Updated Sick Clown Question - 01/03/2006 I am relatively new to salt water aquariums. I had a 55 Gallon tank for 6 months last year and lost everything in. <Happens often.> Not sure why. I took it apart got rid of everything and restarted a year later. I am trying to do everything by the book. I cycled or aged the tank for 1 month with live sand. My pH was off so I  got a pH buffer and everything looked good. I got 4 Blue Damsels and a Diamond Gobi and cycled for another 1 months. I got snails and crabs to help with algae and waited another month. I introduced 2 clownfish and everything seems OK. I get 4 more clowns (store had for 2 weeks and treated them) after cycle and the trouble began. <Treated them for what? 6 clowns in this tank is already asking for trouble, not to mention the presence of the other damsels. Adding groups of fish like this (more than one or two at a time) impacts your cycle/water quality. Things get offset and need to restabilize.> My damsels started getting aggressive so I pulled out 2 and took  them back to the store. The tank was peaceful again. All levels still OK. <An ok measure is really not helpful for us.> Then the trouble. I started to lose my clowns 1 at a time. The first started hiding a lot and it was Christmas time so couldn't get to the store for help. I do not understand a lot of what is written on these sites for self help, so I just hoped for the best. <Don't understand in general, or when it comes to medications and such?> It stopped eating and died. <Not surprising. Clowns need an environment that is low in metabolic wastes. This constant cycle readjustment has not helped. Skimmer? Filtration? You do not mention these.> I noticed that its color seemed faded. Then another one started hiding and not eating and I noticed a long white string from the bottom of the fish. <Feces. Color indicating likely an internal bacterial infection.> If I put the net in he would drop it but it always came back, <Uh...Has to go somewhere.> its color faded and he died. Now I have 3 left and one more is  isolating itself, seems to eat a little but color fading. Help I don't want to  lose everything again. Nitrate slightly elevated to 40 did 25% water change. <40 is not a slight measure. Your poor water quality is causing this. I would do a 60% water change today followed by a 20% change tomorrow. From here, 10% weekly. Avoid using freshly mixed water if possible. Begin feeding a quality food containing a broad spectrum antibiotic.> Store suggested I treat with Quick Cure malachite green and I did for 3 days and it still has a string hanging. <If you don't know what you're doing here I would stop this. It can be quite toxic. Try the above and see if things begin to get better.> Eats very little and still shy and not himself. <I must say, even with your action now, this may be too late for you. Meaning don't expect a miracle turn around. You're going to have to be very diligent in your care here.> Oh I also got a fire-shrimp at the same time of the clowns and he died 3 days later, store said I probably did not acclimate him long enough only 45 minutes she say should be 3hrs+. <Yes, very sensitive.> All my levels except my nitrates (still 40) are perfect. Salt 1.021-1.022 <Uh...Specific gravity.> temp 78. <Am more worried about those "ok" parameters now. These are not to be considered perfect. I'd raise the spg to 1.024, slowly, no more than .01 per day. Nitrite? Ammonia?> Store says probably my tap water affecting my Nitrate and I tested it and it are slightly elevated off tap and very hard. I am starting to do water changes to better water tomorrow. And changing my Ehime filter media stuff (running a SeaClone as well). <You are keeping this filter clean right? Would do well to look into a more capable skimmer.> But afraid something is still wrong with my clowns. <Is.> Other 2 seem perfect but so did he until the other died. GOBY FINE, 2 DAMSELS FINE, CRABS AND SNAILS SEEM FINE I hear about FW dips what is this and will it help? <I'm afraid this pattern will continue for you until you buckle down and study. Don't make any more purchases until you understand better what it is you are doing. I would say similar cause are what happened to your first tank.> I will do anything HELP!!!! Any ideas what is going on? <Lack of knowledge. You need to read, study, google and cross reference until your head hurts. Take a 30, and do it again (after the water change of course). I would point you toward links but there are just too many you need to cover. I will point you to what will help immediately however. Here http://www.wetwebmedia.com/infectio.htm then on to the links above. - Josh>

