|
Home | Marine Aquariums |
Freshwater Aquariums |
Planted Aquariums |
Brackish Systems |
Ponds,
lakes & fountains |
Turtles & Amphibians |
Aquatic Business |
Aquatic Science |
Ask the WWM Crew a Question |
Please visit our Sponsors | ||||
What Could Be Wrong? (Mysterious Coral Death)
11/23/08 Hi Eric, <<Hello Michael>> Hope you are
well, down in South Carolina. <<Its a bit chilly at the moment
(40s), but otherwise fine>> Christmas is around the corner. Are
you ready for it? <<Nope [grin]>> Well this time it is not
a fish problem. They seem to be doing fine, except for two Banggai
Cardinal, who don't seem to love one another, so I guess I have to
remove one of them. <<Very common with this species>> But
this time it is more of a "coral problem" so to speak. Well
at least, I think so. I have just lost a leather coral (Cladiella sp.)
And I am trying to figure out why. I don't have that many corals in
my tank. I bought most of them without knowing much about them.
<<Not too late to learn>> But the latest coral I added to
the tank was almost a year ago, before I knew anything about
WetWebMedia (phew). Since then I have come to understand that the
mixture I have could cause trouble. <<Ah>> So there is
"plenty of room between them. I have Galaxea, Bubble coral, Open
brain, Lobophyllia, Euphyllia Paradivisa (which have grown BIG) Kenya
Tree, an Acropora, Candy Cane coral (which is also expanding much).
<<An aggressive and noxious mix indeed but very common among the
majority of hobbyists>> But until recently everything was fine.
Some time ago the leather Coral seemed to start to shrink and then it
started to dissolve. <<Likely a reaction to allelopathy>>
The latest test results showed the following: Nitrite 0, Nitrate, 0-1,
pH 8.3 Ca, 410 Mg 1390, Phosphate 0, and Ammonium 0. I have also
started to get a little bit of algae. I do a 3 gallon water change
every week <<You might need to increase this>> (RO water)
and top of with pH adjusted RO water. I thought the light could be the
problem. I changed my HQI bulb in May, but for some reason it stopped
working in July. They did not have a brand new of the one I use (250 W
14000 Kelvin) but they had one in one of their lamps that they
didn't use anymore, which I was told was almost new. I went into
the store today, to talk with the owner; he told me that the bulb was
from February/March, so when I bought it in July it wasn't exactly
new when I bought it. Could this be the culprit? <<I'm
doubtful? Your problem is probably a chemical issue>> The store
manager told me it could be a lack of trace elements (I do not add
anything except Calcium, and occasionally magnesium, and on a rare
occasion iodine). <<Your weekly water changes should take care of
any trace element issues this too is not the/a problem>> I use
Tropic Marin salt for water changes. <<An excellent salt
mix>> I do have some bottles of "Trace Hard" and
"Trace Soft" from Salifert, but I don't use them.
<<And probably don't need to>> I have only used them a
few times, but after I read Bob's book I have refrained from them.
The manager loaned me a new bulb, to try and see if that was the
problem. In a way that will be the easy solution, but the bulb costs
$100. But what are your thoughts Eric? Please let me know. <<Well
Michael, based on your info here all I can suggest at this point is
that you add/increase your chemical filtration. Some carbon and or
Poly-Filter, with a bit larger weekly water change, should help
somewhat with the chemical war-fare being waged in your system>>
Thanks, Take care my friend, Michael Fick <<Always welcome mate.
