week and then went to a second store (the one we
ultimately bought from) and found out it was the wrong kind of tank,
needed a heater and all the rest and had to start over again. Now, the
problems we've discussed.
<Hence our usual advice to buy/borrow an aquarium book *before* you
spend any money.>
The more I research, the more I'm concerned that the Emerald Green Corys
are not right for the tank. I love them and how active they are.
However, when we bring back the Gouramis, they may not only grow too big
for the 10 gallon tank, but be too big for the fish we will get as
replacements.
<Green Corydoras (Corydoras aeneus) is an excellent catfish; it is
peaceful, completely harmless towards even livebearer fry, and
long-lived when kept properly. I keep a related species, Corydoras
paleatus in my 180 litre aquarium and watching them plough through sand,
spewing it out of their gills, is a real treat. Both these catfish spawn
readily, and if they're happy you will eventually find their eggs on the
glass. Raising the babies isn't difficult, but that's a story for
another day. But these catfish are potentially too large for a 10 gallon
system, at least once mature. Female Corydoras aeneus will get to at
least 5 cm/2" and potentially 7.5 cm/3". They are not just long but
deep-bodied as well. You also need at least 4, and ideally 6, specimens
to see them at their best. So I agree with your analysis.>
I know you are not big on 10 gallon tanks anyhow, but unfortunately it's
what works best for our space.
<Often the case.>
I have found that there are smaller catfish.
<There are several Dwarf Corydoras species, all reasonably hardy and
easy to keep. Corydoras hastatus swims in the midwater when kept in
reasonable numbers and not scared. Watching the flutter about like
silvery bugs is lots of fun.>
I was thinking that Platys might be a good choice for our tank?
<A bit on the large size. Some varieties of Platy stay quite small, but
in good health most varieties can top 5 cm/2". Personally I'd not
recommend them, though some people do keep them in 10 gallon systems.>
For my boys, we're looking for one fish each that will be characteristic
enough to tell them apart, or maybe two each- space dependent.
<The Catfish/Livebearer combo will work well. Catfish look strange and
usually scoot about the bottom in a very purposeful way; livebearers are
friendly and quickly become tame, rising to the top at feeding time. I
have an 10 gallon system with Aspidoras pauciradiatus (a miniature,
black-and-white Corydoras) and juvenile Limia nigrofasciata. The tank is
filled with live plants, snails and Cherry Shrimps. The result is an
aquarium that's very rewarding and fun to watch.>
They really like the idea of catfish as well, and I have found online
that there are catfish that stay smaller than the Emerald Green Corys.
<Provided you avoid "Otos" (Otocinclus spp.) many of the smaller catfish
are quite hardy. There are also some lovely small loaches, most notably
Kuhli Loaches. Kuhli Loaches are gregarious and rather shy, but they
work well in small tanks.>
I am returning to the store to make an exchange for the Gouramis as the
Powder Blue became sick right away. Would you suggest, while we are
somewhat starting over, that we bring the catfish back as well as they
may be too big to share the aquarium with fish much smaller than them?
<I would, but it's your call. You always have the choice of hanging on
to them for the next year or two, because Corydoras don't grow
particularly fast. By Christmas time say, you might decide to upgrade
the tank to a 20 gallon one. The "footprint" between a 10- and a
20-gallon tank isn't that great, and you can re-use the heater and
filter.>
I hate to do so, but like I said, I want to do this right this time
before we get even more attached. Any advice on the new fish as to what
would be best is greatly appreciated. Thank you!
<Do read these articles for ideas on choosing livestock:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwlivestk.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwlvstksel.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwlivestocking.htm
Take the kids down to the library/bookstore and have look through the
encyclopaedias of freshwater fish. There are literally hundreds of
species on the market, and even if they aren't in stock in your local
store, they can order them or you can go mail order.
Cheers, Neale.> |
|
 |
Gourami disease, eggs?
-03/28/08
hi,
I have just got 4 dwarf Gouramis and 2 are the opalescent blue and the other 2
are orange with stripes. my one striped one has a dark brown appearance on its
head and at the top to,? and appears to be dull and slimy. and the other one
appears to have this too along with a dark blue almost navy stripe near the end
of its belly. is this normal or a disease.
