Box/cow fish
parasites. Parasitized systems, alternatives... reading 8/24/08
I've had a Blue male, Black female box fish and a Cow fish for several years
now. One thing I've noticed is they always have Cryptocaryon, I just have to try
and control it. I've tried hospital tanks and the only successful/safe medicine
was malachite green. However after using low salt and meds for 2 months and
returning them to the 180 gal. tank, they would get "it"
<Uhh... the system itself has "it"...>
again after a few months. Is it true that they always have/carry ick or Cry.?
<Nope>
I've found the best long term solution to housing Box and Cow fish is to have
only them as tank mates, and to use a low salinity of 1.016-1.018. This has kept
them symptom free. My main question is, I will keep the low salt for 2-3 months,
then raise to 1.022-1.023 for 1-2 months then back down when the first spot
shows up. Is this potentially harmful?
<Yep... shortens their lives... due to "stress", kidney damage mostly>
How long can I keep 1.016 for?
<Months to years>
This method seems to be the least stressful to the fish and I don't have to keep
a hospital tank as well. What kind of salinity's do you recommend?
<Near seawater...>
Am I too low and then not going back high enough? I want to give the fish the
best long term care as possible, but need to keep the salt low to avoid
problems. Thanks.
<... There are other means of treating/excluding protozoan complaints with the
puffer families... Read on WWM re Quinine cpd., dip/bath (with formalin)
procedures... Peruse here: http://wetwebmedia.com/mardisindex.htm
Bob Fenner>
Longhorn cowfish w/ich –
01/21/2008
Hello all, great site you have here! I am just going to dive right in here.
I have been trying to fight what I think is ich since September. I currently
have a 1.5" valentini puffer and a 3-4" longhorn cowfish in a 20 gallon. I have
tried hypo twice...I will skip to the last time I tried hypo.
<Have you consistently kept the salinity below 15 ppt (SG < 1.011) for at least
4-6 weeks? Higher salinities won’t work with normal Cryptocaryon isolates. A few
will even live in brackish water with a lower salinity and can only be treated
with copper (or formalin, which is more difficult and potentially dangerous to
apply).>
After I brought the salt back up I did not see any spots, and everything seemed
ok until the cowfish (bugar) would eat. Every time bugar would eat shrimp or
scallops after a few bites he would start darting and flashing around the tank.
<Something may be wrong with his nervous system, but that is more a guess than a
diagnosis.>
He did not do this when eating pellet food only the raw frozen foods. (The
puffer has not shown any signs)...for two weeks I carefully watched the
longhorn, and all day he would not show any signs of ich not one single spot in
two weeks was seen on his fins or body. I do realize that there are certain
stages of ich that you cannot see, and the gills are one of the commonly
attacked places, but to not see a spot in two weeks?
<It can take 4-6 weeks until spots occur again. Please get familiar with the
life cycle of the parasite here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichart2mar.htm and
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm . However, darting alone is not enough
in my opinion to state this is ich.>
Another site suggested that it probably was ich, and so I began some other
treatments. I first used stop parasite, this did nothing to the problem when the
cowfish was eating, next I tried Nox-ich...The cow did fine, but I lost a dwarf
lion...not sure if it was the medicine or not, but it seemed logical. The other
site then suggested that I use Cupramine.
<If it was ich, this would be a good medication probably in contrast to the ones
mentioned before.>
I tried this med a few months ago, and the cowfish did not like it. For the
first time since I had bugar he did not eat, so I pulled the med.
<It had no chance to work.>
The other site said that this is a common side effect and should only last a
couple of days. So I thought I would try Cupramine another shot. Currently I
just added my second treatment of Cupramine last night. The first treatment that
is supposed to take the level to .25 did not bother the cow, but taking it to .5
did. I added it last night, and this morning his color was very dark all over
his body, and again he is not eating.
<Puffers, boxfish and other sensitive fishes should be treated at lower levels
slightly above the minimum level recommended by the manufacturer.>
I am currently pulling the copper. At least he eats when I don't have that in
there. I did notice today that bugar is darting, though he is not eating so this
is not linked. I am at a loss as to what to do?
<Darting alone is not enough for a proper diagnosis. Without knowing at least
roughly what to treat, I would not treat on suspicion.>
Not sure if I should be doing anything?
<If spots occur, treat with a copper product as indicated by the articles
mentioned above. Aside that feed a vitamin rich varied diet to boost the immune
system.>
I have tried hypo twice, I have used a battery of meds. I don't see spots on
these fish. The valentini still shows no spots does not dart around. I have had
them in a qt since Sept. I want to get them back into my dt, but don't want to
introduce anything bad back into it. Any suggestion or insight would be greatly
appreciated.
<See above if your hyposalinity treatment was effective at all. If salinity was
too high or duration of the treatment was too short, Cryptocaryon is likely
still in the system, even if you do not see spots. In this case or if you see
any spots treat with Cupramine as indicated above and in the linked articles.
After at least 4-6 weeks without spots the fish can probably go back to the main
system, which also was free of fish hosts for at least 4-6 weeks. With regard to
the darting: as long as no other symptoms occur, I would not specifically
address this issue, only provide superb water quality and a vitamin enriched
diet. Good luck, Marco.>
Burp the Puffer.. Ostraciid
hlth. 1/14/07
Hello Crew,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I apologize for having to email you, I've been searching and searching but
cannot find EXACTLY what I'm needing.
About a week ago I noticed my Blue Spotted Puffer acting a little strange (75
gal, fowler, had about a year, two clowns only as his tankmates). He was looking
a little bloated, started not eating, hanging out at the bottom, etc. The last
two days he's literally done nothing but lay on his side in the sand. We thought
he was as good as dead, breathing real heavy, LOOKED AWFUL.
<What are the water parameters? ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, pH, SG?>
I had been reading and reading trying to figure out
what the problem was and then noticed that his back end started raising up like
he was full of air or something. Discovered he probably was and I needed to
"burp" him. I did, he still appears a little more bloated then he
used to, but A LOT better. He hasn't been at the bottom of the tank in about 12
hours now, BUT he's definitely not better. Kinda swimming aimlessly, not using
his back tail at
all, turning upside down, etc. He's definitely not breathing as hard, but the
light current is banging him into rocks, and he's kinda looking around like "oh
crap I'm gonna run into it" BANG!! He's appearing to try and stay at the front
of the tank and be a normal fish though.
Is there any hope for this little guy? After the last couple of days I'm VERY
grateful that he's to this point, but was it still too late? Is there anything
else I can do? Burp him again?
<If burping helped him, then try it again. What have you been feeding him?>
I appreciate the help, and also understand that you have A LOT to respond to :)
<No problem--please post answers to the above & get back to me. ~PP>
Jon
Re: Burp the Puffer.. 1/15/08
<Hi John, Pufferpunk again>
Well, he hasn't really been eating the past 5 days now.
<They can go quite some time without eating.>
Before that I was mixing brine shrimp and squid.
<Brine shrimp is not nutritious at all--mostly water, so the only thing he has
been eating is the squid & they need a much more varied & crunchy diet than
that.
See: http://www.thepufferforum.com/forum/library/feeding/feeding-your-puffers/ >
I fed some other types but he refused to eat them (the other fish would
however).
<Another helpful article on problems feeding your puffer:
http://www.thepufferforum.com/forum/library/feeding/problems-feeding-your-puffer/
>
All the levels are good,
<"Good" Means nothing to me. I believe I requested posting your exact
parameters.>
the salinity was a little low about a week ago but nothing to write home about.
As an update I've been burping him a couple of times a day, he doesn't seem to
be doing as good anymore. Sitting at the bottom, he's been upside down at the
bottom since this morning. Still breathing though.
<Possibly a lack of proper feeding.>
I read somewhere that disorientation and the lack of using his tail is a sure
sign of death to follow. Is it worth letting him suffer, or should I just put
him out of his misery :( ??
<There is always a chance of saving him... We need try to
find out the problem though.
1) Your water parameters - pH, Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrate and salinity (if
appropriate). This is by far the most important information you can provide! Do
not answer this with "Fine" "Perfect" "ok", that tells us nothing. We need hard
numbers.
2) Tank size and a list of ALL inhabitants. Include snails, shrimp, everything
that you have and how big the tank is.
3) Feeding, water change schedule and a list of all products you are using or
have added to the tank (examples: Cycle, Amquel, salt, etc)
4) What changes you've made in the tank in the last week or so? Sometimes its
the little things that make all the difference.
5) How long the aquarium has been set up, and how did you cycle it?
We want to help, and providing this information will go a LONG way to getting a
diagnosis and hopeful cure that much faster. ~PP>
Thanks again, Jon
Cowfish... disease...
treatment/s... reading... no useful data 12/3/07
I found your email through links while trying to find answers! I hope you
can help me... if not can you let me know of someone who can.
I have a longhorn cowfish and we have been treating him, along with the others,
for ICH.
<How? With what? Have you read on WWM re medications and Lactoria, other
puffers?>
Just today we noticed red around his eye and on parts of his body (I don't for
sure know the sex).
<Not able to be discerned externally, and doubtful whether this fish is mature,
nor that this is pertinent>
I haven't been able to find any information on this.
<... on "the reddening"?>
Can you please help! We tried a dip twice and it wasn't successful so we stopped
because we didn't want to stress him or the other fish out. Now we have a liquid
medicine
<... what?>
that we have been using for about 1 week and haven't seen any sign of the ICH
leaving. We raised the temp and have lots of oxygen in the tank. What else can
we do? I don't want to lose the fish. The cow fish is just a baby!
Thank you in advance,
Tara
<... please read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/boxfshdisfaqs.htm
and the linked files above... to give you some ready background; and write back
with answers to my questions above. Bob Fenner>
Boxfish 911 to advanced issue,
apparently Crypt
Hello All,
Please help with the following: Longhorn Cowfish has been picture of
health in home tank for 3+ years. He has grown from (body/non horned)
1.5-2" up to nearly 8" body length. In the last 48 hours the fish has
taken a rapid change for the worse. Before the 48 hour first observation
the critter was eating greedily, swimming normally, etc. Symptoms of
slime coat sloughing were observed yesterday then actual skin
sloughing(?) today to where it looks like patches of his yellow skin are
now gone or translucent white. (see attached pics)
<I see this... and a whitening of the cornea>
He is usually the color of the area immediately around his pectoral fin.
Initially only slime coat was affected but today there are a TON of
white spots on the fins/tail. They seem smaller than "ick" size but see
for yourself. He is not eating and he normally out eats a puffer on
nearly anything.
