|
Home | Marine Aquariums |
Freshwater Aquariums |
Planted Aquariums |
Brackish Systems |
Ponds,
lakes & fountains |
Turtles & Amphibians |
Aquatic Business |
Aquatic Science |
Ask the WWM Crew a Question |
Please visit our Sponsors | ||||
Dictyota Algae - Rabbitfish 3/1/19 Stopping the dreaded Dictyota in its tracks (nuisance macroalgae control> 9/1/08 Hello Crew, <Hey there! Scott F. in today!> I am having a problem with Dictyota algae in my 250g reef system. It is not that the algae is completely taking over - it is growing quite slowly due to my low levels of nutrients (nitrate and phosphate are zero, big refugium, powerful skimmer, DSB). <Oh, darn- a healthy, stable system! Seriously, though- consider yourself fortunate, as this can be one of the absolute nastiest macroalgae to deal with. Of course, if you're trying to grow the stuff, I can understand that you might be a bit frustrated!> My pH is quite high (8.4) (Kalkwasser dosing with pH-controller) day and night and I only seldom dose iodine or trace elements, I do an 8 to 10% water change every week. <Great husbandry!> It would not be a problem to siphon the algae out every once in a while. Some parts of the Dictyota do, however, stay attached to the surface of the live rock and sometimes these parts begin to crawl up on my corals' bases. <Yup- seen that before!> It has reached a point where I have to scrape off some coral tissue together with the algae to prevent the Dictyota from slowly crawling further up on my corals. <And so the invasion begins...PLEASE be very careful here. I have seen this algae literally take over some beautiful aquariums. Even the smallest fragments, as you are discovering, can form new aggregations, smothering sessile invertebrates in the process. I'm going to talk a bit about this species in one of my MACNA presentations in Atlanta next week. I'm not a fan of this algae!> Thus, I was thinking of adding a Siganus doliatus/virgatus or a Naso tang to my tank to help with removing the algae from the coral tissue. I know that both fish are said to be among the few to eat Dictyota, and I have read your articles and FAQs (besides reading the daily FAQs ;-) as well as other sources on Dictyota elimination. Due to the small size of my system I would prefer one of the Siganids, my only concern is that due to the noxious nature of this algal family they might not eat it. So my question would be what you would recommend in my case? Which would be the better route to go? And if the Siganids - which species? Thanks in advance & best regards, Alex <Well, Alex- you asked...I am a bit skeptical about these fishes feeding on Dictyota. I have not seen a situation personally in which these fish-or any others-dine on this stuff with any degree of regularity. Sure, a specimen may develop a taste for the stuff, but I'd think that to be the exception rather than the rule. As you surmised, Dictyota is not particularly palatable to fishes. I am also not a big fan of the Siganidae. However, if I had to try one, I'd go for the so-called "One-Spot Foxface" (Siganus unimaculatus), which is about the smallest member of the family regularly available to the trade, topping off at about 8 inches. It's still a big, clumsy, aggressive, skittish, relentlessly active fish, IMO. It is known for producing copious amounts of organic waste, and is also capable of causing damage to corals and clams because of it's relentless grazing habits (gee-can you tell I'm NOT a fan!). Oh, yeah- I forgot to mention that it also possesses venomous spines, creating a potential threat to the hobbyist. All in all, I'd recommend keeping your Dictyota in check by either manual extraction (best accomplished by removing the affected rock/coral from the aquarium and removing the algae in a separate container of tank water. Yes, it's tedious, but I feel it's the most efficient, reliable way. However, please don't take my word and personal experience as the gospel. I have heard other hobbyists claim that the fish can help. If you like the fish, and can accommodate it and it's behaviors- go for it. However, if that is a potential problem, I'd continue with the tedious but effective practice of manual extraction. Hope this helps a bit. Good luck in your battle! Regards, Scott F.> Re: Dictyota - Rabbitfish or Naso? Dictyota- The Algae from Hell (Cont'd) 9/10/08 Hello Scott, <Hello again!> thank you for your answer & wishes - so the prospectus of getting rid of the algae is not very good... I had already read numerous scientific articles regarding the vast array of herbivore deterring secondary metabolites of this genus but had hoped that there was some animal liking the stuff (or at least eating it with disgust - I wouldn't mind). But it seems that in this case the cure could be worse than the disease - if that is possible. <Oh, it can be...> Best regards to all of you & keep up the good work, Alex <As an interesting side note: After my MACNA talk on algae last week, an attendee shared that he utilized a Scopas Tang (Zebrasoma scopas) to eat this stuff! Go figure...and ugly Tang with a beautiful appetite! Good luck! Regards, Scott F.>
