Concern re Incorrect Information on a FAQ Posted. Could a note be Added?
<<Mmm, yes. RMF>>, there are NO naturally white Heteractis species
- 02/21/07
Hello Mich,
<Hello again Brandon!>
Here is the image that seems to be lost in the stream of bits, bytes, one's and
zero's that we call the Internet. I was a programmer before I started messing
with water.
<Oh! Do you know anything about placing rotating banner ads? We have been
trying to place the ads on our site and have run into multiple issues. I
received the image with the other query.>
As promised here is the text that I found that concerned me as well,
<I will inform the powers that be, of your concerns.>
"*Sebae **Anemone*
Hello Again, (It has been about 1 month since my last email, heehee) The tank is
running perfect with the RO water changes and the Prizm, (I don't know about a
90 gallon, but for my 26 it's pulling out tons of dry skim, only complaint is a
little noise, a good compromise though.) I had a sebae anemone surprise
delivered to me in a ordering mix up, I contemplated sending it back but didn't
know if it would survive the shipping again so decided to keep the freebee.
Its white, which scared me at first, but then I realized that all the pictures
of bleached anemones appeared translucent, mine is sort of a creamy off white
sheet rock color. It has purple tips. It attached to my rock in the lower
areas of the tank and hasn't moved yet (1 week). It responds well to being
touched (shrinks away) but doesn't feel sticky as it probably should. The only
thing that it would eat was a little squid, no Mysis, fish fry, or krill. I
have 130 watts of brand new lighting right on top of the tank. Do you think
this anemone has expelled its algae or can I salvage him. Oh he's about 3 inches
diameter and my Percula shows absolutely no interest.
I know clowns have a tendency to fight but could I add a small Clarkii? Thanks
a ton guys.
Eric
<<<Many Sebaes are naturally white so he should be fine. The lighting will be
sufficient for this anemone also. Please read here for more info on these guys:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/inverts/cnidaria/anthozoa/anemones.htm
Cody>>>" <Wrong. RMF>
This alarmed me because I have never heard of a H. crispa, H. magnifica, or any
other Heteractis spp. for that matter, being white. Also it would seem to be in
conflict with a statement that Mr. Calfo made that went something along the
lines of, " <<<<this is a common reality/problem my friend. Your anemone is
dying... and it was not a good candidate from go. Frankly (not berating you),
your merchant should have known not to sell this animal and you should have
known not to buy it (as an educated consumer...
research your livestock's needs before you buy them). This species of anemone is
naturally dark in color (usually brown) with dark purple tips. Yellow is not a
natural color and indicated an animal that is bleached and/or has been dyed. It
will be dead within days. Few live weeks beyond import. I really don't know why
merchants pay for these things when they are shipped to them. If they stopped
paying for them and if consumers would stop buying them, then the collectors
would get their acts together and stop
shipping them unhealthy. Please read more about anemone health and car in our
archives. Be sure to follow the links at the top of the page too. Best regards,
Anthony>>>>" It would at least appear to me that you all seem to advocate not
buying the white specimens in lieu of tan or deep brown specimens.
<Yes.>
Mine is a very deep brown/tan color. I have not made up my mind as to the
pigment, it seems different every time that I look at it.
<Happens.>
As for the attachment, I was trying to narrow this guy down to subspecies. I
know that it is of genus Corallimorph, I am strongly leaning toward a species of
Rhodactis, I really would like to know if this is correct, and if so what
subspecies is it.
<Yes is a Rhodactis. More in other query.>
I bought it mistakenly as a type of leather coral. What I get for listening to
the people at the store. From what I have found I am not quite out of my
league, as I am regularly hand feeding a Plerogyra sinuosa, a Trachyphyllia
geoffroyi, a Heteractis crispa, two colonies of Tubastrea spp., and now the
mystery Corallimorph. I introduced food into the tank and a mouth appeared. It
was quite large, so I fed it. The mouth consequentially went away, after taking
the Mysis of course.
<Yep.>
Also I am going to quote the address of the offending page,
<http://www.wetwebmedia.com/sebaefaq2.htm the 12th
query down.>
perhaps it should be looked at with some scrutiny, again guys I am not trying to
undermine the work that you do. It is as I told Mich, you very wonderful and
dedicated people are often the last line of defense against, haste, lack of
knowledge, and general disregard for common sense. But, I would hate for
someone to see this and think that all was well, when in fact it is not.
<Thank you for your observation.>
I would love to help you guys out in any way that I can, and if there is ever
something that I could do please do not hesitate to let me know.