<I see these as well... do appear to be a protozoan infestation>
There have been zero introductions or anything coming/going from the
tank/household but we did move just under a month ago. All live rock,
bioballs, etc was kept wet and only a barely measurable mini cycle
occurred.
Current water parameters are ~78 degrees F, .020 salinity,
<A bit low... see WWM re spg...>
zero ammonia,
barely traceable nitrite (if any), nitrates under 12.5, ph about 8.1.
(Tetra test kit) His current tank is a 75 gallon AGA with 20 gallon
sump, about 65 lbs liverock, CoraLife 220 skimmer, gallon of bioballs,
and a carbon sock which was removed when disease was first observed. He
lives w' a small dogface who is showing signs of white spots but is
otherwise the same. These two have lived together for all of the last 3
years and believe it or not the cowfish will stop eating and lay on the
bottom for hours/days if the puffer isn't in the tank with him. (???!)
<Mmm, something introduced this parasite... I do doubt if it was
resident this whole interval... Some live food perhaps... most anything
"wet" from a biological setting could be a source>
So far we have done low salinity w' quick cure dip about 15 min.s, half
strength quick cure in tank yesterday.
<And returned the animals to the infested system? This won't help>
Today we have done Furazone dip in
under .010 salinity for 10 min.s.
<A good try...>
Any medical suggestions or plans of action would be greatly appreciated.
Can you diagnose from pics and info?
<Mmm, not determinately... But does appear to be Cryptocaryon
superficially>
This animal has tolerated/recovered w' flying colors from medicating
before so there is a history of successful tolerance to treatments that
most boxfish do not tolerate. Is there any further info or advice you
can provide?
Thanks a million,
Lee
<Mmm, unfortunately at this point, and in the short term, to urge you to
read quickly here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/mardisindex.htm
Scroll down to the royal blue line, tray below... And write back just as
soon if you have questions, concerns. I'll be out a good part of the
next day. Bob Fenner>
Re: Boxfish 911 to advanced issue
7/7/07
Mr. Fenner,
Thank you so much for your time and reply. My fiancé' (copied above) has almost
two decades pet store and wholesaler experience. She has probably seen nearly
anything/everything in that time. However this one stumps us.
I agree the salinity is a bit low per oceanic norm (ie 0.20 vs .023 to .26) but
that is the salinity this cowfish has thrived in for the last 3 years.
<These sorts of "chemical challenges" have ways of "catching up", expressing
themselves... What I really suspect is Mycobacterium marinum... or possibly
Vibriosis... but these are secondary to whatever causative factors here... and
need to be addressed>
I don't dispute some sort of infestation but I cannot pinpoint a cause.
<I can see the infestation, but as you, have no idea of the vector/etiology>
There have been zero live or other introductions. We literally set up QT/holding
tanks from tanks that have been dry for years, moved the fish to the holding
tanks, tore down and set up their old tanks, and reintroduced the fish with a 45
minute bucket ride from start to finish.
<Well... my best guess is that the Cryptocaryon (likely) is resultant from a
resident sub-symptomatic infestation... That it "was" always present... and that
the added stress... triggered a full-blown high-population episode>
All my fish (~500+ gallons) eat fresh/organic market mussels, cherrystone clams,
shrimp, spectrum pellets, and/or Mysis (MYSIS brand).
<These can also be a source...>
All of these come from the same sources. Fresh/Organic from the same high end
grocery store that has been supplying us for the last few years (and all the
other stores who sell "fresh" in the area).
<The protozoans can/do encyst on hard materials...>
The Mysis comes frozen from the LFS but is otherwise sealed.
<Not likely this if frozen>
While possible, one of these introduced a pathogen to no other tank (knocking
daggone hard on wood) that has shown signs. This fish in question has always
been the picture of greed and social interaction.
<Yes... otherwise appeared as a nice, just-sub-adult specimen... always like
seeing these in the wild...>
Since the Furazone dip his attitude has been much improved but the spots remain.
<Need to be treated differently than with an anti-microbial... Unfortunately
either with successive dips (formalin likely), and being moved to other
non-infested settings, or careful (chelated and tested for) copper...>
He is still in a weak quick cure solution
<Mmm, please see my notes re this mixture on WWM... I would NOT continuously
expose any life to Formalin>
for his holding tank but that can be "upped" to full strength or a copper
(SeaCure brand) can be added.
<This IS what I would do>
The Furazone dip seems to not make nearly the difference the antibiotic dip made
but the visible symptoms seem protozoan.
<No; again, it will not>
We did not dip tonight and are letting the fish have some recovery time but are
still observing VERY closely. Only other physical symptom is respiration seems
to be elevated. In the meantime his spots on fins are still very visible and his
color has not changed meaningfully. I do not want to dose with meds to the point
of stressing or injuring the fish worse than what his infection might yield.
<Well-stated. I agree>
The symptoms seem protozoan but the best results seem to come from antibiotic
treatments.
<The operative word here is "seem"... Do you have access to a microscope? I
would be looking for definitive identification here...>
Do you think switching to hypo-salinity would be the answer?
<No>
Please advise... This fish has been a happy/healthy specimen for the last 3
years and is near enough to my best "wet" friend.
What should we do from here?
Thanks immeasurably,
Lee
PS Tasida aka "petstorejunkie" above.
<I see... There is much, likely too much to relate through this process
(emailing daily)... and I want to add my note re being EXTREMELY careful in NOT
compounding your troubles by moving any water, anything wet twixt your systems
and to be VERY observant re your other fish livestock... Once such an
infestation become hyperinfective, it is very virulent... Otherwise, what little
I know re such incidents IS archived on WWM. I ask that you use the search tool,
indices... and write back with specific questions if there is something that is
unclear, insufficiently detailed. Bob Fenner. |
|
 |
Boxfish Troubles 2/16/07
Hello from Alabama,
Thank you for all of the help your website has given me. I have recently
purchased two boxfish (male and female, Ostracion meleagris) for a
maintenance customer of mine. I tried to talk him out of it but it didn't
work. The male is about 6"
<Wow, big!>
and the female is about 3.5". I got them from liveaquaria.com's "Diver's
Den", so we could see what we were getting.
<Nice feature, good company>
They haven't eaten since I received them a week ago. The fish are very
active but show no interest in food at all. I have tried fresh squid,
shrimp, scallops, and even live freshwater ghost shrimp.
<Wow...>
The male does have a small white bump/pimple on his belly, not sure what
this is.
<Likely no big deal>
If you think they may need some type of medication what would you recommend?
<I would NOT treat, or even move these Ostraciids... they can/do go on
"hunger strikes" particularly when moved... and won't starve for quite a
long while if in initially good condition... I would keep trying... with an
opened shellfish... when you call on this account>
They are in a 65 gallon quarantine that shares a wet/dry with a 40 gallon
quarantine that is holding a Rabbitfish. The customer has ordered a medium
Naso tang and a small flasher wrasse that will also go into this quarantine
system (in case this has any effect on
medication types). Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you,
Jeremy <><
<I encourage you to go ahead and place these fish... Will likely feed in the
main/display tank... in time... versus possibly never feeding and perishing
from "stress" in quarantine. Bob Fenner>
Lactoria cornuta... hornless or horny? 9/26/06
Hi guys, a quick question if you would. I have a 3" specimen in a 180; he is
newly collected and doing well, but spooks now and then when I've had to do
maintenance; typically, he tried the flying fish routine and whacked the cover -
he is longhorn no more; will the horns regrow in time? Thanks, Steve.
<Yes, very likely so. Bob Fenner>
- 'Gentle' Ich treatment for cowfish? (Tetrasomus gibbosus) 6/25/06 -
Hello,
<Good morning.>
Have you ever had one of those frustrating days wherein the more you try to
learn, the less you're sure of what you know? <Often.> Dear oh dear. <Bear with
it.> I'm having one of them, and I really hope you can help.
<I will do my best.>
My problem, in brief, is a cowfish (Tetrasomus gibbosus.. common names pretty
much too numerous to list!) with what has all the earmarks of a burgeoning ich
infestation. It started as one dot, vanished, came back as two, vanished.. etc.
until he was covered with dots. Hoping that I "hadn't seen that" was, in
hindsight, a mistake.
The cowfish is about an inch-and-half long; we've had him for about four
months. He is the sole inhabitant of a four year old 54 gallon (yes, 54..
corner bowfront) tank with around 20 pounds of liverock, about two inches of
aragonite sand, and a large clump of cheerful and fast-growing Caulerpa (LFS
calls it "sawtooth".. pretty accurate description of its narrow, jagged
leaves). The skimmer is a CPR Bakpak2, and the filter is an Eheim 2213. My
Visitherm heater has given me so little trouble that I cannot remember its
wattage, and lighting is provided by aging PC bulbs (1 actinic, 1 daylight, 55w
each.) Salinity is 1.023, Ammonia and Nitrites are at 0, and Nitrates hover
around 15-20ish. Temp. is 78 F. pH is about 8.2.
