FAQs on Otocinclus 2
Related Articles: Otocinclus, Loricariids,
Related Catfish FAQs: Otocinclus 1, & FAQs on:
Otocinclus Identification, Otocinclus Behavior, Otocinclus Compatibility, Otocinclus Selection, Otocinclus Systems, Otocinclus Feeding, Otocinclus Health, Otocinclus Reproduction, &
Catfishes of South and Central America, Loricariid Identification, Loricariid Behavior, Loricariid Compatibility, Loricariid Selection, Loricariid Systems, Loricariid Feeding, Loricariid Reproduction, Loricariid Disease, Catfish: Identification, Behavior, Compatibility, Selection, Systems, Feeding, Disease, Reproduction, Algae
Should I be worried that my Oto is this big?
<I would be concerned yes. Could be a few things amiss here... water
quality, foods... Please read what we have archived on the genus on WWM. B>
I heard they don't breed in captivity, so is it getting fat or is it ill?
Oto, no rdg. as usual 12/3/14
I decided against the bandit Cory and got an Otocinclus
catfish instead. It will grow to about 2 inches. It requires a 10 gallon
and the linked files above. B>
I have a tank rated for 29 gallons by the manufacturer. The tank is 36"
L x 12" W x 18" H. The ph is 8 and nitrates and ammonia
at 0. My filter is a sponge filter rated for 40 gallons. This tank
contains 2 guppy females, 5
neon tetras, 10 platy fish, and numerous bladder snails. According to
internet aquarium stocking sources I should have 36 inches worth of
for fish stocking.
With the Otocinclus I will add, will I be overstocking this tank? Thank
Otocinclus question - 05/11/2012
Grr it's finals week, and here I am adding to my stress worrying about my new
Oto which I introduced to my tank a week ago. So I have 3 Otos, they are all
brown-silver with very white bellies and a black line dividing the middle (
sounds like all other Otos doesn't it?)
the newest one looks like the other ones in every single way except for its
tail. whilst the other two have clear spot patternings on their tail fins(2
small ones at the base and a larger clear patch near the edge), the newbie's
tail fin is colored black along the rays (or I think they are called rays?). He
never schools with the others, and seem positively dead during the day. My Cory
will bustle past sending a shower of sand on the newbie - if he's lying on the
sand. And he wouldn't budge an inch. other times he finds a nook somewhere and
stays there for the entire day. I have only ever seen him being busy at night
just before lights off (at around 11pm). When he is against the glass, I can see
that his stomach is fat. There is no obvious damage to his body or anything. I
did notice that he likes to feed with my lonely Cory (who doesn't act lonely at
all, the crazy thing) which is from the substrate when I drop pellets rather
than noming on algae. Is he/she of a different species?
So you think he is lonely?
Should I buy another one?
WWM: If you
can get some from the same batch at the store, sure!
Could it be something else? Water nitrogen param.s are all 0 and PH is 7.4.
Temperature is 73F this morning. Not sure about anything else. The other Otos
are well fed and "school" together (if you can call two fish a school). The only
funny thing is that sometimes one will bend/stretch out his tail slowly all the
way to his head, then snapping it straight again. first one way and then
another. The only analogy I can think of is how people loosen their necks by
slowly tilting their heads side to side. Is this normal behaviour? or should I
be looking for parasites and such?
WWM: If he's
feeding and has a nice rounded (convex) belly, I wouldn't worry.
Thank you so much in advance. This is my fourth email to you guys and I'm kind
of feeling bad about taking up your time...
Thank you for the great work you are all doing.
Re: Otocinclus question - 5/12/2012
Thank you for the prompt response!
Sadly he's not doing too well today, his previously fat (almost bloated) stomach
seems to have deflated profusely in the course of a day. Parasites?
Possibly. Wild-caught Loricariidae (including Otocinclus spp.) are plagued by
both worms and protozoan parasites, and while these rarely cause problems, some
species, particularly Otocinclus and Panaque spp., have a reputation for being
decidedly hit-and-miss shortly after purchase.
I did realize that for the past two days I have been feeding the tank residents
sinking wafers instead of algae wafers.
Shouldn't have caused this particular issue.
Just when I wanted to pat myself on the back for having a low death rate keeping
Otos (1 dead 3 alive so far). It seems that he is blatantly refusing to eat and
is dying of starvation.
It is swimming weakly and sometimes unable to keep its balance. I've taken it
out into a smaller quarantine with an airstone. Leaving him some algae wafers
and algae covered leaves. But he is either refusing to eat or just to weak to do
Also added an IAL (belonging to my Betta), not sure if it will do anything to
Its eyes seem hollow and stomach is caving in. His nostrils also seem like a
large almost eye sized triangular hole whilst the other two Oto's noses are
small holes that protrude slightly outwards.
