
|
|
FAQs about Aquarium Chillers/Chilling: Rationale/Use
Related Articles: Marine Tank Heating,
Cool/Coldwater Marine Systems, Coldwater
Sharks, Related FAQs:
Chilling 1, Chilling 2, & FAQs
on: Fans For Cooling, Chiller
Rationale/Use, Selection,
DIY, Installation,
Maintenance, Troubleshooting, &
Cool./Cold Marine Set-Up,
Heating, Water Temperature, Metal
Halide Heat Issues, |
Water is the "standard" for the measure of specific heat... it
holds/gives away more energy than any other substance per unit |
High temperatures 11/24/06 Dear Crew <Hi
Daniel! Tim answering your question today!> First can I say that I
love your website! It's a great resource and it has already come in
great use! Two things: 1)I'm having a bit of a problem with
temperature in my tank. I live in Australia and am heading into summer.
Recently temps have been getting up to 40C and my tank is staying at a
consistent 31C. I've read you advice about adding a fan to cool the
water, but this is where the problems begin. I have an AquaOne 120
all-in-one setup (wish I'd never bought the thing but stuck with it
now). Since the lights (2 x 30 W actinics and 1 30 W fluorescent) and
filter are built into the top, it makes adding equipment very difficult
without significant drilling of plastic! Do you know of any way I can
modify this system to add a fan? Would adding it to the filter box be
sufficient? A chiller really isn't an option as I've already forked out
a packet and I don't know if ice blocks will work over the long term
either. <Have a look at purpose-built aquarium fans that are often
much smaller than standard fans, and so may be more easy to place into
your aquarium. Also, although your fluorescent lamps will not produce a
considerable amount of heat, it may be helpful to have the lights on at
night, late in the evening or early in the morning, before the heat of
day (though the transition to this should be slow, to allow the
livestock to gradually adjust and avoid "jet lag"). Depending on your
current set up, you may also be able to reduce the amount of time that
the lights are actually on - this will also depend on your live stock,
though I would imagine that with regular fluorescent lighting there is
not much photosynthetic life in your aquarium. Finally, if the aquarium
is in a room with a lot of windows, consider covering the windows with
curtains or blinds to reduce the ambient temperature in the room as much
as possible.> 2) I have also had a pretty bad time with diatoms. My
LFS seems to think it could be due to the old lights that came with the
AquaOne setup (3 x 30W Atman Fluorescents which I have now changed to
the actinics mentioned above). Does this sound likely to you? It's also
worth noting that my protein skimmer has only just started working as I
added it about 3 months after the tank was started. <Check your
water parameters - presumably you have a problem with nitrates and/or
sulphates. Reduce these with large water changes (also be sure to check
your fresh water ANN levels!) and a continued proper maintenance routine
involving regular water changes. Your lights will only be partly
responsible for the problem. Other culprits may include overfeeding and
insufficient circulation. What kind of protein skimmer are you running
on your system? Best of luck resolving this problem!> Any advice
would be greatly appreciated! Dan Miller Live Rock
Thanks for your fast reply. Feel much more relieved.. :D The tank's
still cycling though.. no livestock yet.. I'm worried about the
temperature though.. I understand it should be around 24-27
degrees,<yes> but as I live in tropical Singapore, the it soars to about
29 in afternoons. A chiller is not really feasible due to costs (I'm a
poor 14yr old.. :D) and a fan would look out of place.<agreed> I have
heard from a retailer about freezing bottles and immersing them and I'm
worried about the fluctuating temperatures.<you could do this and put
the frozen bottles of water in your sump> Are there any other solutions
to keeping it cool or must I beg my mum for the chiller? <you could
try the freezing bottles of water idea...but the chiller is probably
your best bet, Good luck, IanB> :D Thanks again, Hector
Keeping His (Tank's) Cool! Hi Scott <Hey!> I have been
browsing through the FAQs on WetWebMedia regarding heating. From what I
have read most of the advise given says that temp in a marine tank is
fine up to 80deg Fahrenheit which is close to 30 degrees Celsius.
<True> Is this true my tank is around 28degrees Celsius and probably
around 30 with my lights on or on a very hot day. <On the high end of
acceptable...> I am gonna be adding a fan or 2 but is temp up to 80
Fahrenheit ok? I need not worry too much if this is the case.
Thanks Again Regards Ziad Limbada <Well, Ziad- I wouldn't be too
concerned if the temperature hits 30 for short periods of time. If
you're exceeding this temperature for extended periods, there is some
cause for concern. It's important to maintain a high degree of
oxygenation and water quality, as there is less margin for error at
higher temperatures in closed systems. In the end, if you're obeying the
rules of good aquarium husbandry, you should be fine if the temperature
gets up there...Stay cool! Regards, Scott F.> The Heat Is On!
Hi Scott <Hi there!> Got another one for ya. <Ask away> My
tanks temperature is extremely high I think it could be because of all
the additional equipment that I have added as well as we currently in
Summer in South Africa so it is rather warm. <Not fun, huh?> Their
is normally not a lot of ventilation in my home during the day as we are
not at home so the place is pretty locked up. My temp is currently
sitting at 28 degrees Celsius and this is not even with my heater
switched on. <I believe it...> I have tried leaving the hood of my
tank open to allow some air to circulate. Have you got any ideas I mean
28 degrees without the heater is really hectic! I am thinking of running
a fan over the tank to keep things cool but then I would have to run
this 24/7 Please help Thanks Again Ziad <Well, Ziad- the idea
of leaving the top open for ventilation, along with some strategically
placed fans can help knock the temperature down a few degrees. Of
course, the best solution is the most expensive (why is it always that
way?)-a chiller. A properly sized chiller can do the trick with a
minimum of hassle, but there is definitely expense involved in the
purchase, setup, and operation of chillers; something to consider when
investing in one. Hope this helps, but I think that it will lead you
into another expensive direction, unfortunately! Regards, Scott F>
Regards Ziad Limbada The Heat is On (8/1/04) My god
It's hot here. <Where?> For 3 days now its been up in the 35c and is
great for swimming in the river and cooling off, too bad it isn't that
easy for my fish. The temperature in my tank has been going through the
roof! <How high?> A couple of times its been past 83 luckily my fish are
fine. I've been trying to figure out how to cool it down, my heaters off
there's 2 fans and a swamp cooler against it and I've been putting
frozen bottles of water in. <Be careful not to shock your fish but
dropping the temperature too much too fast.> Finally I get it down put
its putting a lot of streets on my fish. <Yes, I would not stress them
too much to get it down. Low 80s' should be OK.> The tank is a 55 gallon
saltwater. I have zero dollars for a chiller and am leaving tomorrow for
4 days I'm worried about what will happen. the neighbor can only come
once a day and I'm hoping that will be enough. He can put a few frozen
bottles in if its too warm. Is there any other way I can cool down the
tank that I can leave on all day? <Only a chiller. Fans are next best,
but there will be a lot of evaporation for the neighbor to replace. Read
more ideas here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/chillersmar.htm> Thanks very much your
site if very much a godsend and your dedication to these hobby is
immense. Thank you, Tristan <It is a pleasure for me to play a small
roll <<Heeee! RMF, who intends to play a jelly roll>> in this great
venture. I hope this helps some. In the long runs, a chiller is your
best bet. That or central air conditioning. Steve Allen.>
Chillin' Out (Is a Chiller Necessary for a Small Tank?) Hi There!