Current moment finds "Roz" in a five-gallon Q tank, awaiting his fate. He acts
completely normal, and eats well, but the dots persist (I did try turning off
the skimmer.. alas, it wasn't bubbles). I don't know what to do: half the
crowd says that treating ich with hyposalinity is Great and Good, especially for
copper-sensitive cowfish; the other half says that hyposalinity "treatments" are
a waste of time, because they aren't curing anything. <I prefer hyposalinity as
a dip or bath.> Everyone says "..and for the love of God, be CAREFUL with
formalin if you haven't used it before, it is extremely toxic!" <THAT is for
certain.> Aaahh, what to do!? <You actually have the answers right there.>
I am slowly raising the temp in the empty main tank (had to crack coralline off
the Visitherm to do so. haven't changed it since I set it out of the box!), to
encourage the ich to 'cycle' itself and die, but I'm not sure what to do with
the cowfish. Mr. LFS sold me a wee bottle of Cupramine, but I haven't used
it. I also haven't dipped the cowfish, as Mr. LFS said there was no point in
doing so (parasites under slime coat, etc.) <Even so, often remarkably
effective.> Well, he was wrong about that, it seems. Drat. <Ahh... no worries,
live and learn, right? We'll get Roz hooked up.>
So.. what treatment course would you recommend, here? The cowfish is well, hale
and happy; but I know he won't stay that way without help. <Or will he? It's
been my observation that some of the scaleless fishes are always carrying around
something on their skin - not all of this group, but mostly the advanced ones
(boxfish, puffers, etc.). In spite of these parasites, they always seem to keep
on trucking and behave/eat like they always do with what seem to be no long term
ill effects or contamination of tankmates. Could be that Roz is like this...>
I've warmed the Q tank up a little, to about 80 F.. already there are fewer
visible dots on him. I did put gravel in the Q tank. a scant double handful of
new, freshly washed coral gravel, because the shiny bottom appeared to be
upsetting Roz quite badly. <Yes - is my strong belief that while some fish may
react to their reflection in the side glass, many more are completely freaked by
their reflection in the bottom glass. I paint my quarantine tanks or put contact
paper on at least the bottom (outside).> That 'other cowfish' was talking trash,
it would seem.. Should I remove it? <Without a doubt.> Would Paraguard/similar
Malachite green formulation be a better choice than the Cupramine/copper
formulation? <If things seem out of control, then yes, but I'm not sure we're at
that point.> At this point, the wisest treatment course seems to be the
gentlest, most patient one: if I'm starting with a healthy fish, then perhaps I
can afford to expend more time/effort on my part to spare him a harsh, "last
ditch" style of treatment... I have the luxury of a ich-y (haha!) fish who is
still in good health... but I'm not sure how to be 'gentle' and still get rid of
the ich. <It seems to me you had the answer all along. This is an otherwise
healthy fish in an ideal situation - he has a 54 corner all to himself. I'd
leave him be if he eats and behaves normally. If the spots are frequent and
increasing, then I'd give it a long, pH/temperature-adjusted freshwater dip and
then return to the main tank. If things move beyond that, I'd consider a Quick
Cure/Paraguard bath in a bucket of tank water, treated for the amount of water
in the bucket, perhaps an hour if the fish seems otherwise fine. But for now, a
freshwater dip, return to the tank, and the resultant reduction in stress should
work well. Perhaps some more live rock at some point down the line would help,
but not right now. Keep on a good water change regimen (10% every 2 weeks) and I
think Roz will be fine.>
Thank you very, very much in advance!
Ramie
<Cheers, J -- >
Blue spotter puffer poor eyesight 6/17/06
Hi,
<Hello there>
I have a puffer who doesn't seem to see very well.
<Not uncommon... sometimes traceable to nutritional deficiency, other times to
pathogens...>
It tries to eat but just misses the target. What gives? I have
started feeding it by smashing the food on the side of the tank and that seems
to help, but is there anything I
could do to better it's eyesight. Help!
<Try the Google search tool on WWM... "Puffer eyesight". Read the cached
versions.
Bob Fenner>
Sick cowfish 3/16/06
Hello Ladies and Gents,
I have a 3 inch long Lactoria cornuta who has what I think is some type of
external bacterial infection. There are several small spots by his rear "horns"
that look like the skin has eroded away exposing his "carapace." He also
appears to be breathing fast. (Still has a good appetite though - eats clam, PE
mysis, silverside chunks, and Omega 3 Superveggies - flakes soaked before
feeding so they sink). Water parameters are as follows: Ammonia 0, Nitrite 0,
nitrate ~ 30, temp 79F, SG 1.025, pH 8.0, alk 8dkh (trying to raise this with
buffers). Would Furanace or Metronidazole be appropriate treatments?
<Mmm, w/o knowing that there is microbial or protozoal involvement, I would
not...>
I know that it is best to treat in a hospital tank, but would these medications
harm the display tank? - negatively impact bacteria, live rock, etc.
<Yes>
What do you think of Melafix?
<A mild cathartic at best. I would not, do not use it>
Thank you in advance for your wisdom and help.
Sincerely,
Eric
<I would bolster the animals immune system by soaking the aforementioned foods
in a supplement like Selcon, Microvit... and leave it alone otherwise. Bob
Fenner>
Puffer Tooth Loss 2/28/2006
I have a blue spotted puffer with a tooth problem. We have had “puffet" for
about 1 1/2 yrs. Great eater, one of the best fish we have ever had. Our
problem is that she has lost one of her teeth.
<<Aww>>
The local fish stores that carry these fish have never heard of this. They have
heard of the teeth chipping away but never falling out. Before the tooth fell
out she had not been eating very much and really not very social. Now that the
tooth fell out she is almost 100% again, the eating is not what it use to be but
at least she is eating. What do you make of this? We would love to know if
anyone else has had this happen!
<<I have seen this happen a few times. So long as feeding is not affected,
housing and water quality is up to par, and it is not a result of physical
trauma, I would not worry too much. Keep an eye on her to ensure no infection
sets in, and that she is eating. Also pay close attention to her other teeth,
as they may over grow with this tooth missing. Good luck. Lisa.>>
Boxfish has white film on eyes - 2/28/2006
Help, I have had a yellow cowfish for about a year now and soon after I
transferred him over to a new tank with the same fish he got ICH probably from
the stress of moving.
<To be clear here: the fish and system already "had, have" the ich... the added
stress just brought it to symptomatic level>
Since he is scale less, I have stayed away from copper based meds and LFS
recommended Rid ICH +
<... look at the ingredients here... Malachite Green and... Formalin... much
more toxic>
for a full 14 days with 25% daily water changes. He seemed to be getting better
but when I came home from work both of his eyes were cloudy basically within 8
hours.
<Could be from many causes... likely the medicine exposure period>
I checked pervious posts here and there was some discussion but I don't think
its fungus or a scratch from the live rock. I have several questions, could ICH
actually get on the surface of the eye, is he dying, will he go blind even if I
can cure him?
<Not likely Crypt on the eyes you're seeing... but something akin to chemical
burn>
He is otherwise very healthy, and was trying to eat but could not see the
food. Could the medication cause this?
<Yes>
I have been thinking about a fresh water dip but would the added stress kill
him? And finally, do you know if any links that might list vets that
specialize in
marine fish in Los Angeles area?
<Mmm, I don't... but would contact the LA marine club (put MASLAC in your search
tools) and ask them re. Not likely anything other than clean water, rest
needed/called for here. The cloudiness will cure on its own and feeding resume
with time going by, good care. Bob Fenner>
Cowfish W/Dangling-Broken Horn - 01/10/06
Hello,
<<Howdy>>
I've looked through your site and the net searching for a situation that was
similar to mine. Unfortunately I couldn't find anything about it.
<<Ok>>
My cowfish made a quick movement today near the corner of the tank and somehow
ended up breaking his rear horn that is below the tail.
<<Wow...must have been some "movement.">>
It is barely hanging there and I would like to know if I should let it fall off
or cut the thread of skin that is keeping it dangling there.
<<Unless it is causing a problem/getting in the way of its movement in the tank
I would leave it be. Likely much more stressful/harmful to capture and handle
the cowfish.>>
Also, will it grow back?
<<I really don't know...but am doubtful.>>
Should I take any extra precautionary measures in order to keep it from becoming
infected?
<<Likely will be fine, though iodine/iodide dosed to the system may be of some
benefit.>>
It seems to have broken about a half-inch away from where it joins the rest of
his body. Please tell me anything I can do to make him happier in this
unfortunate situation. BTW he is still eating like a champ and constantly
watering the areas outside the tank as usual (I assume that's a good sign).
<<Ha! Yes...just vying for your attentions.>>
Do you think that he can even feel pain from this, b/c he sure isn't acting like
he's in pain.
<<Is most likely just fine.>>
Thanks,
Garen Wright
<<Regards, EricR>>
Help! Moo is sick 1/7/06
Hello all,
<Moooo!>
I have a sick 2 inch longhorn scaleless who has what appears to be Ich. (I do
know about the feeding requirements and eventual size of this fish. He's going
into a 75 gallon tank for now and then a 220 once he's of decent size).
<I take it this is a Lactoria cornutus/a>
I know that these fish are scale-less and therefore copper is not a safe
treatment. I've read of several other possibilities and wanted your opinion.
<Copper (chelated best) can be used... carefully>
The first was a 30-60 minute formalin bath (I'd use Formalin 3 and follow the
directions) in a separate container/tank filled with water from the display
tank. The second treatment was hyposalinity (which I am familiar with and have
used in the past with mixed results - one fish cured, one fish didn't survive to
the treatment's completion). Currently I do not have a hospital tank with
established filtration (the water and filter media are new so there is no
beneficial bacteria) for the hyposalinity technique. Will the Formalin bath
help until I'm able to set up the hospital tank?
<Mmm, the exposure is toxic to the fish... consecutive treatments are
progressively weakening...>
If I take a bag of ChemiPure from the display tank (been in the filter for about
3 weeks) would this be sufficient for the hospital tank (along with daily water
changes, buffering etc.)?
<Should help demonstrably>
Finally, I'm concerned about transferring this fish from display tank to
treatment tank. A net is out of the question. Going from the display to the
bath or hospital tank will be done by "scooping" the fish into a specimen
container with water from the tank to avoid exposure to air. What is the best
way to get the fish back into the display tank from the formalin bath?
<Mmm, overfilling and dumping most of the water out of the scooper with
new/clean water...>
Thank you for your time and expertise,
Eric
<Glad to share. Bob Fenner>
Re: Help! Moo is sick 1/8/06
Thank you for the quick response.
<Welcome>
The formalin bath did not seem to have any effect whatsoever (Ich parasites
clearly visible 24 hours later).
<... do you understand the "ich cycle?"... if treated with formalin, the life
cycle on the fish themselves will/could be eliminated... the resting stages are
going to cycle back on if you've left the fish in the same system... This is
posted on WWM re Crypt/Marine Ich>
In your reply you stated that copper COULD
be used "carefully." How arduous a process would this be?
<Posted as well... involves testing (at least daily... remoting to a treatment
system>
I'd like to use Cupramine and a Salifert test kit to monitor the copper levels
in the
hospital tank (was planning on using a 29 gallon tank with an Aquaclear 70
for filtration). Is this a viable solution or am I better off going with the 6
week hyposalinity treatment?
<... please see WWM... am not a fan of hyposalinity "treatments">
If you believe copper is the way to go could you please suggest a treatment
schedule - amount of copper in solution
and for how many days.
<Posted on WWM. Bob Fenner>
Thank you for your help,
Eric
Cowfish with eye trouble 12/21/05
I have an adult Cowfish (Kazoo) who started getting a cloudy eye, which he
has had before and recovered. I treated the 110gal tank with melafix and a
heavy dose of Novaqua+ and added aquarium salt. Now after two weeks a huge
amount of swelling and ulcerations developing I have put him in a 5 gal hospital
tank and am treating with Furacyn. Is this the best course of treatment? I am
just sick and love Kazoo. Please advise! Thanks!!!!