<We are still trying to place rotating banner ads on the site and have run into
numerous problems. Any chance you are knowledgeable in this area? Any
assistance here would be most appreciated.>
With the utmost gratitude,
Brandon R. Foster
<Thank you, -Mich>
B <<Got it>>
The photo that he is referring to was sent in another query and was place on
the FAQ’s from 2/20. His note is quite lengthy, but his point as I understand
it is: the response that was given is incorrect and he would like to see a note
added stating as much so other aren’t mislead. It is the 12th query down on
this page
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/sebaefaq2.htm
Below is the text he take issue with and the justification.
<Many Sebaes are naturally white so he should be fine. The lighting will be
sufficient for this anemone also. Please read here for more info on these
guys: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/inverts/cnidaria/anthozoa/anemones.htm
Cody>" <<Is not a factual stmt. RMF>>
This alarmed me because I have never heard of a H. crispa, H. magnifica, or any
other Heteractis spp. for that matter, being white. Also it would seem to be in
conflict with a statement that Mr. Calfo made that went something along the
lines of, " <this is a common reality/problem my friend. Your anemone is
dying... and it was not a good candidate from go.
M
Ritteri update...info for others 12/16/06
Hello folks,
<Hello Kevin, Mich here.>
I know many people have difficulty maintaining healthy Magnificent Anemones, and
I wouldn't recommend them for most aquarists.
<Nor would I.>
For those that try, I thought I would share my set-up that seems to be working
(although it's been only 12 months).
<Thank you for sharing. Success stories are always nice.>
I have a 75 gallon LR set-up with 80 lbs. of liverock. Filtration is a wet-dry
(w/out bio balls) w/ 750 gal/hr. pump and 2 powerheads for brisk water
movement. Lighting is a 10,000K MH w/ reflector suspended about 8 in. above
water surface (it should be noted that even with no hood on my tank, water temp
during light cycle is at 80 degrees F.... try this with a hood or smaller tank
you would likely need a chiller).
Only other occupants in tank are a pair of Clarki clowns (who aggressively
defend their Anenome during maintenance). Simply can't decide what else to get.
<Sometimes less is more.>
Diet is small slivers of fresh shrimp, no more than 1/2 the size of the mouth
(occasionally substituted w/ slivers of fresh, non-greasy fish). Every other
feeding is a processor made "paste" consisting of fresh shrimp, Mysis shrimp,
and krill. I turn off the pump and powerheads and use a syringe to squirt a
small amount onto the Anenome. Turning off water circulation is important here,
as not doing so would likely degrade water quality and result in the Anenome
getting very little. I only feed once every 10-14 days. I think many overfeed
their anenomes. With the intense lighting and resulting zooxanthellae
production, it seems little food would be needed.
Water changes of 15-20 % are done every 1-2 weeks, at which time I also
supplement with Iodine.
This Anenome is of the tan/ pink variety and has grown from about 7 inches to a
little over a foot in diameter when fully opened (I hear the brightly colored
ones don't do as well?). Typical of Ritteri's, it has positioned itself at the
top of the LR, directly under the MH, only about 12 inches from the
bulb. Personally, I wouldn't try this species with less intense light (power
compacts, for example), I don't know if it would be enough. Light cycle is on
timer with 13 hours on, 11 off.
I would like to reiterate the importance of covering powerhead intakes and your
overflow. The only time this Anenome made significant movement was when my MH
bulb burned out while I was at work. I came home to find my Ritteri had been
sucked through my overflow, shriveled and in only about 1 inch of water. I
quickly placed it back directly under the MH and replaced the bulb. It
recovered and hasn't moved from his favorite spot since (that was 6 months
ago). Lesson learned...I think I got lucky there.
<Yes, a valuable lesson.>
If anyone has kept a Ritteri for a long period of time (i.e, a couple years or
more), I would like to here <hear> of your setup and husbandry.
Also, if you don't have extremely intense light, water movement that turns over
your tank volume many times each hour, or you don't maintain very good water
quality, I would recommend you pick one of the easier maintained anenomes.
<Yes, earlier is a relative term.>
Sorry, would have sent pick but digital is in for repair.
<Perhaps in a future update.>
Lastly, read Bob's book, "The Conscientious Marine Aquarist"......the best book
out there.
<I absolutely agree with your sentiments here! An excellent addition to any
aquarists' holiday list. Much success to you! -Mich>
-Kevin Crowe
Sebae/Ritteri Anemone Systems 6/6/06
Hello to all,
<Hello Chris>
I was wondering what are your thoughts on my ability to keep a Ritteri with my
proper set-up.