<Scott F. here with you tonight.> Do I really need a chiller for a
small 24" reef tank in my bedroom that very rarely gets to 24 degrees C?
Some fishy people say I do. Others don't. I'm really confused about
everything though now! <Confused? About something in the marine
hobby? Really? hah! hah! Just kidding. Seriously, unless you have a
significant heat problem you could probably do a real good job by using
a quality fan directly over the water surface. A chiller may only be
necessary in instances where your tank reaches high temperatures for
sustained periods of time.> Anyway, do I need one. They're pretty
expensive though and if I did need one could I do a DIY one with a
fridge compressor and run the filaments through the tank? That is if
even need one!! Thanks for your time anyway. Bye, Ben <Well, Ben,
quite honestly, as above, I only feel a chiller is necessary if you
experience a heat problem. Otherwise, save your money for fun stuff
like salt mix, and activated carbon. Good luck. Regards, Scott F.>
Cooling Options Hello Experts, <Hi! Ryan Bowen with you
today> I currently have a 30 gallon very healthy aquarium. <Great>
Unfortunately, I reside in an apartment which does not provide air
conditioning. The room where the tank is located will get into the 80's
and even low 90's on a warm day. The complex will not allow us to alter
the property for the convenience of cooling ourselves....or the fish
aquarium. I currently run a consistent 76 degrees, but the temp slowly
creeps to around the 80 degree mark and my understanding is that 82 is
lethal. This is too close for my liking and surely the fish are a bit
uncomfortable also. <Surely> I have priced coolers, which I did
not know existed, and they are just too expensive to justify. I almost
feel caught between a rock and hard place because I do not want 8 months
of babysitting this tank to its present state to go for not and lose the
battle to the heat. I need cost effective solution (if there is one) or
any suggestion which may help prior to the upcoming summer heat. The
tank takes no direct light and carries perfect chemical water
composition. Its just the front of our building takes direct sun and
heats the room where the tank is. Can you advise or recommend a
solution.....I care too much for the livestock and want to give the
needed attention, but need advise from someone who knows. <There are
lots of options here- But none of them better than a chiller. Ice probe
chillers are small, compact chillers that run about a hundred bucks a
probe. Each probe does 20 gallons. Two of these, and a controller
would be ideal, but if not, there are still more options. Have you
looked into a swamp cooler for the room? They sit in your window, and
would cool the whole room. They do need a hookup to water,
however. For the tank, another simple thing that you can do is to
fashion a clip on fan blowing horizontally across the surface of the
water. This helps to increase the exchange at the surface of the
water. If you know it's an especially hot day, you can float a frozen
water bottle in the tank. If you tank needs daily water-top-off, simply
leave the top off the bottle, and it will slowly supply the aquarium
with water. Leave the lights off, and that's about it. Hope this
helps, Ryan> Thanks, Eddie Evaporative cooling of a
sump Hi crew, thanks for all the great advice.. this may be a
question in thermodynamics, but I bought a cheap fan from Home Depot
which I have blowing directly down on my sump's water surface, and it
has brought the temp of the tank down from 87 degrees to 84 degrees in
a matter of a few hours. My question is, If I keep the fan on, will it
continue to lower the tank temperature even more through evaporative
cooling, even though the ambient room temperature is around 83
degrees,<< I would say no. I don't see (and it has been a couple years
since I've had a thermodynamic class) how it can cool the water below
ambient room temperature. The energy from the water has to go
somewhere? >> or is it impossible to lower the water temp below that of
the room temperature << I think even if it is possible, it would be very
difficult. >> without the use of more expensive means... (it's a FOWLR
tank, and no one seems affected by the high temps, though I know the
inhabitants can't be comfortable)<< Obviously if you can, cooling the
room temp by 10 degrees would make a big difference. That is what I
would try to do. >> Thanks -Blair << Adam Blundell >>
Keeping coldwater marines I am cycling a 55 gallon aquarium for
local California coast marine inverts. I am adding a chiller to
keep the aquarium below 60. I am an avid scuba diver and will have no
problem collecting what I want. I have researched the laws and am
wondering if the is and source of info for my cold water reef tank.
