Coral Eating Blue Linckia... Diet Is Not Well Understood 11/13/2007
Heya WWM. crew.
<Hi James, Mich here!>
I've had a Blue Linckia Starfish in my system for a little over a year now.
<Mmm, These typically don't do well in captivity. Their natural diet is not well understood. They seldom live over 18 months in captivity, typically dying from starvation.>
While everything has been great with him/her up until last week. When I was doing my daily inspection of the tank and residents, I noticed my starfish was at the base of my Kenya Tree coral. I thought nothing of it and went about my business. The following day I noticed that the Kenya Tree appeared "withered" and upon closer inspection it looked torn and "chewed". I decided to keep a close eye on the coral and within a week it seemed to heal itself and was happy dandy.
<These are pretty hardy corals.>
Yesterday while doing my inspection I noticed the Blue Linckia at the base of the coral again (this time on the other side of the Kenya). And upon waking today see that the coral is wither and chewed again.
<Linckia sounds like it's trying to find food wherever it can.>
Is this common with Blue Linckia Stars?
<I have not heard of this.>
Or do you think there is something underneath the coral he/she is trying to reach, and basically "chewing" the coral out of the way?
<Perhaps... again the foods necessary for survival are not documented.>
Thanks in advance,
<Welcome!>
James

Linckia Problem/Aquarium Suitability - 07/28/06
Hi,
<<Hello>>
I have a blue Linckia that has been happy in my tank for several months.  I have a 20 gal tank, with 20 pounds of Live Rock.
<<My friend...suitability of this animal for aquarium use aside, this tank/volume of live rock is much too small for the continued good health of this animal>>
The only other inhabitants are two Ocellaris Clowns.  The Starfish has always been extremely active and even now is climbing one of the intake pipes in the tank.
<<Mmm, indeed...furtively searching for food...starving...>>
What I am concerned about however is what looks like a white cut or graze on one of the legs.  He is still quite active but I am wondering what this is likely to be, and whether or not it is treatable.
<<Likely the result/culmination of nutritional deficiency...adding/changing out old for new live rock may help but these stars rarely recover in aquarium settings.  Even so, you would only be delaying the inevitable.  This genus of starfish has a dismal survival record.  Those that survive the collection/shipping process still acclimate poorly...those that survive acclimation are usually doomed to slow starvation.  This starfish rarely, if ever, accepts offered foodstuffs (clam, shrimp, whatever), and thus requires large amounts of live rock in order to meet its nutritional requirements...which may also beg the question "is this animal truly reef-safe" as it will surely scour the emergent life from your rock.>>
My nitrates are 0.0, but my SG is slightly high.
<<Tells me nothing...what is "slightly high"?>>
Any suggestions would be appreciated.
<<Unfortunately there's probably little you can do for the star at this point.  But for future reference, I would like to suggest one of the smaller and hardier, easier to feed Fromia species would be better suited to your tank>>
Regards,
Simon Ashby
<<Cheers, Eric Russell>>

Linckia help, please?   7/7/06
I've been a fan of your website for a few months now but haven't really been sure how to ask a question.  If this is the wrong way, please let me
know the right way?
<Mmm, this be it>
Background: 55 Gallon Reef setup since January (moved in May), 2 false clownfish, 3 giant turbo snails, 3 conch snails, 7 hermit crabs, 1 blue
Linckia starfish, 1 lawnmower blenny.
Ph 8.0,
nitrates, nitrites, ammonia 0
temp 78
I purchased the star w/o doing enough homework.  Once we got him home (about 3 weeks ago) I did a lot of research and am now really thankful he
has survived.  I can't find any definitive source on what to feed him and the blenny (bought this week).  We have a LOT of algae in the tank and I
leave the back wall and sides unscraped.  We have about 75 pounds of live rock.  Is this enough to support everyone we have?
<Only time can/will tell... genus Linckia stars feed on numerous small animals, algae, detritus...>
  Have I overstocked my cleaning crew?
<Mmm, well, the Conch will eventually be too big...>
  I have a hard time thinking yes since we still have a lot of algae, but I want to be sure.  I feed the fish/crabs marine cuisine
(1/2 cube twice a day) and everyone seems happy.  I just want to make sure they stay that way.  Any suggestions?
Thank you,
Renée Bress
<Mmm... not given the information presented... Perhaps other than reinforce your statement re investigating before buying. If you had/have a much larger well-established system, I'd move the Linckia to this. Bob Fenner>