Eric Russell>> Coral Issues 8-19-08 Re: Coral issues- some affected, some doing great... (corrected - Mike) Hello all, <Lovely evening...Mike Maddox here tonight> Seeking your expertise once again. <Alrighty then> Having an issue with my 90 gallon tank (35gal sump/refugium). Water parameters are all normal, and I'm running 350w of metal halide and 4x65watts PC lighting, loads of liverock. I recently moved my setup to this bigger tank. I went out of town about 2 weeks later, came back, and some things were amiss regarding corals (fish are all great with the exception of 3 mysteriously missing green Chromis). My water is heavily skimmed, I'm using Chemi pure, and have much macroalgae. My green button polyps and pagoda cup are not looking too good. My Zoanthids, green star polyps, hairy mushrooms, and watermelon mushrooms were doing poorly, but are okay now. Lastly, my hammer coral, orange mushrooms, yellow Anthozoan spp, leathers, toadstool (redundancy?), Ricordea, and open brain are doing very well. What would cause this differential harm? My green buttons are near death, some are falling off. I've had them for years, they're very hardy. I would blame the tank change, but they were thriving for a few weeks after it. No animals are harassing the corals. Lastly, I have some green frogspawn which has been acting goofy for a few weeks (before the tank change, even). It is not extending like normal (hypoextended), but certain parts of it are hyper extending, almost like they're all sweeper tentacles. Its very strange..... <Two things pop out at me: 1) you've fallen into what I call the "Reefcentral trap" aka thinking that everything and its mom needs halides, and the more wattage, the better, and 2) your tank is probably 'too clean' for the animals you're keeping. It's easy to think that a coral is a coral, but this isn't the case. When you visit a reef, you wouldn't believe the vast array of different living conditions that different species are found in. A separation of 5 feet could literally be a different world to a coral. Background info aside, you are keeping coral species that don't need nearly the amount of light you're using! These corals are being photoinhibited and stressed, to say the least, and most likely underfed as well. Ditch those halides permanently, and start feeding your corals - if you have a 90 long you're fine with just the PCs, if you have a 90 tall you may want to get T5s)> Thanks! <Anytime> Whit <M. Maddox> Small SW env. issues, photo-shock of Cnid.s 8/12/08 Hello, before I even start I want to thank you guys for helping me out. I read on this site regularly and it is very helpful. I have a 36 gallon corner tank that has been set up for about a year. 45lbs live rock, 3-4" sandbed, Aqua C Remora skimmer, 4 Hydor Koralia #1 powerheads, and a Marineland canister filter, <Mmmm> weekly 10% water changes, good husbandry. Approx. 15 species of coral <! In this small volume?> mostly LPS and softies. LPS include (2 Caulastrea, 1 large Favia, 1 Euphyllia- sold as a hammer, Duncan, 2 suns), mushrooms, leather, green star polyps, colt, and several different zoo's. All except 1 candy cane doing exceptional. <-ly> Recently I had one of my light fixtures decide to self destruct, it was a 130w Coralife PC fixture. Immediately I ordered a 4-bulb 96w nova extreme T5 online to replace it. However while I was waiting for it to arrive, I only had 1- 48w nova extreme T5 H.O. and 1- 36w nova extreme T5 on the tank.. knowing this was not enough light, I watched the corals closely and was hoping that they would endure while I waited for my new light. (during this time I fed daily with marine snow, reef-roids and coral vitalizer) They looked ok, not great, for a week. My new light arrives and like a total rookie excited to try it out, I fire it up without acclimating the corals to the light. Now my favourite candy cane is sloughing off one of it's heads. It is a large green candy cane with about 15 heads and has done exceptionally well until just recently. With all of this said, a few questions. Am I right in assuming that the over-illumination is most likely the cause for this tissue sloughing in an otherwise healthy tank? <Yes... along with the previous week of low lighting> Should I attempt to remove the head or tissue because it is hanging down about an inch (would be almost impossible because it is right in the middle of the coral) - or - If I just leave it, can it recover? <It can... I would leave as is... unless you have a well-established system/area to move it to elsewise... I would only remove the tissue if it becomes obviously necrotic (likely falling off)> The only thing I test anymore on this tank is Calcium and Alkalinity, because