FAQs about Figure Eight Puffers,
Related Articles: Alone But
Not Lonely: The Importance of Keeping Puffers
Individually by Damien Wagaman, Figure Eight Puffers,
Puffers, Green Spotted Puffers
(GSP's), The Arrowhead Puffer,
Tetraodon suvattii, miraculously malicious, True
Puffers, Puffers in General, Burrfishes/Porcupinefishes, Tobies/Sharpnose Puffers, Boxfishes, Puffy & Mr.
Nasty, Puffer Care and Information, Pufferfish
Kelly Jedlicki and Anthony Calfo,
Related FAQs: FAQs, FAQs
2, & FAQs on: Figure-Eight Puffer
Identification, Figure-Eight Puffer
Behavior, Figure-Eight Puffer
Selection, Figure-Eight Puffer
Systems, Figure-Eight Puffer
Feeding, Figure-Eight Puffer
Disease, Figure-Eight Puffer
Reproduction, & BR Puffers
1, BR Puffers 2, BR Puffers 3, BR Puffer Identification, BR Puffer Compatibility, BR Puffer Selection, BR Puffer Systems, BR Puffer Feeding, BR Puffer Disease, BR Puffer Reproduction,
Larger, faster, meaner types...
the best really are other brackish water species...
Monodactylus, scats, Chromides, archerfishes... Sometimes members
of their own species.
Figure 8 puffer and sole; incomp.
Is a sole safe to keep with figure 8 puffers (ignoring the problem of food
<Not ideal, no. Figure-8s will nibble at anything. A flounder hiding under the
sand with its eyes poking out might be an easy target for a pufferfish... with
the result that the flounder could lose its eyes. I would be very wary about
combining them. As a reminder, Puffers are best kept alone. They barely tolerate
one another, and tend to view other fish as either a threat or potential prey.
If you accept that, your pufferfish experience will be much better.>
I used to have a tank with dwarf puffers that ignored a pair of some fish sold
as flounders. I don't know if figure 8 puffers are much more dangerous or if
it's common for them to bite soles.
<Hard to say. Soles and flounders are mostly nocturnal, so feeding them is
tricky, but since puffers are diurnal, you can work around the needs of both in
the one tank. On the other hand, because the soles and flounders are inactive
fish that rely on camouflage, they're easy targets for aggressive tankmates
within the confines of the aquarium.>
Which common soles are best for 1.005 sg brackish, and is there any sole from
Cynoglossidae that is best for this sg, or they're all unidentifiable and
treated the same?
<It's incredibly hard to identify "freshwater" flounders and soles, with the
exception, perhaps, of Brachirus harmandi. Let me direct you to some notes I
wrote a few years ago that may be helpful.
To be clear, some of the names offered by wholesalers and retailers, such as
Brachirus pan, are used so loosely as to be worthless. There are some very nice
photos in the Aqualog brackish water fishes book, but even with these you'd be
hard pressed to positively identify any "freshwater" sole or flounder. Much
better to treat them all as low-end brackish, as they'll all thrive at, say, SG
1.005, even if that species should be marine or even freshwater. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Figure 8 puffer and sole; now stkg.
How many figure 8 puffers should be kept in a 36 x 18 x 24 65 gallon with heavy
planting and strong flow?
<Oh, a fair few! Allow 15 gallons for the first one, then 5-10 gallons for each
additional one. So at least six, perhaps a couple more. For some weird reason,
this species cohabits well with Bumblebee Gobies, so if you must have a tankmate
species, that might be worth thinking about. Tricky to feed though. Cheers,
Toxotes microlepis and figure eight puffers,
Hey guys! Still trying to get a hold of a group of Toxotes microlepis
at one time rather than increasing them one by one to my 65Gallon tank.
Was thinking about tank mates and was wondering that if i kept the
salinity in the low-end region, say 1.003sg would figure eight puffers
be an appropriate tank mate? I was thinking "no" at first for
a few reasons
-puffers being fin nippers, and possibly trying to nibble/take chinks
of the archers
<Yes. A lot depends on the size of the tank and the relative sizes
of the fish. Big Archers will view small Puffers as food. Archers are
EXTREMELY efficient piscivores, far more predatory than many assume. On
the other hand, in a really big aquarium a single adult Puffer may do
little harm when kept alongside a school of adult Archers. Figure-8s
aren't especially nasty fish, more experimental diners than
-Puffers being somewhat "mean" although I don't have
experience with the figure eight puffer I know some of the freshwater
species can be little boogers.
<Oh yes, but that holds true for most Puffers generally. Puffers
view other fish as at least potential meals, and in the confines of the
aquarium, that potential becomes more real. Sure, Puffers aren't
built for speed, and in the wild, they mostly fail when attacking other
fish and instead go for slow moving or sessile prey like clams, crabs,
etc. But in an aquarium, especially a small one, it's hard for the
other fish to "get away" so the Puffers have more opportunity
to cause harm.>
-The archers eventually getting to about 6" and possibly seeing
the 2-2 1/2 in puffers as food even thought the puffers seem to be more
so rounded out.
however i thought it was worth asking for these reasons:
-Both can tolerate the salt, in this case the puffers requiring the
salt, and the Toxotes microlepis being tolerant and not bothered by
anything over 1.005sg i believe it was so it seems like a happy
<Yes; SG 1.003 would be ideal, and allow potential for plants, which
would break up lines of sight and provide distractions for the Puffer.
In the wild Puffers swim across solid objects, scanning for prey. The
more surfaces in the aquarium, the busier they'll be, and the less
they'll be attracted to other fish. Plants provide lots of complex
surfaces, and if you feed regularly, the Puffers will be nicely
-I can still have most of my hardy lowlight plants and jungle Val (one
strand is 4ft long haha its crazy how fast its growing in the harder
water!) in this salinity.
<Quite so; Vallisneria loves hard water and thrives in low end
brackish, SG 1.003 at 25 C/77 F.>
-If the two species do work out together its sure to be an awesome show
tank as i am quite the oddball lover and friends keep telling me they
want to see me get a puffer....lol of course not without proper
-Also it will give me some experience with keeping salinity levels
stable for when i wish to travel into saltwater...eventually.
<Quite so. On the other hand, Green Spotted Puffers do well in
marine aquaria and get along well with Damsels, so for "trying
out", GSPs might make more sense. If you can get them, Chelonodon
patoca might be a very beautiful alternative, another Puffer that
enjoys brackish to marine conditions.>
So lend me some info in terms of compatibility of these two very
different species, i have a hunch it wont work but it cant hurt to ask
<Hope this helps, Neale.>
Re: Toxotes microlepis and figure eight puffers
Thanks once again Neale! Your comments and info really helped!
<Glad to help.>
My tank is a 65 gallon tank 48"long 18 or 16" wide and about
20 "tall, although it seems the width is greater than the
I ordered some wood that branches off of a single branch and am going
to flip it upside down to create a root likes structure for shelter
from my relatively bright lighting and for a place to seek shelter.
As for the archers, my Lfs is trying to specifically get in the Toxotes
microlepis for me as i helped describe the particular species markings
with back up support from you when i sent in the "ID this
archerfish" email, and have to say because of this, i really love
my Lfs. They said the archers will get in at about 2" or so
sometimes 3-4" as well.
<Yes. The really small ones can be delicate, but the size you're
talking about here should be fine. Get them settled in and eating
before you add the Puffers.>
As for the puffers i was getting a bit mixed up in your reply as to
whether its just a problem with the archers viewing the puffers as food
when young, or even when both species are at full size.
<Archers will view any fish small enough to swallow (about third
their size) as food. That mouth of theirs is HUGE. But an adult
Figure-8 should be safe enough with Toxotes microlepis, these archers
only getting to about 12 cm/5 inches. So when it comes to the adults,
the risk is whether the Puffs will nip the Archers. At a pinch, I'd
risk this, but ONLY if I had a Plan B for rehousing one or other
species if needs be.>
The sizes along with the temperament of the puffers (although seems
like it could be curved by keeping their environment full of line of
sight breaking decor and a full belly of food ) makes it seem as though
it boils down to a no when it comes to housing these 2 species in a
tank like mine being the 65 gallons.
<Yes, 65 US gallons would be a bit small for comfort. Possible, yes,
but risky without a Plan B. Now, 100 gallons would be more sensible
Or is it more of a case of keeping up with the needs of both fish to
keep them happy? Will the archers be guaranteed to try and go after the
puffers when at full size even if both are introduced to the system at
a relatively same size and or time?