<Not normal, and yes, likely a disease. In particular check your symptoms
against 'Dwarf Gourami Disease', an extremely common and contagious problem
among Colisa lalia imports from Singapore especially.
http://208.112.95.51/FWSubWebIndex/dwfgdis.htm
There is no cure. I would simply advise people NEVER to buy these fish unless
from a local breeder.>
and finally the last question I have is my blue Gourami is larger than the rest
of the tank mates and has been hanging out at the top of the tank. but I have
noticed very small,? white circular things near my heater and every now and then
the swollen fish will go up near that part of the tank. what is wrong with my
fish and what are these things, are they eggs?
<Impossible to say. Quite possibly eggs, through whether from the Gouramis or
something else, e.g., snails, is difficult to say. Gouramis are bubble-nest
builders and don't normally stick their eggs to the glass. On the other hand
Corydoras catfish and some snails do this all the time. If you think they're
eggs, then by all means carefully remove them to a breeding trap and see what
happens! Fish eggs tend to be about 1 mm across and small round spheres; snail
eggs are usually laid in clumps, often in blobs of jelly about 5 mm or so
across.>
thank you
<Next time, please send messages with proper capitalization of sentences! Makes
e-mails easier to read, share. Cheers, Neale.>
|
Dwarf Gourami problem – 03/18/08
Hi.
I have 3 dwarf Gourami's, I took one of them out and put it in a small 1.5
gallon tank as it had a swollen upper body and seems to spend a lot of time at
the bottom
<Dwarf Gourami Disease; caused by a virus. Incurable. See here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/dwfgdis.htm
I cannot state this more clearly: People, stop buying these fish!>
The other tank is all out of whack chemically .75ppm No2, 20 ppm No3, 1.00
ammonia and 7.5 PH. I am really new at this and can't figure out what to do.
<Buy a book, read about fishkeeping. Obviously you've added a bunch of fish to
an immature aquarium. Nitrite and ammonia at these levels will quickly kill your
fish. Start here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwlivestk.htm
>
The small tank I set up is 00ppm No2, 5 No3, .15 Ammonia and 7.6 PH. The temp in
both is 78. I tried putting in Rid·Ich+ which is supposed to help with a variety
of problems.
<Yes, but doesn't "cure" bad fishkeeping. Nor does it help deal with viral
infections. The ammonia in here will kill this Gourami even before the virus. Go
here to see how to painlessly destroy this fish:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/euthanasiafaqs.htm
>
I hope I'm not to late as he looks worse and is staying at the bottom. I noticed
while in the other tank he did not eat anytime I was watching.
<Doomed.>
Sorry for the anxiety. I just hope to be able to be better at this whole thing.
<You can be, but you have to read. You also need to make sensible decisions. For
beginners, buying tanks smaller than 20 gallons is stupid. They're too difficult
to maintain and choose stock for. So I'm hoping you have a tank 20 gallons or
larger. Next up, you choose hardy fish, not "pretty" fish you pick without
research. Dwarf Gouramis for example are among the WORST choices for beginners
because they are plagued with disease and weren't even all that hardy in the
first place. Danios and peppered Corydoras for example would make much better
choices.>
Please help.
<Have done so.>
Thanks. Tina
<Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Dwarf Gourami
problem 03/19/2008
Thank you Neale
<You're welcome.>
I really was not properly informed when I was given the tank (70 gallon)
I should never have taken it without doing more reading. The people who
had it wanted it gone. I have however been reading instead of taking
anymore advice from the tank donors.
<Very good!>
The fish that were in it were not my choice.
<I see.>
I am very thankful for the information that you have given. I am glad I
came to you for help. I hope that no more fish die because of my lack of
knowledge.
<So do I!>
Thanks again and I'm hoping the readings on the tank will clear up soon
as I do more water changes.
Tina
<Good luck, and happy fishkeeping! Neale.> |
Sick Flame Dwarf Gourami
2/28/08
Hey guys,
I found your site when I was researching how to care for my two new green
spotted puffers, but I've found your help so invaluable with them that I was
hoping you'd be able to help me with one of my other tanks.
I have a 20 gallon freshwater tank, and in it live 3 dwarf Gouramis (the normal,
red with blue striped variety -- all male), 3 dwarf flame Gouramis (also all
male), 3 balloon body mollies, and 3 Danios (2 leopard, 1 zebra).