<Depends on the root cause of the trouble here... If unilateral (one-sided)
likely the trouble is resultant from a mechanical injury (a bump)... Do keep a
check on the water quality in the small tank, and try supplementing the fish's
foods with a vitamin et al. complex. Bob Fenner>
Hovercraft Boxfish All Stressed Out! - 12/04/05
We have had our Hovercraft Boxfish called 'Ermintrude' now since last March. Everything has been going really well although we find he gets a little stressed with new fish being added.
<<Mmm, a "he" eh...maybe just embarrassed <G>, isn't 'Ermintrude' of female origin?>>
We are extremely careful in this situation and return new fish back to our shop if he's not happy.
<<Hmm...from what I can find this fish (Tetrosomus gibbosus) is considered compatible with a wide variety of species.>>
We've noticed since adding a Boxer Shrimp over two weeks ago that when he goes near he goes really black in colour.
<<Curious>>
We've kept an eye on this and this appeared to calm down however over the last day or two he appears really fat although not eating much. He is also keeping well away from the Boxer Shrimp over the last day or too as well.
<<Coincidence, maybe.>>
Tonight we found him sucked up against the filter, he appeared lethargic and not himself.
<<Tis a real danger with these fish...not strong swimmers. Best to have protected intakes on filters/drain lines.>>
His shape has changed enormously and we fear infection but can't find anything on this. Any suggestions ?
Kay Bosanko-Sheady
<<Hard to say really. Ideally you should remove this fish to a dimly lit hospital tank to reduce stress and watch for/treat any physical injury from the filter incident, if necessary. Do some research on this fish and make sure you are providing a suitable environment...the filter incident aside, it does sound as if your fish is suffering from stress related issues. Regards,
EricR>>
Cowfish Buoyancy Issue 12/10/05
I think my cowfish has ingested some air. He is floating tail up. what should I do?
<True buoyancy problems are often idiopathic, it's hard to determine the route cause. The problem itself however is often associated with the swim bladder (small sack responsible for fishes level in the water
column) This could be dietary, the fish may have an impaction in it's digestive tract so I would use small pieces of easily digestive food (flakes,
Mysis shrimp) and see if this helps. Until then I would move him to a hospital tank so that he can avoid becoming a puppet of your current and avoid being picked on by tank mates. Keep water quality and oxygen levels high.>
Thanks in advance. Marc
<Adam J.>
Cowfish - poorly suited for aquarium life 6/18/05
I have a Long horn Cowfish.
<Ughhh... neat fish, but very poorly suited for aquarium life.>
It eats well and swims around.
<the bigger problem here is its adult size at 1.5 feet long! It will surely
stunt and die prematurely for being kept in an aquarium unless you get it to
a public aquarium sized display sooner rather than later. Its simply not
true that fishes "grow to their tanks size." Again... they just stunt and
die prematurely. Plus... this fish has toxic skin secretions. If stressed,
it can/will exude a substance that will kill every living fish in your
display including the cowfish itself. Please(!) research fishes before you
buy them my friend. This ill-advised purchase will at least cost this
specimen its life, likely.>
The problem is he is getting a stringy white growth over his horn and on the
top of its head. I don't know if it is bacteria or fungus. I have a 40
gallon FOWLR tank with 2 perculas, a neon goby and a blue tang. Any help
with identification and treatment would be great. Thanks
<Any treatment of this toxic fish must be done in an isolation tank. If you
do not have a QT tank, please read more in our archives and beyond about the
critical need for having one to succeed long term in this hobby. Also...
read more about your cowfish here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfishes.htm
and here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfshfaqs.htm
and here:
http://www.fishbase.org/Summary/SpeciesSummary.cfm?genusname=Lactoria&speciesname=cornuta
Do remove this fish to a QT tank as soon as you can condition a sponge
filter (in the display for several weeks). Use medicated food in the
meantime with hopes to buy time on the condition if it seems to be bacteria
or fungus (common on these sensitive fishes). Anthony>
- Long-horned Cowfish is Sick -
We have a 90 gallon tank. We have two puffers, a porcupine and not sure
what the other is, two tangs a fox faced and unsure of the other and two
long-horned cowfish. We have had the cowfish and the puffers for over a year
and they have remained healthy until now. Last week we added the tangs. As of
yesterday, we noticed the cowfish has rapid respiration, pale blotchy skin and
he is laying on the bottom of the tank. No signs of parasites or wounds. Any
suggestions as to treatment? <You may want to remove it to a quarantine tank and
see if mends without pressure from other fish. It's possible that it is the
object of aggression from one or more of your other fish.> Thanks for your help.
<Cheers, J -- >
Sick boxfish
I am worried about my Whitley's boxfish. I have had him for a couple of
months and he seemed to have settled in OK. Recently, he hasn't been eating so well and yesterday, he was lurking at the bottom of the tank.
<Wow... a male Whitley's Boxfish... very rare>
This morning, I found him lying on his side. I thought he was dead but when I nudged him, he
swam away but seemed slow and disoriented, tipping over on to his side. I can't see any external signs of disease and the water parameters are OK.
<What is OK?>
Other fish in the tank are Green Chromis and a couple of clown fish, who are currently fighting it out (I don't know whether this might be a cause of stress).
<Mmm, should be okay... do you see these damsels bugging the Box?>
I also added a couple more hermit crabs yesterday.
Please help - any advice welcome.
Len
<Help with? What about the history of your having this puffer? Your system? What have you done thus far? You did not place chemical treatments in this system I hope... I would at least execute a large (half) water change, add activated carbon to your filter flow path, read on WWM re all Puffer, Ostraciid System and Disease FAQs files. Start here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfishes.htm and work through them through the links above. Bob Fenner>
Boxfish with Marine Velvet
I have a juvenile yellow box fish with Marine Velvet. I just noticed it today. I
have placed him in a separate tank.
<excellent... 4 week minimum please in QT>
I am worried about the copper treatment.
<rightly so... they are scaleless and will overdose on copper. Rely on
closely supervised FW dips and formalin medications instead (without organic
dyes mixed in like malachite green)>
I have read that the box fish when nervous can secrete a toxin and can be
deadly?
<correct... they should not be kept with other fishes in small private tanks.
I suspect that you have a cubicus (yellow with black spots). Most boxfish get
12" or larger as adults. Cubit's exceed 2 feet long!!! This is a fish for
huge public aquariums... I wish they weren't sold to (us) casual aquarists. Most
die prematurely for being kept in small aquaria (under 300 gall)>
Thank you, Shelby
<best regards, Anthony>
Ich? on Yellow Boxfish
<Hello! Ananda here tonight>
We have had our boxfish in our tank for about a month. He has been
very healthy with no signs of disease until today when we noticed about 30 or
more white dots all over his body. We suspect ich, but the dots do
not seem to be clustered around his fins....yet? He is still eating,
breathing and swimming as usual.
<Those are good signs.>
We know not to treat him with copper since he is a scaleless fish, and we know
he secretes a toxin, which could kill everything in our tank, when he becomes
stressed.
<Yup.>
Our concern is will he release this toxin if we try to remove him from the tank
to do freshwater dips? Should we do freshwater dips?
<Yes, it's possible that your cowfish might release toxins if the freshwater
dip stresses it sufficiently. You can minimize the stress of a freshwater dip by
ensuring that the dip temperature and pH exactly match that of the display tank,
and by aerating the dip tank. However, some people prefer to save freshwater
dips as a last resort for these fish.>
Is there any other way to treat this fish? We have already started to
raise the temperature to 80 degrees and are starting to lower the salinity as
well.
<You've already started on the primary treatment: lower salinity and higher
temperatures. These would be best carried out in a bare-bottomed hospital tank,
along with daily water changes, siphoning from the bottom of the tank to get the
greatest number of ich cysts. I've read that people with cowfish are more likely
to use UV sterilizers -- which are good only against the free-swimming stage of
the parasite, mind you -- to help combat ich. Another favorite of the crew on
the Cowfish, Puffers, & More discussion group seems to be StopParasite. I
have no experience with that particular product, so I suggest you check the
Cowfish etc. discussion group for peoples' opinions: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CowfishPuffers_andMore/
>
Is it possible that this is something other than ich? His tankmates
are a Foxface, a damsel, a Kole tang and a couple of snails. Thanks
for any advice you can give.
<More on Boxfishes here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfshfaqs.htm
... --Ananda>
Dying Cowfish... 2/15/03
I have a cow fish Puffer, who'd tail is falling apart. It has the look of
raw skin, It all started when a hippo tang had a parasite so I purchased some
cleaner wrasse they cleaned up the hippo but my cow puffer did not like to be
cleaned. I have now started treatment with copper, and MelaFix, any idea what I
should do?
Thanks
Vince
<Well Vince, I start by putting the puffer in a Q tank
ASAP. Copper is bad for this type of fish. What are you
feeding your puffer? Try feeding the fish krill/shrimp dipped in
garlic extract. The MelaFix should help. You are going to
have to wait this one out. But please stop the
copper! Also is this fish being picked on by other
fish?? Hope this helps! Phil>
- Cowfish Corral -
Hullo Crew!
<And hello to you, JasonC here...>
And a very special but hurried hullo! to whoever is responding today (Bob? Anthony?) because
we are hoping that you can give us some very good advice very quickly-
<I will do my best.>
Our juvenile ( about 2") longhorn cowfish got caught in the intake of our
powerhead this morning; his head from the eyes up was caught. We
don't know for how long he was in there, except that the tank had been checked
about two hours previously, and he was fine then.
We immediately turned the powerhead OFF and freed him; he is currently slowly
wavering about the tank, fins flicking fairly rapidly. The only
obvious damage is a cloudiness/swelling over and around his eyes, and a somewhat
'bloodied' appearance over the back of his head between his horns. I'd
guess I'd call it a bruise if he was human; there are thin red lines tracing the
spaces between his bony skin-plates, he's not actually 'bleeding' from exposed
tissues. <Is actually more like a hickey - blood being pulled through the
skin.> I'll include a couple of pictures - blurry, but I think you can see
what's going on with his swollen eyes; and a 'before' shot for comparison.
http://www.deepdarksea.com/pics/trumpybefore.jpg
http://www.deepdarksea.com/pics/trumpy1.jpg
http://www.deepdarksea.com/pics/trumpy2.jpg
http://www.deepdarksea.com/pics/trumpy3.jpg
<Ouch...>
As of right now, about 20 minutes after we rescued him, the other inhabitants of
the tank are acting perfectly normal (no toxin release, thus far), and he is
moving up and down the water column a little bit more, and ate a little food.
