Dogface puffer worries, Ich treatment 2/10/09
Hi
<Hello>
I have a 5 month old 55 gallon tank with live sand and live rock. and a Skilter (filter and skimmer combo) and keep salinity around 1.25. I have a juvenile emperor, a coral beauty, a couple damsels, a yellow tang, a green spotted puffer and of course, a dog face.
<Too much for this tank.>
About a month ago I had a case of ich and I lost my juvenile emperor.
<You probably still have the parasite in your tank.>
Around that time i noticed spots on my dogface's fins and I dosed the tank with meds, extra frequent water changes, temp raised to 82, but symptoms persisted.
<I would never recommend treating a tank with LR and live sand, impossible to maintain therapeutic levels of medication due to the reactiveness of the rock, most effective medications will decimate the life on your rock, and make maintaining water quality almost impossible.>
Then my tang broke out all of a sudden with thick spots and even on her eyes.
<Water quality? What medication did you treat with.>
My LFS suggested a product called Copperpower.
<Copper should not be used in the main tank, and tangs and puffers are very sensitive to it.>
So after I put that in everyone got better. Today my dogface has spots on his sides (obviously not air bubbles) and he is swollen. he might be a little puffed, but there appears to be bulges (and even after a big meal he never got like that) I think that fresh dips are in order, the only thing is that he is a very sensitive fish. he gets really stressed from anything and everything (except food:) )
<I do not think that will help in this case, something environmental is wrong. Check your water parameters and do some water changes. This could also be a reaction to the copper.>
He won't eat or even move for a couple days. how long do u think he should be dipped for?
<Dips are for external parasites, I see no reason to go down this path at this point.>
I don't have a quarantined tank yet
<You need one badly.>
- if i went out and got one tomorrow do u think a 5 gallon tank would be big enough for a 3 1/2 inch long puffer, and would a heater be enough or should i get a filter too (seeing as this is going to be for just fresh dips)?
<You need a filter and heater for a QT, but 5 gallons is not large enough for the fish you have.>
And since I've learned that copper is bad for scaleless fish, should i do some massive water changes?
<Yes>
I just did a 10 gallon change today and was going to do another 10 tomorrow. what percentage do you suggest?
<I would test for copper, if you detect any keep doing changes. Carbon and poly-filters would be helpful here. Also time to do some reading on ich, your current methods of attack have little chance of success.>
I'm so worried about my little buddy! Thank You for your help!!!
<In future correspondence please spell and grammar check before submitting, otherwise we have to do this before posting. At this point you need to stop and take a breath. Good places to start are http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm and http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichart2mar.htm .>
<Chris>

Porcupine Puffer possibly has ich (UNCLASSIFIED)  12/20/08
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE
<... is this email being spied on? Is this one of my/our civil servants using the public's dime/time? One out of too many...>
Hello,
<Mmm, yes>
I recently set up a 125g FOWLR tank. It has a canister filter, protein skimmer, and two powerheads. I have 130 pounds of live rock and 10 pounds of live sand and 60 pounds of sand. The tank has been up for three months. (The first month no fish were in the system) I have a Porcupine Puffer and yesterday (12/19/08) I noticed a few white spots on his two side fins.
They look like little bits of sand.
<Might be>
I thought that that was what it was little pieces of sand since Puffer likes to go to the bottom of the tank after a meal and rest, but after a few hours of observation I am concerned that it may be ich.
<Could be, but doubtful>
Puffer is not really active during the day, but at night he come to the top of the tank and begs for food. He rests a majority of the day, but he has never been that active. He seems healthy by all accounts. He eats well and besides being a little timid around the other fish (Harlequin Tusk, Naso Tang, Pearlscale Red Butterfly, Blue Jaw Trigger, and 5 Green Chromis)he doesn't seem to have any issues. I have read your forums on Porcupine Puffers with ich but I feel the information given is to scattered and there are conflicting opinions.
<Same as it ever was>
I would like to know if a freshwater dip is worth even trying.
<Mmm, no; not IMO/E>
I know one of your forums say certain stages of ich easily resist freshwater dips. I just don't want to put puffer through the stress of being removed from his tank and then the huge stress of being in freshwater.
<I am in agreement with your point of view>
How resilient are puffers against ich?
<Mmm, more than middling>
He only has a few white spots on his fins and nowhere else. Each meal is soaked in garlic which I hear helps guard against ich,
<Nah>
but does it do anything to combat the illness once a fish has the illness.
<Zip>
I have read that the ich parasite doesn't like the odor of garlic
<Methinks you've got these Tetraodontiforms mixed up with vampire lore>
and the smell will keep them from attaching to the fish.
I have no idea if this is true, but if it is will the parasite detach because of the garlic. It is really hard to get good information so I appreciate the assistance. If you need anymore information please ask.
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE
<I too have not caveats (to mention)... But would take a wait and see approach here... Most likely these two "spots" are nothing. Bob, citizen, person who generates GDP, Fenner>

Ich Treatment, SW, Tangs, Toby...   10/7/08 Crew, I recently purchased a 125 gallon tank from someone who was getting out of the hobby complete with fish live rock and a few inverts. <I see your pic... very nice> I currently also run a 180 gallon reef tank which has completely separate nets and equipment. The 125 had been up and running for about 3 weeks when 2 fish started showing signs of ich. Here is the stock list of the tank as it came. 150 lbs of live rock DSB- new when I set the tank back up, with slight seeding from the old Skunk Cleaner Shrimp Coral Banded Shrimp Misc Large Hermits and Huge Turbo Snails Misc Soft Corals (xenia, zoos) 2" Picasso Trigger <Mmm, will likely eat the Hermits, Snails, perhaps more in time> 2" Maroon Clown 2" Saddle Puffer 3" Hippo Tang 3" Yellow Tang 2.5" Powder Brown Tang After reading over the WWM archives, I have decided on the following plan of attack. (Please correct me on medications:-) 1. Setup quarantine tank with salinity, temp and ph that matches the display. 2. Catch all fish except for puffer and move to the quarantine tank (55 gallons). 4. Move puffer into 5 gallon tank heavily bubbled and dose with formalin for 30 minutes, <Mmm, may well be too long... Likely ten minutes will do all the good that can... I would definitely be in constant attendance, ready to move this fish...> transfer to separate 10 gallon for 6 week stay. <Hard to keep such small volumes stable....> 3. Dose OrganiCure to the 55 gallon tank, no carbon just filter floss filtration for 6 weeks, with frequent water changes and copper testing. <Mmmm, I'd rather go the quinine/Chloroquine treatment route with this mix of fish species...> 4. Return all inhabitants to the main display tank (- the yellow tang, maroon clown and hippo tang that I may sell off to make the quarantine period go smoother). My 180 has been a great success from all of the information that I have read and used off of your site. I included a picture to show it off. Thanks for your help, Tim <I do think I will finally stop putting off my minor "expose" re the use of Chloroquine phosphate... 10 mg/l... Please do read re this, and quickly order, start using... Much better... safer, less toxic than copper, formalin. Bob Fenner>

Box/cow fish parasites. Parasitized systems, alternatives... reading   8/24/08
I've had a Blue male, Black female box fish and a Cow fish for several years now. One thing I've noticed is they always have Cryptocaryon, I just have to try and control it. I've tried hospital tanks and the only successful/safe medicine was malachite green. However after using low salt and meds for 2 months and returning them to the 180 gal. tank, they would get "it"
<Uhh... the system itself has "it"...>
again after a few months. Is it true that they always have/carry ick or Cry.?
<Nope>
I've found the best long term solution to housing Box and Cow fish is to have only them as tank mates, and to use a low salinity of 1.016-1.018. This has kept them symptom free. My main question is, I will keep the low salt for 2-3 months, then raise to 1.022-1.023 for 1-2 months then back down when the first spot shows up. Is this potentially harmful?
<Yep... shortens their lives... due to "stress", kidney damage mostly>
How long can I keep 1.016 for?
<Months to years>
This method seems to be the least stressful to the fish and I don't have to keep a hospital tank as well. What kind of salinity's do you recommend?
<Near seawater...>
Am I too low and then not going back high enough? I want to give the fish the best long term care as possible, but need to keep the salt low to avoid problems. Thanks.
<... There are other means of treating/excluding protozoan complaints with the puffer families... Read on WWM re Quinine cpd., dip/bath (with formalin) procedures... Peruse here: http://wetwebmedia.com/mardisindex.htm
Bob Fenner>

Inverted puffer gill – 04/21/08
Hello,
<Hi.>
My dog face puffer is having issues, her gill keeps getting inverted back into her breathing hole, in front of her side fins.
<You usually cannot see the gills at all, puffers only have these small slits (gill openings) in front of the pectoral fins, the gills are inside. I’m suspecting a physical injury (pump, other fishes) here based on what you describe, but I fail to visualize it, even with a puffer in front of me.>
Like when a dogs ear flips backwards, it’s like that.
<Something wrong with the gill opening (is its skin being sucked inside?) or something coming out of it? A picture would help with diagnosis!>
When it happens, she can’t breathe that well, as it doesn’t open. I keep finding it like this over and over again. If I show her the can of food she gets all excited and will snap it back out but next time I look, its back inverted. This seems to be happening all the time. She has stopped eating entirely now. She doesn’t swim around either.
<Both no good signs…>
Any suggestions?
<Amyloodinium and Cryptocaryon parasites on the gills can result in problems with breathing like breathing with one gill, do you see a velvet like white layer on the skin or small white spots? Flukes can result in similar problems (http://www.wetwebmedia.com/fshwrmdisfaqs.htm and search this link for gills). If something is coming out of the gill slits or if the slits themselves are hurt, there is not much you will be able to do yourself, except for providing a good water quality and varied diet (I hope it will eat again), and hope for the best. Maybe a veterinarian could solve the problem by fixing whatever tissue was hurt or torn apart, depends on the size of the puffer and skill of the vet. Good luck, I hope your puffer’s conditions improves again. Marco.>