it has been stable for so long. So I won't give you all the values, however I can provide them if you think it's relevant. I really don't want to lose this coral so I hope you can lead me in the right direction. Thanks from Canada, Torry <I would pre-mix and have stored about as much new seawater as you can... clean out the mechanical media in the canister filter (in seawater) and add a unit of Chemipure or equivalent to it. Bob Fenner> Garlic 5/18/08 Garlic and Corals-Recipe for Trouble? Hi All: Can one of you tell me if garlic is toxic to corals? Thanks, RB <Interesting question. As far as I know there is no documented toxicity issue with garlic and corals. The theory behind the use of corals is that Allicin, the chemical compound found in fresh garlic, has long been known to have some anti-parasitic properties. Although I do not consider it an effective "cure" for parasitic maladies, it may be It is thought that this stuff works with fishes because it may mask parasites' chemoreceptors with its partially sulfurous chemical signature. There is, however, no apparent danger to corals or their symbiotic algae. Besides, you are typically adding garlic extracts via food, and much is probably processed by the fishes. However, I would not overdo this stuff, as it does cause protein skimmers to accumulate an oily film in the collection cup, and acquire that wonderful garlic aroma (which is actually preferable to my skimmer's typical smell). If you're going to use garlic, use per the manufacturer's directions, and simply don't overdo it. Hope this helps! Regards, Scott F.> Coral Extension 04/07/2008 Hi Crew, <<Hello, Andrew today>> First off thank you for the great web site as I work at a locally owned pet store and in the fish department I am continually referring customers to your web site for set up and random questions that we at the store don't know the answer to. <<All sounds great>> Now I find that I must take my own advice and ask you a question; <<Ok>> I have a 29 gallon oceanic bio cube set up for saltwater for just about a full year now and for the past 2 or 3 months none of my few corals that I have are extended. My tank set up and parameters are as follows in the 1st filter chamber I have a custom built protein skimmer that runs on a lime wood diffuser, in the 2nd chamber layers of sponges decreasing in size then occasionally some activated carbon. <<Ensure maintenance is strict with all these sponges. Wash weekly, change sections monthly, and wash filter media in used tank water>> I have about 25 lbs of live rock in the tank and about 20 lbs of live sand. As for lighting I replaced the power compact lights about 4 months ago and about 2 months ago added 2 of the current usa PowerBrite high output 50/50 LED strips in the hood as well. The photoperiod is 13 hours with 30 minutes of just the actinic and the LEDs on either side of the day light. <<Suggest dropping the lighting period. 8 hours per day is more than enough>> My water parameters to me all look fine ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate are constantly 0, ph is 8.2, calcium is 460 ppm, KH is 8 dKH, my salinity is a little high at about 1.026, <<That's ok at 1.026>> and the temp is kept at a constant 80.2 degrees. My only fish inhabitants are 2 tomato clownfish and 1 Foxface Rabbitfish , I know he will get to big I have a 80 to move him up to, and I have probably 5 hermits crabs and a piece of newly added dragon's breath. My corals are only a purple mushroom, a branching hammer coral, a closed brain, and some star polyps, if I remember correctly they are white (see its been that long since they have been open). The supplements that I add on a weekly basis are API Strontium, Iodine, I add calcium or purple up as needed to raise the calcium levels and I also add Coral Accel. <<Corals are probably white due to bleaching. Maybe change the location in the tank, up higher. Stop adding all the trace elements and only add what shows as a deficiency on a test kit. Certainly stop adding Purple up, iodine and Coral Accel and Strontium. Trace elements will be replenished via water changes, 10% per week. Calcium, well, that depends on the uptake, and your test kit will tell you if this needs to be added or not>> My corals that I had haven't opened up like I said in about 2 or 3 months and the star polyps, which are new because I thought the others were dead, haven't opened up at all. They are at about mid level in the tank with the exception of the brain which is on the sand. <<Does the brain let out tentacles at night after lights off? Could be suffering a lighting deficiency here>> My mushroom actually decided that it wanted to jump off of my rock and now I suspect that it is dead. Is there anything that you can possibly think of that might be causing all of this? <<Lighting is one possibility as you don't mention how many watts are on the tank. A chemical overdose is another stronger possibility from the elements you have been adding, hence stop using them>> Steven <<Thanks for the questions, hope this helps. A Nixon>> QT of corals -03/27/08 Hi, I plan on buying a