<Ahh good... I've done similar in an attempt to let the fish know,
"Everything is cool." Have no clue if it works or not, but good thing
that Trumpy ate.> Still mostly hovering in one place, though, and not
reacting normally to visual stimuli. <I'm not surprised... could very well
lose that eye.>
So - what should we do? <Hmmm...> Watch and wait? <Good place to
start... you could also add some Epsom salts to help work on the swelling a bit
- about one teaspoon per gallon would do.> And if so - what are definite
signs that he's going downhill, and should be removed from the tank? <I'd
look for it to stop eating for starters.> Add more carbon to the filter?
<Yes.> Medicate him? <Not at the moment - might want to do something
about that power head so you don't have an instant replay. Peace and quiet would
be best at this point.> Any advice here would be helpful - we don't have a
quarantine tank, and thus far we've meticulously purchased only healthy fish, so
this is our first experience with an invalid. <I think it will be fine in the
long haul although things may look worse before they get better. Again, most
important to make sure it doesn't get re-injured or hassled by anyone in the
tank.>
A quick rundown on our tank specs:
29G FOWLR (YES, we are getting a bigger tank ASAP for the cowfish! Saving
up, saving up.. 8) )
CPR BakPak protein skimmer
Eheim canister filter (has a little carbon in right now)
2x55w PC hood
Nitrates and Nitrites, 0
Ammonia, 0
SG 1.023
pH 8.1
Thank you thank you,
Dustin and Ramie
<Cheers, J -- >
Formerly long-horned cowfish?
<Hi! Ananda here tonight...>
I have a long horned cow fish, it seems that one of my fish like to bite off his
horns 2 of the horns have been bitten off the cow is fine I'm just wondering if
those horns grow back? Can you please help?
<No, the horns are not likely to grow back. If another fish in the tank is
biting the cowfish's horns, I'm concerned that you're keeping incompatible
species together -- with sufficient aggravation, the cowfish may release the
ostracitoxin, which could wipe out your tank. Please do read up on these fish,
both on the WetWebMedia site, and on http://www.cowfishes.com,
and on the Yahoo group "Cowfish, Puffers, and More" at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CowfishPuffers_andMore/
.... --Ananda>
Thanks for the reply. (Boxfish, ich concerns)
Thanks for the quick reply- spent all day reading on the WWM
site.
EXCELLENT resource, we are lucky to have you. Saturday- moved the
fish to
the LFS. Separated the YP Box (he is in his own tank at the LFS), the
SF
tang and 2 Clowns are in another tank, and the Auriga and L. Blenny are in
another. The thing is, the LFS here in town have 1200 gallon system
that
circulates amongst the entire store- If the boxfish dies will this
contaminate the entire store?<possibly if he is not taken out
of the aquarium ASAP> Not only that- there is no way to up the
temp
and lower the salinity for an individual tank- they are all
linked. They
seemed unconcerned when I pointed out this detail. They are unable to
diagnose specifically (though they seem to think ICH because of the small
spots on the percula), but were quick to asses Copper treatment for the tang
and clownfish (moderate copper for the auriga and the blenny). but
after
reading all day I am kind of freaked out- These are not quarantine
tanks
and they have gravel bottoms, so I'm pretty much assured that the copper
will be absorbed by the gravel and it will be filtered through (no constant
copper) because of the water system set up (so totally ineffective?). <not
necessarily> The
LFS also said to treat there 3-5 days and back to our tank. I (now)
know
4-6 week minimum to run the course of the parasite- (at home while awaiting
fish we can) lower the salinity to 1.021 (says bob) 1.018 (says Steven pro)
and raise the temp. (no higher than 84f) since we have 2 cleaner shrimp
(already) and 2 emerald crabs and 20 lbs LR (no copper here thank you!!) we
are sort of stuck unless we move everyone to the LFS or get 3/4
QT.<agreed> But I am
still concerned for our fish at the LFS.<I would be also> I
know now (add another to the
list) that I should have had a Quarantine tank all set up and ready to go
and I think I need to go back and pick up my fish- like right
now.<agreed> Should I
have two QT? One set up for the box fish (and blenny? he is scale-less
right?<yeah this sounds like a good idea> maybe they should be separate if
the box fish doesn't make it) and
one for the tang, auriga?<yea> (Is the butterfly more sensitive?)
<probably so> I would like
to set up the QT and treat the Tang, Clowns, Butterfly with Copper.
(right?)<yes>
Then does everyone stay in the QT for 4-6 weeks?<yup> I love
my fish- I will be
very sad if they die (I already feel incredibly guilty- why aren't there
laws pet stores selling SWF without a license of some sort???<I honestly
cannot answer that one>
we bought the tank with fish already from people who were moving and have had to
learn
everything the hard way- and the LFS has pretty much told us ALL THE WRONG
THINGS).<most of them normally do, there are some exceptions but normally
they tell you
false info to make the quick sale> So how many QT? <2 of them
would be an excellent idea>
Should I move them again from the LFS to home?<this may stress them out
again, I would wait a while
and see if they progress at the LFS, because you are probably going to stress
the crap out of them
shipping them back and forth, etc> I
called the LFS today- and the owner said they looked fine (moron) and I
don't trust them to treat our fish... what do you recommend?<well you pretty
much
have to trust them right now, because again you don't want to stress them out
more
than they already are> Thanks for the
website- you are all excellent to have this website and answer all of these
questions...
Thanks again.<your welcome my friend, just wait and see how the fish look at
the LFS-with your own eyes
might I add!! lol. If they start to look worse I would setup my own QT aquarium
and treat the fish there. Hopefully
your LFS at least knows the basics of marine fish keeping and treating of
parasitic infections/ich. IanB>
-Erin
Cowfish with something odd in its eye
<Hi! Ananda here tonight...>
I could not find a answer in your q/a section.
<Well, that happens. That's why we're here...>
My cowfish had a attack of ick which I treated in a 25 gal sterile tank.
<Okay>
It cleared up but a short time later it developed a secondary infection of the
eye. The eye became distended, cloudy with what seemed like a thick cream
colored glob along the bottom of eye. I have treated it with copper an it soon
cleared up except for the glob. I do not wish
to continue this treatment if I don't have to, it has been 14 days It may have a
adverse effect on the fish although it seems to be doing fine.
<Copper is *not* something I would use with a cowfish! Do put a power filter
on the tank with some good carbon and consider using a different
treatment regimen. Check out the assorted articles and FAQs on marine ich (note
that's ich with an H, not ick with a K) for more info about treating ich in a
way that will be much less stressful to your cowfish. Also check out the Yahoo
group "Cowfish, Puffers, and More" at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CowfishPuffers_andMore/
...>
Do you know what this is and how I may treat it? ( I have Maracyn 2 but do not
know if it is wise to mix with the copper treatment)
<It may be "eye fungus", or a bacterial or parasite infestation of
the eye. Whichever one it might be, try "Eye Fungex" by Aquatronics.
Also keep a close watch on the water quality in the hospital tank. I am not sure
the Maracyn 2 would help.>
Thank You
R.Doughten
<You're welcome. I would be interested to hear how the treatment works out.
--Ananda>
Please help Mr. Cow!
Hello!
<Hi there Kara>
First off the basics are. 125 gallon tank, all parameters such as salinity, ph,
nitrate, nitrite, temp, etc. are good. In the tank are Mr. Cow
(longhorn cowfish - 7 inches w/tail), dog face puffer (4 inches), Picasso
trigger (2 inches), flame angel, mandarin and a neon puffer (2 inches).
<sounds like very nice fish. All fish with quite impressive
personalities. Though you have probably been told this before, but
Picassos can be quite nippy to slow moving fish, and sometimes more so with
puffer and cowfish. Also Neon puffer, I'm assuming is a Solandri
Sharpnose, very pretty fish>
We have had these fish for over a year and they all get along. At
least they do when I am watching them.
<glad you realize that many times battles happen with the lights are off, and
no one is around to see. It's a hard thing to drill into some fish
keepers.>
5 Days ago Mr. Cow stopped eating!
<defiantly not a good thing.>I believe he is constipated as well. I have
tried feeding him peas, corn, spinach and broccoli but he won't eat anything. He
normally ate the basics such as clam, shrimp, and other various frozen
varieties. I tried garlic extreme in the hopes of tempting him to eat but it
didn't work. I've held him (he let's us
pet/hold him) and tried feeding him but he simply clamps his mouth shut!
<have you changed anything recently in your tank, switched to another salt
brand, or done anything different? Cows can be temperamental at
times, and just suddenly turn off of foods due to a slight change in the tank. I
had a friend who's cowfish suddenly turned off of food for over a week and a
half after changing his salt mix.>
He is the "king" of the tank and would steal the other's food whenever
possible. I would have to trick him to the other side of the
tank with food so that the other fish would get some food. And they
say cowfish are slow movers/eaters! Not Mr. Cow. That's
why I am so concerned.
<I can understand your concern. Be sure to check out some of our
pages on WetWebMedia, you can find some of them here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfishes.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfshfaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfishfaq2.htm
They cover some good concerns over the care of cowfish>
Another thing I've noticed is that he is not as attentive to me. He
used to swim up and greet me all the time and "wag" his fins. He
used to be so happy. Now he seems to be in a haze and doesn't really
notice me. He looks over but that's about it.
< That is a similar trait to puffers and other distant relatives once they
turn away from food they seem to not be interested in anything. It
stands to reason cause food is their number one!>
What concerns me the most is that he seems to be bumping into things like the
glass, heaters and live rock. Not all of the time but he never did
that before. And he swims very slowly now, that is if he's not
"standing still" in the corner. The thing is he still blows bubbles
out of the water (for quite long amounts of time) as if he is hungry. But
he eats nothing. He'll just let the food float by or even hit him on
the face.
<Do you have a Quarantine tank set up to be able to house this fish? If
not you might want to set seriously consider setting up a tank as soon as
possible so you can move this fish away from the others. He might
simply be pestered by the trigger when no one is around and it's starting to
take a toll on him. Beside that, with not eating and these other
signs, I think it might be a good idea to move it to a separate tank so he runs
less chances of becoming sick in his weakened state. That said,
if he does show signs of sickness, then it's easier to medicate a QT then your
display tank.>
Now that Mr. Cow is not eating our trigger swims around more.
<Makes sense, the King is seemingly de-Crowned for the time being and the
trigger in my opinion would be the next aggressive in the tank following the
Cowfish>
In case he might be the problem (but I doubt it) we are giving our trigger away
to our LFS this weekend.