Dictyota control and Rabbitfish - 05/02/07 I am a loyal reader of the WWM site, and have gained a tremendous amount of expert advice and guidance, paying no more than a couple of mouse clicks and some key strokes. For that reason, I feel obligated to share something that I have come across, hoping to give a small piece back to the WWM community. <I/we thank you> I have a 125 Gallon reef tank, with 2 bubble tip anemones (was one, split a few months back), 1 large branching Acropora , 1 large Montipora , 1 orange plate coral, 1 green open brain, 1 clam, several branches of frogspawn, and other assorted small corals. Also swimming are 2 Solomon Island Black Perculas , 1 royal Gramma , 1 Kole Tang, and 2 clown gobys. About 6 months ago, I started to get an algae bloom of what I would later learn was the dreaded Dictyota . Unaware of its nature, I tried to remove the Dictyota , but this only made things worse, spreading like wildfire around the tank. I was removing tons of it every week, but I was only managing to keep it short, it was covering about 2/3 of the visible rock in the tank. I only managed to keep corals from being choked out by siphoning off chunks of the Dictyota that surrounded each one 2X a week. I did my research on line, where urchins, diadema , and sea hares were all rumored to eat the stuff'¦.they didn't. The owner of my LFS said that he knew no way of ridding the tank, short of a 2 month lights out period (that would not be so good for the corals). Naso tangs were also rumored to eat the Dictyota, and in fact on ate some at the store so I brought him home. He started to eat the stuff, but then after one day, refused to eat anymore, and he died a couple of weeks later. If seemed to me that he may have died from eating the algae, which I hear can be noxious. Not wanting to kill another fish, I decided on a last resort, something I had seen written somewhere obliquely on a posting. I bought a two-barred Rabbitfish . He didn't eat anything for the first two days in the tank. On day three, I saw him nibbling a little on the algae. Over the next three weeks, I saw him actively swimming, and nipping only once in while. Yet his belly seemed full, near bursting. It has now been only a month, and the Dictyota is all but completely gone. I cannot believe I have my tank back. I still am in shock that 8 months worth of frustration is over. It seems impossible to me that this tiny wonder of about 3 inches ate what must of amounted to 8 lbs of algae or more. With the algae gone (hopefully never to return), I now have a hero of a fish, who instead of dining on Dictyota , will enjoy a life of Nori , greens, herbivore preparations, and protein. I am not sure if you have a forum for this, <Oh yes... both for Rabbitfish Selection and Brown Macrophyte control> but please share this with your readers. Searches for info on the subject brought about frustratingly pessimistic analyses. I want to let people know that Dictyota can be defeated, and all it takes is a three inch lawnmower called the two-barred Rabbitfish . Brant Goldsmith <Thank you for sharing. Bob Fenner> Dealing With Dictyota - 04/27/07 Hi Crew, <<Hello Tim>> Thanks for taking my e-mail today! <<Quite welcome>> I have a primarily SPS reef tank that has been pretty successful for almost three years now. However, in the past few months I have experienced problems with my AquaC Remora Pro protein skimmer. I am sending it to the manufacturer to get fixed. <<Ah, very good...Jason Kim is a great guy and will take good care of/will treat you right>> Since the problems, I have experienced a slow but steady outbreak of brown algae (Dictyota sp. as ID from your website). <<This alga requires iodine...if you are dosing iodine; the removal of the skimmer may be allowing a sufficient surplus now to feed the Dictyota>> It should also be noted that I have a refugium with Chaetomorpha spp algae to export nutrients. <<Excellent...am a BIG fan of vegetable refugiums>> Once I get my nutrient export (protein skimmer) in control I want to try and combat this alga (I do 20 percent water changes weekly so I don't think it will take too long). <<Maybe so>> It grows in a relatively low lying morphology and is rather hard to crop. <<Isn't that always the case? [grin]>> Is there a species of snail, hermit, fish, etc. that has a taste for this brown algae? <<A Naso Tang is a good choice, if your system is large enough...else you might try a Salarias or Atrosalarias blenny species>> I haven't seen anything this specific on your site. <<Hmmm...I'm pretty sure both of these are mentioned somewhere...maybe for a different species of brown alga>> My goal is to crop out as much as I can by hand and then let the rest slowly die off from predation and lack of nutrients (when the skimmer is fixed). <<Sounds like a plan>> Thanks for the help! Tim Dictyota Algae Control 1/23/07 Crew, <Jeff> I've
been struggling with Dictyota in a 29 gallon for a while. It has
invaded every inch of the tank - as I mistakenly allowed it to spread
before I realized how invasive it is - and outcompetes my zoanthids
unless I dedicate a substantial amount of time to manual extraction.