Dogface puffer with Ich... poor env. period - 4-11-08
Hello!
<How goes it? Mike here tonight>
I have looked around on your site and haven't seen anyone with quite this situation; then again there is a lot on here so I'm sorry if I've missed something.
<Here to help, no worries>
I've had my dogface puffer in a 40 gal tank with a clownfish and a mandarin goby for about a month or two now and my tank has had very steady levels other than a slight mishap the other week where the salinity was spiked for about 1 day.
<Hopefully your dogface is still small - FYI he'll attain a 12" + in length. Also, please read our archives regarding your mandarin> And only a little - I wish I could be more specific but I was away and it was my dad who noticed and put some of the freshwater (treated for the tank - just no salt added) in to bring it back to normal (I have a hydrometer in the tank with a "green" area where the salinity is ok.. he said it was still in the green - just more salt then there usually is.
<No problems here>
My puffer - Bubbles- has been great until a couple of days ago - he started to develop ich.
<Puffers are prone, unfortunately. However, they don't develop diseases for no reason - he's probably being stressed in some way. What are your water parameters?>
I went into my LFS and they said they were getting cleaner wrasse brought in so I should try one of those (they're coming into the store tonight). This seemed like a "holistic" alternative to a fresh water dip - and wouldn't hurt.
<Not a good idea - don't buy the wrasse. Not only is the wrasse likely to develop marine ich (Cryptocaryon), but even if it doesn't, it will likely starve to death due to its specific dietary requirements>
Yesterday afternoon I noticed that he was bloated, hiding (which is not his normal behavior - he acts like a puppy always begging for attention and putting on a show), and appeared to be coughing??
<He's been stressed, as well possibly some GI issues>
I had some gobies to try to entice him to eat as well as possibly help him to "de-bloat" (another recommendation from my LFS - they thought he may be constipated and it was due time for him to have a treat and something to gnaw on). His usual diet is gobies as a treat, brine shrimp and bloodworms - which he has been quite happy on for me.
<Try to vary the diet a little, adding meaty seafoods. Remember, adult brine shrimp have very little nutritional value>
I'm concerned about the coughing as I haven't seen a fish act and look like he has a cold before. As additional information he's been looking pale longer - as though it's taking him longer to wake up in the morning, he didn't even act like he saw the gobies when they were put into the tank for him.
<Definitely stressed. And do you literally mean gobies as food?>
Last night at one point I had to "rescue" him - he had wedged himself between a plastic barrel decoration that I have and the glass; I'm assuming he was trying to scratch after this he seemed to be more nervous than usual (and has been since, although still hangs around the barrel) and has ignored food completely.
<Puffers commonly wedge themselves on purpose while digesting or sleeping, don't worry too much about this, and they also will ignore food if stressed or in poor health>
Also - his eyes look sad...I know this isn't the best description but the look in them is heartbreaking...and he normally could cheer you up from the worst mood.
<I know what you mean - my favorite fish is my A. hispidus (stars-n-stripes puffer)! The eyes of a puffer are actually very good indicators of health>
Thank you in advance! I hope this is enough to have some ideas.
<Make sure you have adequate filtration for this messy fish in your smallish tank (and that you have plans to upgrade relatively soon), and that all of the parameters (pH, ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, salinity, temp) are within norm. A large water change would also be beneficial - make sure the replacement water is the same salinity, temp, and pH, and let it mix for an hour or more. Also, read our archives regarding curing marine ich, and good luck>
Charis
<M. Maddox>

Dogface puffer with raised white spots only on body; not on fins. I've looked everywhere, I can't find an answer!  2/15/08 Hello! My name is Marisa. First and foremost, thank you so much for any and all help. I have been reading WWM for several weeks and have found so many answers. I can't seem to find any information on my current question, though. I have attached three pictures of my dogface puffer (Arothron nigropunctatus, I believe?) <Yes> in his current state, and later on in this e-mail I will address the other pictures. As you can see, he has accumulated these odd bright white spots on the lower part of his body. There seems to be a line of these bumps going from his mouth to his tail along his sides. Before I spend several hours describing what has been going on in my tank for the past few weeks, let me ask this: Just by looking at these pictures, can you tell me what this is? <Mmm, no... look like discrete marks... What might be in the system that would make these?> The pictures I am specifically referring to are titled "pufferspots_1, _2, and _3." I am going to assume not, so here is some background info as to what could be causing the problem: I have a 55 gallon fish-only tank; the dogface is the only thing in there. No live rock, coral, or invertebrates. My tank has been running for several months with no apparent problems, until about... 5-6 weeks ago, when I bought a live rock from (as I later found out) the worst, least respected pet store in town. After researching the "care" online for days before purchasing my live rock, I finally went out to buy one. I was told it was already cycled and so I went ahead and placed it in my tank. It was fine for 2-3 weeks until all of a sudden I noticed my tank was extremely cloudy. There was a grayish type "mold" all around the live rock and on nearby aquarium decorations. I immediately took the rock and the nearby decorations out. My puffer seemed fine. He was eating fine, acting normal, etc. I went ahead and tested my water and my pH, ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates were off the charts. I did a 15% water change (while siphoning a lot of the gray stuff off the sand) and the water cleared up within hours. The picture titled graystuff_1 is what was left over after the water change. I spoke to several people at my LFS (different one from where I bought the live rock), who told me to do another water change that night and treat the water with Stress Coat, Prime, and Cycle. I did a 20% water change later that night and tested my water again the next day. My pH was a little low (7.8 - 8.0), <Mmm, the pH scale is a base ten expression (sort of like the Richter Scale)... this is quite low/different than what you want> but my nitrites and ammonia were back to 0. My nitrates were still very high (100-140), <Yikes... this could be "it"> but I was told it's better to have high nitrates than high ammonia or nitrites. <Yes, but better to have none of all...> Slightly relieved, I went ahead and left my tank alone. I was told to do a 10% water change every week until my levels were back to normal... or a 5% water change every day if the cloudiness came back. No one knew what it was, but I assumed it was some sort of bacteria bloom. <Likely so> Two days after the 20% water change I checked my water again and my pH, ammonia, and nitrites were all good, despite my nitrates still being around 80 - 120. <Way too high. Needs to be addressed> I wanted to figure out what happened, though, so I asked around and discovered a specialty saltwater fish store down the street from me. An employee, who also couldn't figure out what all of this was, called his boss, who said what most likely happened was that the live rock cycled itself in my tank (even though I was told it was already cycled, ugh). He said the gray stuff was probably silt that eventually came out of the rock. That would explain why my levels shot up. <All likely so> I was satisfied with that answer because it made the most sense, and the store seemed very clean and legit. All the fish looked happy and healthy so I figured they were reputable. So, that is the first thing that happened. Here is what happened next: I got home that day to check on my puffer and studied him for about 10 minutes, just to make sure he was okay. I noticed an influx of white, sand-like spots on his fins. I had seen white-ish spots on before, over the past few weeks, but assumed it was just sand sticking to him because he liked to sift through the sand and sit in it sometimes. He often had sand sticking to his belly and face, which were the two areas that came in contact with the sand. Before I got this puffer, I did extensive research on potential diseases and sicknesses, so ich/ick was in the back of my mind. <The images do show what is likely Crypt> I tried to look up some pictures of ich online, but just to make sure I decided I should go back up to the specialty saltwater store and show them the pictures I took of my puffer--to see what they thought. The pictures titled pufferich_1 and _2 are the ones I showed to the people. The person I had spoken to the other day was not there, so I re-explained the weird rock cycling event and showed them the pictures and they declared it as ich, although they admitted ich didn't show up in pictures very well. They said the stress from the rock cycling could have triggered the outbreak, or at least intensified it. Like I said, I noticed he always had a few tiny spots of white on his fins, but they seemed to disappear on a day to day basis, which led me to believe it was sand. <Mmm, yes... you have a resident infestation...> There were about 3 people helping me at the store at this point, and they all agreed that copper was the best solution. I had read that copper and puffers do not normally mix well, and mentioned this, but they assured me that with carefully monitored dosage and the fact that it's a fish only tank, I have nothing to worry about. I asked if any of them had experience with treating ich on puffers with copper, and one of them said yes, and that his puffer is now happy, healthy, and ich-free (he had a porcupine puffer). I must have spoken to these guys for at least 40 minutes, and they were happy to help. I asked them about "freshwater dips" and hyposalinity, but they said if I've been noticing these white spots for a few weeks, I should probably start (copper) treatment immediately. They gave me a bottle of SeaCure (liquid copper treatment) <Yes... a free cupric ion solution (copper sulfate)... as opposed to chelated (which I would have used instead). A product made by Aquarium Systems...> and a copper test kit made by Instant Ocean. <Actually, also A.S.> I was told to keep my copper level between .15 and .20 mg for 3 weeks. <No lower than 0.15 free Cu++> I was also told to add the first dose over a day or so, as to not overload the puffer. So when I got home I made sure to study my puffer for about a half hour to see if he was flashing, scratching, or generally acting weird. I noticed that his eyes seemed cloudy and there was some sort of trail of wispy "stuff" hanging off of him on certain spots of his body. His eyes had been slightly cloudy (but not this bad) for the past few days, but this was the first I had seen the wispy stuff. Continuing on: I went home and took my carbon filters out. To make this easier to read and document, I'm going to list my dosage and treatment day by day. Day 1: Thursday, Feb. 7th: -added 20 drops of copper (they suggested 1 drop per gallon), waited several hours before I added another 20. -checked my copper level several hours later and it read .05 - .10. I went ahead and added another 20 drops. Day 2: Friday, Feb. 8th: -checked the copper level and it read .10 - .15. <Below 0.15 ppm is not a curative...> -I went ahead and added another 10 drops just to top it off, since it was just barely .15. Day 3: Saturday, Feb. 9th: -checked copper level and it read .15, but was still barely .15. -I added 15 drops just in case the level dropped over the next day. *Today I noticed the white spots had increased significantly, as well as the wispiness. My puffer seemed extremely lethargic and would not accept food (freeze-dried krill, frozen shrimp, and frozen squid is what I normally offer him). He hadn't eaten since Friday morning. He looked like he was bogged down by this stuff. Since it looked like everything was getting worse, I took some pictures of him and went to the specialty saltwater store. The picture titled pufferichcopper_1 is the picture I showed the people at the store. The guy I had spoken to last time was there, and basically told me, "You're only on Day 3 of treatment; there's a lot that can happen to him physically as far as getting the parasite out of him." I showed him the picture and he suggested that he is probably going through 'the worst of it'. He explained that when we (as humans) get sick, there's a period where we are overcome with all types of symptoms and problems for a number of days... i.e. with a cold, you may start with a moderate sore throat, but by day 3--even with medication--you can feel, and look, a hundred times worse. That sore throat can develop into sneezing, coughing, vomiting, and overall unhappiness, etc. He said my puffer was just getting over the hardest part of the ich, and that every fish reacts differently to parasites. <An apt description> He said to give it 2 weeks before I freak out over anything, because a lot will probably change in my puffer's attitude. I mentioned him not eating, and he said most fish won't eat when medication is first introduced. He said he will be fine, and not to worry if he doesn't eat for a while. So, I felt a little relieved that all of this behavior was "normal." Day 4: Sunday, Feb. 10th: -checked the copper level and it read .15. -I added 10 drops to maintain the level. Day 5: Monday, Feb. 11th: -the copper read somewhere in between .15 - .20 so I did not add any copper this day. *I forgot to mention that I have been checking my water levels every day, just in case. The people at the saltwater store said if my ammonia/nitrites begin to go up, do a water change. Today my ammonia was at .50 so I did a 10% water change. I made sure to check the copper level before and after the water change and added drops accordingly. Day 6: Tuesday, Feb. 12th: -checked the level and it was barely at .15. -I added 10 drops. *Despite my puffer still refusing to eat, the ich seemed to have cleared up completely today. I did not see any white spots on him whatsoever. He also seemed more alert and interactive. *My ammonia is back to 0. Day 7: Wednesday, Feb. 13th: -checked the level and it read .15 - .20, so I did not add any drops this day. *Still looking good; he is becoming more active, but still not eating. Day 8: Thursday, Feb 14th (today): -checked the level and it read barely .15. -I added 10 drops. *To my surprise, he ate today! I gave him a piece of squid and after a minute or so, he ate all of it. This happened in the morning. He was even more interactive--really getting back to his normal self. So, I am 8 days into my copper regime and all seems well... except what I noticed a few hours ago. I figured since he ate this morning, everything can only go up from here. My boyfriend and I went out today in the late morning/afternoon and returned in the evening. I checked on my puffer as soon as we got home and there were these very strange, bright white bumps on him. As I explained at the beginning of this e-mail, they are raised and only on his body--not on his fins or eyes. At first glance I assumed it was the ich reappearing (maybe trying to bury back into him?) but the spots look completely different in size, shape, texture, and placement. I am still continuing my copper treatment like usual. My puffer seemed pretty normal... he was swimming around and seemed alert. He did not seem to be flashing very much... I've seen him do it maybe once or twice in the past few hours. The pictures pufferspots_1, _2, and _3 are of these new white spots. As you can see, they look completely different from the ich. No matter how hard I search, I can't find anything--neither pictures nor similar descriptions--about this. The only thing I can guess is that the parasites are attempting to burrow back into the puffer? <Mmm, no> The bumps actually appear to either be burrowing into the skin, or are trying to push themselves out. Looking at them closely, it makes me want to scrub them off of him--do you know what I mean? <I think so> It seems like they are raised enough and could be rubbed off. I'm not suggesting that I would do this, but the roundness of the bumps evokes that sort of feeling/description. Whereas the ich did not appear raised or round (i.e. not being able to be scrubbed), these seem like they could be picked off. They are the brightest (as you can see) near his underside, and darkening/becoming more flesh colored toward the top. They also appear smaller and shorter on top. Also, please note that this morning he looked 100% clear and normal, and when I returned home a few hours later he had all of these bumps. How did something like this flare up so quickly? <Autoimmune reaction...> It has been about 5 hours since I got home and noticed the bumps, and I just checked on him a minute ago and his color is extremely dark (normally this means he is very stressed, from what I have observed. he is usually a milky/creamy tan color). He has some splotchiness, which also seems to be a sign of stress. The bumps seem to have, more or less, dug deeper into his skin. It does not appear that they have "fallen off" or anything; if anything, they are less raised and seem to be lodging themselves further in. He is not very responsive and is not swimming around as much. He's kind of resting on the bottom of the tank. He seems bothered by these things, and his breathing is slower than normal. I apologize for the extremely lengthy e-mail! I just wanted to include as much information as possible. If you have any questions about anything I have mentioned, please ask me. I just want to do everything for this little guy--he is so special to me. I thank all of you SO very much in advance! I appreciate you taking the time to read this. If you need any more pictures of these bumps, please let me know. Sincerely, Marisa <... I would discontinue the copper exposure... and switch to a quinine based treatment... See WWM: http://wetwebmedia.com/quinmedfaqs.htm Am of the guess/opinion that these marks are an expression of the puffer to the copper, nitrate and who knows what chemical irritation here... See WWM re copper use on puffers... Bob Fenner>