<If you set up a Quarantine Tank and move the cow to a new home, then the
need to trade in the trigger is not longer there.>
I've searched all over the internet, I have inquired on the puffer/cowfish
newsgroup, and no one has experienced this.
<I've had many folks with cowfish experience some similar. Many
times the cowfish bounces back with no problems other times it needs a bit of
TLC. I suggest you look at some of the mailing lists. There
is an amazing group of people totally dedicated to cowfish on the yahoo E-groups. My
advice to you is check out this group, I have a few friends there that are
extremely knowledgeable on the Cowfish. The link to that mailing
group is:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CowfishPuffers_andMore/
I've learned a great deal from the yahoo group lists. Many experts
there.>
Some people say that it might be a phase. I might be inclined to
believe that if he weren't also bumping into things.
<Agreed, not many "phases" in animals go by, not wanting to eat,
becoming lethargic and bumping into things.>
By the way - his coloring is normal, his fins look good and his eyes are clear. We
have 2 filters and two UV's running on the tank. The other fish are
all fine.
<That is good to hear. No spots or discolorations, so it might not
be a bad health concern. But, if this persists then the cowfish will
become weaker and less able to defend itself from infections and illness. >
If anyone has any solutions I would greatly appreciate it! I
am very worried and don't want to lose Mr. Cow. And I don't like to
see him
suffer because it breaks my heart. Thank you.
<Just keep monitoring the little guy, make sure that you offer it fresh and
meaty foods now. Try to spoil him with his favorite
"treats". I think that if you are going to trade in the
trigger to the LFS then maybe think about getting some equipment to set up a QT
for this cowfish. It is a good investment, and if you use it once
then it has paid for itself. Be sure to look through our FAQs, and
also check out the e-group being offered through yahoo. Hope that
helps. -Magnus>
Re: Please help Mr. Cow!
Hi Magnus,
Thank you for your quick response!
<That's what we are here for. We worry about your fish almost as
much as you do!>
To answer your question - no changes were made to the tank. I wish it
were something so predictable. My husband and I did bring our Trigger
to our LFS. Mr. Cow is still behaving oddly.
<Darn I was hoping it could have been something changed, so it could be a
possibly quick fix.>
And yes I had already joined the newsgroup at yahoo for cowfishes last week
before contacting you. Basically none of the members knew what to
make of it. Some said to wait a few weeks and that it might be a
phase.
<Well they are very knowledgeable on the subject of cowfish, a few of them
there are the ones that taught me.>
I also looked at the links you had also sent me at wet web media. I
found nothing and that's why I wrote to you. (By the way are there
more than just 2 pages of FAQ's on cowfishes at wet web media?. I had
seen only 2 pages and when you had sent me the links they were the same
pages. Are there more? Perhaps I am missing something.)
<Hopefully more pages will be added in the near future...>
So in conclusion it has been well over a week and Mr. Cow still isn't eating,
isn't responsive and is bumping into things? Do you know what
it could be?
<It's that mysterious illness that fish get ever once and awhile.. no visible
signs of sickness, no reason for it. It's times like that when you
wish the fish could just tell you what is wrong. I've lost a few
random fish though the years by having similar problems, and have had as many
fish suddenly get better with little to no help from me at all.>
We wouldn't even know what to treat him with in a quarantine tank. Oh
- his face seems to be getting paler (whiter). As in humans when we
are ill and our complexions pale. I guess we will set up a
quarantine tank and wait and see what happens.
<I found a really nice article discussing how to set up Quarantine tanks, it
gives you a general how to.
http://www.reefnut.com/Quarantine%20Article.htm
I highly recommend checking out the Forum on Reefnut, there are a couple people
who are extremely knowledgeable on medications and will no doubt be able to
help.>
If you have any ideas what this illness could be please let me know. I
gather once fish start bumping into things they don't generally last.
Thanks for all of your help!!!!!
<Not sure yet.. but I'm looking around for anything that can help. Not
all fish that bump into things are marked for death, many times medicines do
cure this up. But, check out Reefnut, see if one of them on the forum
might help.>
Sincerely, Kara
<Wish you and Mr. Cow the Best -Magnus>
Re: Please help Mr. Cow!
Hello again!
Sorry to bother you AGAIN.
<No problem. that is what we are here for.>
But I just noticed last night that Mr. Cow (by the way - nothing has changed
yet. He's still bumping into things and not eating) has a
"bubble" in his left eye. It's above his pupil in the outer
ring of the eye. I hope I am describing this correctly. It looks like
an air bubble if that's even possible. It is crystal clear - no puss
or any signs of infection. Do you know what this "bubble"
could be? It doesn't protrude from the eye either. It's like it's a
part of the eye but of course it doesn't belong there. This bubble
just appeared yesterday. I am worried that it will grow larger and
larger.
<Have you tried a freshwater dip yet for your cowfish? I might try
that if you haven't already. Do a 5 minute dip to see if it helps. Also,
I had a friend who had a similar issues with a porcupine puffer, he ended up
having a quarantine tank set up with Hypo-salinity. He lowered
salinity to 1.018-19 and kept the fish in there for a while. It
seemed to have a marked improvement. The fish can handle it, while
the bacteria and parasites could not. Cowfish/puffer/triggers are
often found swimming in to brackish environments to clear themselves of
pests.>
Once again, thanks for your help. Have a Happy New Year!!
<I do hope that you guy gets better. -Magnus>
Boxfish died
Hi crew,
<Hi! Ananda here tonight...>
I am sad to report that my little yellow spotted boxfish ( and I mean little)
died today :-(
<Sorry to hear that.>
On waking this morning, I checked the tank, and noticed he was swimming with a
fin clamped on one side, and it appeared to have a 'pod' of some sort hooked
onto it.
<A parasitic arthropod of some sort, I suspect.>
I was watching him, and he backed right into my Malu anemone.....Hmmmm didn't
like the look of that, so I did my "ER" routine, and did a 10% water
change, using the changed out water to immediately fill a hospital tank.
<In this case, I would have used non-tank water, from the stuff that you keep
ready for a water change.>
(I keep filter sponge for my little air powered hospital filter lying inside my
canister, so that I can get a little tank running in a few minutes if needs be).
<Good plan. Do rinse out the sponge in tap water to kill off anything now,
and pop it back in to re-cycle.>
An hour later, he/she seemed OK, if a little bewildered.....but
The poor little chap unfortunately expired during the course of the day, and is
now covered with a whitish coat (don't think it's an infestation, because it was
so quick).
<There are diseases that can move that quickly, but in this case, I
agree.>
Anyway, the tankmates......a Yellow tang, a couple of percula clowns, shrimp
anemone and a few cleanup crew, seem OK.....but
(here's my question)
Is there anything I should be doing precaution wise, and is there any way I can
test to see if the boxfish released any toxin?
<I don't think there's anything you could buy off-the-shelf to test for the
toxins. But I would immediately put a goodly amount of quality activated carbon
and perhaps a Polyfilter in the canister filter.>
Should I just do a succession of water changes?
<That will help, too.>
Is it possible that the Malu zapped the boxfish when he backed into it, rather
than it being an illness?
<Both are possible, but the boxfish's reaction after its encounter with the
anemone leads me to suspect it's the culprit in this case.>
The tank is 240 litres and the boxfish must have been a total of about 1 cubic
centimetre in volume (easy one with cubic fishes...huh?)
<Good grief, that is tiny.>
cheers, and thanks for invaluable help in the past.
Bob ( UK)
<You're quite welcome. --Ananda>
Re: Boxfish died......
Hey Thanks Ananda!
<Sure thing.>
I've already got the carbon running anyway, and the main canister filter top
layer is a double thickness of PolyFilter ( which I run as a usual course of
action).
<I'd change the carbon if it's more than a week old.>
I'll up my water changes for a while, and keep an eye on things.
The "box" was very small, and maybe just wasn't really up to life in
the tank, but he/she was to cute to miss........
It's funny how taking out 1/24000th of the volume of a tank can leave it so
empty.......the little chap seemed to be everywhere, nosing around.......
<The size comparison you're mentioning -- 1 cu cm fish in a 240 litre tank --
makes me realize just how much area these fish will cover, given a chance.
Should you get another one later, do consider a bigger tank as it gets older!
(Your 240 litres is about 63 gallons... not a large tank by any means, for a
marine system.)>
Thanks for the advice
Bob (UK)
<You're quiet welcome. --Ananda>
Boxfish acting "funny", but no one's laughing
Hi guys,
I have an adult yellow boxfish. It has been in my tank for about three
weeks and had been eating okay. Yesterday I found it on one side at the
bottom of my tank. It shows no sign of ick or any discoloration. It's
fins all are clear and still move, but as I said it just lays on it's
side. My tank is well established and is a 150 gallon. I have a dwarf
angel a Clark clown one anemone and lot's of live rock. Please help!!!
Scott
<Mmm, it may be that this fish is still "settling in"... and Boxfishes,
like all puffers, do occasionally go on "feeding strikes", often with
no discernible "reason". I would be patient here (for about a week)...
and try offering a myriad of frozen/defrosted meaty foods... particularly a
whole cocktail shrimp (sans sauce) and an opened bivalve/clam or mussel. If this
animal is still not eating in a week, please write back. Bob Fenner>
Boxfish, in the big aquarium in the sky
Yeah he went on a feeding strike. In fact he went on a breathing strike
too! It blows!!! Or doesn't, rather. He's gone.
<Appreciate the humor, sorry for the loss>
I appreciate the help
but my fears were realized Wednesday. I found him in the same place on
his back and since there were no free weights in my tank I can only
assume he had passed. I zip locked him in a bag with some water and
froze him. I understand this is still the most humane method, even
though he was for sure dead, in removing a fish from your tank.
<Wish you were my neighbor, make that the prez!>
Anyway
thanks for the help. I am just glad I wasn't attached. I really hate to
lose any fish but it is so much worse when you've had them for a while.
Peace,
Scott
<And to you my friend. Bob Fenner>
Longhorn Cowfish with Ich (7/25/04)
Hi there <Hi there to you as well Leslie here this evening!>
I have a Longhorn Cowfish that has ich. < Awwwww bummer I'm sorry. It's not
unusual for these guys to get ich. They are ich magnets. > I have tried the kick
ich treatment and it doesn't seem to be working. < I have not had much luck with
this product either> I was wondering if there is anything that I can do for my
fish. < My preferred treatment is hyposalinity I find it quite effective and
the fish seem to do very well. The nice part is the fish can be treated in the
main tank as long as you have no critters that will be adversely effected by
hyposalinity. The following links will tell you all you need to know to do
this.....