This dying Oto is kind of discouraging to me, I have never had a fish die of
starvation. and even though I have read that starvation amongst Corydoras have
been cured by simply isolating the Cory and giving it food, it seems that Otos
are not the case…
Correct. As you'll see if you go back over the WWM replies, Otocinclus are not a
catfish type with a high success rate in captivity, and I rarely recommend them.
Quarantining and deworming, and ideally treating for intestinal parasites (e.g.,
with Flagyl) are probably very useful.
I also read up on force feeding, but don't believe it can be done with such a
miniature fish in its fragile state.
so. Worth a shot though, and with a hard-bodied fish like an Oto, you might just
get away with it. A tiny piece of prawn, pressed into the mouth with a blunt
needle or similar could be workable.
I can only come up with a few theories. 1. He is dying of depression without one
of the same species.
2. He only ate algae wafers and two days without this staple starved him.
3. He came with a parasite which caused the bloat then the starvation.
4. he is an abused Oto and was on its way out when it arrived.
So this is my 4th Oto, as I always wanted 6 but wanted to work my way up slowly.
WWM: Do buy
them the day they arrive, so the pet store has no time to mess them up, and then
quarantine them yourself. If you can, proactively medicate.
I don't even know how the first Oto died. he just vanished on the second day of
purchase. And try as I might, searching high and low under ornaments and the
like, I could not find it. I don't think the resident fish -a Corydoras and an
Oto-at the time could have eaten the body. The other suspects were two cherry
shrimps and two ghost shrimps. There was no ammonia spike after this death, so I
assumed that the plants in the tank simply absorbed the excess. Any
recommendations of how I should act now? Should I watch how the other two goes
before introducing any more?
even though they've been in the tank for a month. Or should I not give up? Is
there a recommended "safe period" for quarantining Otocinclus?
Honestly, no. Quarantining helps, but it's really Russian Roulette with this
genus. Warm water slowly kills them (anything above 25 C/77 F) and their natural
habitat -- cool, fast-flowing streams with lots of algae -- just isn't often
replicated in the community aquarium.
Is there a certain way to condition them to eat vegetables or wafers in case
they consume all of the algae in the tank?
really. Green algae is really what they want, so bright light and flat surfaces
(like pebbles) are what you need to provide. Algae wafers make an adequate
supplement, and some go for finely chopped or small invertebrates. But it's a
group of catfish to approach with caution, despite their widespread sale.
I have tried blanched spinach before and never saw them touch it (but I did fish
out a horde of baby snails I didn't know I had.) Thank you greatly again in
advance for either confirming or correcting my suspicions and answering my
Welcome. Best of luck, Neale.
thanks for the kind words.
Question about my Oto cat
A while ago I had a 10 gallon tank with 4 Guppies and an Oto
<A bit small for Guppies.>
The Oto did just fine, was always eating, and very lazy.
<Shouldn't be "lazy" at all. This SCHOOLING
species should be buzzing about in a group of five or more
specimens, pretty much all the time, flitting from leaf to
Now I have a new tank with 4 GloFish and an Oto Cat.
<Again with "an" Otocinclus. They're schooling
fish that don't do well singly.>
This is my second Oto for this tank the first died after two
<Unfortunately a very common experience. Most aquarists kill
their specimens quite quickly, and retailers aren't any
better at all.>
When I took it back the pet store they said it was because it was
<Likely correct. Otocinclus are notoriously difficult to feed.
In the wild they consume green algae (not diatoms, and not hair,
bush or thread algae either) alongside what is called aufwuchs,
tiny invertebrates that live among green algae. In captivity they
can be maintained in mature tanks with a combination of green
algae, finely minced seafood, and standard algae wafers, but they
don't compete well for food and shouldn't be kept
alongside greedy fish that feed in the same way, e.g., loaches or
So I got another one and put blanched zucchini in the tank, as
many sites said they'll like.
<Some specimens will eat softened vegetables, but it's not
Problem is he hasn't touched it. I don't want to starve
another one.. I have also put in an algae wafer and he hasn't
touch that either. He keeps sucking the sides and swimming all
over from side to side of the tank like he's looking for
something to eat. Any suggestions??
<Will likely not settle down without four or more friends of
his own kind.
In a group this species is happier, and therefore more ready to
Should I just wait to see if he makes it or not?
<If you want, but I'd put money on a swift death.>
Also right now I'm leaving the light on 12 hours to try and
<Green algae needs strong lighting to grow. If you have plants
that grow so quickly you have to remove a handful of foliage
every week or two, you probably have the right amount of light.
If your plants basically sit there and throw out the odd leaf
every few weeks, then you probably don't have strong lighting
and the dominant algae types will be diatoms (the brown scum on
the glass) and red algae (hair, brush and thread algae, which
aren't red, despite the common name for this group).>
I'm stumped I don't know what else to do.