Crypt.

Discrete markings

Grey stuff... silt?

Longhorn cowfish w/ich – 01/21/2008
Hello all, great site you have here! I am just going to dive right in here. I have been trying to fight what I think is ich since September. I currently have a 1.5" valentini puffer and a 3-4" longhorn cowfish in a 20 gallon. I have tried hypo twice...I will skip to the last time I tried hypo.
<Have you consistently kept the salinity below 15 ppt (SG < 1.011) for at least 4-6 weeks? Higher salinities won’t work with normal Cryptocaryon isolates. A few will even live in brackish water with a lower salinity and can only be treated with copper (or formalin, which is more difficult and potentially dangerous to apply).>
After I brought the salt back up I did not see any spots, and everything seemed ok until the cowfish (bugar) would eat. Every time bugar would eat shrimp or scallops after a few bites he would start darting and flashing around the tank.
<Something may be wrong with his nervous system, but that is more a guess than a diagnosis.>
He did not do this when eating pellet food only the raw frozen foods. (The puffer has not shown any signs)...for two weeks I carefully watched the longhorn, and all day he would not show any signs of ich not one single spot in two weeks was seen on his fins or body. I do realize that there are certain stages of ich that you cannot see, and the gills are one of the commonly attacked places, but to not see a spot in two weeks?
<It can take 4-6 weeks until spots occur again. Please get familiar with the life cycle of the parasite here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichart2mar.htm and http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm . However, darting alone is not enough in my opinion to state this is ich.>
Another site suggested that it probably was ich, and so I began some other treatments. I first used stop parasite, this did nothing to the problem when the cowfish was eating, next I tried Nox-ich...The cow did fine, but I lost a dwarf lion...not sure if it was the medicine or not, but it seemed logical. The other site then suggested that I use Cupramine.
<If it was ich, this would be a good medication probably in contrast to the ones mentioned before.>
I tried this med a few months ago, and the cowfish did not like it. For the first time since I had bugar he did not eat, so I pulled the med.
<It had no chance to work.>
The other site said that this is a common side effect and should only last a couple of days. So I thought I would try Cupramine another shot. Currently I just added my second treatment of Cupramine last night. The first treatment that is supposed to take the level to .25 did not bother the cow, but taking it to .5 did. I added it last night, and this morning his color was very dark all over his body, and again he is not eating.
<Puffers, boxfish and other sensitive fishes should be treated at lower levels slightly above the minimum level recommended by the manufacturer.>
I am currently pulling the copper. At least he eats when I don't have that in there. I did notice today that bugar is darting, though he is not eating so this is not linked. I am at a loss as to what to do?
<Darting alone is not enough for a proper diagnosis. Without knowing at least roughly what to treat, I would not treat on suspicion.>
Not sure if I should be doing anything?
<If spots occur, treat with a copper product as indicated by the articles mentioned above. Aside that feed a vitamin rich varied diet to boost the immune system.>
I have tried hypo twice, I have used a battery of meds. I don't see spots on these fish. The valentini still shows no spots does not dart around. I have had them in a qt since Sept. I want to get them back into my dt, but don't want to introduce anything bad back into it. Any suggestion or insight would be greatly appreciated.
<See above if your hyposalinity treatment was effective at all. If salinity was too high or duration of the treatment was too short, Cryptocaryon is likely still in the system, even if you do not see spots. In this case or if you see any spots treat with Cupramine as indicated above and in the linked articles. After at least 4-6 weeks without spots the fish can probably go back to the main system, which also was free of fish hosts for at least 4-6 weeks. With regard to the darting: as long as no other symptoms occur, I would not specifically address this issue, only provide superb water quality and a vitamin enriched diet. Good luck, Marco.>

Burrfish With "Ich"? 8/7/07
<Hi Mark, Pufferpunk here>
I was trying to find out if a burr puffer could get ick?
<Actually ich, which is a freshwater disease, short for Ichthyophthirius multifiliis.><<Mmm, both fresh and marine are commonly called "ich". RMF>>
I have had him for a month or two, its doing great, eating fine. I just started seeing little white dotts on its fins and body. Could you help me and what could I do.
<Yes they can get crypt, short for Cryptocaryon irritans (the marine form of ich). Best treatment is hyposalinity. You can look here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm in addition to countless other articles at WWM on the subject. Also: http://www.thepufferforum.com/forum/library/hospital/swich/ How long have you had this fish? There is a high death rate of this fish in captivity, due to refusal to eat. ~PP>
Thank you, Mark.

Re: Burr Puffer with SW "Ich"  8/9/07
<Hi Mark>
I have had him for about two months and he has no problem eating and even takes food from my hand. He is always looking, for or eating food non-stop. Will the puffer work thru this or should I do something? He is housed with a Huma trigger, Yellow tang, Snowflake eel, Lyretail wrasse and a pair of Marron Clows.
<Maroon clowns?>
Should I worry about any of these fish?
<It's up to you, whether you should treat all the fish or wait it out to see if the burrfish gets any worse. He's more sensitive to the parasite, since he has no scales. Sometimes I have seen a light case of crypt goes away on it's own but you are chancing all the inhabitants getting it. I'd at least QT the puffer & treat it. If you see the parasite on any of the other fish, then you will have to follow the instructions for hyposalinity for everyone (in QT of course) & leave the main tank fallow. Were there any new tank mates added recently? ~PP>
Thank you for all your help, Mark

Puffer in Quarantine   6/21/07
Hi Bob and Crew;
First, of course, I want to thank you for the service that you provide to the Aquarium Hobby.
As a refresher, the tank is 90 Gal FOWLR, Corner Overflow with a Tidepool 2 Sump, Tunze DOC 9005 Skimmer in sump (not collecting much skimmate), Prizm Skimmer in tank (actually working very well). Tank, being repopulated after sitting fallow for 6 weeks following an Ich outbreak, currently contains only a 10 inch Snowflake Moray.
I currently have a Dog face puffer in quarantine (only 20 gal), where s/he has been for about 12 days. I feed the Puffer every other day, with a feeding stick, so nothing remains in the tank uneaten. The problem I am having is keeping Nitrates down in the QT tank, even with daily 50% - 75% water changes. In fact, the DFP chooses to "poop" right after the water change, which doesn't help the Nitrates.
Based on the fact that the Puffer appears free of external parasites, but must be suffering from the Nitrates, would you curtail the QT and add him/her to the display, or would you wait 30 days?
Thanks Again.
Roy
<I would end the quarantine, dip this fish in transit and place this Tetraodont. BobF>

Re: Puffer in Quarantine   6/21/07
Bob,
Thanks for the quick reply.
When I got home last night, much to my chagrin, I notice Ich on the DPF's Dorsal and Pectoral fins in the QT tank! S/he had been perfectly clean, but maybe because of the stress of the high Nitrates?
<Maybe a factor... but the Crypt would have had to be present...>
Since I do not want to use copper, I gave the DFP a PH adjusted Freshwater Formalin dip, while I changed the QT tank water. I then removed the carbon and treated with 2 tsp Formalin per 10 gallons?
<Yikes! Way too much... see WWM re formalin use>
To you think this in any way will be efficacious?
I should have moved him a day sooner!
<Ah, decidedly NOT! You would have introduced the asymptomatic infestation! RMF>
Roy