<A difficult anemone to keep for any length of time.> I have a 55 gallon
aquarium that is only 15" deep,
<Do better in larger tanks.> I have (2) 175 watt Metal Halide and plenty of
actinics. I planned on placing the anemone on the top of my largest rock in the
aquarium which is about 7" from the surface. My water quality is near perfect
and I have excellent water flow (wave maker, sump return pump, etc..).
<Wavemakers are a plus.> Or do you think that I maybe over killing my aquarium
with so much light (although it never bothered my carpet anemone before in the
aquarium)?
<Lighting is fine.> I recently moved and don't have any livestock in it right
now, but a saddleback clown, and wanted to start it up again with a Ritteri.
<Chris, do read here and related articles above. http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/inverts/cnidaria/anthozoa/anemones.htm
Thanks,
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Chris
Ritteri do I have it in me? 6/3/06
Good Afternoon, .....excellent site, you guys ( girls included, no offense)
rule. I have a 50 gal aquarium that I have ran for many years as an exclusive
anemone tank (no other creature but anemones.. not even clowns), and I just
moved and I am starting it up again. I have kept just about every type of
anemone (Bubble, Sebae, LTA, Carpet...for only a month though, quarantine
situation for a friend), but the one that I have never kept was a Ritteri (the
one that I always wanted to). I have a ton of experience with all types of
anemones with everything that could go wrong to everything that goes
perfectly. So I am not questioning my abilities or knowledge, just my
lighting. I have (2) 175w MH....1 6500k and the other I think is a 10k or 12k,
and (2) 65w actinics. I have learned through the years (and this lesson was
costly) that if you have doubt, it best not to try, so I am asking the experts
(yes you). And I know that even after my tank cycles again it will be at least
6 months before I can put one in. If you don't think I have the lighting for a
Ritteri, what about a carpet long for the term?
Thanks,
Michael
<<Michael: Many experts consider the Ritteri not only difficult to keep; but,
due to their lifespans/infrequent reproduction they should not even be pulled
out of the ocean. It would be a shame to get one and then lose it. Some people
also think that clownfish are good for the well being of the anemones. As for
me, I have RTBA, GTBA, LTA and a Condy under 400W MH lighting. I also have a
RTBA, Condy and Green Carpet under VHO lighting. I feed the anemones every few
days and they seem to be doing well. All the anemones came with tanks I
bought. If it were me, I would stick with a clone of a RTBA or GTBA. That way,
you're not experimenting on a critter that just got pulled out of the
ocean. Best of luck, Roy>>
Magnificent Anemone Compatibility 4/27/06
Hello folks. Thanks for all the wonderful info.
<Hello and you're welcome.> I think I know this answer, but want to make
sure. First, my tank and water parameters:
-75 gallon with 75 lbs. of liverock, 1 open-end 250 watt MH (clean-ace 18,000
lumen, 6,500 K) in reflector suspended 8 in. above water, wet/dry filter made
for 125 gal tank (no bio balls), pump and 2 powerheads=1600 gal/hr. water flow.
-pH=8.3, temp=79 day (heat off MH), 77 night, specific gravity=1.024,
nitrite/nitrate=0, free ammonia=0, alkalinity=4meq/L. All water is RO with 10-
15% water changed weekly.
Occupants are 1 magnificent anemone and 4 Clarki clowns....that's all. Although
I acquired this tank 3 months ago with just a Clarki (the damsel, brittle star
and coral beauty I inherited were given good new home), it had been up and
running with previous owner for 3 years. I know Ritteri's are among the most
difficult of all anemones to maintain long-term but I'm trying to provide
everything it needs. I've only had it 2 months but I've never seen a healthier
one- fed regularly with small slivers of shrimp, squid, scallop, or non-greasy
fish briefly soaked in vitamin sol'n every other feeding, Iodine supplementation
with water changes, a robust body and thick, full tentacles, rich pink-tan
color, and has grown from ~6 to 8+ inches.