I've had this tank for probably about two months, and it's completely cycled,
but I'm going through a bit of an ammonia spike right now --
<?>
exact numbers to follow below. The Gouramis were the last fish I added, and
they've been in there for several weeks now. Recently (within the last 2 days)
I've noticed that one of my dwarf flame Gouramis looks rather ill. He's laying
on the bottom of the tank, gulping air. He's more or less propped himself up
against the side of the tank. He's not interested in food, though he is still
responsive to stimuli (including the other fish coming over and checking him
out. I've had no aggression problems at all, and my tank is filled with lots of
plants (floating and rooted) in addition to various other forms of cover.
Something isn't right with him, but I don't know what. Water temperature is 78.2
degrees. There's a bit of salt in the water for the mollies (following the
recommendations on the API Aquarium Salt box), though I wouldn't call it salty
enough to be brackish...just enough salt to keep the mollies happy (which they
certainly seem to be... piggy little buggers).
Readings are as follows:
0 ppm Nitrites.
20 ppm Nitrates (holy crap...I just did a 20% water change yesterday...how did
that happen?)
<Accumulates easily...)
The ammonia levels are reading somewhere between 0 and .25 ppm, but it looks
much closer to 0 (sorry, my ability to distinguish colors is
just not what I wish it was...)
<Mine neither...>
pH is around 7.6 (it's usually between 7.6 and 7.8).
What's going on with my tank???
<Something perhaps amiss with the test kit...>
No one else in there seems to be having problems, though with nitrate levels
like that I fear they soon will be.
What do I do?
Thanks for any help!
Micah
<Add some biological filtration (an "auxiliary" filter...)... For the Colisa
Gouramis... they're notorious for being imported with persistent
Hexamita/Octomita et al. protozoan infestations... and a particularly nasty
virus... Please read here re: http://wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/dwfgdis.htm
Bob Fenner>
Dwarf Gourami Disease
2/25/08
Hello again!
<Ave,>
Okay, I read up on the links, and now I am worried for the rest of my Gouramis
(dwarf and regular).
<It's only Colisa lalia and Colisa hybrids you need to worry about; other Colisa
and all Trichogaster seem resistant or immune to the Dwarf Gourami Disease
pathogen.>
If I remove the sick fish, are the rest of them going to catch it?
<See above.>
I just did a water test: my nitrates are about 30ppm (I am due for a water
change), nitrites are 0ppm, the water is testing at 150 (hard), 120
alkalinity and pH at 7.2 (neutral). Should I be adjusting anything?
<Nope.>
if Yes, how do you advise as the best way?
<Broad advice for water chemistry is this: if you don't know how/why to adjust
the water chemistry, you probably shouldn't do it. It is easier to mess things
up completely. In fact, your water chemistry is just about perfect for a broad
range of community fish.>
Sorry to keep asking, I do appreciate the assistance!
Cheryl
<Happy to help, Neale.>
More of a comment, really....Dwarf Gourami disease 2/10/08
Having found a sore on the lip of my male dwarf Gourami early last month, I
looked for info on the internet and found Neale Monks' material as posted on
your webpage (below):
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/dwfgdis.htm
(FAQs on Colisa lalia, C. chuna... "Dwarf" Gouramis of Many Names, Honey,
Flames, Neon Blue, Sunset Fire... Disease/Health)
I was horrified to hear about Dwarf Gourami disease as described in these pages,
as I - perhaps naively - believed the breeding of tropical fish for the pet
market to be 'all right' (ecologically, in animal welfare terms, ethically) and
having purchased the fish from a reputable supplier, I assumed he would be in
good health. My despondency deepened the more I read of the webpage....after
some time I was convinced that my Gourami was doomed to a painful, wasting
death, and was considering euthanising him to prevent further suffering.
My husband suggested that I was perhaps being a bit too hasty about all this,
and that we give the fish a chance since he seemed to be alert and happy
(feeding well, obsessed with his bubble-nest). The sore lip slowly healed and
now (touch wood) he is OK.
The information you provide on your site is an invaluable resource, and Dwarf
Gourami disease certainly seems to be a terrible problem that needs to be
eradicated at source. Neale Monks obviously - and rightly - feels very strongly
about this disease, but my point is that perhaps his opinions on the Dwarf
gouramis (the ones that have already been bred and exported by disreputable
suppliers, and are pets currently living in peoples' homes) are at times a
little too pessimistic - my very limited experience (this far at any rate) shows
that gouramis can recover from slight abrasions and do not always succumb to
bacterial infections immediately. Of course I don't know that my fish isn't
affected and can only hope that he survives to a good age.
This is a minor comment on an excellent web-based resource, and I hope it hasn't
caused offence.