Re: Puffer in Quarantine
Bob,
The Kordon's Formalin 3 Bottles says that it can be used up to double the usual dosage of 1 tsp per 10 gallons. I actually used something closer to 1 1/2 Tsp per 20 Gallons.
<... Please read where you were referred to... 37% stock soln... too much... DO increase aeration, DO keep an eye on the animals exposed...>
Has anyone ever had luck with nosickfish Ich cure, aside/since last posted in FAQ? I wouldn't use it in my display, but id it works in the QT the $52.00 may be worth it.
Roy
<See our notes re... the search tool, indices. RMF>

Re: Puffer in Quarantine
Bob,
Thanks again,
When I saw him last night all the spots on his fins were gone
<... likely just cycled off...>
and he was actually hungry for the first time since I got him. He had one remaining embedded cyst that came of this morning after doing a 50 percent change and re-dosing appropriately.
My tank sat fallow for 8 weeks, and reintroduced my snowflake (which was treated for Ich in the qt while the display sat) 4 weeks ago. Since I originally used water from my display for my quarantine tank, it is conceivable that my display still has a sub clinical infestation (the moray does not look or act infested, although the Ich could have come in with the Puffer (he looked clean and was dipped before QT).
<Is possible>
Based on this I was thinking of adding the Puffer to the display as soon as all external signs are gone,
<Please... stop... READ re Cryptocaryon life cycle... on WWM, elsewhere... You do NOT want an ongoing infested system...>
immediately breaking down the QT tank, sterilizing it, and re-preparing and cycling with non-display water, so I would have it available immediately if I needed to either let the display sit fallow one more time, or nuke it and start it up again.
<No sense... you won't be able to safely add any more fish life to your display system>
Since it isn't unusual to have some parasites in an otherwise healthy system, since I keep up my husbandry, healthy specimens should stay that way. I only plan to add a 3 or so specimens of a smaller shoaling species when I find something that can coexists with the snowflake and puffer?
Does this idea have any merit or am I just rationalizing a way to add a possibly diseased specimen to my display.
Indebted as always,
Roy
<Have just skipped down... Read. BobF>

Re: Tetraodont Crypt Trtmt.    5/20/07
Thanks for the quick reply. I did read the FAQ's, but that made me more confused.
<Yikes! How about the articles?>
The first FAQ titled Tank with puffers, a moray eel and Amyloodinium (velvet) – 05/08/07 states : "My quarantine tank is only 25 gallons and if I stick all of them in there, besides being stressed, doesn't it defeat the purpose of the quarantine by only treating the fish?
<No. The best would be to treat the two puffers in a bare bottom quarantine tank with copper and to let the display tank run fallow for about 6 weeks (without using copper in this tank). If the moray eel does not show symptoms, I’d leave it in the display."
The following FAQ titled Dog faced Puffer OD on copper says: "We noticed some white spots on his fins and was treated with copper at least 3 times now.
<Big no-no!  Puffers are extremely sensitive to copper, and it should never be used on puffers (or other sensitive animals like inverts/corals etc...).  It will be best to stop treatments like that ASAP.> "
<I am of the opinion (note there are many other folks here presently and in the past that make/made up our Crew) that puffers CAN benefit from Careful exposure to copper... given initial good health, monitoring...>
Then another FAQ about cowfish titled 'Gentle' Ich treatment for cowfish? (Tetrasomus gibbosus) 6/25/06 says: "I don't know what to do:  half the crowd says that treating ich with hyposalinity is Great and Good, especially for copper-sensitive cowfish; the other half says that hyposalinity "treatments" are a waste of time, because they aren't curing anything. <I prefer hyposalinity as a dip or bath.>"  Would you suggest a long FW dip?
<Me? No>
I'm really not sure what to do here! Personal experience says that hyposalinity will kill ick on a fish,
<Mmm, not often>
but then it will often return once salinity has hit around 1.018. But I've also read over and over that copper is not good for puffers.
<Is actually "not good" for any life... all fishes experience discomfort, poisoning to a degree with exposure... Not unlike the use of mercuricals and arsenicals for humans...>
I really don't want to use formalin. Is a long FW dip my only safe option here?
<No>
or should just go ahead and use a weaker solution of copper? (Re: urgent _ seriously ... Crypt - 04/24/2006 <My friend... this is posted over and over on our site... with cautionary remarks as you suggest here. I would not use formalin/formaldehyde... or formalin... I would use a minimum concentration (due to the puffers mainly) of a chelated copper commercial product here... with twice daily testing with a matched test kit... Read on first! Bob Fenner>)
I don't want to seen confrontational or ungrateful here.
<Nor I... and you don't come off as this at all. I also only seek to render useful, practical, semi-immediate information... Formalin dips/baths might be efficacious, given movement of the fish subsequently to a non-infested setting... FW/hypo treatments I do not find to be usually (much less than 1%) of the time to be useful... as you state above... Only weakening hosts... forestalling their ultimate re-infestation, increasing morbidity, leading to death>
And I know why you stress time and time again to read FAQs first. The more knowledge your readers have the more success they will have. I understand that, and agree! : ) It's just that there are so many opinions on the web... in books... it's hard to know who is MORE right than who.
<I do agree with you here... Absent some sort of "Vulcan Mind Meld", am at a loss of how to enhance our experiences thus far...>
Ahhhh... it would seem that keeping fish is not an exact science after all. Thanks for the info.                                                                     -Jay
<Thank you for your earnest sharing, intelligent discourse... I do hope my input is more to the point here... I WOULD use a chelated copper solution, at a lower/est concentration... Perhaps 0.20 ppm free copper equivalent, no lower than 0.15 ppm. Bob Fenner>

Tank with puffers, a moray eel and Amyloodinium (velvet) – 05/08/07
Hello <Hi Amanda.>, I believe that our tank has velvet. We have a dogface puffer, a stars-n-stripes puffer, a tiger reef eel, live rock, snails and hermit crabs. Our tank is 125 gallons. I want to use Coppersafe to clean out the whole tank. The directions say to add it only once and it treats for a whole month.
<If you treat your display tank, you will kill a lot of your beneficial bacteria. Monitor ammonia and nitrite if you treat it that way.>
I know I need to take out the live rock, snails, and hermit crabs and I need to clean out the tank very well after the treatment is over.  My questions are -
Can I leave my puffers and eel in their 125 gal tank while I am treating it?
<The moray eel should not be treated with copper, except if it shows symptoms. Puffers can be treated carefully, but bare in mind that overdosing can be lethal. It’s appropriate to get a testing kit that can be used with your copper product and to monitor the copper concentration at least once daily.>
My quarantine tank is only 25 gallons and if I stick all of them in there, besides being stressed, doesn't it defeat the purpose of the quarantine by only treating the fish?
<No. The best would be to treat the two puffers in a bare bottom quarantine tank with copper and to let the display tank run fallow for about 6 weeks (without using copper in this tank). If the moray eel does not show symptoms, I’d leave it in the display. That way you are taking the risk that the parasites may use the moray as a host, but this case is rather improbable due to the high resistance of these fish against Amyloodinium. If you do not want to take this risk, you need a second quarantine tank for the eel, which is not treated with copper.>
Do I still give them freshwater dips to get the parasite <off>, while I am treating their tank?
<Such dips can be done in severe cases to get rid of some of the parasites.>
Do I dip the eel?
<If it shows any symptoms: yes.>
How do I dip an eel?
<A bucket of well aerated, pH and temperature adjusted freshwater. Catch the eel with a net and transfer it to the bucket. If you cannot catch it with a net, lure it out into a clean bottle with a large enough opening and a piece of its favourite food and transfer it. Put a lid on the bucket. Leave it there for about half an hour to one hour. Return it to the tank.>
Do I also have to wait a month before putting the live rock and the invertebrates back in or how long do I have to wait?
<If you treat your display with copper, you should filter with fresh activated carbon after 4 weeks and hope none of the copper remains in the substrate.>
I know this needs to be treated now, but my puffers are my babies and I don't want to hurt them.
<I’d consider what I described above as the best way. Also read http://www.wetwebmedia.com/cuduration.htm and http://www.wetwebmedia.com/amylloodiniumart.htm and the related FAQs.>
I know I have a lot of questions for y'all. I would appreciate your help, so I can make my fish happy again.
<Hope they pull through.>
Thank you so much for your time.
<You are welcome. Marco.>
Sincerely, Amanda.

Dog faced Puffer OD on copper
My office has a saltwater tank professionally cleaned and cared for once a week. We have grown very attached to our fish and have recently
enjoyed the addition of an adorable dog faced puffer.
<Congrats, Dogface puffers are one of my favorite fish!>
We noticed some white spots on his fins and was treated with copper at least 3 times now.
<Big no-no!  Puffers are extremely sensitive to copper, and it should never be used on puffers (or other sensitive animals like inverts/corals etc...).  It will be best to stop treatments like that ASAP.>
I have noticed each time it is treated our dog faced puffer will become very immobile and has some discoloration, changing to a darker color.
<That is a typical reaction to copper.>
After checking your website I am afraid this "professional" company has no idea what they are doing to our adorable dog faced puffer.
<This sounds that way.  I learned back that many of the "professionals" aren't that professional.  They don't know everything, and it's best if you do your research to be sure that accidents like this don't happen.>
Please offer any advice on how to save our puffer and possibly a new truly professional company in Salt Lake City, Utah.
<Sadly I'm not sure of any professional companies in Salt Lake, I had done a search on Aquarium Maintenance online to see if I could help, but it gave me a list.  I wasn't sure who would be good or not, so perhaps if it's best if you ask around. As for you puffer care, the simple act of giving you puffer a freshwater dip for 5-10 minutes and placing him in a tank that is copper free will be the best way to help your little dog-face.  Here are some great places to start learning about puffers.
http://www.reefnut.com/Puffer%20Article.htm
This is a handy article dealing with puffer care and info.
http://puffer.proboards2.com/index.cgi?board=faq  
A puffer board.  Totally devoted to puffer care.  A very good place to start getting info.>
Thank you for your time. -Sarah
<Good luck with your dog-face puffer!  I do hope that it gets better, these are some of the best fish I have ever had the pleasure to keep.  I'll keep my fingers crossed for you. -Magnus>

Spiny Box Puffer with Ich - 5/17/2006
What is the best way to treat a Spiny Box Puffer that has ich?  It is currently in a quarantine tank.
<<Read here: http://www.thepufferforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9. >>
Thanks!
<<Glad to help. Lisa.>>