My question. I am considering making this tank a Clarki/anemone tank,
exclusively. Which I think could be quite beautiful. <Yes, such systems are
very interesting.> Given the large amount of unpopulated space in this tank,
would a 2nd anemone still be out of the question? I know that is normally a
no-no due to the likelihood of a "chemical battle" b/t the anemones, but most
don't have this much "unpopulated" space and I'm anal <Anal??> about maintaining
perfect water parameters. Could 2 anemones (Ritteri or not) ever co-exist in a
setup such as this? <You're 75 doesn't have that much real estate.>
I forgot to add. I am about to move this setup into a 125 gal and adding 50
lbs. more liverock, a 2nd 250 watt MH for a 4:1 watt/gallon ratio with both
lights suspended 8 in. over the water. Just wanted you to know in case the
extra room influences your answer. <Don't think you would have a problem
here. Wouldn't
get the second anemone until the tank transfer is complete. I would get a
Ritteri, would not mix species.>
To me, having a beautiful setup is secondary to the well-being of the
inhabitants. That's why I'm asking. I'd rather have just one healthy anemone
(I know, that term is relative with a Ritteri) with multiple Clarkii's instead
of two anemones just "getting by" or worse. But would love to have 2 if you
think they could co-exist with TLC. <I'd give it a shot.>
I just ordered Bob's book "The Conscientious Aquarist" and will read it cover to
cover. <Bob thanks you and do enjoy reading it.> Thanks so much for your time.
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Regards,
-Kevin
Re: another ritteri question - 5/2/2006
Hi Salty Dog!
<Hello Kevin>
I've written you a few times about my Magnificent Anenome.....you can tell to me
to stop bugging you anytime, I won't be offended. <Will not.> I just keep coming
up with new questions the other articles didn't quite answer.
As you may recall, <Do not, receive too many queries to remember an individuals
tank/specs.> I have a 75 gallon LR tank (~70 lbs.) with suspended 250 MH w/
reflector 8 in. off water, wet/dry without bio-balls, Prizm Deluxe skimmer
(rated for up to 300 gal.), ~1600 gph water movement (it chooses an area of LR
where there is significant movement, the Clarkii's have to fight the current to
nestle down at night), <Could power down powerheads at night.> water parameters
excellent, iodine and trace elements added with RO water changes, etc. Only
inhabitants are Ritteri acquired about 2 1/2 months ago, 3 Clarki clowns, and
snail "cleaner pack". So far, the Ritteri is doing very well. <Good to
hear.> Growing rapidly with thick, full tentacles, etc. My question is about
feeding frequency and other foods you would recommend. So far, I've fed it
small slivers of fresh raw shrimp, shellfish, squid, and non-greasy fish (thank
god the farmer's market is just down the road). I also feed a homemade "paste"
that I make in my food processor. It consists of a mix of a couple of the
aforementioned meats with thawed Mysis
shrimp and krill. <A good diet.> I turn off all pumps except one powerhead (if I
don't, the food just gets blasted around the tank) and squirt a small amount
onto it's tentacles via syringe (it really seems to love this concoction). I've
read some conflicting information on the recommended feeding frequency. I've
been feeding 2-3 times a week, but have read some articles that say more than
once a week may be too often. It never refuses a meal. Would it refuse if
satisfied? <It may at times. One feeding per week would be plenty as anemones
do produce much of their food by way of photosynthesis.> I assume, with my MH
lighting (which the Anenome is directly below), that the anemone's zooxanthellae
are healthy and providing food, and the Clarkii's give him occasional tidbits,
plus I'm sure he gets his fair share of Clarki poo. Is my feeding schedule
appropriate? <As above>> Would you recommend any other food items, either fed
directly or added to my "paste"?
<You are doing fine as is. Might want to add a little Selcon to the paste.>
Thanks again.
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Also, send Bob my kudos. I'm halfway through his book......absolutely fantastic
reading.
<Will do and yes, it is a no nonsense straightforward book. James (Salty Dog)>
-Kevin
Heteractis magnifica? - 01/27/06
Wonderful Fish Gods,
<<Mere mortal EricR here tonight.>>
Simple questions, well I hope.
<<Me too <grin>.>>
I have read thru the related FAQ.
<<Ok>>
The reason I am double, even triple checking is I want to make sure I am feeding
properly.
<<Ok>>
1. I was told this was a carpet anemone, is it?
<<Hmm...looks like Heteractis magnifica to me. Very nice pics, by the way.>>>>
2. I have a Deltec MC500 on a 55g, will this be good enough for the 55?
<<Yes>>
3. I have 4 65w PC 2 actinic, 2 10k, is this sufficient lighting?
<<Possibly...just... I would rather see 4x96w PCs for this anemone.>>
Thanks very much for the great Site!!!
<<Glad you like it.>>
P.S. I do have a 46g with one 250w MH that I use for my corals. Which I will
move the Anemone to if it is better for him/her.
<<Ah, yes! This tank (sans corals) would make an excellent specimen display for
this anemone. Regards, EricR>>
<RMF can't find file... >
Heteractis magnifica And Maroon Clown? - 12/15/05
Hi,
<<Hello>>
Can you put Premnas biaculeatus family with Heteractis magnifica?