<Mmm, yes... the works by Dan Gotshall and Dave Wrobel should be in your
use. Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/cold.htm and the Related FAQs
(linked, in blue, above)> Last weekend my daughter and I collect
live sand and ocean water from south of Point Lobos. In a month or so I
will be ready to add animals. Can I add live ocean rocks with anemones
and corals? Thx Mike <Mmm, not to be disingenuous, but
yes, if they're compatible... Bob Fenner>
Lights getting
water warm Sorry, I just wrote 5 minutes ago. I forgot one more
thing. The new fluorescent lights are making my water temp go up to
about 82...how do I keep it down? Thanks, last time I'll bug
you...I promise! <Most of these fixtures come with a cooling fan
built in, and even at that, if they are in an enclosed canopy without
sufficient air inlet/outlet, water temps will elevate. If the fixture is
just sitting on a glass top with nothing over it then I would take it
back to the dealer and have him order you one with an enclosed fan such
as Orbit or Current fixtures. James (Salty Dog)> -A Real
Chiller of A Question- Thanks for the reply <Certainly> I
will still be purchasing 400 watt halides (the cost difference isn't a
lot and I have more wattage to play with ). <Ok but please take extra
time acclimating the corals and put all the lower light corals under
overhangs or shady areas as they will bleach out possibly with such high
lighting.> I will be buying a large room fan to get rid of the excess
heat. I am also investigating making a DIY chiller as you suggest but
not using an old fridge unit (far big a risk of water contamination re
parts etc). <Hmm not really simply drill into the side of a fridge
and run the tubing closed through a container with water in it then back
out the side or the other side then to the sump. no contamination and
far cheaper if you have one around. you can even keep drinks etc in it.>
I will be looking at a tray of cool freshwater (regularly changed during
top off) with blocked heat conductive piping of some sort into running
through and back into the sump (simple effective and very very cheap).
Here in the UK we only occasionally get big heat waves, so I am hoping
the single large fan across the water surface will suffice for the short
term. <Very possible, though those MH lights can really put out the
heat. Do keep an eye on temperatures at first when the lights are moving
to their final place and then when they are in final position to avoid
any costly deaths and or losses of corals and fish.> Thanks for the
info Jim <Hope this helps> <Justin (Jager)> Do I need a
chiller? Hello WWM Crew, <Hello Anthony, James here> Thanks
for answering my question 2 weeks ago about my first SW fish (True
Percula). He had a white spot - looked more like a small white-head
pimple than ich - I've had my share of ich with fresh water
tetras. Anyway, it went away after I dipped her in Methylene Blue for
30 min.s or it could be the skunk cleaner shrimp that did the
job. Should I have dipped her or not???? <I'm sure the dip helped more
than the cleaner shrimp.> Back to my question about chillers, I
have two 60 gal tanks in separate rooms which I plan to stock with at
least 60 lbs of LR each. For now both would be fish only
setups. Anyway, I live in a part of Southern California where we only
have at most 6 - 8 weeks of about 90 degree temps. Most of the chillers
I've seen are for much bigger tanks. Anyway, I mail ordered a Titan
Thermoelectric 150-W Chiller ($250) that says it's good for 40 gals (I'm
assuming they're referring to a reef setup). <No, they are just
referring to 40 gallons of water in general.> Is this sufficient? <Most
chillers come with charts that show how low it will cool versus ambient
room temperature. If you don't have such a chart, contact the
manufacturer and ask. Do I really need chillers or can I just set both
tanks' heater to 78 and the apartment air conditioner to 80 degrees
during the hottest part of our summer? Assuming that the small chiller
can cool down the tank by 4 degrees, I would still need 2 of them
(another one for the other 60 gal tank - minimum $500 investment). I'm
also sure that with the air off, the temp could reach as high as 88
degrees in my apartment unit. So I would still need to keep the air on
or buy bigger chillers which would run me close to $900 for 2. Don't
you think it would be more economical to just keep the air on for 6 - 8
weeks of the year? <A boxer fan flowing across the water will help lower
the tank temp also. Myself, I would rather keep my A/C on than buy a
chiller. Chillers work like air conditioners. At some time it will
require a recharging of the coolant which can be expensive since Freon
is no longer used. James (Salty Dog)> Again thanks in advance,
Anthony Heat in new tank, too high tech.? 7/14/05 Hi
reef folks. <Howdy> I have some questions regarding heat
transfer in my newly set up reef (no sand or living creatures yet). The
tank; 180 gal. with 70gal. sump and 40 gal. refugium. Main return pump
is Ampmaster 2100 that feeds a manifold above the perimeter of the tank
with six T's. The second pump is a Super Ampmaster 4500(3600gal/h)
running a closed loop manifold on the back wall of the tank. The third
pump an Iwaki 40 hooked up to the sump goes into the refugium. I was
running the 2100 and the 4500 for over 24 hours and was not running any
skimmer(2), reactor nor the lights. I was confused to see that the water
seemed quite warm. I put digital heater in the tank to check the
temperature. I was 78. Now, can a these pumps be the cause of this heat?
<Oh yes> Does friction in the pipes induce this heat?
<Minimally> My ambient temp was 66 and goes no more than 70 because
I live in the fog belt of Daly City Ca. I realized that I am going to
need a chiller that can handle 300 gal. combined tanks. <Maybe... I
would first look into using cooling fans> Which chiller brand, size
and lowest power consumption would you recommend? <Mmm, can we step
back a bit first here? What is the rationale of using two good-sized
pumps for two separate manifolds? You might want to look into just one,
larger, cooler pump... my pick? A Sequence model...> What are the
pros and cons with an In line versus coil type? <Coil types are more
gimmicks than real... and ugly to look at to boot> On a different
subject. My sump has quite a bit of flow coming thru and I would like to
make it a refugium of some sorts. What would be the ideal medium or
animals? <This is posted on WWM> I was thinking an NNR at best,
live rocks O.K?. <Could... a DSB w/o rock would be better here>
And finally, What is your take on motorized union ball valve (they are
all plastic)? Are they reliable and can they be connected to a my
Octopus controller? <... Not a good idea... too much likelihood of
failure... "More biology, less technology" needed here... study for now.