mushroom coral and a toadstool coral to add to my tank. I would like to
put them in QT for about one month. I have read the articles on QT of
inverts on WWM and feel I am prepared. However, I have a question about
lighting. I have a 20G long QT tank that I can light with three
standard AGA fluorescent strip lights about 20W each. I believe they
come standard with 8800K or 9250K bulbs. Will this be sufficient and is
the K. alright for these corals? <This depends on the lighting under
which you plan to ultimately put them (in your display). Ideally, the
QT lighting should be similar to the lighting over the ultimate
destination of the corals. As for the K values, yes, typically
aquarists use bulbs with K values ranging from 6500 to 20000.>
Thanks <Best,
Sick mushroom coral and bubble coral... no reading, use of WWM 2/19/08 I've had my mushroom coral for a month and it was doing fine - always spread out and looking happy - up until yesterday. Yesterday when I looked at my tank the mushroom and the small rock it sits on had fallen off the bigger rock they sit on and fell face down in the sand. <Oooh> I picked it up as soon as possible and put it back on the rock. Its been a bit shriveled ever since, and now it is completely shriveled up and looks like it has a tear in it with lots of tiny white things in the tear. <Not good> My bubble coral has also been ill for about a week. Some parts of it look fine whilst others are shriveled and also look torn, and it usually has one of its mouths wide open. Am I supposed to be feeding it? <... Yes!> I don't know what it eats. <My friend... why are you writing us? This is posted. Read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/caryfdgfaqs.htm > What do you think is wrong with it? I did a water change yesterday and I don't think the salt was fully dissolved when I put the new water in and both the bubble and mushroom gave off a cobweb-like substance. Would that have had anything to do with it? <Keep reading. Learn to/use the indices, search tool on WWM...> I add marine snow <Worthless. Worse than worthless... Of no nutritive value whatsoever> and calcium to my water, and use a sand with extra calcium in it. But I have not been able to measure my calcium levels as my LFS hasn't had any in since I bought the bubble coral. My water parameters = Ammonia - 3.6, Nitrate - less than 5, Nitrite - less than 0.1, pH - 7.5-8.0, copper - 0 <... keep reading. Bob Fenner>
Snow storm... Phosphate removal rxn on Cnid.s 1/3/08 Hi Crew, Small 10 gallon saltwater tank. I bought a filter pad that is made for reducing phosphates. I was able to cut out two pieces to match my filter. I put in the first one almost 8 weeks ago and it did a good job. I hardly have any hair algae left. The water was not going through so easily so I just replaced it with the second pad and I noticed white flecks coming out of the filter. By morning I had what looked like the aftermath of a snow storm. The part of the tank directly in front of the filter was covered in white. Sand and mushrooms and candy canes. <Mmm, these need some soluble phosphate...> The mushrooms were closing up. I contacted the seller and after convincing them it was not pods they said it may be some of the phosphate remover from the pad. <Maybe> How important is it to remove from the tank. <I would> They did not think it was much of an issue other than to remove from the corals. I rinsed it well before I put it in the tank so I do not know why this pad was different than the first being that they both are from one big pad. <I don't think "it" is the pad per se, but a reaction/series from the pad... the life...> Anyway the main concern is will it harm anything by staying on the sand. Thanks <I would remove the new pad. Bob Fenner> Corals suddenly wilted! A joke? No useful data, or
reading 12/12/07 so. This happened a couple days ago
and finally finished yesterday. I came home to look @ my tank and saw
that all of my hairy mushrooms, my branching hammer coral and another
branching polyp coral had all suddenly wilted and looked dead. Around
the rock where the hairy mushrooms were, a cloudy milky white ooze was
covering the rock and some of the mushrooms were completely gone. The
other 2 corals were near it seem to be affected by what ever happened.