Re: Spiny Box Puffer with Ich - 5/28/2006
I started the treatment described in the link you gave me for Hyposalinity last week.  For the first few days the ich started to clear up nicely, but over the last two days it has gotten progressively worse.  It is now much worse than it was before I started the Hyposalinity treatment.
<<What SG is the puffer in now?>>
The Spiny Box Puffer will no longer accept food.  Is there something else I can do?
<<He is very, very stressed.  It sounds to me like something is off in your water parameters.  Are you keeping a close eye on water quality?  Please search WWM re hyposalinity.>>
Thanks!
<<Glad to help. Lisa.>>

- Ich never to cease and barrel-rolling boxfish 6/23/06 -
Hello WetWebMedia Crew! <Hello.> I'm an avid reader of your site! I hope you can help me like you've helped so many others. I have a 55 gallon tank with a male and female spotted boxfish, and a lionfish. Up until last week, it was just the female box and lion--both were eating and doing fine. However, I did notice some ich spots on the female box, so I removed the live rock, (considering this was a new tank, I left the base rock in, as I believed it didn't have enough time to have any of the nitrifying bacteria on it) and lowered the salinity down to about 1.011. The tank was left like this for a week, and I thought the ich had gone. Last week I added a male boxfish, quite a bit bigger than the female, to my tank by acclimating it in a separate quarantine tank to get it adjusted to my current salinity. Well the fish was added, and every one went back to their normal fish lives. However, the new male boxfish hasn't eaten a bite of food since I've gotten him more than a week ago. I've offered frozen and fresh mussel, a blend of frozen algae, Mysis and brine shrimp, Marine Cuisine, krill pieces, algae sheets, etc. It has thus far refused them all, but the female continues to feed eagerly. I wanted to try live black/bloodworms, but my LFS won't be able to get them in until next Tuesday. Anyways, the ich has come back within the last few days and viciously attacked both boxfish, covering them completely. They also both seem to have somewhat cloudy eyes, and the male will swim, and then do half of a "barrel-roll" in the water. Sometimes he'll swim down towards the rocks and do this, but he doesn't rub against them. So today I was reading around on the internet, and found somewhere that said hyposalinity wouldn't be effective unless the salinity was at 1.009. Well it made sense to me, since I've had the salinity at 1.011 for a good week, maybe more, and the ich was still there, strong as ever, so I did a water change and lowered it yet again down to 1.009.
As we both know, it would be very unfortunate for one of my boxfish, (more than likely my male, as he's the one not eating and rolling around), to die and nuke out the rest of my tank. Is there anything I can do to get him to eat and make his odd behavior, as well as the ich on both boxfish go away? <How about bringing up the salinity to something marine fish can tolerate without excessive stress?> A hospital tank really isn't an option, as the only other tank I have at the moment is a 10 gallon quarantining a filefish, and both boxes would probably get even more stressed being in that small of a tank. <As opposed to the stress of 1.009 salinity?> I really thought the ich would have gone by now, maybe not out of the tank, but at least off the fish.... Please help! <This situation sounds to me like what they call "A one legged man in a butt kicking contest." You've got too many things going on here that you are the point of doing more harm than good. It is my considered opinion that there is likely nothing you can do for this one box fish - it is dancing what is known in the hobby as the spiral of death, and if has not yet passed on, it will do so soon. I would even go so far as to suggest that you preempt this fish's suffering and freeze it and move on to solving some other problems. Hyposalinity is useful as a bath/dip but not as ongoing treatment. Saltwater fish actually need the salt - they drink their water and use the salts to regulate things inside their bodies. Without enough salt, things go wrong from the inside out and you find yourself where you are now. Preventing ich is as much about managing stress as it is killing parasites and if you only work on one side of this problem, then you're likely to never solve the problem. Consider doing this - put the remaining boxfish in with the firefish in quarantine. Try to get the salinity up to at least 1.018 (and very slowly - not all in one day). Then, let your main tank go fallow - no fish - for at least one month, six weeks would be better. Likewise, slowly bring the salinity back to a normal range in the main tank (1.023-ish).>
Thank You!
Neil
<I suggest you read here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/mardisease.htm
Cheers, J -- >

- 'Gentle' Ich treatment for cowfish? (Tetrasomus gibbosus) 6/25/06 -
Hello,
<Good morning.>
Have you ever had one of those frustrating days wherein the more you try to learn, the less you're sure of what you know? <Often.> Dear oh dear. <Bear with it.> I'm having one of them, and I really hope you can help.
<I will do my best.>
My problem, in brief, is a cowfish (Tetrasomus gibbosus.. common names pretty much too numerous to list!) with what has all the earmarks of a burgeoning ich infestation.  It started as one dot, vanished, came back as two, vanished.. etc. until he was covered with dots.  Hoping that I "hadn't seen that" was, in hindsight, a mistake.
The cowfish is about an inch-and-half long; we've had him for about four months.  He is the sole inhabitant of a four year old 54 gallon (yes, 54.. corner bowfront) tank with around 20 pounds of liverock, about two inches of aragonite sand, and a large clump of cheerful and fast-growing Caulerpa (LFS calls it "saw tooth".. pretty accurate description of its narrow, jagged leaves).  The skimmer is a CPR Bakpak2, and the filter is an Eheim 2213.  My Visitherm heater has given me so little trouble that I cannot remember its wattage, and lighting is provided by aging PC bulbs (1 actinic, 1 daylight, 55w each.)  Salinity is 1.023, Ammonia and Nitrites are at 0, and Nitrates hover around 15-20ish.  Temp. is 78 F.  pH is about 8.2.
Current moment finds "Roz" in a five-gallon Q tank, awaiting his fate.  He acts completely normal, and eats well, but the dots persist (I did try turning off the skimmer.. alas, it wasn't bubbles).  I don't know what to do:  half the crowd says that treating ich with hyposalinity is Great and Good, especially for copper-sensitive cowfish; the other half says that hyposalinity "treatments" are a waste of time, because they aren't curing anything. <I prefer hyposalinity as a dip or bath.> Everyone says "..and for the love of God, be CAREFUL with formalin if you haven't used it before, it is extremely toxic!" <THAT is for certain.> Aaahh, what to do!? <You actually have the answers right there.>
I am slowly raising the temp in the empty main tank (had to crack coralline off the Visitherm to do so. haven't changed it since I set it out of the box!), to encourage the ich to 'cycle' itself and die, but I'm not sure what to do with the cowfish.  Mr. LFS sold me a wee bottle of Cupramine, but I haven't used it.  I also haven't dipped the cowfish, as Mr. LFS said there was no point in doing so (parasites under slime coat, etc.) <Even so, often remarkably effective.> Well, he was wrong about that, it seems. Drat. <Ahh... no worries, live and learn, right? We'll get Roz hooked up.>
So.. what treatment course would you recommend, here?  The cowfish is well, hale and happy; but I know he won't stay that way without help. <Or will he? It's been my observation that some of the scaleless fishes are always carrying around something on their skin - not all of this group, but mostly the advanced ones (boxfish, puffers, etc.). In spite of these parasites, they always seem to keep on trucking and behave/eat like they always do with what seem to be no long term ill effects or contamination of tankmates. Could be that Roz is like this...> I've warmed the Q tank up a little, to about 80 F.. already there are fewer visible dots on him.  I did put gravel in the Q tank. a scant double handful of new, freshly washed coral gravel, because the shiny bottom appeared to be upsetting Roz quite badly. <Yes - is my strong belief that while some fish may react to their reflection in the side glass, many more are completely freaked by their reflection in the bottom glass. I paint my quarantine tanks or put contact paper on at least the bottom (outside).> That 'other cowfish' was talking trash, it would seem..  Should I remove it? <Without a doubt.> Would Paraguard/similar Malachite green formulation be a better choice than the Cupramine/copper formulation? <If things seem out of control, then yes, but I'm not sure we're at that point.> At this point, the wisest treatment course seems to be the gentlest, most patient one: if I'm starting with a healthy fish, then perhaps I can afford to expend more time/effort on my part to spare him a harsh, "last ditch" style of treatment... I have the luxury of a ich-y (haha!) fish who is still in good health... but I'm not sure how to be 'gentle' and still get rid of the ich. <It seems to me you had the answer all along. This is an otherwise healthy fish in an ideal situation - he has a 54 corner all to himself. I'd leave him be if he eats and behaves normally. If the spots are frequent and increasing, then I'd give it a long, pH/temperature-adjusted freshwater dip and then return to the main tank. If things move beyond that, I'd consider a Quick Cure/Paraguard bath in a bucket of tank water, treated for the amount of water in the bucket, perhaps an hour if the fish seems otherwise fine. But for now, a freshwater dip, return to the tank, and the resultant reduction in stress should work well. Perhaps some more live rock at some point down the line would help, but not right now. Keep on a good water change regimen (10% every 2 weeks) and I think Roz will be fine.>
Thank you very, very much in advance!
Ramie  
<Cheers, J -- >

Crypt...urgent _ seriously  - 4/24/2006
Good Morning
<Still>
I have been reading ich and puffer FAQs for the last 7 hours. I think I have the groundwork covered.  I had a small outbreak about a year or so ago and came out with no losses. That was partly a result of very diligent dips etc but a lot of luck too: You've heard this story a thousand times but yeah,
<Likely more>
I used CopperSafe on the advice of LFS guy and my 2 puffers and 1 trigger made it. And that was in my display tank - even all of the hermits survived. The live rock is back now. but that took forever.
I'll chalk that up to luck. These fish have been there before and after looking at some risk management, they (some our fish are going on three years old) have decided copper is an unacceptable risk. I would love a response this morning. Here are the details -
• 180g + 50g sump.
• A few damsels
• Small Heniochus pair
•  S&S Puffer 9" (This is his tank of course)
•  Tiny dogface puffer
•  Small flame angel
•  4" Huma Huma
• 2 small yellow tangs
•  mediumish snowflake moray
•  lots of crabs and liverock
My wife spotted an ich outbreak this morning, so at least we have the head start. I'm pretty shocked at how quickly it manifested though;  
<Mmm, has been there all this time... just some trigger... not the fish.>
this wasn't here on Friday evening. This is the early stage, everyone is behaving normally but I know I need to move quick.
Both puffers have light spotting on fins - same for both Henis. Damsels are all clear. The angel and the trigger already have body spots.
I bought a good hospital setup after I found out today. 55 gal generic with decent hardware.
<... not so sure all these fishes will go/get along here>
I have a good understanding of hyposalinity and temp etc.
We are pretty good dippers too. I really just want to know what   product to pick up..?
<?>
I'm thinking no copper,  no malachite green, methylene blue is a maybe but Formalin at 37% is a good idea.
Yes?
No?
<... Please read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/formalinart.htm
and the linked files above...>
I need to start this now, advice would be appreciated beyond words.  
I'm scared for there guys.
<More knowledge will lessen to almost completely diminish your fear>
Cheers,
Christopher
<Bob Fenner>