I've been toying with the idea of adding a long-spined urchin. Is a
29 gallon (with roughly 30 lbs. of live rock and a 1/2" sand bed)
too small for a small long-spined urchin? If not, how long could I
house the urchin in the tank before it outgrew it? I'm pretty
confident I will have room for a large tank in 2-3 years. Thanks for
all your help and the website. <Jeff, rapid growth of this specie of
algae usually indicates a high nutrient level in the
water. When nutrient levels are low, they can be
out-competed by other species of algae (Caulerpa, etc) more suited to a
lesser nutrient content in the system. It may be difficult
to find an animal that eats this specie of algae as they contain some
very potent anti-predation chemicals. I don't believe an
urchin will help you here as most graze on hair algae. Do
read here and linked files above for more help on eliminating this
algae by means of nutrient control. http://www.wetwebmedia.com/nutrientcontrol.htm I'd
consider a small hang-on refugium to propagate Caulerpa
algae. James (Salty Dog)> -Jeff
Urchin saves the day - eating Dictyota 2/2/04 Hello again Anthony, I wanted to give you an update about our Dictyota problem. Our urchin is now eating it. :) <outstanding to hear. I do love those urchins> We could not be more happy to see the right upper half of the tank free from this plague. Slowly the little urchin is going to town on it. Mark took a picture of the urchin to the SeaBay meeting but he never got the chance to show it to you. <Awww... no worries. DO send it here if you like> We are now sure it must be a long spined urchin. I hope he keeps up eating the Dictyota. If it eats all of micro algae will it be happy to eat any coralline algae? We don't want it to starve. <hmmm... tough to say. If so, I don't think it will survive on it. Fortunately, they will scavenge food bits. Offer an algae based frozen food and likely it will be fine (2-3 times weekly) after the nuisance algae is gone> Sincerely, Clair & Mark Dawson <best regards, my friends. Anthony> Nuisance Dictyota Algae 1/7/03 Anthony- I hope it is OK
to write to you here. Amy told me it would be better to write to this
address with my question. If I messed up I do apologize. <no
worries my friend... very welcome to e-mail here or any addy I have
(readingtrees.com , yahoo.com, etc). Its nice here though as answers
can be shared/archived for the benefit of others. Very sorry for the
delay by the way... I left for the Colorado Rockies on Friday when you
e-mailed and just got back> I have a question about a Dictyota
problem we are having. <Arghhh! Can be pretty to look at, but
becomes a nuisance> Some back round about my tank as follows:
125 gallon, 2X250 watt radium's. Euro-reef skimmer and a 45 gallon
refugium. Ammonia nitrite nitrate all test zero and our ph is 8.2
during the day 8.0 at night. Alk 11dkh and CA 375. We keep the temp at
81 degrees. A 4" DSB and 140 pounds of live rock. We have a
mixed reef that I know you will not like to hear about. Sorry about
that. <heehee... no worries. Just try to focus/group better
animals (more natural/biotopic or akin/"amiable" species)
when possible> We get preached about it all of time but I am
not going to change it no matter what my husband or Amy tells me.
Sorry. You can chew me out if we meet soon. <you are safe :)
> About the Dictyota. It has spread all over the rocks. We
pull it out daily and mess with the skimmer so that we can get a least
1/2 cup of dark stuff each day. We have tried every animal we can think
of to eat this and nothing has. <indeed... it can be highly
invasive, is noxious and not readily controlled by herbivores>
A Longspined urchin was put in two weeks ago with the hope of it eating
the Dictyota but it only eats the coralline. Do you have any
suggestions? <hmmm... odd. Diadema urchins are one of the few
that are likely to control it. They are also one of the least likely
urchins to eat coralline. De send a pic or recheck the ID of your
urchin. I wonder if its a Diadema?> We are afraid for our LPS
after reading about this algae in your new book. <being an
educated consumer gives you the freedom to shop anywhere... including
the less knowledgeable places. Great stuff to be found even there (and
often so) as long as you have done your homework. Don't give up on
that LFS just yet :) > Thank you for any advice you can give.
I hope my husband and I can meet you at the SeaBay club this month.
Kindly Clair <outstanding!... be seeing you soon :)
Anthony> Dictyota Hi Crew <Joe> I am at the verge of tossing all my live rock in the trash. I have had a Dictyota outbreak in my 90 gal for a while now. I bought a small Naso that wiped it out but as we know the Naso was too big and now resides in a 200 gal. I have an ev120 skimmer and a 30 gal sump with macros growing. I do 10/15 gal water changes weekly with 0 TDS. I don't know what to do. <Re?> Joe Culler, <You could kill off this brown algae by placing your LR in the dark for a few weeks... Bob Fenner>
|
|
Features: |
|
Featured Sponsors: |