<Adult Archers will view a baby Puffer as food, no question. But
provided the sizes of each species are similar, then predation by the
Archer on the Puff shouldn't be a problem.>
Sorry for all the questions, i just really enjoy researching fish
hahaha...sold my Xbox for aquarium plants, now tell me that's not
Re: Toxotes microlepis <stkg. now> and figure eight
So in terms of the archers, I've talked to you before on
how many in a 65 gallon tank. Are groups of 5-6 necessarily better?
Is there a better sense of security between them when they are in
groups, as i recall you informing me that a single archer alone will be
<Singletons are easy to keep, but a bit shy and nervous. In groups
they behave more confidentially and naturally, but they can be
aggressive towards one another if you don't keep enough. From
experience, 2 or 3 isn't a number I'd recommend, and the more,
the better. Five should be fine.>
I assume the space issue is due to the 5-6 5 inch archers versus the
smaller puffers even though the puffers are quite the messy eaters and
producers of ammonia as well.
<Yes. Do also peruse today's FAQs; we had one message from
someone who had a Figure-8 that dismembered her Mollies! These fish are
Few are as nasty as that, but do understand the risks and have a Plan B
if you see anything untoward happening.>
I also remember that if you keep them in groups of 3, more than likely
one of the archers will get picked on. Anything you can enlighten me on
in terms of the subject? Thanks again haha
Re: Toxotes microlepis and figure eight puffers
Ruling the puffer fish out. Was just curious about them more so. Can
you recommend any other fish? Or are 5 Toxotes microlepis in a 65
gallon tank pretty full already?
i really like the African brown knife fish, and their smaller size
compared to other knife fish seems to make them a good choice for
my size tank.
<Quite so. Excellent fish, and potentially viable with T.
So how about this
5x Toxotes microlepis
1x Brown African knifefish
and if its not too crowded and does not out compete for food with the
Knifefish, possibly an active bottom dweller during daytime hours might
be appropriate? Sorry for re stating old questions Neale, I'm just
not so used to having a large tank...lol
Snail Question; sys., comp. w/ Figure Eight Puffers
Hi WWM team
I picked up 2 apple snails today and I was wondering if it is
possible to keep them in my brackish tank with my figure 8 puffers.
<No. Any salinity high enough to keep your Figure-8s happy will
quickly kill Apple snails.>
I understand that they have a trap door which will inhibit the puffers
from eating it and they're quite big, so the puffers probably
won't be able to get their little mouths around it.
<Ah, by no means! The Puffers will eat the snail one bite at a time,
starting with its tentacles. Apple Snails do badly with almost all fish
except perhaps uber-peaceful species like Corydoras. Even Neons nip
these poor snails!>
My salinity is roughly 0.004, no lower than 0.003 and no higher than
Can the apple snail survive in that level of brackish?
Will my puffers manage to eat it ?
Thanks a ton
Re: Apple Snail Question 1/11/12
Thanks for quick response...I see I made a typo error, my brackish tank
isn't 0.004...it's 1.004. Silly me.
<Indeed. But understood what you meant!>
Anyway, I forgot to ask another question about the apple snail. I
read online that they may even eat other snails.
<Seems improbable, but I'm sure they scavenge and will eat a
I have them with my red ramshorns which are laying eggs like it's
going out of fashion and I don't want the apple snails to now
devour all my other baby snails I'm breeding as food for my
puffs. Would it be advisable to get rid of them all together and
stick to the ramshorns?
<I honestly can't imagine Apple snails would make much
difference. They are very much herbivores, and mine were very keen on
Also, I had a situation where I decided to add a couple of mollies to
the brackish tank with my f8's. I came home one day to find
one floating with it's head and fins chomped off and I swear all
the puffs had a guilty look on their faces.
<Indeed. Figure-8s are extremely variable. Some specimens are
entirely placid, others just occasionally nippy. But a few, as
you've seen, can be very aggressive and nasty. That's pretty
much Puffers across the board.>
Today, at the petstore, I was told by a very experienced fish keeper
that if I want to add any other fish with f8's, I should remove the
puffers, rearrange the tank, put the new fish in first and then add the
puffers afterwards, to give them the idea that they are new and
it's not their territory that a new fish has entered.
<That is one approach that works with territorial fish.>
Do you think this will work?
<Might. But absolutely no guarantees, and you need to have a Plan B
for rehoming the Puffer or the new fish if the two don't get
Or will the f8's just chomp anything?
<Potentially anything that looks edible and doesn't eat the
I did however take one of the more aggressive f8's back to the pet
store today, unfortunately. I was told to remove one as I have a
29 gallon tank and I should only have 2 f8's in that size.
<Possibly, or else a group of 5 in a slightly bigger tank, so that
none of them take ownership. Overcrowding brings its own problems
Thanks in advance.
Re: Apple Snail Question 1/12/12
Sorry bout this Neale
How long should I keep the puffers out the big tank to try the approach
I mentioned previously?
A few hours, a day, a week?
<If using the "remove and rearrange" approach, taking the
fish out for an hour or two should be ample.>
I think this will be the last msg from me for a while now.
Keep well, and happy new year.
<Glad to help and good luck. Cheers,
Are F8 puffers and a Dragon goby ideal
tank mates?... not. 4/17/11
I know you have had this question before.
I feel a bit dumb asking but I have had so many conflicting
I have a Dragon goby he is about 8-9in long. I have had him for a
little over a year. He was only about 3in when I got him. My LFS
was selling them as aggressive FW fish (I know you have heard
that a thousand times!)
He is in a 29gal brackish tank at the moment. Yes, I researched
before buying him.
My husband actually makes jokes about how I research and write
everything down planning my set-ups down to exactly what and
where things will go. I keep a log of the water conditions as
well lol. Anyway, I plan on moving him to a 55gal in about six
<Sounds ideal. Be sure to add some tubes or caves he can hide
in. Ideally, use sand, not gravel.>
Right now he is all alone. He has been the whole time.
<Not especially social animals, though keeping them in groups
can be fun, if each one has its own PVC tube.>
I have been wanting to add an F8 or two for a while and have not
done it yet because of all of the conflicting things said about
them during my research.
<Not a good choice of companion.>
So I am wanting to get your opinion on the subject. I have really
wanted one or two puffers for over a year!
<The golden rule with puffers is this: Want a puffer? Then set
up a pufferfish aquarium! They aren't sociable fish.>
I am at the point that I will set up another tank if need be! I
would prefer to be able to have it/them in with my goby if
<Well, Figure-8s do vary in personality, and some are quite
peaceful. You might choose to try the combination out, and see
what happens. Any signs of fin-nipping on the Violet Goby, and
the puffer would need to be rehomed.
The risk is that Violet Gobies are big, slow-moving, and have
tasty-looking fins. They're a sitting target for
And I would also like to know if two figure eight puffers would
together for a few months with the goby in his 29gal or if I
should wait till I have the 55 established.
<Either has the potential to work, depending on their relative
sizes. But as I say, it's a risk, likely a 50/50 sort of
I was also thinking about putting a small school (6-8) of Celebes
Rainbow in the 55 once it's established.
<These don't really need brackish water, though
they'll tolerate slightly brackish conditions to around SG
1.003, as will most of the hardier Australian
The info I have on them is conflicted (as to whether or not they
are brackish) as well though so I am at a loss and need you
<The idea Rainbowfish generally need brackish water goes back
a few decades. As a group they're closely related to marine
fish, and a combination of that and occasional reports of them in
brackish water led people to believe they needed a little salt in
the aquarium to survive. In fact Celebes Rainbows are happiest in
moderately hard to hard, slightly basic water, i.e., 10+ degrees
dH, pH 7-8. They do fine in slightly brackish water though. If
you have a higher specific gravity than SG 1.003 at 25 C/77 F,
then they wouldn't be on my list of fish to keep. There'd
be much better choices such as Wrestling Halfbeaks, Guppies and
Limia in small tanks, or Mollies, Monos and Scats in larger
Re: Are F8 puffers and a Dragon goby ideal tank
I wanted to thank you for your quick response!
Ok, I do have lots of ground cover for my DG. He has a hollow
tree trunk, java fern, a couple of nicely shaped coral rocks he
likes to hide under as well, and he does have sand. I did use
playground sand though because it's cheap (I though it was
pretty much the same and a lot cheaper than marine sand)
<Play sand is fine.>
It took a lot of bucket rinsing but I think it was worth it.
So, I think I will pass on the CRs neither of my aquariums are a
good place for them.