Bob Fenner> Cooling a 24gal Nano Cube 9/11/05 Hey
There… I currently work at Pure Ocean Aquatics in Littleton, Colorado
during school. I decided to go ahead and get a 24gal Nano Cube (small,
but fits in my room). I plan to make it into a reef tank… but I have a
huge problem. My room is over a garage in a house that isn’t air
conditioned. My water temperature is reading at 86-88 degrees
Fahrenheit. <Yikes...> So far, I’ve been keeping the lid open,
and that helps a little (3-5 degrees), but then I can’t have a light on
the water (big problem if I want a reef tank). <I'd put the unit on
a timer... run the lighting at night, not day> All I have in there
so far is sand and cured live rock, so no big hurry. I want to know if
a “Cool Works IceProbe Micro 50W Chiller” is a decent product, <Some
folks state so> and if I have any other options. Also, I need to
know how hard it is to set up, and if I should even bother drilling into
the glass if I were to get an internal chiller, and so on. I got a tank
knowing water care, and fish, but I underestimated the temperature
problem. Sincerely, Ben <Mmm, if you use a chiller for this
tank, best to hang the plumbing lines over the side... Try changing the
light cycle for a few weeks, and monitor the temperature... cooler
weather is coming. Bob Fenner>
Chillers 12/15/05
Hi I have a question about my 250 gallon marine {fish only} aquarium.
it's stocked with a Queen angel, lion fish, Foxface, yellow tang,
emperor angel and yes the two angels get along just fine lucky. The tank
has been running for 4 yr.s with no problems. Now it's a sealed acrylic
tank with a canopy top.. So no water evaporation.. And the sump is also
sealed with a cover. Now I have one large pump outside in a shed running
the hole system. I have two 40 aqua UV sterilizers. And a good skimmer..
The temperature in the shed is about 50 f degrees in the winter.. Very
well vented.. now finally my question. Why do I have to use a chiller
all year long. The temp in the tank just climbs when I shut it off I
never let it go all the way up I got scared. I live in New York and now
its 15 f degrees outside and the chillers is on ... Also I use regular
lighting and only when I view the aquarium maybe 6 hrs a day... Any
suggestions on how I could shut the chiller off and save some money.
Also how high can the temp in the tank go without harm. I also now
maintain a temp of 80 f degrees with a 2 degree diff... Thank you so
much I love your website... Jimmy --jamgabby <... you need to
look for other sources of heat introduction... likely pump/s... possibly
powerheads, and look for less energy wasting/producing models/makes...
Bob Fenner> Lighting raising tank temperatures
3/4/06 Also, my Compact lighting 4X 96watt set right on the
glass. Would it help to get some legs to raise it about three inches
above the glass? <Yes> Will small fans help with the lights either
right on the glass or raised above it about three inches? <Best to blow
under the lights.> Bob, <James today> I have my heater set to
78F on my reef tank but my tank stays very consistently between 79.5F
and 81.5F. Is this (81.5F) a problem? <The temperature swings are more
of a problem, but in your case a 2 degree swing isn't too bad. I'd try
to cool those lights down or adjust your heater to 80 degrees to
minimize the temperature swing.> Room temp stays between 67F and
72F. 135ga. tank Compact lighting 4X 96watt and 2X 30Watt
18Watt UV Wet/ Dry pump (2) power heads Thanks, <You're
welcome. James (Salty Dog)> Kent
Night Time lights ?
6/26/06 greetings, hope that all is good. the website is amazing
to say the least, I spend a lot of my "spare" time at work just reading
and learning, thank you for the wonderful resource! So on to the
fun....... its summer here in sunny San Diego, <Oh! I live here as
well> and my SW reef is starting to get to that dangerous temp
level......got up to 82.9 today before I realized and tuned on the air
conditioner....here's my question, I have read a few times on the
website that running the lights at night when its cooler can keep the
temp in check <Can definitely help, yes> (I am running fans),
but I have a fairly bright room during the day. The tank doesn't get
direct sunlight per se, but normal daylight. Will my fish take on their
normal "night time" activities, sleep etc. with a day light room, and
hood lights off? <Mmm, not so much no... better to use timers,
dimmers even if moving the light cycle further into the night>
.....or do I need to cover the tank during the day to keep it dark in
the tank ? <I would not do this last> second....if I do switch
the system to lights on at night, do I need to slowly phase the lights a
few hours each day/week..... or just suddenly make the switch? <Best
to move gradually> Thank you in advance for your advice, and once
again thank you for the service to the hobby. <Welcome. Bob Fenner,
in Mira Mesa... aka "East" La Jolla...> -
Do you think I will need a chiller? 6/16/06 - Hello WetWebMedia
Crew, <Hello.> Thank you for taking the time to look at my
e-mail. I am planning on upgrading the lighting on my 75 gallon reef
tank (48" x 18" x 21"). The reef tank also has a downstream refugium
that holds roughly 15 gallons. At the moment, I have a 260 watt Odyssea
power compact fixture on the display and a 130 watt Odyssea power
compact fixture on the refuge. I also have a heaters in both the
display and the refuge that were bought to match their respective sizes,
but I cannot remember their exact wattage. I realize the heater in the
refuge is unnecessary but I was having flow problems and have yet to
take it out... I also have an Eheim 1260 (634gph, 65watts) pump for
circulation in the display and an Eheim 1250 (320gph, 28watts) pump
running the refugium and display. A mag drive 3 (350gph, 35watts) pump
runs my Remora Pro protein skimmer. I found a 48" Maristar fixture
by sunlight supply that has 2 150 watt HQI bulbs and 2 54 watt T5
bulbs. This light was discontinued but they still make it custom
ordered. The temperature in my reef is about 77 degrees with the room
temperature being 72 degrees. Based on your experience with similar
setups, do you guys think I will need a chiller. Any advice you can
give me is appreciated. <Hard to say for certain as even two identical
set-ups really aren't identical once they go to someone's home. It
really depends on the temperature you want to keep the tank. Without a
doubt, it's not going to stay at 77 F, but it may only go up to 79/80 F
- is that ok with you? Can you be certain it won't go higher? If you
want to improve your margin for error, you may want that chiller
anyway.> Thanks, Tim <Cheers, J -- >
Trying to Keep Cool!! 8/2/06 Hi Crew !!! <Hi
Janice, Leslie in for the crew this warm and muggy afternoon.> Just
a quick question.<Sure> I wanted to know what is the best way to keep my
90 gal salt water tank cool on these really hot days? We have a fan
going and an air conditioner. The temp. is about 88. <I am not sure
what temp is 88…. Inside, outside or your tank. I am assuming you mean
your tank, but hoping not. No matter….. other than a chiller there are a
few little tricks I use. If you can get hold of 2 to 4 clip on electric
fans, you may be able to get your tank down 2 to 4 degrees. They work
pretty well. Clip them on the rim of the tank so the air blows across
the water surface. If you can adjust them so they cause the surface of
the water to ripple a bit even better. This will increase evaporation
and require more frequent top offs. You can also fill a few empty 2
liter soda or water bottles (the type with plastic caps) with
dechlorinated tap water, freeze them and place in the tank one at a
time. Rotate them as they melt. Decreasing the photoperiod if possible
depending on your inhabitants is also an option.> Things just don't
look so good. <Yes I know this heat wave is a bad one.> I really
appreciate the help. Thanks Janice <Best of luck keeping cool. Your
most welcome, Leslie> Another Idea for Cooling Your Tank in the
Summer - 07/22/06 First, please accept my admiration and thanks
