Dogface.. many rather a Toby, sel. For a new tank – 05/28/08
Hello,
<Hi Dawn.>
I have a 55 gallon aquarium. I have been researching fish before I set up. My problem is I have fallen for a fish that I cant have because my tank is not big enough. My forbidden love is a dogface puffer. My question is could you give me some alternatives that are not so big. What I love about this fish of course is the personality and the cuteness.
<A Toby e.g. a Canthigaster valentini. http://www.wetwebmedia.com/tobies.htm . They are puffers, too and share the traits you list.>
I would also like some pretty, colorful tankmates.
<Many possibilities, see http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/fishes/part2.htm and http://www.wetwebmedia.com/fishindex3.htm . A small number of small to medium sized fish (no surgeons/tangs) should work with proper filtration. Just avoid too passive fish like small cardinals and too aggressive fish like some damsels and maroon clowns.>
This will be a fish only tank. I do have some fish keeping experience. this tank has been a fresh water community and brackish in the past. I would now like to try my hand at saltwater.
<Be sure to prepare well with the help of literature and the internet. Maybe also contact a local club.>
My son wants an eel ugh, my boyfriend wants a stingray.
<Both are no choices I would combine with a puffer in a tank of 55 gallons.>
So what advice do you have for me and my men.
<Among eels there are many possibilities, morays are very robust and come in many sizes, but I’d recommend them only for a separate tank, see http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/fishes/index.htm (scroll down to marine eels). A fish similar to an eel is the Convict Blenny (it’s no real blenny), which might work with a Toby in your setup, see http://www.wetwebmedia.com/pholodichthyidae.htm . Stingrays and skates all need very large quarters and are definitely not recommended for beginners with saltwater maintenance, see http://www.wetwebmedia.com/rays.htm . If you like Tobies and your son likes the Convict Blenny two of you can be happy, but I fear your husband should not have a ray in this tank.>
Thank you
Dawn
<Hope that helps. Marco.>

90 gallon for dogface puffer? Please pass. 6/18/05
I'm am in the process of moving out of state and had to sell back my 90 gallon reef to my LFS. Since my new job will require more of my time, I have decided to do a fish only setup. Many of the fish that I have interested me before, I can now get. This would include a puffer. I have always enjoyed porkys, but am aware that they would outgrow my tank.
<Yes, indeed... far to big too live a full lifespan in a 90 gall or anything even close. Huge adult size>
What is your opinion on the narrow lined puffer?
<Arothron manilensis still grows waaaaay too large for a home aquarium. The adult size is a full foot long and they produce copious amounts of waste. And I am also not a fan of buying juveniles on the hope/promise of a huge tank "someday.">
The info on this species is slim. Also, could you suggest some tankmates for a system of this size.
<The tank is not big enough for this fish let alone tankmates... do consider other fishes, my friend. But avoid Diodon and Arothron>
I will be running an urchin pro skimmer along with a trickle filter.
<best of luck/life. Anthony>

Puffer size problem...? Actually Aquarist Choice & LFS Info Problem
I think I made a big mistake. I knew that I should have put the fish on hold for a couple days to research more about it.
<Bingo>
I bought a puffer from my LFS on Thursday, and after doing some research on your site, I have found out that the puffer that I purchased is a narrow-lined puffer (Arothron manilensis). This is a problem for me because he can grow to about a foot long, or even 20 inches. My tank is certainly not big enough for him. I have a 29 gallon tank, and the reason I thought it would work was because I was told that he would only get to be about 4-5 inches long. I thought he would work nicely with my spotted hawkfish, but I now know that I was wrong.  My other problem is this, my LFS will not let you return a fish, so I am assuming that you can't trade him in either.
<I wouldn't assume anything here... ask them, other shops>
How long can I keep him in my tank, how fast will he grow? My biology class at school has a 125 gallon tank that could be his future home, but I don't know if I really want to make that $20.00 donation to the tank housing a 5 inch barracuda, and soon a Lionfish from another tank when he outgrows it. Have any ideas of what I should do?
<Ask the school... would go with what you list>
I know from now on to research anything I am going to put in the tank before buying. In fact I was only going in to get another Damsel. By the way, if I get rid of the puffer, would an Arc-Eyed Hawkfish be compatible with the Spotted Hawkfish?
Thanks, Daniel
<No... not a good idea to mix cirrhitids. Bob Fenner> 