I have another 55 but it is an Amazon type set up. Soft water,
slightly acidic for my tetras. I have blue, green fire, and
diamond tetras in there with 6 Cory cats. I am going to go ahead
with the puffers but I am going to slowly turn my other 29gal
sick tank into another brackish set up (ironically my DGs tank
started out as a sick tank for my tetras but I changed it for
him) incase the puffers decide to start in on my DG. I want to
make sure I have a place for them just in case. I would cry if I
lost my DG!
I have had this 29gal set up for the tetras but I have not had to
use it at all in the two years that I have had the tetras. I
haven't lost one of them yet!
<Well done. Your water chemistry has likely been an asset here
-- many problems with South American tetras likely come down to
keeping them in hard water.>
So, now my question is... How do I slowly raise the hardness and
salinity without crashing the biological filter?
<Go slow! If you're keeping just the Violet/Dragon Goby,
then a salinity of SG 1.005 is ample. For this, just doing your
usual 20% water changes each week, swapping out lower salinity
water for higher salinity water should adjust things slowly and
I have lots of experience with FW (tetras, African cichlids that
sort of fish) but my DG is the first BW fish I have had.
<Is often the case. The same with Mollies, the other classic
species for a first foray into brackish.>
With him he was sold in FW so I just put about a cup of Instant
Ocean in every other week till his water was at 1.005-1.008.
I had some plants in there with him that just so happened to be
<Few plants do well above SG 1.003 at 25 C/77 F, so I
wouldn't bother above SG 1.003. Java ferns and a few other
species will do okay up to SG 1.005 at 25 C/77 F. Do note that
temperature and specific gravity should be tested together -- for
any given salinity, the specific gravity (SG) will be lower in
warm water and higher in cold. Most books assume 25 C/77 F when
giving salinities in terms of SG numbers.>
I want to acclimate the sick tank before I get the puffers just
Should I do it the same way or should I do it different?
<Sure. Shouldn't take more than a couple of weeks to do
though. Up to SG 1.005, acclimation of bacteria from freshwater
to brackish is usually easy and uneventful.>
I know the puffers need an established set up so I would also
like to know of changing the hardness/salinity will make the
aquarium unstable for a while?
I didn't have and problems with Gimpy (my DG lol) but he
started out in FW anyway.
I think I will pass on other tank mates at the moment as well. I
am staring to think about maybe adding some Mollies to it once I
have the 55 established.
<An excellent choice, especially if you can get true Giant
Sailfin Mollies, which are massive (females 15 cm/6 inches!)
beasts with beautiful colours.
Like the Gobies, these do well across any salinity up to marine
conditions. Alternatively, Black Mollies make a great addition,
offering a nice contrast to the silvery-purple colours of the
Goby. Again, they're fine up to marine conditions. So at SG
1.018 upwards, you could even keep some hardy marines, like
farmed Clownfish! One of the nice things about brackish tanks is
being able to mix in marines.>
I was also wondering about BBGs.
<Nice fish, can be tricky to feed.>
Would they be compatible with my DG?
<Yes, but they might have problems getting enough to eat. A
bigger goby species, like Knight Gobies or the wonderfully named
Crazy Fish could work better. If you want some sort of character,
look out for Dormitator maculatus, or even Neovespicula
depressifrons, not a goby, but sold as the Butterfly Goby by some
Or the F8s?
<BBGs and Figure-8s have been combined, and they usually work
Would they nip at the Mollies if I got some?
<I've never found BBGs nippy.>
My LFS also carries Knight Gobies. Would any of those be
compatible with my DG or F8s?
<Knights would work extremely well. They're predators
though, and will eat Molly fry.>
I can easily forget about the Mollies if I would be able to put
one or two or more of these guys (BBGs or KGs) any thoughts?
<By all means try a selection, Mollies, Knights, and your
Thank you so much for all of your help!
Re: Are F8 puffers and a Dragon goby ideal tank
Ok, I am going to go ahead with the KGs and Black Mollies.
What do the KGs need for a balanced diet? ( I am Googling it
online but I would greatly appreciate your input )
<They're pretty adaptable, but leaning towards carnivory.
So apart from baby Mollies, they're going to enjoy brine
shrimp, daphnia, wet-frozen bloodworms, small chunks of tilapia
fillet, squid, mussel and prawn. Most specimens will take flake
after a while, especially good quality brands.>
The LFS I go to keeps both of these in BW already. I do find it
strange though that he keeps GSP and F8 puffers, KG, BBG and live
baring fish in BW (each group in their own tank with their
required salinity) but not the DG he and I have argued about that
<In the US the species almost always sold is Gobioides
broussonnetii, and this definitely does better in brackish
conditions than freshwater, and can be easily adapted to full
marine conditions too. In the UK (and I presume Europe generally)
a closely related species called Gobioides peruanus is traded
more often than Gobioides broussonnetii. Now, Gobioides peruanus
is a freshwater to brackish species and doesn't particularly
enjoy high salinities (above, say, 50% seawater or SG 1.012) and
may even do okay in plain freshwater if water quality is
excellent (though I personally wouldn't recommend it). But
because both species are traded, there are plenty of reports of
"Violet Gobies" or "Dragon Gobies" doing okay
in freshwater tanks. Doubtless some of the people who report
success are keeping Gobioides peruanus, and whereas people
(particularly in North America) who are keeping Gobioides
broussonnetii will find maintenance in freshwater fraught with
problems. Although Latin names can be annoying if you're not
familiar with them, this is one of the those cases where knowing
precisely which species you're keeping really does make a
difference. FWIW, Gobioides broussonnetii has more of the violet
bands along its flanks, whereas Gobioides peruanus has very faint
bands and mostly only on its head.>
I know he should know better! He claims that the people he gets
them from say that it's not true that they need brackish
<A common myth.>
Is there anything I can tell him to read to prove to him that
they need BW?
<My book! Brackish-Water Fishes from TFH. Until then, my FAQ,
And of course WWM has pages on these fish, starting here:
I know he cares about the fish he sells he's just
misinformed. (And unfortunately will not listen to me because he
knows more than me in other areas. I have straight out told him
that I am always open to new info and he should be as well. That
when it comes to this I know more because I have done extensive
research) What kind of cover should I get for the KGs?
<Something secure! These fish are NOTORIOUS jumpers. But
otherwise floating plants are good. Hornwort and floating Indian
Fern are both reliable in low-end brackish conditions, SG 1.003
or so. They don't so much use burrows
as swim in midwater, often underneath plant leaves. A big plastic
could work nicely. Otherwise a large Java fern or Anubias, or
even better, Cryptocoryne ciliata, a Crypt that naturally
inhabits brackish water! It's a big species, 30+ cm
My DG has his places but I want to add more for the KG. I also
want to know how many of the KGs I can put in the 29 and how many
more I could add once they are in the 55.
<Are territorial, but a half dozen shouldn't cause
Also, I don't have much in the way of taller cover for the
mollies and the F8s I have a lot of ground cover just not
anything above 6in except the java fern. And some Anacharis and
Anubias (they are at/under 6in though).
Someone in the puffer forum suggested fake mangrove roots and I
am going to check them out today at PetSmart (I am also going to
see if my favorite LFS carries them) but I would also like some
other options in case I don't like the way they look.
<Mangrove roots or similar are ideal. Do also consider gluing
(with aquarium silicone) oyster shells to rocks and bogwood roots
to create an oyster reef -- one of THE classic brackish water
habitats. Oyster shells make great hide-outs for gobies and
killifish (such as Florida Flagfish).>
I am going to wait until the other tank is ready before getting
Again thank you!
Re: Are F8 puffers and a Dragon goby ideal tank mates?
Nice thanks! I will check out that crypt you mentioned and am
currently looking into the hornwort. I am not sure which of the
two species you mentioned are what Gimpy is. I am going to send
you a pic if I can get a halfway decent one to send to see if you
<Likely Gobioides broussonnetii; this species has numerous
violet chevrons from the head almost down to the tail. On
Gobioides peruanus these are much weaker, often limited to simple
purple spots along the lateral line, and even these may not be
apparent. So far as I know, Gobioides broussonnetii is the
standard species in the US, so if you live in North America,
that's almost certainly the one you own.>
I don't have a background on his tank nor is it up against
the wall. I have it so that it can be looked at from three sides.
It makes it easier to see him.
I am assuming then that when you say 6 KGs together that it is
for the 55.
Which is great! I was holding I could put 2 in the 29 for now and
maybe 2 more when I get the 55 done. That way they have more
room. I won't mind them eating Molly fry. Less population
overload. A lot of what you are saying they eat I already have
for Gimpy! All I need is the tilapia, squid, mussel and prawn!