With all best wishes, Katrina
<Hi Katrina. No offence at all taken. It's always good to get comments about
things I write, even when people disagree. Yes, I do feel strongly about Dwarf
Gourami Disease. And it isn't me saying these things are disease-ridden.
Australian vets looked at Dwarf Gouramis closely because the virus they carry is
very similar to one that's suddenly appeared among populations of a native fish,
the Murray Cod. The vets found that 22% of the Dwarf Gouramis exported from
Singapore carried the Dwarf Gourami Iridovirus, and they believe the virus at
some point mutated and then started infecting the Murray Cod. Furthermore, the
quality of Dwarf Gouramis has been declining for at least ten years. Wholesalers
in the UK have been attempting to source Dwarf Gouramis from better suppliers.
http://www.practicalfishkeeping.co.uk/pfk/pages/item.php?news=1139
As I hope my comments in those Dwarf Gourami articles implies -- Dwarf Gourami
Disease (DGD) has a very specific pathology. Not all Dwarf Gouramis with
scratches or sores are infected with DGD any more than not every human who
coughs has Bubonic Plague. But if you have a Dwarf Gourami that loses colour,
hides away, stops feeding, has stringy faeces, develops bloody sores on the body
and ultimately keels over and dies, then there's a pretty good case to believe
this fish has DGD. If all your Dwarf Gourami has is a small blister or
something, then by all means isolate the fish (always a good call with any sick
fish) and monitor for other symptoms. If the fish swims and feeds normally, then
precisely as you've reported, the damage could be something as simple to treat
as Finrot or plain mechanical damage that needs time to heal. But if the fish
subsequently develops the full set of DGD symptoms, then isolating that fish is
critical, because infected fish rarely (if ever) get better, and the viruses can
spread very easily through the water. In other words, not all sick Dwarf
Gouramis have DGD, but some do, and the aquarist should *aggressively* isolated
suspected cases, particularly if the tank contains other Dwarf Gouramis (and
potentially other Gouramis I suppose). Hope this helps, and thanks for writing!
Neale.>
Dwarf
Gourami, hlth. 1/29/08
Hi.
I have been going though your WWM website. Thank you very much for your
support, help and lots of information.
I have a question about one of my dwarf Gouramis.
He has been attacked by the male Platy 2-3 weeks ago and since that
doesn't look right to me.
He looks as if his scales are gone on one side and some of scales stick
out like a pinecone, and color around that area getting darkish.
He hides in the corner of the tank, always head up position.
I noticed stringy white poop and bloat, slightly swollen around gills.
Also his top fin has a crack ( you can see it on the photo)
Today he wasn't interesting in the food.
I checked the water parameters - they are good. My community tank is 55
gal. Not overstocked. I did 30% water changes, just in case. I usually
do a weekly.
I started to add a MelaFix.
Could you help me to advise with the name of medication I can use to
treat my guy?
Thanks
Larissa
<Hello Larissa. If you're lucky, this is mere Finrot. Treat with a
proper Finrot medication of your choice, but not Melafix which doesn't
really work reliably. Maracyn is popular in the US, but here in the UK I
prefer to use eSHa 2000. Use whatever you want really. If you're
unlucky, this is an early stage of Dwarf Gourami Disease. This causes
swellings and blisters on the body, as well as lethargy, loss of colour,
loss of appetite, and eventually death. It's incurable. It is caused by
a virus, and is so common among Dwarf Gouramis that I simply WILL NOT
recommend anyone keep them. It is highly contagious, and will affect all
Dwarf Gouramis including the "fancy" sorts like Neon Gouramis and Robin
Gouramis. If you have any of these in the tank, assume they are
infected, and likely doomed to a premature death. The reason Dwarf
Gourami Disease is so common is that people keep buying the things, and
so the breeders out in Singapore make no effort to stop the virus. There
are much better Gouramis out there, such as Colisa fasciata and Colisa
labiosus. Cheers, Neale.> |
|
|
Gouramis
disease, Colisa lalia... 1/18/08
Hi,
I have a 130lt aquarium and it hosts 9 fish (6 gouramis, 2 goldfish, 1
angel and 1 neon tetra). 4 days ago all of a sudden my 2nd angel died
(didn't show any symptoms before that) and ever since I have the one
problem after the other in the aquarium. I did partial change of the
water but the next day one of my gouramis (red in colour) stayed at the
bottom of the tank swimming only to go up and grasp some oxygen and then
come down to the bottom of the tank again. I decided to get my water
tested, so I took a sample to the pet shop that showed a small rise of
nitrates in the tank and he gave me a liquid to change the nitrate