for the time and effort you all put into this site for the benefit of
all aquarists and our charges. <<Thank you...gratifying to hear>>
It's July in Georgia and it's hot, very hot! <<Indeed!>> I have
a 120 gallon reef tank in my den since January 1, 2006. Temperature was
not a problem in the winter or spring, however, even without a heater,
to my horror, the temperature crept up to 86 degrees. I was afraid I'd
have 120 gallons of fish soup. A chiller for this tank was not feasible
financially for me right now so I bought a window air conditioner unit
for the room. <<Mmm, yes...and likely at a quarter the cost of a
chiller>> The directions tell you how many BTUs it should be for the
size of the room, directional facing and number of people who usually
inhabit the room. We added 4 extra people to account for the tank and
to determine the adequate size to purchase. <<Wise/intuitive of
you>> It took 4 days, but the temperature of the tank has lowered to
an acceptable 78.5 degrees and has been consistent for the 3 weeks it's
been running. <<Outstanding!>> That $159.00 has been the best
investment I've made and much more affordable for me at this point than
a chiller. <<Agreed...and I'll bet the room is more comfortable to
the "human" inhabitants too! This may be a more viable solution to
high temperature readings and easier on the wallet for other people as
well. <<Likely so...though as I'm sure you are aware...this solution
too may not be feasible for everyone>> I realize this may not work
for huge hundreds of gallon tanks but I hope this information will be of
benefit to those with somewhat smaller tanks. <<Ah, yes...another
avenue to investigate at the least...and maybe even for "huge" tanks,
where the sumps/ancillary systems are congregated in a small dedicated
room where the ambient temperature could be easily lowered with a small
air-conditioner...similar to what goes on in a computer server room>>
Susan in "hot'lanta" <<EricR, just northward in steamy Columbia>>
Tank Temp 8/23/06 Hi Crew, <Hey there>
Thanks for the great site. I have a rather unusual problem in that my
20g aquarium maintains an 86 degree temperature without the heater being
plugged into an outlet. I have 2 percula clowns and yellow and domino
damsel that I am afraid of losing if the problem persists.
<I've had the same problem in my smaller tanks too. Its something you
really have to be careful of in the smaller system tanks. The lighting
required to keep corals really heats things up.>
Tank specifications: water
quality tests well 25lbs of live rock
100 SeaClone skimmer 150 penguin filter
power head regular lighting that came with the
tank (one fluorescent bulb) This has just become a problem after I
installed my SeaClone skimmer and I was curious if there was to much
going on in the tank. Should I invest in a chiller? Thank you for any
help that you can provide. <I don't really see how your skimmer is
all of a sudden causing this problem. Its more than likely the
lingering heat across the country. To tell you the truth unless you
have the few hundred lying around dying to be spent I wouldn't buy a
chiller for that size tank. I would invest in some venting fans -
install some under the hood. (Actually, if you ever want to get corals
or any light loving inverts - you should also invest in more lighting,
which could possibly come with some fans.) Also, you can add a refugium
- extra water volume will not only help you with you temp problem but
will make water quality MUCH easier to keep up. Do some searching on
WWM re: heat issues. Good luck! Jen S.>
Regards, John Coral greenhouse
in the tropics? - 09/14/06 Dear Bob and WWM crew,
<Alan> I am thinking of setting up a coral greenhouse in my region
(south east Asia) to propagate corals. I was thinking of having like 18
of 6ft X 2/3ft fiberglass tubs as holding tanks. I skimmed through the
articles in your site about coral propagation. My concern regarding
using natural sunlight would be the high temps as its hot all year round
in my country and in a green house its certainly not gonna fall within
acceptable range. And using chillers to chill all the tanks wouldn't be
economical in the long run either. Is there anyway I can solve the heat
problem through the design of the green house? Any input is appreciated.
Thanks. <Mmm... I would look into lowest expense, most appropriate
technology for cooling the system water (likely storing a good
deal/percentage of volume underground, evaporative cooling... or pumping
it from the sea...) along with passive air-circulating methods to keep
all "about right" here. Bob Fenner>
Tank cooling prob.s
9/29/06 Late summer I attempted my first marine tank setup. Good
idea, but bad move due to the results I received as far as temperature
is concerned. Ambient air temperature inside my house where I live
during summer exceed 30 degrees centigrade for periods exceeding a week.
This caused my tank to absorb this heat and reach a temperature that
averaged out to about 32 degrees centigrade. I have a main display
tank (300 litres) connected to a refugium (100 litres) and a wet/dry
sump (50 litres). Without lights running and with lids off all tanks and
just one external pump, I reached the 32 degree centigrade minimum water
temp I get during summer. (90 F. thereabouts... too warm> I
tried directing fans onto the water surface to employ latent heat
removal. This was not a practical result as I dropped my water temp only
by half a degree and ended up with high evaporation rates and heaps of
salt spray and creep. Humidity during summer is quite high (average 75+
percent) where I live and latent heat removal did not employ good
results. I researched direct water cooling methods such as
refrigeration, ice cubes and cold water replacement. I am basically a
lazy bum which left the refrigeration of my tank water as the only
solution to my problem. I am not rich either...I made my tank stand and
hood from wood I got from the local rubbish dump ( I also get my pumps
from there). I purchased my two metal halides -complete- for 16 Ozzy
dollars each from the local recycler shop: might I add here that the
cheapest LFS up here wants 270 Ozzy bucks just for one and the local
electrical supplier is much the same. I even get my fish and live rock
LEGALLY from the ocean, as I live in the tropics next to the Great
Barrier Reef. Water heating during winter should I need it, is done by
throwing black irrigation piping on my house roof during the day and
running a by-pass from my tank pump to a solenoid and temperature sensor
etc that is attached to this black irrigation tubing to save power on
heating water both in my tank and in weekly water changes...my solenoids
etc are run by solar power, solar panels I got from solar powered garden
lights from the dump. <Mmm, you could do something like this for
cooling... by drilling too holes in the house esky/fridge to yanks, and
running a length of tubing, immerging it in a water bath in the
fridge... for heat exchange> Back to cooling by refrigeration, I
used a bar fridge (purchased from local dump) that was gutted and had
the cooling element sitting in my sump. I was able to drop the water
temperature of 450 litres by three degrees to sit on 29 degrees
centigrade. I actually would like to reach 27 degrees centigrade as the
ocean water I get my fish from etc is at that temp. My little critters
such as crabs and teeny weenie anemones were all happy at this
temperature until they get cooked after a few days. (when I go to the
ocean to get live stuff, I get sea water and flush my tank with it). Now
the problem I had, was that the fridge was running all the time and a
large pedestal fan was needed to help cool the element and stop the
condenser from overheating. <Too much electrical consumption,
expense here... Use the more efficient house unit if it can be
practically located near by> Not good for my power bill and
standards for doing things on the cheap. <Bingo> Now I have a
question ... would gutting a freezer this time round - instead of a bar
fridge- be able to cool 450 litres of water by 4 degrees centigrade?