Everything else is already in my freezer lol.
<And those are easily obtained at, for example, an Asian food
market. Buy them frozen or fresh as preferred; I like to buy the
fresh stuff, slice into small strips, and then freeze that in a
Tupperware for convenient use.>
Plus his algae wafers.
<Gobioides broussonnetii enjoys these too, along with brine
shrimps and bloodworms.>
I don't usually feed live food. I don't want to have to
worry about parasites. Do they eat ghost shrimp?
<Knights will eat anything small enough to swallow.>
I do have a few of those in with Gimpy. I don't really care
if they do but I am curious. Thank you so much for those links! I
am going to give them to the guy at my LFS so that hopefully he
will take it upon himself to advance his knowledge. I have never
understood why people are so strange when it comes to being
corrected. How else you we supposed to learn anything
<Oh, well, I guess we get to a certain age and decide
we're full up with information and can't take any
Anyway, would you be able to give me your opinion on which of the
two species you think Gimpy is?
add Figure 8 Puffer to
I have a 90 gallon low-end brackish tank, sg fluctuates between 1.003
and 1.005. I inherited a disparate group of fish about a year ago that
I've been trying to accommodate. In this particular tank, I have
one archer (Toxotes jaculatrix), a tire track eel and a fire eel. The
eels are both 8" long. The eels seem to tolerate the salinity--do
you think this will be OK long-term? Conversely, do you think the
archer will be happy in this level of salinity? The archer seems very
happy at the moment (it's probably about 1 year old). I realize
I'm compromising a bit from either side of the salinity scale with
these fish. Next, I have a scourge of Malaysian trumpet snails in this
tank. I am toying with getting a figure 8 puffer for the tank because
1) I love puffers and I understand figure 8's are low-end brackish
and less aggressive than other puffers; 2) I don't see much in the
tank at any given moment except for the archer because the eels hide;
3) I would like to control the snail population.
Is this a bad idea?
Thanks for your help in advance. I appreciate your time.
<Hello Laura. Tyre-track Eels will certainly do okay at up to SG
1.005 at 25 C, but Fire Eels I'm less certain on, and I'd tend
to nudge the salinity down to about 1.003 at 25 C. The Archer
shouldn't mind, and that'll still be salty enough for a wide
range of species, both true brackish water fish and salt-tolerant
freshwater fish such as Brown Hoplo Catfish, Horseface Loaches and
virtually all of the livebearers. Now, as for Figure-8 puffers, while
this might work, I think you'll be disappointed at the impact
they'll have on Melanoides snails. You'd be much better off
with Assassin Snails, Clea helena, which should acclimate to SG 1.003
without problems given they're members of a marine snail family,
though I've never tried it
myself. They're cheap enough that trying them out won't be
expensive. Allow 3-4 Assassin Snails per 10 gallons if you want them to
exist in sufficient strength to depress Melanoides snail numbers. The
thing with puffers in general is that they won't eat snails if
softer, easier food is on offer -- and that can sometimes mean the fins
of other fish. Plus, the small size of Figure-8 puffers makes them easy
prey for adult Archer Fish, Tyre-track Eels and Fire Eels. Obviously an
adult Fire Eel will need a tank bigger tan ninety gallons, so you may
be planning to rehome him as/when he gets above a certain size. But an
adult Archer fish could swallow a Figure-8 puffer in one gulp! Do not
underestimate how predatory Archer fish -- sure, they enjoy eating
insects, but they are dedicated fish-eaters as well. Finally, do
understand that Melanoides snails are not in themselves harmful, but
they are indicators of aquarium conditions rich in organic matter. It
may well be that your tank is less clean than you think, and you're
overfeeding your fish far more than you suppose, and if you have a lot
of algae, then adding fast-growing plant species might make a
difference. Treat snails as a symptom, not a problem, and it's much
easier to effect a long term
solution. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: add Figure 8 Puffer to tank? 11/10/10
I sure wasn't thinking about the Archer going after the Puffer, so
thanks for that! (I actually saw the Archer eat one of the snails the
other day, but I figured that was an anomaly.)
I'll check out Assassin Snails. Luckily I don't have algae in
this tank, but I am trying to find the right amount of food/feeding
times for the eels.
I've probably been overfeeding the eels. They seem so temperamental
and unpredictable. I understand they shouldn't eat every day and
will sometimes go for a couple of weeks without eating, but this makes
me nervous! I don't want them to starve. I probably just need to
calm down about it!
By the way, I searched but couldn't find how long it takes for a
fire eel to reach full size--do you know?
<Hello Laura. Fire Eels growth rate varies with age, but specimens
under a year old can add about an inch in length per month. Growth
slows down a bit after that, but you can expect yours to be at least a
couple of feet long within 18 months, and nearer three feet by the end
of the second year. If the Fire Eel was stunted for whatever reason
while it was younger, it will grow quite slowly, and may never reach
its full size, fish growth rate being determined by age, not the need
to reach a certain size. This is why some people find their Fire Eels
get really big, really fast while others find their Fire Eels quite
slow growing fish. A bigger problem will be aggression: all the
Mastacembelus species are territorial, and Fire Eels and Tyre-track
Eels are unlikely to coexist in a relatively small tank, Fire Eels in
particular being notoriously grumpy fish. Look out for unusual white
marks on their bodies indicative of fighting. Sometimes juveniles
along well, even sharing caves, but do be aware than this situation may
not persist. When feeding predators, the "art" is providing
enough that their bellies are gently rounded, but not obviously
swollen; if the latter is the case, you fed too much in one sitting!
Earthworms are the best food for Spiny Eels, but they sometimes escape
into the sand, and when they die there, you'll get lots of nitrate
and phosphate in the water you don't want, as well as food for
Melanoides snails. Best to feed little but often, rather than gorging
the fish a few times per week. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: add Figure 8 Puffer to tank? 11/11/10
Thanks, Neale, this is very helpful indeed. I think I may start looking
to re-home the fire eel now.
<Glad to help. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Flower Pattern eel - What kind of Spiny eel? Now:
Tiger bumble bee gobies? 4/5/10
Thanks for the info on my spiny eel Neale, but I think Bob forwarded
along this message because of the last part.
I'm wondering if you have ever heard of tiger bumble bee
<Nope. I'm reliably told that identifying Brachygobius species
is extremely difficult and that virtually every photo in the hobby
literature is misidentified. The safest thing to do is assume these are
merely Brachygobius sp. of some sort, and treat them accordingly. There
are two basic species group, the small Brachygobius (such as
aggregatus) and the large Brachygobius (such as Brachygobius doriae).
Apart from size differences, care is remarkably uniform. Best kept in
brackish water, and the prime source of mortality tends to be
starvation, so don't
mix with other fish likely to consume the food they need.>
Are they any different than a regular bumble bee goby? The gobies are
not going in with the eel, they will be housed in a 20G brackish tank
most likely with a F8 puffer or two.
<I wouldn't keep two Tetraodon biocellatus in a tank as small as
this. Apart from that, yes, the species should coexist, but have the
gobies settled in and feeding before adding the puffer.>
Now: Tetraodon biocellatus incomp. (RMF, second
Sorry I must ask. Would you not keep two Tetraodon biocellatus for fear
of them bullying one another?
<Largely, yes; puffers aren't social for the most part, the
South American Puffer being the exception. So they're best kept
singly (the ideal, and often the only approach) or in groups of three
or more (which means the bully can't harass the same fish all the
or because of possible waste production,
<Less of an issue, but always a factor with Tetraodon spp. because
they have minimal tolerance for nitrate and no tolerance at all for
I have it over filtered, the back fully fake planted, a very complex
mangrove stump root deco, a ceramic cave and a ceramic small log all
tucked in nicely so that there is still plenty of open ground....
substrate is aragonite sand. Also there is a good visual breakup from
one side of the tank to the other. I looked into getting a 30G tank
specifically for this application however on this very site it is said
multiple times that a good rule of thumb for F8s is 10 gallon per
<I think that's an under-estimate, and even if you went with
that rule, you'd still keep either one or 3+ specimens. Keeping a
single Tetraodon biocellatus in 10 gallons would be completely wrong,
but three specimens in 30 gallons, or 5 in 40 gallons, would be
eminently doable, and leave plenty of space for a swarm of
Brachygobius, Redigobius or Chlamydogobius spp.>
I read and read and read some more but there is always differing
opinions, apparently even between crew members. I guess I'll just
do one, but beware that on the F8 FAQs it mentions the 10G/per fish
rule quite often.