Re: urgent _ seriously ... Crypt - 04/24/2006
Thank you for your quick reply but  I'm confused
I have re-read the formalin page; is this a cautious endorsement?
<Perhaps>
I guess to distill my question to it's essence: I would like to know specifically which product would be best to start treatment now; methylene, formalin or something else?
Thanks in advance,
c.
Christopher Roberts
<My friend... this is posted over and over on our site... with cautionary remarks as you suggest here. I would not use formalin/formaldehyde... or formalin... I would use a minimum concentration (due to the puffers mainly) of a chelated copper commercial product here... with twice daily testing with a matched test kit... Read on first! Bob Fenner>

Re: urgent _ seriously... Crypt  - 04/24/2006
Thank you Bob
<Welcome>
I appreciate your directness. Do realize that many many WetWeb crew posts here absolutely forbid the use of copper with puffers (in ALL CAPS)- period.
<Yes... am fully aware of some others opinions here (have placed almost all materials on WWM... over the last decade)... My opinion, experience varies you might say>
But yes, I was aware that you are a proponent of it.
<Oh! Good>
I am out the door to pick up a good copper test kit in a moment.
Please advise a suggested dosage.
  1 ppm, monitored 2x daily over a 2 week period?
<... no... posted on WWM for all's review though>
Many Thanks.
*Hopefully I won't write you again until I just drop a brief  Thank You that all my guys are flourishing.
Cheers,
c.
<Write away. Just do please search and read first. Bob Fenner>

Ichy Porcupine Puffer
<Hi, MikeD here>
I purchased a 3.5" porcupine puffer about 5 weeks ago.  I named him Gizmo<LOL! That's a very popular porcupine name!> and placed him into a 20 gallon tank that had been set up with a considerable amount of live rock and a Fluval 304 cartridge filter.  The tank was set up about a month before introducing him to the tank.  I already had some hermit crabs in there, and believed the tank to be stable.  Approximately 4 days after introducing Gizmo to the tank, I had a considerable ammonia spike which prompted me to move him over to my 30 gallon tank which had been fully cycled<Not surprising. The meaty foods required and the bad foods many people buy from LFS will frequently cause the system to overload>.  Gizmo stayed in that tank for approximately two days when I noticed the telltale signs of Ich on his skin and fins<Yep. Porcupines are quite delicate in regards to ich>.  Not wanting to expose the other fish, I moved Gizmo back into the 20 gallon tank after doing a 50% water change and verifying that the ammonia was sufficiently low (almost 0)<OUCH! Almost is still enough to break down the fish and weaken it for further attacks>.  I went to the LFS and they gave me a bottle of medication.  Before medicating I decided to investigate the treatment on the web.  After reading some horror stories
regarding puffer susceptibility to Ich treatment toxicity, I hesitated to use the treatment.  Ultimately I opted to begin freshwater dips instead.<To me, freshwater dips are too hazardous for puffers>  I prepared the bath with deionized water, buffered the water to achieve an pH of 8.3, and then raised the temperature to match the tank's.  I performed a freshwater dip for 10 minutes with no apparent ill effects to the fish, and continued to do dips once every 24 hours for the next week.  All signs of Ich disappeared from Gizmo, and I thought that I had it licked.  Unfortunately, my freshwater dips were postponed for 3 days because I had to travel for business.  During that time my girlfriend did the feeding for me, and she reported no visible signs of Ich while I was gone.  She did say, however, that Gizmo didn't want to eat on one occasion, which was strange for him.  The evening that I returned from my trip, I arrived home to find Gizmo covered with more white spots!  I immediately resumed the freshwater bath routine, initially doing
it once every 12 hours, and later only once every 24 hours.  This routine once again resulted in the elimination of Ich spots.<Ich has a cycle where the spots disappear, then reappear in about 3-4 days>  I kept up the freshwater baths for another 10 days after seeing the last signs of Ich on Gizmo.  All was going well until yesterday when I came home from work to find Gizmo covered with spots again!  When I left for work that morning, he had almost no visible signs of anything that resembled a spot.  I gave him another freshwater dip, and this morning the spots were still there.  I gave him another freshwater dip today, yet the spots still remain.  Additionally, he didn't want to eat very much today, and I fear that he is getting weak.<Very likely>  I don't know what to do at this point.  I don't want to give him chemicals, as I'm afraid that it might kill him.<The ich and stress is already killing him>  I'm also worried that he is excessively stressed from the daily freshwater dips.  He actually puffed up twice while in the freshwater dip two days ago<very bad, only worse if they puff up with air while being dipped. I'm surprised that he hasn't>, and he bit at the bucket wall.  He now also swims
frantically for his life at any time that I put anything into the tank.<That's just absolute terror>  My contingency plan has been to set up a 30 gallon tank and artificially cycle it with ammonia so that I can use it to put Gizmo in after the freshwater dips leave him spot free.  Unfortunately, Gizmo needs to go into it NOW, and the tank is not yet stable enough.  Please help!  What should I do to keep Gizmo from dying?  I'm already so attached to the little guy, and I don't want anything bad to happen to him.
<OK, with puffers, being scaleless fish, they are very sensitive to copper, but they do handle the formalin treatments, particularly if used half strength, which is what I suggest. The brand name of the formalin treatment available in this area is "Quick Cure" and needs to be used in a separate hospital tank.
Don't be surprised if he makes several trips back and forth but he will eventually settle in and toughen up once you quit the dips. Use caution in what you feed him as too small of foods (brine shrimp, poor quality or unrinsed Mysis, etc. will cause a spike very quickly. If you switch to frozen shrimp from the Seafood section of your supermarket as a primary food you should find him easier to care for>
Lou    

Ich Counter-Attack...Follow Up
Hey crew,
<Hi there! Scott F. here again>
Well the good news is that the fish in the main tank are looking 100% better, no visible signs except for the tang.
<Good to hear that...Give the treatment its full course, and I'm sure that the tang will follow suit>  
The bad news is that this morning I lost the puffer, I guess that the copper treatment wasn't so good.  But  what I read in Mr.  Fenner's book said puffers are ok with copper.  
<Some are- some aren't...>
Well at least now if the ich has a comeback, I can quarantine all of the fish. Best regards. Ryan King
<Hang in there, Ryan- and follow the manufacturer's full treatment course...Regards, Scott F>

Another Ich Battle...
To my wonderful and resourceful crew,
<I like that one! Scott F. with you today!>
I have had an outbreak of marine ick in my main display tank.  I believe my Yellow Tang started it after I introduced a new Flame Angel to the tank.
<Uh- oh..>
My problem is that I only have a 20 gallon quarantine tank and too many fish. I have a 3.5" porcupine puffer, 3" yellow tank, 2.5" flame angle and two 2" damsels. I have about 30lbs of live rock and a few hermit crabs. The puffer has the worst case of ick followed by the tang and angel, the damsels seem to be fine.  To fight this plague I first lowered my SG to about 1.018 and also took my temp up to 80F.  I gave all of the fish a freshwater dip.  I set up the quarantine tank and put in "SeaCure" copper treatment and I put in the puffer.  I was thinking of leaving the puffer in for two days and than putting in the tang and the angle for two days.
<You really may want to refrain from using copper on puffers. They do not always take well to this treatment. Formalin-based products might be a better choice>
Back in the main tank I cleaned out all/most of the substrate and did about an 8 gallon water change.  Will this treatment be good enough or should I buy another tank (really don't want to but would to save the fish) so that I can quarantine all of the fish for the month and let the main clean up?
<Personally, I would remove all of the fish for observation and/or treatment (if necessary) to a separate tank (or even large Rubbermaid containers). The "fallow tank" technique is generally the most successful method, IMO. As long as there are fish in the display tank, the causative protozoan can complete its life cycle, assuring you of more rounds of misery with the disease.>
Thankfully, Ryan King
P.S.  --- Is there any trick for moving the puffer from tank to tank?  Right now I catch him in a 1.5 gallon bag and it works ok but there is probably a better way.
<I like that idea- it keeps them submersed at all times, which seems to be less stressful. Perhaps Jeni (Pufferpunk) or Ananda, (who have forgotten more about puffers than I'll ever know) can chime in if they know of a better way? Good luck! Regards, Scott F>

Ich Meds for Puffers
I have two dog face puffers with ich and was glad to find such detailed articles on how to treat for it. I have been looking for the product mentioned in three articles, Mardel Marine Maracide. I can't find the "Marine" version at any local fish stores or on the web. 
<Well, time to come clean, I said that had been a mis-type on my fault. Please read below my improved method of treating puffers.. I have been doing some heavy duty research and work studying ich. My marine puffers have recently come down with it. With my puffers I have been doing different methods for treating ich! and have been very happy with the results. I was turned on to a product called Stop Parasites or Biospheres Antibacterial for treatment, following directions exactly. The person that I had learned this trick from had said to turn off the lights during treatment. I originally thought it was just a bit of superstition but after chatting with a microbiologist on the matter he gave me this bit of advice. Free Swimming Ich is attracted to light, the parasites swim up towards the source of the light were it expects to find a host. Keeping the lights of just makes it more difficult for the ich to find a house and failure to do that within a day or so cause the ich cyst to die without reproducing. (interesting bit of trivia that might make a difference when treating medicinally). I have raised the tank temperature during treatment which speeds up the metabolic processes of the parasite as well as the fish to help in immune systems. Also I have found that puffers do quite well if you begin to SLOWLY lower your specific gravity to somewhere around 1.016-1.018. the lower salinity is safe for puffers, but ich cysts will not survive the reduced salt levels. I have also found that giving my puffers a 10-15 minute freshwater bath VERY helpful. Most marine fish should only be given 5-8 minute freshwater dips, but with puffers they seem to handle it quite well, and the freshwater dips of 10+ minutes really work great at removing the parasites from the fish. While you treat the tank for the remaining parasites with the medicines listed above. Also during this time vacuum the substrate to remove the fallen cysts, it's something that is over looked frequently. I do like the "Stop Parasites" medication. because it's a natural product. made from a hot-pepper, mint based liquid. It's reef safe (even said to be human safe). Have Tetracycline on hand in case you need to help with secondary bacterial infections.> 
Thanks in advance for you help! Kim 
<sorry for the confusion, but I have been treating my puffers this way and have been extremely happy with the results. in fact I have been keeping my puffer's tank at a slightly lower salinity and it seems to be keeping them quite happy and healthy. I was amazed at how well the freshwater dips worked on my fish! Good luck with your puffers. Magnus>