Now I Wanna Be Your Dog (face Puffer)!
Hello, WWM Crew!
<Good Morning>
First of all, I have to tell you your site is magnificent. My husband and I recently set up a saltwater tank (yes, we have small children and did the Nemo thing.) While we have received abundant conflicting advice, we decided on the "slower is better" school of thought as best (as in, don't rush anything - curing a tank, adding live sand, adding fish, etc.) 
<Great, in this hobby patience is rewarded with stability.>
Here is what we have going on now: we have a 55-gallon fish-only tank humming along nicely, with 2 Ocellaris Clowns (we started with one, as advised by our LFS store owner, who then soon reversed himself and we soon added the second; regardless, the new addition, "Marlin," promptly took a chomp of the original, "Nemo" - of course -which only increased the resemblance of our "Nemo" to the movie Nemo, who has a shortened "lucky" fin. At any rate, all is well with them now, though as Clowns go, I guess "Marlin" should be renamed "Coral." ;) 1 Regal Blue Tang, 1 Yellow Tang
and 1 Flame Dwarf Angel.
<I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but each of these tangs needs a 75-90 gallon tank when they reach full size. As well as these tangs as they get larger, will be at higher risk of fighting, and or killing one another with their bone spines on the sides of their tails. Please try to return one or both soon or invest in a bigger tank (120-180 gallon for these fish to care for them properly for the long term. Both tangs get over 8" easily.>
Everyone is getting along, and the tank appears - and according to our daily, and scrupulously recorded, tests - to be doing well. (TetraTec PF300 Filter, two "bubble bars" as we were advised the Tangs did much better with them, 40 lbs of live sand, and a 1 lb of live rock which we plan on soon augmenting, as we have recently learned it would be very advisable.)
<Yes. Live Rock is the best filtration that exists for a saltwater tank. Though I think a protein skimmer would also help you a lot here to remove protein wastes from foods and fish waste form all these fish. do research one that will fit your needs. An Aqua C Remora should do fine>
As I said before, we have received, from various books and alleged "experts" conflicting information. For example, two
"experts" swore that a Regal Blue Tang was inevitable bad news, while another one said that they're tetchy and there's a high mortality and a fourth was ambivalent: as I wrote above, our "Dory" - the kids have named them, of course - seems to be doing just fine. She likes hanging out behind a large ornamental (fake) coral, and went through a period when she liked to fold herself up like an origami and hide out within another piece of ornamental (fake) coral which looks somewhat like a mutant cauliflower or an alien brain from Star Trek. 
(For whatever reason, this activity appears to have bored her, or she discovered there was nothing interesting within the mutant cauliflower folds, and now has staked out the area behind the taller (fake) coral formation, though she's pretty amiable about sharing the space.)
<I fear this will not last for very long at all. If or when it does become aggressive the situation will deteriorate quickly. Tangs generally as a rule do not play "nice" together. And in a 55 gallon they wont play nice for much longer if at all.>
My question is, I'd like to add a dog-faced puffer (the desire was always there, and the puffer-writers on WWM just increased the desire. 
I have read the FAQs and the articles written on WWM in regards to puffers, and they are so well-written and appealing that they have only encouraged me. (We have dogs - cockers, specifically - and I swear the dog-faced puffers look hopeful and expectant at me when I see them in our favoured shops. Ja Ja, they probably just want a hand-out, as do our cockers, but they are very hard to resist.  I understand (again from the FAQs) that puffers are predators, but it also appears that, handled correctly and fed, one would not necessarily provide the distressing scene for my adoring children to see of Mr. Puffer seeing Nemo, et al, as a too-tempting hors d'oeuvre.
<Well as one of the resident puffer people here at WWM I know the draw, However, that is only asking for trouble in your present tank, and would be asking for trouble unless everything was moved to at least a 180 gallon. These fish get 15" and poop like adults even at small sizes. As for their mood or temperament, each puffer is very different and only by watching the one you want will you know what you are getting into. They are very personable, but at the same time they are very demanding as to water quality, feedings and tank sizes and can turn on tankmates quickly to fight for territory of if they are threatened. If you do get a bigger tank the puffer should be fine with the clowns provided it is well fed and not overly aggressive. Puffers eat invertebrates mainly and are not normally fish eaters.>
Our original plan was, when conditions were right, to add two black clowns (at the LFS where we purchased our "Nemo" Ocellaris Clowns, we saw orange and black ocellaris coexisting quite happily in some display tanks - not in tanks where fish are available for sale) and then consider our tank complete, but I am hoping that there might be room and compatibility for a dog-faced puffer. Your thoughts? Pros? Cons?
Thanks for all your help!
~ Candace
<Well, As I stated above, a dog faced puffer is like a dog, it needs special care and a lot of room to roam. Those tangs are the same way. Please do not add any more fish into this tank until you get a much larger one. Also I do NOT advise getting more clownfish. Clownfish are very dominant and the pair you have has settled, but adding more simply means a new pecking order must be settled and that might mean one or more die after its all said and done due to stress or disease. Please do continue researching on WWM and fishbase.org before you buy any fish to make sure you know their adult full sizes and whether you can care for them.>
<Justin (Jager)> 