<I'm surprised you're stumped, because the aquarium
literature on Otocinclus spp. is actually quite good. Most any
tropical fish book will tell you that these catfish need to be
kept in groups, need cool water (22-25 C/72-77 F), and are
difficult to feed.>
I attached 2 picture to see if your think he's okay or not.
He's slightly blurry because he wouldn't sit still.
He's very active. Thank you!!
<Glad to help.>
P.S The pet store got new fish in Thursday and Friday when I
brought my dead one back and got the new one, he was the last one
left. I'm not sure if they just sold that quick or if there
was a reason to why they didn't get more.
<Many pet shops buy Otocinclus because they know [a] they die
quickly and [b] people will keep buying new ones to replace any
losses. Somehow, there's a rumour that Otocinclus are good
algae eaters for small tanks.
That's total and 100% rubbish, but sadly you'll hear it
said in some pet shops and written on web sites by people who
perhaps don't know any better.
There are some excellent catfish sites, like PlanetCatfish, that
will provide very useful information.>
It just seemed weird to me.
<Not weird; typical.>
I checked and there was no dead fish in the tank so I assume they
were all in good health. I was thinking of getting another one so
he has company, but no other pet stores around here sell them. If
this one doesn't work out I'm going to stay away from
them for a while as much as I don't want to... I really like
these little guys.
<I agree with you that this genus is best avoided by casual
aquarists. They can work in largish (20+ gallons?) systems with
bright lighting and lots of plants, where there's enough
growth of green algae to supplement algae wafers and other such
foods. In smaller tanks and less brightly lit tanks they become
totally dependent upon the aquarist to feed them, and that is
very difficult to do. Not impossible, but difficult, and you do
need to ensure two or more small meals per day. Kept singly the
poor thing may well be so nervous it'll never feed adequately
well. For small tanks Nerite snails are infinitely better
algae-eaters, not least of all because they consume diatoms. Hope
this helps. Cheers, Neale.>
|Re: Question about my Oto cat
Thanks for your help Neale.
So basically I need to get more, which is impossible because the
pet store is out,
<Otocinclus spp. aren't rare, and shopping around or online
should yield results. Alternatively, ask your retailer to order
or take him back/wait for him to die and get something else..
do you have any other suggestions other then snails? I always start
out with one snail and end up with like 10.
<Nerites don't breed in freshwater; they lay eggs, but the
larvae need to drift to the sea and develop in the plankton. This
is why I specifically recommend Nerites. One or two per 5 gallons
is about right.>
At pet smart they have albino Cory catfish in the tank with the
Glofish but it says they get to 3" and I think that's to
big for a ten gallon though it says 10+ gallons on the tag.
<Albino Catfish are typically Corydoras paleatus, and while they
could be kept in a 10 gallon tank, they wouldn't be my
recommendation. Yes, exceptional specimens can exceed 7.5 cm/3
inches, though 5 cm/2 inches is much more typical. Do read the
following for more on stocking:
Would it be okay if I moved my Oto out of the tank to feed or would
it stress him out more.
<Yes, that would be stressful. Guppies shouldn't compete
against him for food, but Corydoras surely would, at least in a
tank this small. Nerites and Cherry Shrimps would be the most
logical bottom feeders.>
I'm really wanting to keep him around. Thanks again.
algae eating catfish... Oto et al. reading --
I've heard about an algae eating catfish referred to as an
"Oto". Can you tell me anything about these little guys.
<... read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/otocinclusart.htm
and the linked files above>
<There are better choices for most settings, species mixes... Learn
to/use the search tool, indices on WWM. Bob Fenner>
Thank you, Otos 4/6/2009
To whom it may concern,
<Come on Irene>
Thank you for sharing your knowledge and expertise on Otocinclus
I have learned much valuable information from your website. I have
raised these fish but sadly with no success.
<Not easily kept admittedly... Take a beating through collecting,
holding, shipping... and then need a rather narrower range of water
quality, consistent... and high DO to do well>
I do not want to give up on the possibility of raising these fish
successfully so I am trying to research as much as possible about them
as much as possible until I plan to get more. At one time, I had one
successfully survive for about a week until it disappeared. I assume it
was devoured by one of the
other fish in the tank. The full grown ones did not survive much longer
then a month. A couple of times I saw an Otocinclus vittatus move above
the water line to suction against dry part of the glass aquarium. I am
sure if this was normal.
<I do consider this a "normal" part of their (waterfall
climbing if you will) behavior>
It seemed strange. One of the fish that did this I believe died as a
result of being dried out.
<This is/would be unusual IMO>
Anyhow, thank you for providing thorough information about this
interesting fish. I would appreciate any further advice that you may
provide me regarding how
to raise them.
<To keep gathering information, folks personal experiences as well
as scientific. Bob Fenner>