levels that I used in conjunction with sera Nitrivec, after another
partial change of the water. The day before yesterday my sick Gourami
got a swollen belly and I decided to look for a cure. It seemed like an
internal infection and I found a treatment with sera BACTOPUR direct
that I used today. Yesterday, after the med for the nitrates a few other
gouramis started showing weird behavior. They swim like crazy up and
down, and one of them seems like it's fainting for a while, then getting
up and swimming normally. Today, nearly none of my gouramis ate, and the
sick one cannot swim at all, it has the swollen belly, the colour of the
Gourami becomes darker and it seems like he is peeling off at a small
part of her body. I went to the pet shop and bought sera BACTOPUR direct
today, and added 2 tablets to the tank. I took out the sick Gourami and
put it in 2 litres of water 1 tablet of sera BACTOPUR direct for a more
drastic treatment, left it for 30 minutes and put it back in the tank. I
didn't see any change yet, and I really do not know what to do. I only
have the aquarium for a month, I do not have any live plants, and
they're the first fish I introduced in it. I also rose the temp to 28
Celsius degrees. Please help me, if I can save their life. Thank you
Elena
<Hello Elena. Are these Dwarf Gouramis (Colisa lalia) by any chance? If
they are, then the problem is almost certainly "Dwarf Gourami Disease".
This is not curable, at least, not at the point where the fish display
symptoms. Typical symptoms are: first shyness and loss of appetite, then
the colour fades, then ulcers and lesions appear on the body, then the
abdomen swells, and then the fish dies. The best you can do is
painlessly destroy sick fish, because they won't get better. (Or at
lest, I've yet to hear of any Dwarf Gourami with Dwarf Gourami Disease
get better.) Dwarf Gouramis are simply not worth keeping any more.
Avoid, and never keep them again. If you must keep a small Gourami, then
look to hardier species such as Colisa fasciata and Colisa labiosus. Do
also understand that a "new" aquarium (which yours is) doesn't have a
fully mature filter. Many fish will become sick when kept in such a
tank. Use a nitrite (with an "I", as opposed to nitrate-with-an-"a")
test kit to measure the nitrite level; if you detect nitrite, the tank
is still immature and potentially deadly to your fish. Do lots of water
changes! I'd suggest 10-25% per day for the next week or two. Stick with
a few, very hardy fish to begin with. Corydoras paleatus for example, or
Danio species. Only keep things like Gouramis and Angelfish after 2-3
months. Cheers, Neale.>Re:
Gouramis disease 1/18/08
Hi Neale. Thanks for the quick response. Yes, I checked now on google, I
have the dwarf gouramis (Colisa lalia). Ok, so I will take back to the
pet shop the gouramis that don't look sick and the angel. I will only
keep goldfish in for a couple of months. Do you think that this disease
will affect goldfish now it exists in the tank? I have to admit I am new
in the aqua world and I hardly know anything about fish. I am constantly
trying to read and learn now though. Ever since I set up the aquarium I
change the water every week. I didn't know gouramis were so sensitive,
but I got really upset not being able to help them. When I take gouramis
out, do I have to change the water? Because the medication is still in
the water. I am supposed to change it in 3 days. I live in Cyprus and in
pet shops I couldn't find a huge variety of species but I will do
exactly what you said if I am to avoid having them suffering again.
Thanks again, you have a wonderful website.
<Hello Elena. Goldfish will be fine, provided you keep on top of water
changes. No, Goldfish don't catch Dwarf Gourami Disease (as far as we
know!). Not much is known about the virus that causes the disease,
except that it is VERY widespread.
http://www.practicalfishkeeping.co.uk/pfk/pages/item.php?news=1139
Yes, change some of the water after you remove the Gouramis, but not
because of the disease, but because that's a good thing to do. Water
changes are GOOD! They're the cheapest and easiest way to have healthy
fish. 50% per week is what I recommend. But finish to coarse of medicine
first. So if it says no water changes for 3 days, then don't do water
changes for 3 days. Wow, Cyprus would be a GREAT place to keep fish. If
I was there, I'd spend all my time at the beach, collecting cool gobies
and blennies. The Mediterranean is just packed with excellent fish that
do really well in aquaria. But if you want FRESHWATER fish, then you'll
have to work with what's available! Dwarf Gouramis just aren't worth it
in my experience. Lots of better gouramis. Avoid MALE blue or gold
gouramis though (Trichogaster trichopterus), as they can be very
aggressive. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Gouramis disease 1/18/08
Hello Neale. Thanks for that. I will do as you told me. Thanks again.