Thanks for the reply. (Boxfish, ich concerns)
Thanks for the quick reply- spent all day reading on the WWM site.  
EXCELLENT resource, we are lucky to have you.  Saturday- moved the fish to the LFS.  Separated the YP Box (he is in his own tank at the LFS), the SF tang and 2 Clowns are in another tank, and the Auriga and L. Blenny are in another.  The thing is, the LFS here in town have 1200 gallon system that circulates amongst the entire store-  If the boxfish dies will this contaminate the entire store?<possibly if he is not taken out of the aquarium ASAP>  Not only that- there is no way to up the temp and lower the salinity for an individual tank- they are all linked.  They seemed unconcerned when I pointed out this detail.  They are unable to diagnose specifically (though they seem to think ICH because of the small spots on the Percula), but were quick to asses Copper treatment for the tang and clownfish (moderate copper for the Auriga and the blenny).  but after reading all day I am kind of freaked out-  These are not quarantine tanks and they have gravel bottoms, so I'm pretty much assured that the copper will be absorbed by the gravel and it will be filtered through (no constant copper) because of the water system set up (so totally ineffective?). <not necessarily> The LFS also said to treat there 3-5 days and back to our tank.  I (now) know 4-6 week minimum to run the course of the parasite- (at home while awaiting fish we can) lower the salinity to 1.021 (says bob) 1.018 (says Steven pro) and raise the temp. (no higher than 84f) since we have 2 cleaner shrimp (already) and 2 emerald crabs and 20 lbs LR (no copper here thank you!!) we are sort of stuck unless we move everyone to the LFS or get 3/4 QT.<agreed> But I am  still concerned for our fish at the LFS.<I would be also>  I know now (add another to the list) that I should have had a Quarantine tank all set up and ready to go and I think I need to go back and pick up my fish- like right now.<agreed>  Should I have two QT? One set up for the box fish (and blenny? he is scale-less right?<yeah this sounds like a good idea> maybe they should be separate if the box fish doesn't make it) and
one for the tang, Auriga?<yea>  (Is the butterfly more sensitive?) <probably so> I would like to set up the QT and treat the Tang, Clowns, Butterfly with Copper. (right?)<yes>   Then does everyone stay in the QT for 4-6 weeks?<yup> I love my fish- I will be very sad if they die (I already feel incredibly guilty- why aren't there laws pet stores selling SWF without a license of some sort???<I honestly cannot answer that one>
we bought the tank with fish already from people who were moving and have had to learn everything the hard way- and the LFS has pretty much told us ALL THE WRONG THINGS).<most of them normally do, there are some exceptions but normally they tell you false info to make the quick sale>  So how many QT? <2 of them would be an excellent idea>
Should I move them again from the LFS to home?<this may stress them out again, I would wait a while and see if they progress at the LFS, because you are probably going to stress the crap out of them shipping them back and forth, etc>  I called the LFS today- and the owner said they looked fine (moron) and I don't trust them to treat our fish... what do you recommend?<well you pretty much have to trust them right now, because again you don't want to stress them out more than they already are> Thanks for the website- you are all excellent to have this website and answer all of these questions...
Thanks again.<your welcome my friend, just wait and see how the fish look at the LFS-with your own eyes
might I add!! lol. If they start to look worse I would setup my own QT aquarium and treat the fish there. Hopefully
your LFS at least knows the basics of marine fish keeping and treating of parasitic infections/ich. IanB>
-Erin

Alternative Therapies For Ich (1/27/04)
   Greetings WWM Crew! <To You as Well. Steve Allen here.>
   I seem to have gotten into an Ich mess despite my best attempts at quarantine.  Here is my current situation - I have a 150 fish only system housing 5 fish - a damsel, a striped puffer and a longhorn cowfish from another tank in my house, a yellow tang and a juvenile queen angel, both recent purchases.  The tang entered near the end of cycling, the angel shortly there after, followed last week by the three others.  Nitrites and Ammonia are zero, Nitrate just barely registers.
   I've never seen Ich in my old tank, and I guess I wrongly assumed that I was okay... and of course failed to quarantine the last 3 fish. <Live and learn.> Yesterday I noticed a couple white spots on the fins of the puffer and cowfish, and they sure look like Ich. <You are almost certainly right.> I'm now in the situation of having 5 large-ish fish to house and treat. with only a 15 gallon hospital / QT tank (my secondary QT is also my water mixing trash can). I definitely can't house 5 separately, and I think the stability of the big tank is best for the fish. <Big Rubbermaid tubs with biofiltration, circulation & heat work well.>
   I travel quite a bit for work, and don't have anyone I trust to do daily water changes, etc - my girlfriend has learned to feed correctly, but that's about it. <Understood.>
   I know you're against treating in the main tank, but I guess I'm looking for some alternatives.  I like the idea of hyposalinity, but I've found a lot of conflicting information on the subject.  <Many opinions out there.> I've already started to lower the salinity <Do you have inverts?--could be dangerous to them>, and I'm now running the UV sterilizer 24 hours a day. <May kill the free-swimming organisms if flow rate correct. The theory then is that if few are able to get to your fish, most eventually die for lack of a host.> I'm also tempted to try copper.  <Resist this with all your strength. This will be nothing but trouble and disaster. Will kill your biofilter and inverts. May kill your cowfish and thus wipe out your tank. Will ruin your sand and rock, causing them to leach toxic copper forever. Should only be used in QT.> What exactly are the detrimental effects of doing these in my main system? <As above.> Am I just wasting time, or is there viable "if-you-have-to-do-it" alternative? <The QT/fallow method is the only proven way.> I'd love to run fallow for weeks, but I just don't think my fish would make it. <I understand your predicament. I can tell you that I had a few spots of ich on two fish in my tank last July. I was very careful about water quality and ran UV for several weeks. I have not seen a spot of ich on any fish since. A word of warning: ich will "disappear" after a few days and then may come back a hundred fold a couple of weeks later when the next, bigger generation is ready to leave the substrate and infest fish. It may then be too late to save your fish. That's the risk you take if you do not immediately treat aggressively. You have to weigh the factors and decide what's best for your situation. There was a good article by Scott Michael in Aquarium USA 2004. You should be able to find this at Petco or PetSmart. Advanced Aquarist Online is running a good series of articles right now too. Unfortunately, this month's is only number 3 of 5. Check here: http://www.advancedaquarist.com/issues/jan2004/toc.htm>
Many Thanks, Dave <Hope this helps.>

Porcupine puffer with ich (08/28/03)
<Hi! Ananda here tonight...>
I have been reading your puffer FAQs.. but yet to find any help for my problem. I have an 80 gallon tank w/a porcupine puffer fish, a lionfish, a trigger fish and a yellow tang (the latter have been moved to a non-infected tank).  my puffer has had ich for about two weeks now...other than the obvious visible symptoms, and heavy breathing and sometimes twitch- like movements he is eating and functioning fine.
<So you have just the puffer in the 80 gallon tank? I would put him in his own hospital tank and let the display go fallow for at least a month.>
After calling my local fish store as advised I turned up the heat to around 82 degrees, kept the lights off and have done a few water changes.  The levels test fine.  My boyfriend has gone several dips that while clearing the fish up a bit...still has not gotten rid of the problem. We were advised not to do anymore for fear of stressing them out even more.
<Dips alone will not get rid of ich if you're putting the fish back into an infested system.>
We treated the tank with Marisol (I believe that was the name) for a week daily, and it seemed to have no helpful effect.  The lionfish has gotten worse w/one clouded eye now, and the puffer's white patches are getting more dense in some areas (make sense)???
<Cloudy eyes are usually a symptom of poor water quality. You might want to check your test kits.>
We are trying to stabilize a hospital tank to put them in...but it probably won't be ready for a month.
<Good grief, don't bother trying to cycle a hospital tank right now. Get the infected fish in there ASAP. Then you'll do daily water changes to keep the ammonia/nitrites/nitrates under control and bring the specific gravity down to 1.010. And keep the tank temp up.>
I really don't want my fish to die...please please please email me back with any suggestions...I will appreciate it indefinitely!!!  Thanks again,  Bonnie
<Do check out the ich articles and FAQs on the WetWebMedia site, starting here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ichartmar.htm. --Ananda>

Ich? on Yellow Boxfish
<Hello! Ananda here tonight>
We have had our boxfish in our tank for about a month.  He has been very healthy with no signs of disease until today when we noticed about 30 or more white dots all over his body.  We suspect ich, but the dots do not seem to be clustered around his fins....yet?  He is still eating, breathing and swimming as usual.  
<Those are good signs.>
We know not to treat him with copper since he is a scaleless fish, and we know he secretes a toxin, which could kill everything in our tank, when he becomes stressed.  
<Yup.>
Our concern is will he release this toxin if we try to remove him from the tank to do freshwater dips?  Should we do freshwater dips?  
<Yes, it's possible that your cowfish might release toxins if the freshwater dip stresses it sufficiently. You can minimize the stress of a freshwater dip by ensuring that the dip temperature and pH exactly match that of the display tank, and by aerating the dip tank. However, some people prefer to save freshwater dips as a last resort for these fish.>
Is there any other way to treat this fish?  We have already started to raise the temperature to 80 degrees and are starting to lower the salinity as well.  
<You've already started on the primary treatment: lower salinity and higher temperatures. These would be best carried out in a bare-bottomed hospital tank, along with daily water changes, siphoning from the bottom of the tank to get the greatest number of ich cysts. I've read that people with cowfish are more likely to use UV sterilizers -- which are good only against the free-swimming stage of the parasite, mind you -- to help combat ich. Another favorite of the crew on the Cowfish, Puffers, & More discussion group seems to be StopParasite. I have no experience with that particular product, so I suggest you check the Cowfish etc. discussion group for peoples' opinions: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/CowfishPuffers_andMore/ >
Is it possible that this is something other than ich?  His tankmates are a Foxface, a damsel, a Kole tang and a couple of snails.  Thanks for any advice you can give.
<More on Boxfishes here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/boxfshfaqs.htm ... --Ananda>

Puffer With Ich
Recently I emailed you guys about my puffer getting stuck in my uv sterilizer pump, well now he has healed up great, but now has a pretty good case of ich.  I just came off a week of using Melafix, and performed about a 20 percent water change for the wound.  Now I want to address the ich problem, tonight I soaked his food in garlic juice.  The remainder of the fish have no signs of ich.  The ich on the puffer has reached his eye.  In addition I have one star polyp and 1 xenia. I would like to keep them.  Plus I don't have a separate tank, and at this time of year I don't know whether I can afford another one, however this is my favorite fish. Thanks a ton. David White, Ann Arbor MI
<Well, David- treating ich really requires a separate aquarium to do the job. My concern is that once ich is in your system, the parasites have the potential to affect all of the fishes unless you treat them, or leave the tank "fallow" for at least a month to deprive the causative parasites their hosts, the fishes. If you absolutely cannot get a treatment tank for these fishes, perhaps you could try an inexpensive plastic garbage can, or a Rubbermaid type container of known volume, equipped with a simple inside filter and heater? Copper sulphate is the generally accepted treatment for ich, and should never be administered in the display tank, particularly if you have inverts and corals present. Garlic as a treatment is not 100% proven to be effective. Much of the evidence for garlic's use as an ich "treatment" is anecdotal. In theory, a substance produced by crushing fresh garlic has some properties which can mask the receptor mechanism of the parasites, making them unable to find their hosts. While the theory seems to have some validity, much more refinement and research is yet to be done before garlic can be considered a "treatment", rather than a preventative. I guess another treatment option would be daily freshwater dips of the puffer for about 5 minutes, if you cannot treat him in another tank. Do keep a careful eye on the other fishes in the tank...There is a distinct possibility that they may become infected, too. Please do not use one of the allegedly "reef safe" treatments- they can be really ineffective and wasteful, IMO. Do some research on ich in the wetwebmedia.com site using the Google search feature for more info. Good luck!  Regards,  Scott F>