The rest of the corals and fish in the tank seem to be ok. What
happened?! Can they be saved or should I say a prayer for them now... I
have already pulled them out of the tank and put them in a bucket with
a heater and fresh saltwater... please help! ~mike <Uhh, can't
tell you much from the data presented... no information re your system,
water quality, foods/feeding... What you list can't all be simply
jammed in together in a small volume though. Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/cnidcompppt.htm and the linked files
above... And soon... your system is crashing. Bob Fenner> Candy cane/ torch coral loss, help please! 8/23/07 Hi Crew, I have a 37 gallon salt water reef tank. My nitrates are in the o.k. range, and my filtration system is (2) 50 gallon aqua clear filters, lighting is coral life, 30in 130 watt fixture, (1) T-5 30in 36 watt fixture, salinity perfect, 50 lbs of live rock. I have torch coral that shrivels, falls apart, dies one head at a time, (no brown slime). I also have been battling red algae (with frequent water changes & rock cleaning) which seems to also be on the stem of the torch coral. <These events may be related...> I do maintain an arsenal of snails in the tank. How can I salvage what is left of my torch coral?? <Break off the living heads, or the dead ones... move the live part/s to another system> I also have candy cane coral which appears to have some sort of pale yellow calcified growths with one small tube protruding out per growth. The growth surrounds the base of the heads and at this point I have lost 3. The growth is starting to appear on the live rock at various points in the tank. What should I do to save the rest of my coral and do I need to eradicate the growth, and if so, how?? Thanks, JP <"Frag momma frag, whatcha gonna do?" Need to discern what the real/root cause/s of the trouble in this one system is/are... and fix... "Small systems are hard to keep stable, optimized"... Perhaps a cursory reading on WWM re toxic tanks will bring something live to your consciousness. Bob Fenner> Corals seriously have something against my
tank!!! 8/23/07 SORRY- LONG STORY I have a 75 gal, 260W PC
lighting and about 45 lbs of live rock in tank that was established for
8 months. I had several fish in there and everything was doing great.
The only problem I ever had with it was I couldn't get my nitrate
levels down. They always hung around 30-40. <From?> I finally
decided to get some button polyps and some mushrooms. I had them in my
tank for a week or so and they were both all closed up and didn't
look like they even wanted to open any time soon. I called the LFS and
they said it could just be acclimation. <Yes> Finally after 3
weeks, I actually put them in my wife's tank that is a little 12
Gal setup that was established for about 5 months at the time.
Everything started coming to life. She has a 32W PC light in her tank.
Her water parameters were pretty much the same as my tank. <Mmmm,
no> I then tried putting them back in my tank a couple weeks later
after they were pretty much flourishing in her tank. They did not open
up once in my tank and I gave it a week and back in her tank they went.
They literally started opening up the same day they went in her tank (
the jerks). <Heeee!> Now, (many months gone by) since then I have
completely redone my tank. I have about 90Lbs of live rock in there,
Metal halide lighting, added a whole sump system with a good AquaC
EV-90 protein skimmer and waited almost two months till everything was
stable. I even use RO water now and have no problem with nitrates since
I found my tap water was pretty much the whole source of them. I
finally decided to add those corals again and they haven't opened
up in the past 5 days they have been in there. I even put them at the
bottom a little bit shadowed from the new more intense lighting so they
didn't get a lighting shock. I also have two Aquaclear 50
powerheads and a dual outlet return from a Mag 9 pump for water
flow/circulation. I have one cinnamon clown and a few hermit crabs in
it at this time. I am at a total loss for what is going on... and these
are supposed to be some of the easiest corals to keep!!! I had to put
them back in her tank today as the mushrooms were so shriveled up, a
couple almost looked non-existent. Do you have any idea what is going
on!?!!? what else I could check for? <This reads like some sort of
biological "poisoning"... likely an algae, bacteria... of
some sort (my bets on a BGA) is "hogging" this system by
toxifying it for other photosynthates...> Currently my tank
parameters are as follows: Salinity - 1.023 <I'd raise this to
1.026> Temp - 83 PH - 8.3 Ammonia - 0 Nitrite - 0 Nitrate - 10 Both
mine and her tanks are virtually identical water parameters. We even
use same water and the same salt. I don't know of any other
parameters that could effect corals that bad that quick. I have learned
the hard way that you cannot take shortcuts on anything because you
will at some point see a negative effect from it, to have patience and
to quarantine EVERYTHING. Now I have spent all this money on all new
sump/filtration, lighting, twice as much live rock, an RO unit for the
purest water and I still can't even keep the easiest corals out
there. Any input would greatly be appreciated! Thanks in advance. Josh
<Mmm, well... a few things might be tried... the use of a couple
pounds of good quality carbon (perhaps a pad of Polyfilter to see if
there is color/metal contamination at play here)... Perhaps the
modification of the sump, to make it live... a refugium... with an
added DSB... See WWM re conversions... Otherwise time, succession
itself should fix this... in months to years. Bob Fenner>
|
|
Features: |
|
Featured Sponsors: |