Hyposalinity:
http://petsforum.com/personal/trevor-jones/hyposalinity.html and
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/martrthyposalfaqs.htm
Marine Ich: Fighting The War On Two Fronts: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm
Ich:
http://petsforum.com/personal/trevor-jones/marineich.html and
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm
Please also see this article and the associated FAQs
The Three Sets of Factors that Determine Livestock Health
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/mardisease.htm
If you can help me out that would be great. Michelle
< I hope this helps, best of luck with your Cowfish, Leslie>
Strange color on Cowfish (5/15/04)
Hey you guys! <Hi there, you have Leslie here tonight>
I hope you can help me on this one... < I will do my best> I just purchased a Lactoria cornuta from the LFS. He's about 1.25 in and he's spotted in a strange manner. I included a picture. I'm keeping him under quarantine for a month < Excellent plan> and I hope he doesn't have ich < they are prone to ich> or some other disease because I only have
Coppersafe and can't seem to find any formalin-only med in my area (rid-ich doesn't qualify I suppose). <No worries, there are several meds available online. Two good sources are ....
Dr Foster and Smith http://www.drsfostersmith.com/Product/NavResults.cfm?Ne=40000&ref=3167&subref=AC&N=2004+113521
and National Fish Pharmaceuticals http://www.fishyfarmacy.com/
It is a good idea to keep some of the common ones on hand. I prefer freshwater dips and hyposalinity for ich myself.>
Can you identify if the spotting is normal or not? and if not what is the recommended remedy - and what is the creative remedy! < It is really hard to tell from that photo but his markings look normal form what I can see. Have a look here and compare your fish to these for a better idea
http://www.divegallery.com/cowfish.htm
http://www.divegallery.com/cowfish_pair.htm
>
I plan to put him in a 29 gal for about 6 months and then transfer him in a 75 gal. The fish in the 29 gal are 2 Amphiprion ocellaris of 1.5 inches (clownfish) - 1 Chromis xanthurus of 1.5 inches (yellowtail damsel) - 1 very mild mannered
Diodon nicthemerus of 2 inches (porcupine puffer) - 1 Canthigaster epilamprus of 2 inches (blue dot puffer) - a bunch of hermit crabs and a coral banded shrimp and a
Mithrax crab - see the puffers are very mild! <They are still small and young> the only bullying going on is the damsel chasing the fish out of it's live rock caves. I know I might be overstocked a tad <I would say a few tads more than a tad> but so far everyone seems cozy and the 75ver should make it roomier for when they grow. <You are looking at 240 plus gallons for when they grow. A general rule of thumb is 10g per inch of Puffer. Your Cowfish has the potential of reaching 19 inches and that Puffer 24 inches.
Here are the specifics:
Specific Gravity - 1.020
Ammonia - 0pmm
Nitrite - 0ppm
Nitrate - < 50ppm < this is a tad high under 20 would be much better for your fish>
pH - 8.2
temperature - 80F
and the setup is:
1 hang- on filter 125gph
1 Prizm skimmer
20 lb of live rock
crushed coral sub
thanks in advance for your time! José
<Your welcome, Leslie>
How Is The Cow Now? (Sick Cowfish)
I have a very gorgeous cowfish. He shares his tank with a yellow Tang, Sailfin, Trigger, Clownfish, Goby and a
Valentini Puffer. I've had this tank for almost 2 years with no problems. My Nitrate, ammonia, nitrate and pH is all good. Last couple of weeks, I lost my yellow tang and my goby.
<Yikes! Sorry to hear that...Scott F. with you today>
I checked for ICK and did not find any spots. I'm an not sure what's going on in this tank. No white spots (ick) visible but
I'm wondering if this is a parasite issue. My sailfin seems to be scratching on the rock and now my Cowfish is not eating and he looks as to be a little itchy. He also has a slight pink color on him.
<Well, it sounds like you may very well be dealing with a parasitic disease of some sort...The lack of visible spots
doesn't mean that it isn't Ich or Amyloodinium. In fact, the pinkish color that you describe could be tissue being
liquefied..
signs of the more serious Amyloodinium...The fact that your other fish died quickly after contracting this malady leads me to believe that this one may be a distinct possibility...>
What do I do??? I have a hospital tank all ready to go and I will put him in there. My question is, how can I treat the parasite issue? What medication (If any) do I need? Please help. I
want to do all I can to help my babies. Thank you in advance for helping. Frank
<Well, Frank, I'm glad that you have the "hospital tank" ready to go. I'd utilize freshwater dips, followed by a course of treatment with a
based-based product for this malady. Follow the manufacturer's instructions exactly. Be sure to observe the fish carefully, and make sure that the fish starts eating again. Frankly, I'd remove all remaining fish from the main tank and use the "fallow tank technique" that we advocate for dealing with parasitic infections...Hang in there. With quick action on your part, you can beat this malady! See the WWM parasitic disease FAQs for more information. Good luck! Regards, Scott F.>
Cuban Yellow Boxfish
<Hi Bryan, just want to apologize somehow I overlooked this email. I'm very sorry for the delay in response.>
Hey guys I just got a Cuban yellow boxfish 2 days ago. Everything was fine until I got up from watching the NCAA games to find the boxfish stuck to the side of my filter.
<This happens quite frequently with box fish. They can't swim very quickly and often get caught in the intakes. Place a sponge around the intake and it will take away the risk of it getting stuck on there.>
I turned off and the filter and freed the fish, but I am worried that the stress may have caused him to poison the tank.
<It's a viable concern, but it doesn't happen as frequently as you read about.>
I have taken him out of the tank and put him in a quarantine, but how long will it take before I will know if he poisoned the tank?
<within 12 hours you will see lethargy in the other tankmates. Doing a large
water change will help dissipate the toxin should there be any in the water.>
Obviously I'll know if the other fish are dead in the morning, but any there any other signs. I have already done a water change on the main tank and have my carbon running as well.
<That would be the best course of action. Hopefully it all worked out well. Another thing you might want to consider is having a skimmer on hand just in case. If you do feel that he might have spread toxic material in the water,
I have read reports of how skimming the water and doing water changes have greatly reduced toxin-kills.>
Sincerely,
Bryan Mortlock
<Best of luck, and like I had said before, sorry for the oversight. I do hope it all turned out okay. Add a sponge cover to the filter and it will take away the danger of that happening again. -Magnus.>
Dip a Cow?
>Hi, I have a couple of questions on quarantine and dipping. I
will be purchasing a juvenile tank raised percula clown and a small juvenile
long horn cow. My questions are: will it be okay to quarantine them
in the same tank (10 gallon with a 3" PVC elbow for a hiding
spot)?
>>I wouldn't unless they're both 1" or less. I would also
provide a few more hiding places, and/or cover the tank sides with black plastic
so they feel a bit more secure. Three of the four sides should help
tremendously. If you can get a 20 gallon, that would be much better
(or a Rubbermaid tub).
>With the dipping, I have Meth blue I had intended to use with freshwater,
but is it safe for the cow?
>>The Methylene blue is safe, but I would be careful dipping the
cowfish. Post dip I would definitely place it separately from the
clown. Cows are one of the few species I've actually made a practice
to not dip.
>Should I just use freshwater, or use saltwater with the Meth?
>>I think an acclimation in separate vessel (all acclimations should be
done in vessel separate from final destination) with the Methylene blue would be
fine for the cow.
>I don't want to stress the cow out too much, in fear of toxin
release. Also, on another note. I have a 2 month old 72
gallon tank. 50 lbs of live rock, 25 lbs of base rock. 25
lbs of live sand and 25 lbs of marine sand. Inhabitants are 2 turbo snails, a
camel shrimp ( in memory of my peppermint shrimp, the happiest shrimp in the
world ), and a handful of dwarf blue and scarlet hermit crabs.
>>Watch the camel, they're not always so amicable as peps.
>I have been unable to keep the pH up in this tank for quite some time
now. I have carbon and some phosphate sponge running in the
filter. The pH keeps dropping to about 7.9.
>>That's actually not terribly bad. If the inhabitants are
happy and healthy, then consider these other issues: wintertime in colder
climates many folks experience sufficient build up of carbon dioxide as to lower
pH. Faulty/inaccurate test kit.
>I have done a 50% water change with fresh salt in hopes that it would
balance out the pH, but with no luck. I had even taken water out of
the main tank to fill the quarantine tank, and the main tank is down to 7.9, but
the quarantine is at 8.1. Any ideas on what is draining the pH in the
main tank?
>>Not at this time.
>When I first filled this tank, the pH was at 8.4, so I figured a large water
change would work.
>>Don't fiddle with pH so much, 8.4 was fine, too. You can
QUICKLY kill many animals doing this.
>I know sometimes it is hard to keep the pH up in well established or older
tanks, but this one is neither. I plan on buying a buffer for it, but
I am wondering on what may be causing this. Will I need the buffer
for the life of this tank?
>>This depends, I would tend to look at these other
issues. It's difficult for anyone to say without knowing much more
about the life, etc., to determine what's going on.
>I thought today's salt mixes were made to establish a correct
pH.
>>Allegedly, I like good old Instant Ocean, but prefer Real Ocean over
that.
>Please, any suggestions would be wonderful. Thanks again for the
fabulous info.
Cat
>>You're welcome, try testing with a different kit, OR, if you can afford
it, buy a pH meter instead (be sure to calibrate it
carefully). Marina
Quarantine Query (Pt. 2)
Thank you Scott for your advice.
<My pleasure!>
A follow up question I have is why is it
not a good idea to dip a cowfish? I have actually dipped him a few times
for up to ten minutes and he did not seem to mind it at all and
afterwards I could see that some of the ich had burst. I don't really
need to dip him anymore however as the copper is working nicely.
Thanks, Matt
<Well, Matt, these fishes can release toxins when stressed or agitated, and
this toxin can kill the cowfish or other fishes present in its container or
tank. This is why I err on the side of caution with these fish. You're right,
many specimens have no problem with such dips, but they can be stress-inducing,
so be careful. Glad to hear that the copper is working well! Good luck! Regards,
Scott F.>
Boxfish Ostracion Cubicus sick after powerhead injury (8/9/04)
Hello All, <Just Leslie here this evening>
I have had a tank for almost 3 years now and the boxfish nearly that long. Two
days ago he was stuck in the intake to my overflow box.