<I've only been here a couple of years, so older FAQ responses
are nothing to do with me. But I can't ever imagine telling someone
two Tetraodon biocellatus would be good in 20 gallons.><<Me
Re: Tetraodon biocellatus incomp. 4/5/10
Also, I value everything I read and everything I get emailed on here
very very much, the last email was not meant as a I'm right
you're wrong email.
It's just a little frustration coming out since I thought I did
everything right with this 20G brackish tank I set up. I had my little
heart set on a pair of F8 puffers and I could have just as easily got a
30G tank before I set this tank up and started the fishless cycle. I
mean I even read every puffer and bumble goby FAQ on here before I did
<I'm sorry about this. But it's not my fault. Some folks
might be fine with two Tetraodon biocellatus in 20 gallons. But if
you're asking me if I'd do it, the honest answer is no.>
My last question is sincere though, would your main issue with two
F8's in a 20G tank be waste or bullying?
<More "experience" than anything else. Keeping two
pufferfish of uncertain gender in a tank this small is asking for
trouble. Get two females and it'd be fine. But two males or a male
and a female, and you'd have trouble. The males are territorial,
and since these aren't a pair-forming species, the notion of a
"pair" of Tetraodon biocellatus is meaningless.>
Thank you for your input Neale.
<You are most welcome. Cheers, Neale.> f8 roomies &
I was wondering what fish can room with f8 in a 20g tank and what foods
do f8 eat?
<Almost nothing lives happily with Figure-8 puffers. It is crucial
to realise when buying pufferfish that these fish are kept on their
own. When you buy one, you're buying a fish that will probably live
its entire life in its own aquarium, either by itself or with other
pufferfish of its own kind. Your species, Tetraodon biocellatus, can be
kept in groups of three or more specimens, but your tank is too small
for that, and just two specimens is risky, because bullying can occur.
Good foods are snails, krill, Mysis, chopped cockles, and bloodworms.
All these foods can be
bought wet-frozen. Avoid dried foods, and forget about flakes or
is every single type of goby brackish? thanks!
<No, not every goby lives in brackish water. Most are marine fish.
Some live in only freshwater. Of the species in the trade, the one type
that reliably lives with Tetraodon biocellatus are the Bumblebee
Gobies, Brachygobius spp. These do well in brackish water at SG 1.005
at 25 degrees C. They need lots of caves and shells to hide in. They
are very difficult to feed, and most specimens end up starving to
death, so do read up on their very specific needs. Cheers,
I have a question about Figure 8 puffers? Comp.,
I am thinking about starting a half brackish half fresh water fish
<Not sure what you mean here. You can certainly have a low-salinity
(around SG 1.003) brackish water aquarium that contains undemanding
brackish water fish alongside salt-tolerant freshwater fish such as
certain killifish. But you can't mix freshwater fish with brackish
water fish beyond that. Once you add enough marine salt mix to the
water for your brackish water fish to be happy, you will be creating
conditions hostile to
with 1 figure 8 puffer (in a 20g tank I have), and I'm wondering if
I could add some non fin nippers small-ish brackish fish to the tank
that'll go great with the puffer.
<There are few reliable tankmates for Tetraodon biocellatus. Small
gobies including Bumblebee Gobies work well, and in larger tanks,
Orange Chromides can work well too. But that's about it. As with
pufferfish generally, these are best kept on their own or in groups of
their own kind.>
and if you could send me some feeding instructions?
<Tetraodon biocellatus is easy to feed, but like all carnivores,
it's important to offer a variety of foods to avoid problems with
vitamin deficiency. Squid, prawns and mussels bought from the grocery
store are good foods to begin with, and can be used 2-3 times per week.
They contain thiaminase though, so shouldn't be used too often. The
rest of the week offer wet frozen bloodworms and krill, small pieces of
white fish fillet such as tilapia, and chopped cockles.>
Thank you -Jordan
Neons Gone!!!!! In with a brackish puffer...
Hi all. My name is Gerard.
I really need some help here. I have a figure 8 puffer and had 10 Neons
in the tank.
<You do realise these fish cannot be kept together? Figure-8 puffers
(Tetraodon biocellatus) are BRACKISH water fish. They need to be
maintained in a brackish water aquarium around SH 1.003 to SG
For some years there was confusion over this, possibly because Figure-8
puffers were mistakenly identified as Tetraodon palembangensis, a truly
freshwater fish. In any case, Figure-8 puffers need brackish water,
whereas Neons need soft water, so there's no overlap. Pufferfish
also tend to be non-social fish, at best they're territorial, at
worst they're predatory.
Figure-8 puffers are nippy and somewhat territorial, and best kept
either singly or in groups of 3+. Do read here about puffer
I woke up yesterday morning and 8 of them had vanished. I mean not even
a fin left. Now I thought that my wife took them out to give to her
sister for her tank......but this is not so.
<Somewhat mysterious. Of course, a big Pufferfish will eat small
Sorry wife. So this morning I wake up and I find that the other two are
now also GONE!!! what is going on?? At the pet shop I was told to feed
the fish every second day with flakes or pellets and bloodworm twice a
week for the puffer. not more than that otherwise the tank water will
go off because bloodworm is very high in protein, so the puffer would
eat what the others eat (terrible spelling sorry).
<Pufferfish need crunchy foods, not flake.
Offer them things like unshelled prawns, woodlice, small snails,
chopped squid, krill, and so on. Avoid freeze-dried foods (these seem
to cause constipation). Focus on fresh or wet-frozen foods. Don't
feed them live feeder fish!>
At another pet shop I was told that the puffer only eats bloodworm and
to feed it once a day????
<Why are you relying on what pet stores tell you? Would you listen
to what a car salesman said? Or someone selling clothes? Of course not;
you'd do your own research and make your own decisions. There is
information on this puffer species here at WWM.
I'm 50 bucks down overnight and a very empty looking fish tank.....
Please could someone tell me the truth. I don't know who to
<Luckily for you I write about brackish water puffers, and even have
a book about brackish water fishes that you might want to buy or borrow
from a library. So you can trust me!>
When you go back and off load your frustration...... it's always
something you have done... Eagerly waiting for a response Kind regards
<Hope this helps, Neale.>
Re: Neons Gone!!!!! 10/13/09
Hi Neale, yes thanks for the quick response. Please tell me, could that
puffer have eaten all 8 and 2 the following night??
<Yes. Puffers will eat a lot of food! In the wild they eat
"poor quality" food, meaning their food contains a lot of
shells. So they have big stomachs, and need to eat a lot of food across
the day to get all the energy they need. In an aquarium they are given
soft, good quality food, so seem very greedy. Their instinct is to fill
themselves up on whatever they can find; if that happens to be a bunch
of small fish, particularly dead fish, then that's what happens. I
should say that Figure-8 puffers do not normally eat fish, not in the
wild and not in captivity.>
That really baffles me. oh and what is the difference between brack and
<Brackish water is what you have in an estuary. It is half seawater
and half river water. In the aquarium, for the Figure 8 pufferfish, you
would add 9 grammes of marine salt mix (like you'd use in a marine
reef tank) per 1 litre of water. Do read in particular here:
Soft water is water with low levels of hardness. It was what you find
in rivers hundreds of miles inland, like in the Amazon or the Congo.
You *cannot* keep soft water fish and brackish water fish in the
Brackish Tankmates 4-23-09
Hi, I have a 26 gallon brackish tank with 2 figure 8 puffers, a
Pleco, a few snails, and tiny feeder fish.
<Hello! Merritt here!>
They have been together for about 3 months and seem to be doing
good. However I have had several people tell me the Pleco
needs to be taken out because he wont live long in the water due
to the salt content. Is this true?
<Plecos are found in freshwater mainly but also brackish
water, so he should be fine.>
The Puffers don't seem to eat other fish like I was told when
<Puffers are not fish eaters.>
I feed them bloodworms and snails, is their anything else that
would balance their diet better?
<You can feed them thawed shrimp and live ghost
Also I have wanted to get a Dragon Goby and the setup is made
with the perfect hiding space for him, but wanted to know if he
would eat my puffers or if they would bother him too much?
<Puffers love to pick on other fish, I am surprised your Pleco
has made it this long. I would not advise in adding the dragon
goby to your tank. Also, they will not eat your puffers, they are
more like filter feeders. They may look mean, but certainly are
I attached some photos of the puffers and tank.
<Great looking tank!>
Thank you so much!