Re: Help with Dogface Puffer
Hi Bob, Leslie here. 
<Hi Leslie, Craig here>
You helped me a while back with a tank that had unsuccessfully gone through treatment for Amyloodinium infestations on 3 successive occasions. I asked about microwaving the contents of the tank, my Dad's suggestion..... since I had tried everything else I could think of to kill the darn bug.
<I can relate to the desperation!>
Anyway...... I have had my Dogface Puffer for about 6 weeks. He is a real looker. Pitch Black with clear black speckled fins and a white caudal fin with black speckles. Several weeks ago he developed some of what I believe to be Ich spots on his pectoral and dorsal fins. I saw him flash a couple of times, nothing continuous. He developed an occasional spot on his body which have disappeared. This is a FO tank 50g. I know small for him, but he is only 4" at this time. I have plans for a bigger tank. The thought of investing in a huge tank for this fish, after all those tank crashes didn't seem to sensible. I figured I will get the BIG tank if I can keep him alive long enough to need one. I hope not a stupid mistake.
At the suggestion of a highly respected published friend in the marine community I have been using something called OST....osmotic shock therapy. Are you familiar with this? If so what are your feelings about using it prophylactically in a Q tank as well as to treat parasites? 
<Lowered SG in conjunction with copper and temp raised to 83F in a QT is the preferred treatment. This is fine if done over time....days.>
The recommended specific gravity for FO tanks is 1.010. for 3 to 4 weeks. So I had this guy at that specific gravity for about 3 weeks, when I slowly slowly increased the specific gravity to 1.018 the spots began to appear. He otherwise looks and acts very healthy. The spots have been quite stubborn. I panicked at first because the Amyloodinium outbreaks started like this. I have since increased the temp of the tank....slowly to 80 to 81 degrees, fed garlic laced food and treated the tank with a product called Stop Parasites. The spots look about the same. One of the spots on the pectoral fin is a bit bigger, perhaps looking like 4 or 5 coalescing spots, but not as bright as the other spots. On that fin there is a tiny area at the fin tip directly in line with the bigger spot, that looks like it is worn away, just a very small area. I placed a 15w UV unit with a 90gph flow rate on the tank 3 days ago and FW dipped him last night for 15 min. He did very well......not even phased by it. They look a bit better today.
Is it possible this is not Ich or perhaps something in conjunction with Ich? What else would you recommend I do for him. Thank you so much for your help :) Leslie
<Yes, remove to quarantine tank and treat with copper @0.25 ppm free copper as above. For more on this go to WetWebMedia.com and enter "copper" into the google search. I wouldn't advise any of the stop parasite type treatments. Craig>

Tang and puffer disease question
Hi, I have a hippo tang, yellow tang, maroon clown, Huma Huma trigger, and dogface puffer. My hippo tang and puffer seem to have Ich, that won't go away. All other fish are fine. On the hippo tang, I noticed what appeared to be a pimple next to one of his gills and then he broke out with ich. One of his eyes is also starting to become cloudy. The puffer develops ich in one location and the next day it is in another location. I don't understand?
<Completely normal. Ich has a short lifespan and is constantly dropping off the fish, depositing eggs (cysts), and then reinfecting in a different place.>
I dropped my salinity to 1.021
<I would go lower, 1.018.>
and raised my temp to 83 F. All fish are eating well, and swimming like crazy! I have been doing fresh water baths for the hippo tang and puffer for 9 min each for the past 2 days.
<Good>
Neither fish seems to be getting better?
<Two days is not enough time to effect a cure. You will be battling this for at least one month.>
Does this seem like ich, or something worse?
<No, sounds like Ich.>
Will the freshwater baths be fine for treating or do I need to add medication?
<I would stick with them for the time being. If you do decide to medicate, please do so in a separate quarantine/hospital tank, not the main, display tank.>
Thank you. JPK
<You are welcome. -Steven Pro>

Ich again
Hi WWM guys,
<greetings from friend/author Anthony Calfo!>
First off, thank you for all you do for aquarists and our livestock. You save many lives in your endeavor.
<thank you... I chose this career exactly for that reason...and the fact that I was to short to be a fireman...hehe>
 I have what appears to be a common ich infestation, 
<yes, but have your fish caught it from you yet... and just how itchy are you?>
but with an additional variable that I'd like to run by you. 
<this doesn't involve a story about the south side of town and a tutu does it?>
I believed that my infestation was cured (rather in check) by lowering spg, maintaining high temp, and adding a UV sterilizer. 
<OK...perhaps>
I returned spg to 1.020 and temp to 78ish. I also removed 1/2 of the bio-balls from my sump in preparation for mud/LR/Caulerpa filtration. My nitrates came down from about 80, to 40 within a week or so, with my water changes. My nitrites have risen to .25 pH is 8.4-8.6
For the record, I have dipped and quarantined all new additions, but the ich-prone tang must have carried enough to infest my tank. I've never treated with copper.
<I hope you don't most likely>
I assume that my nitrite rising is affecting the fish health, 
<not so much as any one water change with water accidentally 3+ degrees cooler... that is the easiest way to flare Ich in marine aquaria...are you checking the temperature of your evaporation and water change waters?>
and a contributor to the ich problem. 
<unlikely at this level>
If I return the bio-balls, will the bacterial level re-establish quickly, or would I be as well to wait without re-introducing the bio-balls?
<shouldn't need the bio-balls with enough live rock>
I have a host of inverts, 50lbs LR, 
<get more please>
and only 3 fish in my 72 gallon aquarium: 1 clown, 1 blue tang, and 1 lionfish. My quarantine tank is a 30 gal hex (not having expected to put multiple fish in at one time, live and learn...). My tang has a serious infestation, and has shown many spots every morning for the past 5 days or so. My lionfish may have developed some spots overnight, last night. The clown looks fine. Since the spots returned on the tang, I have reduced spg to 1.017, and raised temp to 83. The tang shows no improvement, actually deterioration.
<do look at today's post called Re: Cowfish II for protocol on meds, QT WC's and the like>
I am unable to fit all of the LR into the QTank in order to introduce copper into the main system.
< actually a bucket or plastic garbage can (new... no chemicals) with strong water movement will be fine instead>
Ideally, I would treat all fishes with copper in my quarantine tank, but I'm not comfortable with all 3 fish in a 30 hex, it's rather tall and narrow.
<agreed>
I'm afraid the tang's activity will be too stressful for all. If you think this is worth trying, I plan to put the wet/dry on the 30, and run my cc skimmer & Caulerpa only on the main tank during this period, and probably ever after.
<copper is not your med of choice , however...the lionfish is quite sensitive as a scale less fish to it, and any remaining calcareous media (gravel) will just suck it up... what you need is a bare-bottomed aquarium and daily water changes from the bottom for 8 days to remove the larval tomites>
Secondly, I could remove the lionfish to the quarantine, monitor him, and possibly adding copper to his water. 
<see above>
This would allow for a cleaner shrimp in the main tank, and after 6 weeks or so, I could switch the lion and cleaner - and maybe find the cleaner a new home.
<OK... may help, but don't count on to effect a cure>
Thirdly, should I spring for a 20long or what recommended size, and quarantine all 3 fish in that? I'd rather not buy yet another aquarium, but will if that's the best course of action for my fish.
<admirable>
I love this hobby, but really had no idea what I was getting into a year ago. I would support legislation to mandate reading of your FAQs and horror stories of livestock losses to anyone interesting in a marine aquarium!
<even with me participating now?>
Thank you again for all the help I've received from you in the past, and going forward.
<kind regards, Anthony Calfo>

Re: Ich again
Hi Anthony,
<Salute, Daron>
As you have noted, I sympathize with my fish - I've been itching for weeks.
<And I bet you the rapid breathing from the gill parasites is quite embarrassing for you on the phone...hehe>
Is copper a safe treatment for me? I don't have scales either, but I've been carrying pennies around in my pockets for a few days.
<copper bracelets will be sufficient...they help with joint aches as well>
Seriously, you gentlemen at WWM have definitely made my life easier, but it's still stressful and expensive to keep these guys happy. Without your FAQs and answers, I would probably have already lost all my fish a few times over, then taken up bowling.
<"the horror...the horror..." signed, "Kurtz">
Thank you for your advice - I do have a few questions about my course of action, though. 
<OK...buy your own shoes if you must bowl>
I am deciding between removing the (bought as dead, but now very alive with copepods) sand substrate, LR, and inverts from my 72 and the choice of purchasing a q-tank for the 3 fish.
<believe it or not.. here's the suggestion if we must move the fish... leave the rock and sand untouched...buy/borrow a 55 gall food grade plastic drum (or like vessel(s))...kill the poser on the tank momentarily and drain into the drum... with the last remaining water, the fish will be easier to catch and lower stressed in your doing so...remove the fish to the bare bottomed quarantine and proceed as normal. And simply pump the water from the drum right back into the display tank. A fast water/sump pump for the drain and fill will make very short work of this. The full 4-week quarantine period will leave the display fallow/without a viable fish host and reduce the parasites sufficiently>
Will I need to keep the current sand, LR, and Inverts fallow for a month or so?
<as above but leave undisturbed>
If I run filtration such as my wet/dry on the FO, will that support the tomites, similar to how the substrate does? Sponge filter?
<best bet is a bare bottomed hospital tank with a sponge filter suspended off the bottom...and rinsed gently in the old daily water just before that water is discarded>
I'm thinking my best approach may be to move the inverts, sand and some of the LR to the hex, and the rest of the LR to a trash can. 
<sounds like too much work to me>
I can then keep my wet/dry on the 72, so I it won't have to cycle with my sick fish in it -
<the need for filtration for the fish will be tempered in QT by the daily WCs>
unless I change more water than I am foreseeing. 
<daily for more than a week in QT>
And, I'd might as well circulate water through my UV sterilizer - I know it isn't the cure-all I once thought it was, but it should help.
<agreed>
Thank you for your insight, it is much appreciated.
<you are quite welcome...good luck. Anthony>