<Very good. Enjoy your fish! Neale.> |
Colisa
lalia/chuna (?) with sickness/discoloration. 1/17/08
I have a dwarf Gourami, Colisa lalia (I think), which I believe is
sick.
<Yes, this is Colisa lalia, but an artificial morph.>
I say *believe* because behaviorally there don't appear to be any
problems.
<Not yet, anyway. But the sore does look troubling.>
However, he’s developed the coloring/marking shown in these pictures in
the last week, week-and-a-half, and it doesn’t appear to be going away.
It also doesn’t seem to be growing/changing…it was just ‘there’ one
morning. He’s been in quarantine since Dec. 26 (along with the other
fish I got at the same time) and none of the other fish have developed
this… problem.
<Good.>
The whole batch had Ich when we picked them up (I got them for pennies
on the dollar) but that cleared up nicely and we only lost a clown loach
(out of $120+ worth of fish and the one we wanted most kicks the bucket
;-().
<Hmm...>
Treatment was QuickCure (at half the dose--group includes tetras), salt
(2 tbsp/ 10 gal), and Melafix (don’t knock it… it’s helped me many
times) for 12 days. I’ve since put him into his own quarantine (3 gal
Eclipse) and am at a loss.
<Not a fan of Melafix. Yes it works sometimes, but not always; the
alternative medications may be more expensive, but at least they work
consistently.>
My first thoughts were DGD or some kind of tumor, but the coloration
doesn’t seem right to me and it doesn’t seem elevated so I haven’t
considered it a growth.
<I'd go with Dwarf Gourami Disease as well. Only time will tell...
Regardless, don't mix with any other Gouramis, and certainly don't place
in a tank you intend to add Dwarf Gouramis to any time soon.>
Nitrates/Nitrites/Ammonia are all easily within allowable limits (15
ppm/ 0 ppm/ 0 ppm). Temps were on the high end to clear up the Ich (82
F).
<Fine.>
Hardness is 4 dH, pH is 7.4, and water changes are weekly with treated
tap-water of the same hardness and pH. Do you have any thoughts? Thanks!
<None really. You're doing/thinking what I would. It's possibly physical
trauma that's damaged some nerves, and so what you're seeing are the
"colour cells" (chromatophores) stuck in an odd position (think: broken
pixels on an LCD screen). There certainly seems to be a puncture at the
centre, but whether that's a puncture inwards (i.e., a cut) or a
puncture outwards (i.e., a burst cyst) I cannot say. If this is DGD, the
fish'll be dead in a few weeks, so you may as well maintain in a
quarantine tank (or at least a tank without labyrinth fish) and see how
things go. If nothing happens after a month or six weeks, at the very
least you should see the central wound heal up, in which case keep the
fish in a community tank without labyrinth fish are accept it as just
being odd. Please get back in touch as and when you see things change or
improve; I'd like to know more. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Colisa
lalia/chuna (?) with sickness/discoloration. - 1/17/08
Neale (and WWM Crew),
<Branon,>
Thank you for the quick response! It looks like we're on the same sheet
of music on this one.
<Cool.>
I'm concerned when you say not to put him into a system with
Anabantoids...I have a Betta (which is currently in a separate QT) I'm
planning on including in the system (150 gal community tank) and I was
thinking these two are far enough distant in relation to rule out
susceptibility to DRD...?
<I'd guess that'd be a fair comment, but I'm just not 100% sure.>
I may also not be familiar enough with DRD... is this an infection which
can/will remain in the tank for months/years even if there aren't viable
hosts (i.e. non-resistant labyrinth fish)?
<Likely yes. It's caused by a virus -- Dwarf Gourami iridovirus -- and
as far as I'm aware, no-one knows how to kill it, how long it can
survive in an aquarium, if it can be carried by other fish without
causing symptoms, or really much of anything at all!>
Is there an all-clear time-frame?
<Not aware of one, no.>
If it doesn't clear up and he isn't dead by the end of the additional
4-6 wk. QT, do I assume it isn't DRD?
<Sounds reasonable to me.>
Thanks for all your wonderful assistance!
<Happy to help!>
Branon
<Cheers, Neale.> |
|
 |
|
|