<You are welcome! Merritt A.>
Figure Eight Puffer - new tank/tankmates
1/27/09 Hello, I have a 10g low salinity brackish tank with a
year-old figure eight puffer and one bumblebee goby (I had two, but one
recently died). My puffer is in need of a bigger tank, and I'm
exploring new tank setups and new tankmates. I'm a college student
and, when I'm not at home on breaks, my fish are in the capable
care of my mom. With this in mind, I'm trying to figure out what
filtration system would be the best balance of effectiveness and
maintenance. I'm considering a tank size between 45g and 70g. What
are your filtration suggestions for a tank like this, with fairly quick
water turnover and 'mineral mud' or some sand-like equivalent?
With a bump up in tank size, I'm also looking to add a few fish.
I've been doing a bit of research on dusky panther gobies and
knight gobies. Would these fish be compatible with my puffer (and with
each other)? Aside from disc fish, which I'm not a big fan of, are
there any other species that would live well with my puffer? It is
fairly docile, showing no interest in the goby, and even allowed a
fiddler crab to live in the tank unbothered for its lifespan. Thanks
for your suggestions. With the sparse resources and controversy over
brackish setups, all your help is greatly appreciated. -Ben <Hi Ben.
Ten gallons is not a lot of space, and your decision to trade up is a
wise one. Even switching to a 20 gallon system would make all the
difference in the world! The bigger the tank, then the more stable the
water chemistry and the less likely water quality problems will develop
in between the times you're about to check on them. So having a
bigger tank will make life easier for your mom during your absences. So
whichever tank you get, I'd encourage you to under- rather than
overstock it, so that its bigger size works in your favour. Beyond
that, I don't really think it matters much what filtration system
you use. Personally, I find canister filters require the least
maintenance, and while external canister filters are certainly the best
in terms of value, they're a hassle to maintain. On the plus side,
if you're around every most weeks, and only gone for, say, 6-8
weeks at most, then a canister filter or two would surely be the best
choice. Internal canisters are (by contrast) more expensive in terms of
filtration capacity, but they're very easy to maintain, requiring
little more than switching off, pulling out of the tank, and then the
relevant media either replaced or rinsed. Otherwise, most any filter
will do, provided you accept the pros and cons of each type and work
around them. Now, "Dusky Panther Groupers" are, I assume, the
Waspfish Neovespicula depressifrons. They're also sold as
"Butterfly Gobies". Anyway, they're neither gobies nor
groupers, but more closely related to things like stonefish and
bullrouts. They are hardy and quite good community fish, provided they
aren't kept with anything they can swallow. They are fine with
Knight Gobies of equal size. Feeding them is a bit awkward though as
they're a bit slow, but then so are the gobies. Both species are
predators with a fondness for small invertebrates and fish. I
wouldn't use feeder fish for either though, for all the usual
reasons. River shrimp are readily taken though, and once settled, both
take frozen foods. I wouldn't risk mixing either with Figure-8
puffers; puffers are just a bit too nippy, even this rather mild
species. While the Knight goby might be active enough to avoid trouble,
I can't help but feel the Waspfish would end up being bitten at
some point. Figure-8s are best kept either alone or in groups of their
own kind. They do mix quite well with Bumblebees as well as Orange
Chromides, which seem to be punchy enough they avoid becoming targets.
That's the problem with puffers. If your specimen happens to be
mild, you might risk it, and see what happens. But certainly provide
lots of hiding places for all concerned, in the form of empty oyster
shells, barnacle clusters, plastic seaweed, and so on. There is quite a
bit of stuff out there on brackish fish now. Besides the many resources
on WWM, there's my own book from TFH as well as a book from
Aqualog. Both books are entitled 'Brackish-Water Fishes'. They
target somewhat different markets, the Aqualog book being smaller and
more about identifying common and rare species and describing their
basic needs, while my TFH book is a much bigger book that goes into a
lot more detail, though primarily on species available in the US,
Europe and Australia. Cheers, Neale.>
Biting fin... Figure Eight Puffer,
incomp. 6/22/08 hi crew, I was just wondering, is
there anything I can do to distract my fig. eight puffer from biting my
other fishes fins? It's not serious, but I am really worried.
Please help me. Thanks. <The short answer is 'No'. More
specifically, several species of pufferfish view the fins of larger or
slow moving fish as potential food. So biting is as instinctive for
them as swimming and breathing, and nothing you can do will change
that. There is variation within some species though, which means that
sometimes a given species will be fine for one person, but trouble for
another. For example, I keep a pair of Carinotetraodon irrubescos in a
community tank where they behave absolutely perfectly, and have done so
for years. Most people experience the same thing, but there are a few
reports of this species being extremely vicious. So putting any puffer
in a community is a gamble, and I'd always recommend you have a
Plan B ready. Your species, Tetraodon biocellatus, is usually peaceful
but as you've experienced some specimens can be biters. Such
specimens are best kept alone or with their own species if you have
sufficient space (puffers are often a bit territorial). I'd argue
with your comment that the biting isn't serious, as it is
undeniably stressful for the victim and wounds can of course become
infected with Finrot bacteria. Given that Tetraodon biocellatus is a
brackish water species, the marine salt mix you're adding to
maintain the specific gravity at SG 1.003-1.010 will be helping here,
as salty water appears to inhibit casual secondary infections. You
could also ensure the tank is large enough for the "victims"
to stay out of trouble, and add lots more plastic plants and rocks so
they can hide away from the puffer is need be. Fin-nipping in puffers
is often related to feeding behaviour, so if the puffer has other
things to explore in terms of foraging, its tankmates may be ignored.
Offering more filling foods (such as unshelled shrimps or krill) rather
than processed or soft foods will make the puffer feel more satiated
and therefore less likely to nip at tankmates. But realistically, if
this puffer carries on attacking its tankmates, you can't in good
conscience leave it in this system. Cheers, Neale.>
Figure 8 Puffer Compatibility - 04/20/07 Hello
PufferPunk, <Hi Mark> I have two questions, could a Figure 8
Puffer and a Red Eared Slider (1 1/2 in.) live together in the same
tank. <Absolutely not. Turtles eat
fish. Puffers are poisonous.> Next Question: I am looking
for an expert opinion on my idea of a Figure 8 Puffer tank (If it
can't be with the slider): 10 Gallon glass tank with regular hood
setup <Minimum tank size for 1 F8 is 15 gallons.> Lots of Lava
rock <I like the mangrove roots at PetSmart.> Fake plants
Substrate? <Crushed coral or a 1" layer of aragonite sand is
best, to maintain a steady pH of 8.> Airstone <They love playing
in the bubbles!> HOB Filter rated for 15-20 gallons <More like
30g.> 1 Figure 8 Puffer 3-5 Bumble Bee Gobies <15g is minimum
tank size, without tank mates. If you add more fish, you
need more room--at least 20g.> Salinity= 1.005
<Perfect! Fishless cycle the tank in the SG that the
puffer is in at the shop. If freshwater, then raise the SG
no more than .002/week.> Thanks a lot, Mark <For more info, go to
Pufferfish Aggression 1/4/06 <Hi,
Pufferpunk again> Our green spots are the most passive of the
puffers we own... <They are juvies now... Just wait till they mature
& one morning you wake up with maimed or dead fish.> We have the
salinity levels between what the figure eights and greens spots need
and there is a level which both can live in. We bought all the fish in
1.010 and that is what they are now in... <Figure 8s are best kept
at 1.005 for life. GSPs will eventually need marine
conditions. LFS rarely know what is best for puffers.>
This particular green spot has gotten sick on several occasions where
as the other green spot and the figure eights don't get sick. The
red-eye and the dwarf are now in their own tank. <You're not
worried about the red-eye killing the dwarf? Puffers are
best kept in species only tanks. The species are not to be
mixed.> The first time the green spot got sick he had gill disease
and this time he had something that medications did not cure... So far
I have found that the most aggressive of all is the red-eye, contrary
to what every website I have read has said. <It is possible that
your red-eye is the more aggressive lorteti. They are almost impossible
to tell apart. As you have already witnessed, puffers have
their own personality & levels of aggression. Hence
keeping species & sometimes individuals separate. I know
of puffers that had previously gotten along with it's tank mates,
only to wake up one morning to it being the only survivor of a
massacre. Have you read the profiles & articles I linked
you to? I highly suggest that you do. They are
written by the top puffer experts in the world! ~PP>
Figure 8 Puffer Question - 6/6/6 Dear WWM Crew, <<Hi
Ronald.>> Thank you for this great source of help. I
recently moved the inhabitants of my 37 gallon hexagon tank into a 75
gallon tank. I have the 37 gallon tank in my office and
would like to restart it with something different, and I am considering
a Figure 8 Puffer. <<Very cool puffer.>> I have read the
articles on your site and it seems that they do best as the only Puffer
in the tank. <<Figure 8s in general are better with their own
kind than some other species.>> My question is, are there any
other fish that I could add to the tank with the Figure 8, or would he
need to be the only fish in the tank. <<Some recommend Bumblebee
and Knight gobies, but it is really hit or miss. Orange
Chromides are my choice, but not for the tall style tank you
have.>> I realize that they are a brackish fish, and I am looking
forward to using some of the decorations from my old marine tank.