<Yes... as would a simple fridge with the coils set in a water bath
there...> Assume that the air temp is sitting constantly at 32
degrees centigrade and there exist no other heat inputs. Would my
freezer motor thingy be running non-stop? <Might work pretty much
full time during the heat of the day, yes> Would you be able to
point me to some really verbose links regarding cooling water by
refrigeration...maybe I missed some you know about. <I understand
you perfectly. I'd go the fridge, holes, bath-coil route m'self. Cheers,
BobF> Temperature Control Bob I might
have a problem. I have set this tank up and I have been letting it run
for a couple of days. I am getting ready to put the rock in tonight. I
checked the temp in the old tank that I am letting the live rock sit in
until I have the big tank ready and the temp read 84 degrees. I checked
the big tank and it is running 82 without any lights on it. Am I going
to need a chiller and if so what would you recommend for a 46 gal.
<Maybe... but first read through the "Chiller FAQs" posted on our
website: www.WetWebMedia.com> If at all possible I do not want to
spend a ton of money on it. Thank You for your help and if it is not a
problem I am sure I will be talking to you again. <It may well be
that you can use "other technologies", approaches in keeping your
systems water about right temp. wise. Read the section and we'll chat.
Bob Fenner> Jason Questions about Reef Lighting and Chillers
hello Mr. Fenner, <<JasonC here, one of Bob's "associates">> I am
brand new to the hobby of reef keeping and trying to educate myself. I
know you are diving right now, but I hope one of your associates could
answer my question. I have a 58 gal. tank with one power compact strip
on it with two 96 watt bulbs-one blue and one white. I have been told by
my local coral store owner that it is a little underpowered. I do have
leathers, mushroom, and polyps in the tank now , but I only started this
one week ago. What is the ideal lighting guidelines for power compacts?
<<should be fine for your tank, sounds like perhaps that store is trying
to shake some more money out of your pockets. As far as guidelines for
power-compacts... well, it's really amount of light applied to the tank,
not the type of bulb one uses - this is the nut to crack. Do give the
following link and subsequent FAQs a read-through:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/lighting.htm >> Secondly, my tank runs
about 80-82 degrees, I was also told to start saving for a chiller, what
are the parameter to know you need a chiller? <<parameters for a
chiller? Live in the desert, already bought all the spare pumps you
need, aching for something to spend your money on. Chillers are
expensive and really should be saved for a problem you can't solve any
other way - like with a simple fan blowing across the top of the tank.
Here's another link:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/chillersmar.htm >> grabmayer
<<Cheers, J -->> Chiller, lighting, and sea urchin question!
<<Greetings, Kevin, JasonC here... >> My tank is about 80-82 degrees
and I was thinking I need to get a chiller or maybe some cooler lights
cooler lighting unit). <<80-82 isn't really out of hand compared to
conditions in the wild.>> I have a 150g tank with 2 fluorescent hoods
and they don't have any ventilation. Can I get a good light that has
ventilation? <<Why not do a retro-fit and add some ventilation, fans,
etc?>> I was looking at the power compact lights, any ideas on those
kind or any other kinds of lights, I need something soon! <<All lamps
produce heat, it cannot be avoided.>> Is a chiller necessary to reduce
my tank temperature just a couple degrees, they're very expensive, but
in case I do get one, do you recommend one? <<I don't generally
recommend chillers unless you live in a desert or are attempting to do a
low-temp system; something less than 75F. Usually a one or two degree
pull-down can be easily accomplished with one or more fans blowing over
the surface of the tank to produce evaporative cooling, or placed in the
light hood to evacuate the warm air.>> I liked the idea of the coil that
sat in the sump! <<Honestly, those are a very poor design and not worth
the money.>> And lastly, I have a sea urchin that I've had for a couple
years and he's losing his spines. I've heard that when this happens it
means they are going to die and they should be removed from the tank.
<<certainly a sign of declining health.>> He only has the bottom half of
him that have the spines! What should I do? <<Perhaps crush it and feed
it to the fish if you have triggers or wrasses, or just toss it out.>>
Thanks for all your helpful advice you always give me, you're the best!
-Kevin <<Cheers, J -- >> Heat/Chiller Hi Guys
<<Hi.>> Once again I seek your advice. I have written earlier about
the temperature problems in my 110 gallon fish only system. I am running
an Iwaki external pump and two power heads in the sump (one for the
Euro-reef skimmer and the other for the U.V.) My problem remains in that
my water temps are going up to 83* this after following your advice to
replace the glass canopy with egg crate, putting an exhaust fan in the
hood and running a clip on fan aimed at the sump. I keep the house
between 75-79* but cannot keep the water temperature down. I even
unplugged the heater "just in case." <<Well, I can relate my own
experience... I had a 54g corner tank with a 150w metal halide, in my
bedroom on the second floor of my house. I live in a valley and in the
Summer, we often get temperature inversions in conjunction with the smog
blowing up from New York city and this creates stifling, hot and humid
days. That tank could easily get to 88-90 degrees in the dead of summer.