-The incredible shrinking Linckia-
I have a blue Linckia that is orange in color. <Isn't that an oxymoron? :) > I have had it for over six months. She  moves around actively has no sores of any sort.  The problem is that she keeps getting smaller and smaller, I feel that she may be starving what can I do, I don't want to lose her? <Unfortunately, this is all too common with Linckia stars, especially larger ones. Since their diet consists of mainly microfauna, it takes a pretty large and well established tank to keep them truckin'. You can hand feed them by placing bits of seafood (got any sponge based marine angel food?) on the substrate in front of it's path or literally drop it right on top. Try this a few times per week or more. Good luck! -Kevin>

Blue Linckia, leopard wrasses and angels
Good evening Bob!
<cheers, bub... Anthony Calfo in your service>
Well, I know you've probably heard this a hundred times now.... I bought something for once without doing any research, a blue Linckia~ I was at a wholesalers and it was $5 and I've always wanted one. 
<impulse and cheap price... a recipe for death>
Don't shoot me! 
<oops...sorry. I jumped the gun on the harassment>
As soon as I put it in the tank it promptly disappeared into the woodwork, "Great! I just bought a lovely blue star that I'll never see!" hehe. 
<or worse... it will starve, dwindle and die back in the rockwork and wipe out the while tank when you go on vacation. Have a nice Holiday! <G>>
He's being more social nowadays and hanging around the clams. (Been in the tank about 2 weeks now) I read the FAQs and he's relatively healthy, he was kind of a grey/blue when I bought him, but he's not "cob webbing" or anything. Ok, my question is do they have any food requirements other than detritus and micro creatures? 
<wow... these starfish like most sea stars need a lot of food. If you do not/cannot target feed them weekly if not daily, then they need very large aquariums (over 100 gallons) and very mature displays (well over 1 year old with a lot of live rock). Else they will slowly starve over a period of months like most. Surely not to live beyond one year, I am truly sorry to say>
Currently he's in one of the most beautiful/healthy 58gal tanks in Miami that has been established for over 5 years. ;] It has a 3"+ fine sand bed, tons of little benthic critters, etc. 
<awesome... the maturity of the tank is a tremendous help. Still... spatially... it is a bit small in surface area to sustain this deposit feeder. Especially if you have any blennies, gobies, tangs, etc that graze the rock competitively>
Other than fish food (Spirulina flakes and pellets) I feed the tank Dt's concentrated plankton every other night, which the brittle stars seem to love. Also, are Linckias nocturnal? 
<yes>
It doesn't seem to move around during the day at all, like the brittle stars. Is it normal for Linckias to stay in the same position for a day and a half or more? 
<common for imported ones...duress>
Do they feed on diatoms that accumulate on the glass as well as feeding on stuff in the sand? 
<not only diatom algae per se>
His suckers seem to be in good shape, nothing looks irregular. 
<good to hear... a good sign>
Just they move really slowly, so a person tends to worry. 
<understood>
And he doesn't seem to get all excited like the brittle stars when I add plankton. ;] 
<true... he is a strict detritivore... no suspension feeding at all>
On another note, (thanks for reading all this, I have a special skill at rambling!) would a leopard wrasse and a yellow Coris wrasse be compatible? 
<likely not... and you truly must avoid putting a leopard wrasse in a tank this small. They are categorically very difficult to sustain for more than a year or two. Best success is in huge aquaria (over 200 gall) with few other fishes>
And would they be compatible with a bicolor blenny? 
<stick with the yellow Coris and you will likely be fine... although there is always a chance of territorial aggression from the blenny>
(My bi-color is currently in my 10gal nano, where he is king, I can't wait to see his expression when I put him in the 58g that I'll be moving to once my boyfriend has the 75g setup, heehee Two reefers living under the same roof is a dangerous combination. ;]). Also, are Rusty Angels reef safe, hardy, okay for keeping w/ above mentioned fish? 
<now that's a hardy choice :) Seriously... a fine angel. Reasonably hardy and easy to feed... tends to be long-lived in captivity. As far as reef safe... eh... as reef safe as dwarf angels get (nibbler)>
If so, should I keep a pair or single? Okay, that's it I swear!! 
<oh... you are headed for a smack <G>. You do recall that you have a 58 gallon aquarium, don't you :) >
Oh, can you sex bicolors? 
<is this a trick question... Ok, I'll bite: yes... the male is the one wearing the smoking jacket and the female wears a silk Kimono>
The males are so pretty during mating time. 
<OK>
Thanks so much for everything, I think you guys are awesome and I hope to know as much as you do someday. Sweet dreams~ Morgan Moore
<ha! Thank you for putting up with the wise guy in your luck if the draw. Best regards, my friend>