<<In your tank, Id think two figure eights and perhaps some
gobies will be fine. Check out www.thepufferforum.com for
more information on caring for your puffers.>> Thank you for your
advice. Ronald Boudreau <<Glad to help. Lisa.>>
Blenny Aggression...And A Brackish Puffer In A Marine Tank -
01/10/07 Hi there! <<Hello!>> I have looked online and
consulted with various people I work with (a large public aquarium) and
cannot seem to find a solution to my problem so maybe you can help, or
have a different perspective. <<Let's see what I can
do...>> I have a bicolor blenny, a red firefish, and a
figure-eight puffer in a 20 gallon, as well as a decorator crab but I
doubt he figures into this equation. <<Something to mention
here...Tetraodon biocellatus is a "slightly brackish water"
species and will not fare well in the long-term in a full-strength
marine environment. This species is also best kept as single
individuals (it will eventually bite/kill its tankmates), and though a
small species (to less than three inches) it likes having some room to
roam with minimum recommended tank size being
30-gallons. You can find much more information re this
species by perusing our articles and FAQs. A good place to
start is here, following the associated links in
>> And yes, I know the figure eight is usually brackish...
<Not usually...is>> All that considered here is my
question. The blenny is getting aggressive with my
firefish. It is not at feeding times, so I doubt the theory
that he isn't getting enough to eat. I thought it could
be a territorial/spatial issue. <<Very likely this "is
" the issue>> I had one big pile of live rock, so I split it
into two piles thinking that maybe the blenny would pick one to call
his own, but no luck. <<This tank is too small...does not afford
enough "separation">> He swims between the two like he
owns it all. :) <<Indeed...these blennies generally occupy
relatively small territories on the reef (sometimes smaller than a
square meter...but still larger than a 20-gallon tank) and will defend
vigorously from perceived invaders>> I have thought about
splitting it into three piles, but not sure if this would help.
<<probably not>> Any suggestions would be appreciated.
<<I'm afraid your best option is to remove one or the
other>> And just as a side note, no one else in the tank is
involved in this dispute. <<Not surprising...only the blenny and
the firefish would compete for the same food items/occupy the same
niche on the reef. Nemateleotris magnifica is a peaceful
(conspecifics aside) almost timid fish that can be difficult to keep
under the best of conditions. The continued aggression from
the blenny will likely result in its demise>> Thanks a lot! Robin
<<A pleasure to share, Eric Russell>>
Figure 8 Puffers Will figure 8 puffers get on well with these
fish. If I get two fish, will they bother each other instead of the
other fish? Sucking loach Red tailed black shark Dwarf Gourami Kuhli
(Eel) loach Bronze Catfish Neon tetra Zebra Danio Guppies Flame tetra
> > No... these fresh to brackish puffers are "nippy",
and will outright eat the Neons and guppies... and bite the other
fishes as they can approach them... Bob Fenner
Re: Figure 8 Puffers Are there any other types of freshwater
puffer that will get along with these fish? Thanks Tim Jeffree > IMO
not really... even the truly freshwater species from the Africa and
South America are fin nippers... Best kept with other similarly
"mean" fish livestock. Bob Fenner
Figure 8 Puffers--A Brackish Water Puffer 9/12/04
Dear Crew <Hi, Pufferpunk here> Over the past eight months, we
had fish as pets, learning new stuff, and one day we finally found
puffer fishes and we ended up setting up a new tank for
them. So far so good, but we have three of them and one I
guess, is trying to setup dominance over the others, so I called Petco,
where I got them and they suggested feeding them everyday so they will
stop nipping each other, but it seems like the dominant one always nip
the others after feeding... :( I do not want them to keep getting
stressed and die, so please help! <1st of all read this wonderful
article on F8s: http://www.aaquaria.com/aquasource/8puffer.shtml
This should answer all your questions on the care & feeding of
these great pets. I am concerned that you said you set-up a
new tank for your fish. Did you cycle it 1st? How
large is the tank? F8 puffers require at least
10g/puffer. Puffers personality vary from fish to
fish. Some may be very mild-mannered, while others may be
killers. If you have a killer, it must be kept singly, or it
will kill their tank mates. You just never know with
Bossy Puffer 10/26/04 <Pufferpunk here> I
ignored you warning about my GSP "Pongo" being too aggressive
for my F8, but now "Munk" (he has the scream face on his
back) the F8 is pushing Pongo and eating almost everything I throw into
the tank. I don't think this is that bad of a problem now I'm
sure if the GSP was hungry he would push back but I though to cut down
on hostility could I re-arrange the tank plants and drift wood? I'm
sure this isn't the biggest case of civil disturbance you hear its
more like sibling rivalry but any ideas would be nice. <You're
GSP may be less aggressive as a juvenile & could possibly starve,
if you don't give him a chance to eat. Moving the decor
around may help, but you might just have to separate the
two. You can also try feeding at opposite ends of the
tank. ~PP> Thanks
Mixing BW Puffers in a 20g Tank <Hi, Pufferpunk here> I
have started my 20 gal brackish puffer tank with a medium GSP and a
figure 8. I can already tell the GSP is a little more pushy
than the figure 8. When I chose my next two puffer should I exclude
getting another GSP or the less aggressive figure 8, and what would be
the ideal choice to have a happy tank? Thanks for your website <1st
of all I need to request that when writing your emails, please use
proper capitalization & punctuation. I have to correct
this myself, before sending it on to the FAQs at our
website. I'm not sure I understand your
question. Are you adding 2 more puffers to your 20g
tank? As you have already noticed, the GSP is too aggressive
to house with the milder F8 in such a small tank. As
the GSP gets larger & even more aggressive, it will only get worse
for the poor little F8. Also, a 20g tank really isn't
big enough for an adult (6") GSP. What I'd do is
find a home or return the GSP & get 1 more F8. Only 1
F8/10g. Here's a great article on them: http://www.aaquaria.com/aquasource/8puffer.shtml ~PP>
Figure 8 Pufferfish 6/23/04 Hey Again! <Hey again
yourself!> Geez, that was a fast response! <I'm on the ball
today!> I have one more quick question. Would it be alright to add
one of those suckerfishes (I can't think of the name.. but they are
the ones who swim around and suck up all of the algae and stuff in the
tank) into the tank? <The "suckerfish" you are talking
about is a freshwater fish & doesn't like
salt. It's called a Plecostomus. If you plan
to keep these puffers for any length of time, they are best kept in
brackish water.> Or would a snail be better, since a suckerfish
lacks the protection from the Puffer? <Puffers eat snails & they
don't like salt either.> Oh, and you're right. Figure
8's are cute! And I've got somewhat bad news.. I think he died.
He hasn't moved lately.. <Sorry to hear that. Did you
get the water tested?> Well, thanks for the help for my
next fish! <Make sure & read that article I linked you to.>
Btw, how long has your Pufferfish lasted? Do you also have a Figure 8?