I tried fans all over the place but could never get the heat down... the
problem, I wasn't actually getting rid of the heat, I was just moving it
around as hot air. My solution was to run a window air conditioner.>>
I think that the only real solution appears to be a chiller. (please
correct me if I'm wrong) I do not have the room inside of the stand so I
will have to place the chiller next to the stand. Since this is in the
living room I don't think that I want to use the inline models
(appearance plus potential of water leaks). What's your feelings on the
Aqualogic and or CSL drop in models? If I go this route, is the Medusa
controller worth the upcharge over the Aqualogic. <<Well... keep in mind
the previous little ditty, if the unit sits in a hot living room, all
the while creating heat, you may find it running more than you'd expect.
That being said, drop-in units are less efficient that their
flow-through cousins... but they do work. If it were my money, I'd
forego the 'looks' in the living room - this is only for the summer,
yes? - and do a flow through unit with a dedicated pump you can place in
the sump. The electronic thermostats are more precise, but obviously
adds to the cost. Your call on that.>> I await your counsel as you
have been dead on in your suggestions on other products that I have
purchased. Thanks once again, Joe <<Cheers, J -- >>
Temperate Starfish... is it warm in here? Hi Bob, 11 days ago
I found a star fish at Myrtle Beach. <I am very sorry to hear
it...seriously> It traveled home and I have setup a tank for her. She
seems to be doing fine. I would like to know what she is and how to take
care of her. She's gray on top with teeth like spines all round her
arms. They are reddish at the base and white on the tips. She is peach
and orange underneath. I also brought sand and shells from her beach to
setup my tank with. She likes to bury herself under the sand. This
morning I found her completely on the glass, which to me is a social
improvement. Please help me if you can, or at least point me in the
right direction. Thank you so much, Tammy Shilling <my friend...
this is a temperate species that will suffer and die in time if not
provided with chilled water. Even room temperature is too warm for year
around maintenance. And a tank without a heater will allow temperature
fluctuations that are even more stressful between night and day. I'm
sorry to be a buzz kill, but such animals belong in the ocean if they
cannot be provided for adequately in captivity. Temperate species need
refrigeration units (chillers) that cost nearly $1000 for hobbyists
models. Without it, your starfish will hang in there for some months
perhaps. Over a year in rare cases. My advice is to find a local public
aquarium that will take it in assuming they have temperate species
displays. Best regards, Anthony> More on summer cooling -
3/25/03 The only problem with your suggestion is that I don't
have any need to use heaters in the summer where I live. <Oh. Whoops!
Okay, then I would not worry about it. If it gets higher than 82 degrees
then I would blow fans over the surface of the water or even tank in
general> The heaters are set on 77 degrees now but they never come on
due to the fact that the water temp is always steady at 80 - 81.5
degrees. <Got it.> The house temp stays at about 72 degrees even!
<Nice> I guess the temp is that high due to our VHO lighting, MAG 12
pump, etc.????? <My thoughts exactly. Direct a fan or two on the tank
just to circulate the cooler ambient house temp around the tank and also
move the heat from the VHO hood. Hopefully that will help. Check this
out as well if you haven't already:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/heatingf.htm Thanks again for your
patience and help. <My pleasure, Elizabeth. Paulo> Elizabeth
Cooling Hi Crew, I don't have a question today, more of an
opinion which I would like your comments on. I have read in a lot of
places about chillers not being necessary and than fans will do the job
of cooling. <Within "reason", many circumstances, yes> Here is
my setup and situation. I have a 90G acrylic reef tank that will house
mostly SPS corals and some clams. I am using two 250W 10,000K bulbs. I
went with these over the 175W because I didn't want to be limited to the
top half of the tank for things like clams. The canopy has about 12
inches of height in it, the lights are about 10 inches from the water
surface. I have one 4 inch fan blowing over the right side of the tank
and another fan on the opposite side drawing out the air. The back of
the canopy is open. I have a 30G sump below. Since I need a lot of
flow, I started out with 2 Iwaki MD40RLXT's, one for the sump return,
the other for closed loop circulation. They turned out to be too loud
for a living room setting, so I replaced the sump return Iwaki with a
Velocity T4, kept the other Iwaki for the closed loop. I would be
willing to bet that the Velocity is one of the quietest pumps out
there. It makes my wife very happy! Problem is that it produces A LOT
of heat. I also have a Rio 2100 pump in the sump running my Aqua C
EV-120, another pretty big heat producer. I have two 3/4 Sea Swirls at
the ends of the sump return lines which I imagine produce some heat as
well. Beyond this, all else is pretty standard. No excessive 90 degree
elbows, etc. Our house has central air, thermostat set to 80
degrees. With fans blowing over the top of the tank, cover off of the
sump, ambient room temperature of 78 degrees, the tank temperature is at
86 degrees. I suppose I could run two more fans in the canopy, but the
amount of evaporation would not be worth it. I don't have any sort of
auto top off device, too difficult where it is located. It would
probably have a detrimental effect on my specific gravity. Plus, since
it is a standard acrylic tank, the openings on the top are not very big,
so blowing the fans across the top helps cool it down, but in turn,
covers the top with salt. Then my lights become less effective, to much
crud on the top of the tank. I can run a fan over the sump, but I don't
think this well help too much, plus back to having too much water
evaporating. <Worth trying though> The rear of the stand is
completely open, so it doesn't get warm in there at all. I can blow a
fan over the Velocity pump, I have read that somewhere, but I don't
believe it will help that much. The room temp is 78, still have another
couple of degrees to go before the AC kicks in. So in my case, I didn't
see any other solution than using a chiller. Now I don't have any
worries about the salinity level changing drastically. I put covers
over the tank top openings so the canopy fans remove the heat from the
lights, but doesn't get salt all over the place. The JBJ Arctica
chiller is pretty quiet and only runs about 15 minutes every few hours,
so it is not too bad. But without the chiller, I don't think the tank
would ever drop below 84 degrees which is still a bit high. What are
your opinions? Hope you are having a good Memorial Weekend Paul
<Thank you. I do think your system is a good candidate for a chiller.