Puffer species comparison
Well, my partner has been wanting a puffer for months now, and we have even set up a small tank in anticipation of getting a baby - with plans for a much larger (125-180) tank for a future home.  He had been mostly attracted to the dog faced variety (nigropunctatus), but these suddenly became scarce in our area after we got the tank ready.  After waiting for our LFS to special order one, he finally came home with what they got him last night - not a dog face.  After searching your site and fishbase, I am fairly certain it is a white spotted (hispidus).  It has the regularly sized and spaced white spots over a gray mottled background, although none on the tail/fins.
It has pinkish lips, and thin gold rings around the base of the clear pectoral fins.  There are no bars or stripes.  This seems to be within the variation range I have found in pics.  I will try to count rays on the fins tonight I guess.
He seems to like the fish, although it is bigger than we anticipated at about 6-7".  So far I have learned that they grow bigger in the wild than the dog face - 20" compared to 13".  How big should we be prepared for in captivity?  Also he has proven quite noisy at night, making grunting and clicking noises, and splashing water in the tank.  Should we assume this will continue?
<Arothron hispidus (Linnaeus 1758), the White-Spotted Puffer. Indo-Pacific, Red Sea, east African coast, tropical east Pacific coast. To twenty inches in length in the wild. Cute when small, and very hardy... just big eaters and mess makers. Here are pictured a four inch juvenile in captivity, a one foot specimen in the Red Sea, and a fifteen inch mottled or "koi" one in the Seychelles.
He will likely get at least 2/3 his wild size. He may settle in and some of the activity subside, but he is a puffer! They are very intelligent and engaging.>
What other considerations/surprises are there with this species compared with the dog face?
<They are both big mess makers, have very good filtration and regular water changes.>
We have the option of returning him and waiting for another specimen, but that's not really fair to the fish or the dealer.  I can already see that owning this puffer is going to be a rather more engaging experience than with most fish.  Mike
<Like a water dog. Make sure you get the bigger tank underway ASAP. Enjoy!  Craig>

Peacock Puffer & Spotted Puffer  9/4/04
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I have a 50 gal talk with four happy inhabitants, Scott's fairy wrasse, a pair of perculas with their maroon ritteri and a 10 inch wolf eel. Recently I found at my local aquarium store four 3 inch peacock puffers and I immediately wanted to inform you and ask a few questions my self the manager noted theses were very peaceful puffers and only would double in size I have a spotted fresh water puffer and even though he is 4 inches he is the king of his domain. Could the peacock puffers be so docile and if so is there a chance they could be an easy snack for my wolf eel.
<There seem to be an influx of these "peacock puffers" (Takifugu ocellatus), available in the aquarium trades lately.  It's a shame really, since there has never been anyone (even the best puffer experts, Robert T Ricketts, a puffer keeper of over 40 years & Dr Klaus Ebert, author of The Puffers of Fresh & Brackish Waters) able to keep these puffers alive more than a few months.  
RTR said, "I have tried 4 of them, various times and various water conditions. My shortest-lived was on the order of a week, the longest did grow a fair bit, but was still only a handful of months at the most - I don't have the exact figures handy. All were definitely still juvenile fish, all ate, all were active to hyperactive, and all died."  
With that in mind, it would be best not to buy these puffers, as it will continue to deplete the natural populations, only to have the fish in a tank for a very short while.  It's such a shame that collectors have no idea--they are taking them out of their home, to certain death!  
I wanted to also write to you about your "FW" spotted puffer.  If your puffer is a green spotted puffer (Tetraodon nigroviridis) or  GSP, Then it is not a FW puffer.  It needs high-end BW when younger & prefers SW as an adult.  At 4" it should already be in a SG of around 1.018.  Please read: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm  ~PP>

Pufferfish
Bob, this is Les Vargas, the LAPD cop you met at Tideline and the one you talked to the other night about the angel fish.  I have a question:  In your opinion, would a dog face puffer fish (scientific name is Arothron nigropunctatus) be able to peacefully co-exist in my 240 gallon aquarium.  The fish I have in there now are a Sohal tang, blue tang, Naso Tang, French angel, masked butterfly, yellow tang, tomato clown, and Fiji damsel, and a banana wrasse. All of these have peacefully co-existed for the past three to four years.  Would the puffer fish be a fin nipper or attempt to eat the smaller fish?  Please let me know.  I'll be guided by your word.
Thank you.
Les Vargas
<The Puffer should make a fine addition. They can be nippy, even big biters, but your other fish are not slow or dummies... And will stay out of its way. This is a great aquarium species... very intelligent.
Bob Fenner>

Fish Selection
Hello. I hope you can offer me some more advice. I have a 150 gallon
tank with the following fish:
Clown Trigger(6 inches)
emperor angel (6-7 inches)
fire clown
purple tang
Sohal tang (4 inches).
Unfortunately, I recently lost my green bird wrasse to unknown causes.
There was no sign of disease and all the other fish look fine. I was
wondering if you could suggest a new tank mate for my fish. I was
thinking possibly a dog-face puffer or an auriga butterfly. I think a
butterfly fish may be a little too shy for my tank considering the other
inhabitants. Please let me know what you think of these choices or if
you have any other suggestions.
Thank You, Heather Mann
>>
Many, MANY possibilities for your rough and tumble assemblage... But I think you've mentioned a real winner in the Dog Faced Puffer... Do get one of these... great personality fishes... and hardy.
Bob Fenner