<Yes, I have 3 figure 8 puffers. I've only had them
for about a year, but they can live 18+ years if cared for properly. I
have a total of 14 puffers in all ~PP> Mixing
Puffer Species 5/30/05 <Hi, Pufferpunk here> I have a 20
Gallon tall Hex tank, fully cycled, with a BioWheel filter. I have let
it cycle over the past several weeks and in that time I have grown a
nice amount of aquatic plants. <What do you mean by cycle? Are there
fish in there or just plants? Without fish to produce ammonia or
another source of ammonia, there is no nitrifying bacteria.> Now for
my question. I was originally going to stock the tank with a few dwarf
puffers (Carinotetraodon travancoricus) and an Otto. I have since
fallen in love with both the South American (Colomesus asellus) and
Figure Eight (Tetraodon biocellatus) Puffers. The tank is full
freshwater right now. I was wondering if there is anyway to house 2 of
these types of puffers together. I hear conflicting things about the
required salinity for the figure 8, and just as often I see it listed
as freshwater, hence my confusion! I have read that the South American
and Dwarf Puffers can be housed together, and was wondering your what
your recommendations for stocking ratios and such are. <F8s
are indeed BW fish, so those 2 species cannot be mixed. I would stick
with a species only tank for a 20g. Either
2 F8s in a BW environment, or
2 SAPs in FW. With F8s you could keep a few bumblebee gobies
or w/SAPs you could keep faster moving fish, like danios & maybe
some Corys.> Thanks so much for your time, you are truly an amazing
resource! <That's what we're here for! ~PP>
Mixing Puffer Species 5/31/05 Pufferpunk, Thanks so much for
the quick reply, <Sure!> By 'cycled' I mean that I
allowed the nitrifying bacteria to build up by having my niece's
goldfish in the tank for a few days several weeks ago. I took her
out, and now she's no worse for wear. The ammonia, then
nitrite spiked and has since leveled out (meaning both at 0, nitrate
low). <I'm sorry to say that if there have been no fish in
there for over 24-48 hours, the tank has to be cycled
again. There has been no "food" by way of ammonia,
to keep the bacteria alive in your tank. You can always buy
Bio-Spira at the same time as your fish, to "instant cycle"
your tank. Just do a 90% water change before
hand. I'm afraid cycling w/GF can also add certain
diseases that other fish can't handle, to your tank.> I have
decided to stick with a freshwater set-up, and I was wondering if
mixing dwarf puffers and South American puffers would work.
<The vicious biting dwarves have caused problems for my SAPs, even
in a much larger tank--I don't suggest it.> If not I think
I'll stick to my original plan of dwarfs and an Oto. Thanks
again, I really appreciate it! <Good idea! Should be a
nice, interesting tank. For info on DPs go to:
www.dwarfpuffers.com ~PP> Bad Advice about Puffers
3/16/05 <Hi, Pufferpunk here> I was fooled by a pet store
employee. I bought a figure 8 and a leopard puffer. They said that they
would be fine in my 55 gallon together and with my Pleco, my 2 African
frogs and a few barbs. The leopard bit the leg off my frog and keeps
beating up on the figure 8. <No surprise there at all.> I have no
more tanks to separate them. Could I just give the leopard a new home
and keep the Figure 8? I really want to get more fish but I fear their
lives with the leopard in there. But if I do that will the figure 8
just eat everyone in the tank? ~*Tara*~ <The leopard, or
green spotted puffer (Tetraodon nigriviridis), is an extremely
aggressive fin biter. The F8 (T biocellatus) is a little more mellow,
but has issues with the same. Both are actually brackish water fish.
The nigroviridis, prefers high end BW & SW as an adult. You can
read about them here: http://puffer.proboards2.com/index.cgi?board=brack.
Neither of those fish will work in your tank. ~PP>
Combining Puffers in One Tank 3/14/04
<Pufferpunk at your service> How will a GSP and a Figure 8 puffer
get along? My GSP is real chill. <GSPs require at least 20g
each. I know it is probably small right now & looks
dwarfed in a tank that size, but if you look at mine (the puffer photo
in my article) you'll see how large they wind up
growing. Also, GSPs prefer SW as adults & are extremely
aggressive, while F8s prefer low-end BW, they only grow to 3"
& are mildly aggressive. Not really a good match.>
Also, there is a red eye puffer I want, how would he get along with my
GSP? The red eye is pretty big. <Puffers are best kept in
species only tanks. I have had success in keeping
similar-mannered puffers together (GSPs W/Ceylons, or dwarves with
South Americans) but in very large tanks with a heavy load of decor
& many broken lines of sight. As far as a red-eye
puffer, there are many puffers w/red eyes that could be labeled as such
by a LFS. Common names are difficult to ID a fish
with. If you're still interested in this fish (in a
separate tank) & you are concerned about it's care &
temperament, you can look for an ID here: http://www.pufferfish.co.uk/aquaria/species/pufferfish/index.htm
<Good luck with your puffer, I'm glad it's doing
Tank Mates for Figure 8 Puffers? 11/29/04
<It's me, Pufferpunk again!> Guess I'll get a bigger
tank!! You are right - my fault for not looking deeper into these fish
-- So can I put another fish in with the F8 puffer? What type?? I'm
headed to the library after work today ... <I have a lovely 29 g
tank with 3 F8s, 2 pairs of knight gobies & 6 bumblebee
gobies. A 30g long tank would be even better for that
combo. ~PP> Thanks Pufferpunk -- Looks like I will be
getting a bigger tank!! <Come & join us over at
Figure 8 Puffer Hi Bob, I was wondering what other
"mean" fish will a figure 8 puffer get a long with. Thanks!
<Larger, faster, meaner types... the best really are other brackish
water species... the other not-so freshwater tetraodont puffers,
Monodactylus, scats, Chromides, archerfishes... you can find a bunch
about these possibilities, even brackish water plants through a read
through past hobbyist magazines... and goosing me to get more of my
brackish pieces on our WWM site... Bob Fenner>
Figure eight puffer Hello, <Cheerio, old sport! Anthony
Calfo in your service> I have owned a freshwater fish tank of some
form for many years. Whether it was 50 gallon, 20, or 10 (I have a 10
right now because of the convenience), I have never really paid
attention to pH, ammonia, etc. <like an ice pick in my
ears...hehe> I use a water X and add a teaspoon of salt for every 10
gallons. <I like that part <wink>> Right now I have a 10
gallon tank that follows me pretty much everywhere. <most
people have cats and puppies for this but hey... enjoy> Today I
bought a figure eight puffer, I have always wanted a puffer and finally
I decided to get one, but not before asking the dealer a bunch of
questions. He said that although he may get territorial, he is a good
community fish. <your dealer is a fibber <G>> He said
the fish will eat flake food, which is what I normally feed my fish,
but I often give brine shrimp. <Puffers are cute, lovable and
dedicated fin nippers. They also will suffer on a diet of flake and
brine shrimp. As crustacean eaters, they need hard shelled foods to
wear down their naturally growing teeth. Without it the teeth will
become overgrown to the point where the animal cannot feed. As such
flake food is too soft and brine-shrimp without enrichment (Selcon
soaked and the like) is a useless fare that is essentially water made
to look like shrimp. Too bad it is so well liked by fish... it is the
lowest grade food. Add frozen Mysid, krill and plankton to the diet
(freeze dried krill too). Some folks keep fast breeding live snails
(the puffers love them!!!) to help with the teeth too> He said my
salinity would be fine. <probably although they could take and
might enjoy a lot more salt to truly be brackish> Once I bought the
fish and released him into the tank, everything at the moment appears
to be fine. I haven't fed yet, so I don't know how that will
go. I started looking things up on the net here and one guy has me
really afraid. He seems to know what he is talking about, but he says
that having all these conditions right is vital and puffers are very
sensitive. Can you help me out a little here? <some truth to
it... they are scale less fish and as such are sensitive to water
quality and medications> Also, since I have released my figure eight
puffer into the tank, he has swam up and down the side wall non-stop.
It appears normal, but I saw a comment somewhere saying this was a bad
thing, is this true? <common but not normal or healthy in the
long run. A stress induced response to many factors (salinity, light,
water quality, etc)> Please help me out, thanks. Dave <no problem
my friend... much has been written on this topic. Do a search on this
site (tag the bullet for WWM only under the keyword field at the bottom
of the home page) and look through the archives of FAQs. Much
information there. Also, look through the brackish articles by
following the links from the WWM homepage as well. I suspect that you
will be enlightened and able to enjoy your puffer very soon. Best
Freshwater Puffers? I found your address on the wet web media
site. I seen a figure eight puffer and a green puffer at the pet store
the other day. The worker was unable to help me. I was wondering if you
could. I would like to know what kind of things they like to eat, are
they aggressive, and where could I find more info about them? Any help
you could give me would be greatly appreciated. Thanks Jodi > Hi
there. Yes these two (really marine, though somewhat adjustable to more
freshwater conditions) Puffers are eager eaters of most anything meaty.
Most folks feed them "human consumption" type shrimps, fish
flesh... And, unfortunately they're both notoriously
"nippy"... not necessarily aggressive, but do real damage to
easier going tankmates (fish and invertebrates), and thus should be
housed only with "tough, mean" types of livestock... best,
really in a dedicated "brackish" setting with other rough and
tumble fishes, plants that can/do tolerate some concentration of salts.
More information? Hmm, try inserting the word for their genus,
Tetraodon, in your search engines, directories. Be chatting, Bob