The mid-eighties can be a dangerous place if "something goes wrong". I
also encourage you to look into a top-off device... some simple "float
valves" can be attached to the sump wall and serviced by pressurized
water from a distal location. Bob Fenner> Chillers Hi
Crew,<IanB here tonight> I don't have a question today, more of an
opinion which I would like your comments on. I have read in a lot of
places about chillers not being necessary and than fans will do the job
of cooling. Here is my setup and situation. I have a 90G acrylic reef
tank that will house mostly SPS corals and some clams. I am using two
250W 10,000K bulbs. I went with these over the 175W because I didn't
want to be limited to the top half of the tank for things like
clams. The canopy has about 12 inches of height in it, the lights are
about 10 inches from the water surface. I have one 4 inch fan blowing
over the right side of the tank and another fan on the opposite side
drawing out the air. The back of the canopy is open. I have a 30G sump
below. Since I need a lot of flow, I started out with 2 Iwaki
MD40RLXT's, one for the sump return, the other for closed loop
circulation. They turned out to be too loud for a living room setting,
so I replaced the sump return Iwaki with a Velocity T4, kept the other
Iwaki for the closed loop. I would be willing to bet that the Velocity
is one of the quietest pumps out there.<very quiet indeed> It makes my
wife very happy! Problem is that it produces A LOT of heat.<for
everything good there is always a drawback> I also have a Rio 2100 pump
in the sump running my Aqua C EV-120, another pretty big heat producer.
<yea> I have two 3/4 Sea Swirls at the ends of the sump return lines
which I imagine produce some heat as well.<to some extent> Beyond this,
all else is pretty standard. No excessive 90 degree elbows,<good>
etc. Our house has central air, thermostat set to 80 degrees. With
fans blowing over the top of the tank, cover off of the sump, ambient
room temperature of 78 degrees, the tank temperature is at 86
degrees. I suppose I could run two more fans in the canopy, but the
amount of evaporation would not be worth it. I don't have any sort of
auto top off device, too difficult where it is located. It would
probably have a detrimental effect on my specific gravity. Plus, since
it is a standard acrylic tank, the openings on the top are not very big,
so blowing the fans across the top helps cool it down, but in turn,
covers the top with salt.<that can be a problem> Then my lights become
less effective, to much crud on the top of the tank. I can run a fan
over the sump, but I don't think this well help too much, plus back to
having too much water evaporating. The rear of the stand is completely
open, so it doesn't get warm in there at all. I can blow a fan over the
Velocity pump, I have read that somewhere, but I don't believe it will
help that much.<don't think so either> The room temp is 78, still have
another couple of degrees to go before the AC kicks in. So in my case,
I didn't see any other solution than using a chiller. Now I don't have
any worries about the salinity level changing drastically. I put covers
over the tank top openings so the canopy fans remove the heat from the
lights, but doesn't get salt all over the place. The JBJ Arctica
chiller is pretty quiet and only runs about 15 minutes every few hours,
so it is not too bad. But without the chiller, I don't think the tank
would ever drop below 84 degrees which is still a bit high. What are
your opinions? <I too doubt the temperature in the aquarium will drop
below 84 degrees (and you need a temperature around 78-80 degrees), I
would purchase the chiller (better safe than sorry). I am enclosing a
link that might help you http://www.wetwebmedia.com/chillersmar.htm good
luck with the chiller, and aquarium, IanB> Hope you are having a good
Memorial Weekend, Paul - Chiller Selection - Hello to
all the fine folks at the CREW. <Hello to you, JasonC here...> I
searched the archives buy I couldn't find an answer to my question about
chillers. I have the opportunity to buy a brand new 1/4 hp Via Aqua
flow thru chiller on an online forum for a ridiculously low price and I
am curious if any of you are familiar with the Via Aqua brand of
chillers? <I am familiar but have never used one.> I have a total system
volume of 240 gallons in my two reef tanks combined. I don't
particularly need a chiller at the moment because I have central A/C but
in case I do need to have a chiller I thought maybe I should buy one of
these chillers just in case. <If you don't "need" one, I wouldn't spend
the money - often times you can do an effective amount of cooling by
running a fan over the surface of the water, either in the sump or the
tank - is evaporative cooling and works quite well.> Do any of you folks
think these are good chillers and would one of this size/type be able to
bring my system temp down a few degrees if I needed to use one in a
pinch at some point in the future? <Again, for only a few degrees... I'd
use a fan. If you wanted a cool marine system, that would be a different
story, or if your house didn't have air conditioning...> Are they
reliable and trustworthy? <More importantly... what kind of condition is
it in, being used and all... I wouldn't buy a used chiller.> All the
other brands are ridiculously expensive and I can get this one $300-$400
cheaper than anywhere else and it's brand new. <Hmm... if it's not used,
then perhaps a good value, but I'm still in favor of fans unless you
have heating problems you can't get around any other way.> Any thoughts
on this? <Well... I am always suspect of deals that are too god to be
true, and the Via Aqua chillers are priced below much of their
competition. Do keep in mind that more often than not, you get what you
pay for.> All input is gratefully appreciated. Thanks again, Jeff
<Cheers, J -- > Temperature control I'm having a
problem keeping my 55 gallon tank cool. Its summertime and I don't have
central a/c in my house. Currently I'm putting one liter bottles filled
with water and letting them freeze then putting them in my tank to bring
the water temperature down. But it goes right back up to 80* in no
time. Do you have suggestions on trying to keep the water cool are there
any good water chillers out there?? Would you recommend having a
chiller? I also have a fan blowing on the tank but it runs all day I'd
rather have a chiller and let that run than the fan all day. Thank you
again for your time. <Hi Scott, Don here today. You don't say what
type/size of tank this is, so the following assumes were are discussing
a marine setup. Actually, 80F is not that bad of temp. If you can keep
it around this, I think you are OK. If you look into a chiller, look
into the type that uses a pump to run the water through the unit rather
than a remote coil that goes into the tank. Be warned that running a
chiller is like having a small air conditioner in your fish room. They
can generate a bunch of heat themselves. I would think that it would be
almost as affective and maybe about the same cost to put a small window
air conditioner in the room if you can. Good luck.> Scott
|
|