<OH no :( so sorry to hear that.>
His skin injuries are minimal, but he is growing steadily weaker.
< I think there is a good chance you are dealing with internal injuries>
This morning he was on the bottom of my tank, but I nudged him and he went
swimming around. Not very well I must say. He does not seem to have any external
parasites, he has always had an ich spot or two. He also ignored food the last
two days.
< Oh not good I am afraid. >
I am thinking of treating him with antibiotics.
< I really do not think antibiotics will help your fish...it sounds like he
sustained internal injuries. IMO antibiotics will just add insult to injury and
stress him further. >
Do you have a suggestion as to what to treat him with or is there something else
I can do? .
<These fish possess ostracitoxin a positions substance which they can and do
release when stressed. This toxin has been know to wipe out entire tanks and
it's effects are not reversible. I think your best bet would be to isolate him
in another tank. >
The tank parameters are pristine, the other fish are behaving normally.
< Well that is excellent news. My preference would be to error on the side of
caution and remove your boxfish to a nice quiet tank by himself. This would
serve 2 purposes.....keep your other fish out of harms way and give your boxfish
a nice quiet place to rest and if you decide to medicate him the best place to
do it. >
Thank you for your time. Michael
<You are most welcome, best of luck with your boxfish, Leslie>
Boxfish Ostracion Cubicus sick after powerhead injury Follow up 8/13/04
Thank you for our response.
< Your most welcome!!!>
I actually did put him in an isolated, slow
current tank (no Meds). I had to 'force feed' him, but the results are showing.
He is looking stronger and more alert. I will move him back as soon as he can
find food and eat on his own.
<That's great news Keep up the good work!>
Thank you again for the valuable information contained in this website! Michael
<Again your most welcome :), Leslie >
Boxfish Tank Nuke
Hi,
<Hi, Bruce from Oz, Mike D here>
A Couple of days a go my boxfish died and did what everyone is warned
about, nuked the tank.. well almost. I think I found it very soon after
the death. I quickly did a water change and bagged all the fish and
took them to my pet store to house them.<ouch> I have lost 4 fish out of 8
including the box.<Was it a Blue Box? That's the only species well known for
"nuking" a tank, per se> My question is how to deal with the tank. I have 50
gal (200 litres for us Aussies), anyway I have done about 40% water
change.<You'll likely end up doing more, but I'd slow down and do it in more
gradual conditions to avoid stress to the corals> The corals are looking a
little sick, but I think that is
because of the water change and moving all the rock to catch the fish.<You're
quite likely correct here>
I have a protein skimmer going full bore and you should see the black
stuff that it has got out.<THAT'S not from the boxfish, and may be the actual
reason for your catastrophe> The worms in the rock are still doing what
worms do, the bloody mantis shrimp I know is in there (and suspect cause
this mess) didn't die (bastard) and can still be heard (yes, I have so
far got rid of 2 but I keep hearing the bastards).<Are you sure it's mantis
shrimp and not pistol shrimp? Both are extremely secretive and make the famous
"popping noise"> I have cycled the
tank for a day and put in a couple of blue/green Chromis to check the
water.<I'd suggest doing 5 gal/day and hold off on adding fish. If they break
down, they're prime targets for ick or such and you may be breeding more
problems for yourself. You don't need fish to "cycle" anything, a even the
mantis shrimp will accomplish that for you> One looks ok, but is hiding in the
rock (sort of strange for these
type of fish) and the other after a couple of hours is panting and
scales are slowly turning black. I'd get them back out, if possible, myself> I
have been checking around the web on
what to do if the toxin is released, all I can find is warnings. Yes I
knew about it before I put the guy in. He was happy and feeding and
loving life for weeks.<There's a very real problem with boxfish that many people
don't understand, being that they have very tiny mouths and stomachs, thus need
to eat non-stop. Many that people think are doing well are slowly starving to
death, and the smaller the boxfish, the more likely this is to occur, as even
more food is required fro growth>
The list of fish dead are:
Boxfish, Foxface Rabbitfish (he's death was not pleasant to watch)<very few
are>,
flame hawk, flame dwarf angel
Survivors (so far)
2 blue/green Chromis (well they might kick it due to reintroduction too
early), goldenheaded sleeper goby, fake clown, coral-banded shrimp,
sixlined wrasse
The stupid thing about it was the tank was close to being complete,
with a little bit more mantis shrimp hunting and a couple more corals.<I'm going
to go out on a limb and say I truly don't think the boxfish was the entire
problem, with impatience likely being as big a culprit>
Any thoughts, suggestions and I guess actively calling me stupid
welcome.<Never stupid Bruce, for as hard as it is to deal with, it's sadly all
part of the learning process. You didn't say how large the tank is, what the
ammonia and nitrite levels were, nor how long the whole thing has been up and
running. I suspect that you'll find you had high nitrite and ammonia levels (as
evidenced by your skimmate) and that too much was placed in the tank too soon
after it had cycled. You DID let it set for six weeks before adding fish to
allow it to cycle, correct? If not, I'd suggest using our google and entering
cycle or cycling, as well as reading
FAQs on same. If I'm wrong, I'll personally apologize, but I suspect the boxfish
is being used as the excuse, while it was quite likely just one of the victims>
Thanks
Bruce Moyle
Re: Boxfish Tank Nuke
Hi Mike,
<Hi again, Richard>
!Thanks for the reply, I eventually lost 6 fish, but on the better note,
all is back to normal in the tank.<That's good to hear!> I am sorry I didn't
give you some
info, so I will give it now. I cycled the tank for 8 weeks before
adding fish (about 12 months ago)<OK, my apologies here. Many people rush to
load a tank to capacity as soon as it finishes cycling, not realizing that tanks
remain relatively unstable for up to a year>. Slowly adding fish every 2 weeks
or
so between some corals.<This may have played a part as well, as with their
constant grazing Boxfish can occasionally "bite off more than they can chew" and
may well "sample" something that could lead to a fast decline>.
The nitrate levels were at 0 at time of nuking,
the ammonia was up, but I think that was due to fish dying<Very possible, but
the large amount of skimmate you were getting indicates a lot of extra organic
matter coming from somewhere>. pH was
normal too. I agree with the boxfish starving, just so hard to tell.<And even
harder with boxfish. With "normal" fish you can tell when they are getting
"hollow" but the rigid shell of the boxfish makes it nearly impossible from
visual clues>
The boxfish wasn't a blue unless they are different colour before
changing. He was a cream base with brown scribbles all over him, and
was 4-5 inches long.<These aren't noted for being particularly prone to release
toxins, but being stung by an Elegance coral, for example, might well trigger
it> I also know that there is mantis shrimp, took me
ages to identify it, but it definitely is one.<This could be another causative
factor then. A boxfish would quite likely attack it on site as it would any
other shrimp, and a mortal blow from the mantis shrimp could DEFINITELY trigger
a defensive toxin release> I ran lots of carbon to clean
the tank and did one more water change. I have fish back in the tank,
and they are doing great.<Excellent!> An article on cleaning out poison would be
great.<Not a bad idea.
while the odd boxfish/cowfish nuking incident does occur, two even more common
causes are 1) household pesticides, many of which can wipe out a 200 gal. tank
with just one drop, and 2) deceased puffers and porcupines that are "scavenged"
before being found missing. Any fish that samples even a single bite is usually
doomed, and in cases where the tank contains a fish such as a large wrasse, the
violent dismemberment of the corpse, much like a dog with a rat, is sometimes
capable of creating a very similar condition>
Thanks <You're very welcome and the best of luck
ahead>
Bruce
Cowfish Poisoned Tank
Hi Bob,
<George>
I have a 120 gallon tank I converted to salt water about 4 months ago and
went through the cycle and all my fish were doing fine. About every other
day I checked the salinity, nitrite, nitrate, pH and ammonia and they are
always perfect. I had 2 Yellow Tangs and A Powder Blue Tang
<Not easily kept>
and a few
Damsels and about 2 weeks ago I purchased a cowfish. The aquarium store I
purchased it at didn't tell me the fish was poisonous and if they had, I
wouldn't have bought it.
<This is mentioned several times, places on our site:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfishes.htm>
It seemed to be OK for a day or two and then it
kinda started just floating around in the tank, swimming a little every now
and then. I told the pet store I purchased it at and they said that it was
just stressed because it was in a new tank and that it would be OK in a few
days. I believed him and then the next afternoon when I came home from work
it was hung behind one of the decorations I have in my tank and it was dead.
I carried it back to them and they gave me a different fish to replace it.
When I got back home about 3 of my other fish were dead and the others were
swimming around with hardly no life at all. Then, the next afternoon they
all were dead. I found out that if the cowfish becomes stressed before it
dies it releases a poison that will kill everything in the tank and it did.
I went to a "Barnes @ Noble" book store and after looking through all their
Aquarium Fish books and reading about the cowfish they all said that it was
poisonous and it will release a poison if it becomes stressed and it will
die instantly and poison the entire tank, and it did. Over the past two
weeks since this happened I have changed about 50% of the water 3 times and
one time I changed about 75% and each time I did a test on the water and it
was all perfect.
<I would change ALL the water... in fact, if this were an account, I would drain
it all, re-fill it with fresh and lightly bleach (acid) wash all... yes, killing
all biota, oxidizing the ostracitoxin>
I have also replaced the carbon in my two filters every
other day as I was advised by the aquarium store. I have added a few
damsels to it and they have all died after being in the tank after about 2
days. Every time they died I purchased 3 more damsels and about 2 days later
they died. They all seemed to be doing well and then the next morning when
I turned the lights on they were all dead. I am trying everything I can
think of. I would appreciate any suggestions you have before I recycle my
tank.
George
<Sorry to hear of the losses here. Please refer to WetWebMedia.com re how to
thoroughly clean your system... and start over from "square one". Bob Fenner>
Disease
Hi guys,
<Hello> I am the proud owner of a camel cowfish. She is very little, only about
2 cm. She has developed one eye larger than the other and has not been able to
feed for over a week now. She knows the food is there and tries to eat it, but
it would appear to me that she cannot see when close up to the food and misses
it by 1/2 cm or so. There is no sign of disease, no cloudy eye, nothing wrong
that I can physically see. Just one eye appears to be quite larger. She is
starting to show signs of distress at feeding times as she madly swims around
trying to get to the food but is unable to. She is so little and I feel so
helpless. Any suggestions would help me please.
<I'd put some Maracyn in the tank. James (Salty Dog)>
Thanks
<You're welcome>