Starving Sea Star??
Dear Bob- (or Anthony...)
<cheers, mate>
I have been reading your FAQs and I emailed the other day about my orange Linckia. Exactly what kind of greens and meat do I need to feed him so I don't overfeed the tank or underfeed him? 
<tough to say... we first need to ID the genus of the star. Numerous genera are collectively shipped as "Linckia sp". Please scour the web, this site, Indo Pacific Field Guides, other books etc to get a genus and species of possible. In the meantime, simply a wide variety of frozen foods like you would feed a Marine angelfish to be specific>
(29 gal reef tank, 2 months old, 2 clowns, 2 cleaner shrimp, 1 horseshoe crab (3"), 1 orange Linckia and 35 lbs of live rock! 
<for what its worth... I'm certain that the horseshoe will die in their tank in 6-12 months despite your best efforts. They need a lot of food and a lot of room to grow, scavenge, bury/forage. They need huge tanks!>
(seems like the Linckia goes around the rocks once, ends up on the glass and sits there. I clean the front glass so I can see the tank whole idea of reef tank!) and he sits on the clean glass. 
<alas... not indicative of anything specific, my friend>
After reading your info, I figure I need a protein skimmer, is the SeaClone™ Protein
Skimmer ok for me? 
<Ahhh... do read through the FAQs on this topic. Or visit the message boards. You'll find that most people like me won't even take this skimmer for free! You can add Prisms, Berlin and Nautilus to this category for me. I like to get a lot more bang for my buck... my strong advice without spending too much money would be an Aqua C Remora (for hang on the tank <H.O.T.>) or Tunze's smallest unit (model 210)... see here at General Aquatics:
http://www.generalaquatics.com/myProducts.cfm?CFID=382338&CFTOKEN=23764741
&parentcategoryid=1%7Cprotein%20skimmers&categoryid=1|protein%20skimmers&
vendoridtoDisplay=21|Tunze&collection=1%7Cprotein% 20skimmers >
I don't want to take all the food out of the water for the star, but I notice it is getting cloudy! 
<not sure that I follow the last comment? In reference to skimmer efficiency? If so... no worries... Seastars are deposit feeders. If in relation to target feeding... no pieces should be left more than a few hours to rot and cause cloudy water> 
Please help and thank you very much!! Ron 
<I sincerely thank you for caring, my friend. I truly believe that your empathy will make you a fine and successful aquarist. Best regards, Anthony>

Re: Orange Linckia (Target Feeding Deposit feeders/ Sea stars)
What is the best way to feed these guys ? 29 gal tank with 2 bags live sand and 35 pounds of live rock. Tank only a couple of months old.
<hmmm... going to be challenging here to be honest. Most would say the tank is too small to conceivably support a sea star. If possible, small daily feedings of a great variety of foods (green and meaty). Perhaps consider making a homemade food recipe (many on the net and in Bob's book, on WetWebMedia, etc)... freeze all in party cube trays and offer the star a food cube daily (mixed nutritious fare with vitamins) from the substrate>
Have 2 clowns, 1 horseshoe, 
<Doh! er... Horseshoe crab? Forgetting the adult size of about 12" in diameter... there will be no easy way of providing enough food in the sand to keep this crab alive in such a small tank. Too bad... indeed a fascinating creature. My string advice is to get this crab to an aquarist with at least a 200 gallon tank and DSB. In the meantime, bury mysids in the same place daily just under the sand (other meaty foods too of course for variety)>
1 linkia,2 skunk cleaners shrimp. I feed spectrum daily as well as Mysis shrimp (every other day), I have a few shrimp left on the sand when creatures are done eating. Can I hand feed a Linckia??? 
<yep>
Small children perhaps?? 
<only if they misbehave or seem inclined to vote Democrat in the future>
Thanks a lot for your response. Ron
<my great pleasure... best regards, Anthony>