Jeff Keith
<<Mmm...is one of the 'better' choices I believe. EricR>>
Re: Yellow Eye Kole... cnidarian compatibility, Ritteri... 11/16/05
Bob,
<Carrie>
Hi thanks for the reply. I did a 10 gallon water change on my 60 gallon, added Polyfilter, and added carbon. Here is what I really
would love from you. My ex-boss seems to think that my zoanthids are not the problem in my tank, but another LFS who knows about corals said
they can be dangerous as far as chemical warfare on other corals.
<Yes>
I have placed an order with Live Aquaria on Saturday and I will be getting 2 aquacultured
Montiporas tomorrow at 3 p.m. (Tuesday) I want the best conditions for them and I would like you to maybe wade through
my corals (most are frags of a couple of heads or inches) I will pull the chemical warfare causing monsters!
I have:
*3 types of trumpet/candy cane corals (one green, one "purple/green, and the brown with green center each
having only 3 to 4 heads)
*Yellow Polyps (maybe a dozen on a branch)
*Several different type of the stemmed zoanthid (4 frags have like 6 to 10 polyps each)
*Several different type of the flat mat zoanthids (Maybe like 20 to 30 on 3 different rocks)
*Pagoda Cup Coral (I love and doing great)
*Red Donut.... charity case, but with your help I am sure it will improve
*Colt Coral (6 to 7")
*1 Purple fuzzy mushroom......they said it was hairy.....not!
*2 Green hairy mushrooms (I plan to frag at each split and keep the population to 3)
*2 Green mushrooms given to me for a trade
*1 1/2" frag of a light blue Acropora (bleached out from stress I assume)
*1 1" Kenya tree.....seems to not be doing good
*1 Rock of green star polyps that wont come out.
*1 Small speck of a purple mushroom and 1 quarter size purple mushroom
*1 HUGE and stationary Heteractis Magnifica....LOVE this thing!!! I have 2 different species of clowns living in it and I plan it to be my
center piece in my 150 gallon so you can't talk me out of it! Sorry, to be stubborn, but unless he spews out poison to kill everything, I
really want to keep him.
<Am hopeful all this mis-mix can/will "growing up together" learn to get along, tolerate each other... There is a distinct possibility that the Heteractis magnifica will detach at some point... real trouble not if, when it contacts other cnidarians... hopefully someone will catch this quickly... Remember this pre-admonition>
NOW, I never really wanted to go down the mushroom route, but I DO suspect them! I will remove whatever I need to keep the
Montipora digitata. The little frag that got lost that I had did great, but that
was BEFORE the 2 green quarter size mushrooms. Tell me what you would suggest.
<More tanks... separating a good deal of this life into general "soft", "hard/stony", and anemone tanks...>
I am going into a 150 gallon next week and I have someone that had pom pom xenia for me, but I would choose the xenia over other
items if they would harm the xenia. I looked over wet web and thought that a chart of compatible corals would be GREAT instead of wading
through all the emails....
What do you think? Or do you know of a web site?
<A great idea... but don't know how we might make a multi-dimensional representation... that is, how to display the many "this goes with this semi-okay", "but now with these"... not a simple Cartesian plane>
My favorites I really would like to keep are one hairy green mush, one purple fuzzy mush, my
Het... mag., colt coral,
Montiporas, candy canes and trumpets, and Kenya and hopefully the Acropora. I don't need any
of the other mushrooms and would lower my Zoa collection to my 3 "mats on rocks", seems they are not as dangerous as the stemmed zoa's...am I
right? Take Care Bob!
Carrie
<Not as dangerous, toxic, but still so... Perhaps your employer would like/prefer for you to gather, assemble disparate opinions re these organism mixes from the various BB's? Bob Fenner>
Magnificent/Ritteri Anemone Lighting 10/31/05
Hello,
<Hi Ben.>
At the moment my lighting consists of 2x150w 10k MH's and 1x150w 20k MH in between. Also a t8 blue for first on last off. I have a Ritteri and wondered
if this lighting was ok.
<Mmm, maybe. To be honest the only time I ever saw a healthy Ritteri was directly under a 250 watt metal halide (single ended) but the HQI’s are quite efficient so it may be enough. Having said that the lighting may or may not matter in this case as the anemone rarely adapts to captivity anyway.>
The lights are 9" off the water surface and the anemone is 6" below the surface. I also have 50k bulbs which could be used instead of the 10k's.Which
Kelvin do anemones prefer?
<Most photosynthetic organisms prefer lighting in the 6500K to 10000K range.>
any advice is great, thank you.
<Quite Welcome.>
Ben Hustwayte
<Adam J.>