Re: Updated Sick Clown Question, Josh Is A Jerk - 01/03/2006 I appreciate your feedback although it sounds a little sarcastic. <Hmm...I must admit I'm hopelessly sarcastic. I'm beginning to realize that it translates poorly through the net. I never mean it in a hurtful way, especially in such cases as this. I just seem to type the way I talk without thinking how it reads rather than sounds. I apologize.> I explained I was a new aquarium owner. <I understood this.> I came looking for help and I would think that is a good starting point. <I just meant to impart that the best starting place is from the "beginning", meaning before purchases, before these situations can arise.> I had gone to the store for info on everything and also I had purchased The saltwater aquarium book for dummies, not meaning I am one, before I started. <Such books are "handy" at best (for quick reference). I would advise you to purchase better, all around type books. "The Conscientious Marine Aquarist" by Fenner, "The New Marine Aquarium" by Paletta would be a great start. As far as the LFS advise given, I wouldn't ask them for any more than a price check at this point. Six clowns. Just two that aren't mated are a gamble!> I purchased the filter and the skimmer they suggested I used the salt and live sand they said I needed. I asked many questions about compatibility of fish and quantity. <Understood. The main problem here is, with many LFS, you may as well just be asking them if your $20 and your $50 are compatible with their register.> I questioned aggressive fish and all the non aggressive fish. I started with what they told me and I only added fish as they said  I should. <They've betrayed your trust.> So I am not stupid, I am apparently misinformed by our store. <I agree. I was given some good advice on how to pick a store when I first started, maybe it will help you. Put together 10 questions that you already know the answer to without a doubt (make at least 5 of them real "toughies"). Ask the employees or owners these questions and see how they react/answer. It's a quick way to lure a snake out of the grass so to speak.> I felt very upset reading some of your comments to me. <Again I apologize. Just a draw back of this medium.> If my statements sound a little vague or a little to much in detail I was trying to hit everything that may have been important. I am worried about my fish and will take steps to correct any of my problems, but when someone comes to you for help perhaps you can be a bit more gentle. <Scouts honor, didn't intend to be a jerk.> It is already stressful knowing my fish are in bad health. I love my fish like people love their dogs or cats and it is distressing that you make me out to be an idiot. <I've got two dogs, a cat and my tank. Honestly, I love them more than most humans. I understand that this is an upsetting time and I stand by my advice earlier. Both on your fish and your studying. You really owe it to them and yourself to make sure no one can put you/them in this position again. Defend them like a crazed mother hen (it's what I do), but you must arm yourself first.> Thank you, Kimberly Nadeau, Realtor <I hope this sets us straight. Truce. - Josh>
Re: Updated Sick Clown Question, Josh Is A Jerk - 01/04/2006 NO harm no foul.  Thank you for the info and I am on it now. Thanks,  Kimberly <Good stuff. Be chatting. - Josh>

Dying clownfish   12/28/05 I want to thank you first for having such a great sight. <Likely site, but thank you> You are such an amazing resource for so many "marine dumb".  I have 2 quick questions for you though.  I have a 40 gallon tank that has been quite healthy and much easier to manage than I thought.  I recently have/had added 2 tank bred false clownfish and a carnation anemone.  At the time I had a domino damsel, a coral beauty, and a scooter blenny. <... you need a larger system...> The first day I added the new guys I saw that one clownfish had a injured eye. <... no quarantine?> He died the next morning and my pet store "kindly" replaced him.  I then had an outbreak of ich and added a cleaner shrimp how everyone but the clownfish took to quickly.  The domino then started to "befriend" the anemone and was rubbing against it all the time.  The clownfish had no interest in the anemone.  The damsel then stopped eating and turned a very pale color and was very listless.   <Likely mal-affected, influenced by the Domino's presence> After about a week of this getting worse we "put him to sleep".  The next day one clownfish started losing his color and not eating.  Within 3 days he died and this pattern was then played out with the last clown.  I have read a lot and believe they had Brooklynellosis... <Doubtful... tank-bred clowns rarely have, bring this... and none of your other fishes should have acted as reservoir hosts. More likely what you experienced is simply "stress"... from crowding, mis-mixing... the Dascyllus> My question is, can I add an another clownfish in the future and how long do I need to wait?   <Till you get a much larger system, remove the Domino...> All the water parameters are great, the coral beauty and scooter are healthy and happy.  I would like to add a clownfish in the future though. I can promise you I will not longer buy from that pet store again.  All the fish that died are from the same place and all the ones still alive are from another store.  I had a fish credit at the first store and wanted to use it us on "safe" fish, little did I know I was throwing away money one way or another.  Thank you for your time, I know you are very busy, but this tank has become my life's work for my little girl.  Thank you again. <Mmm, please do read, take heart of what is posted on WWM re proper acclimation, quarantine... Systems for the life you list. Bob Fenner>  

A. clarkii Disease  11/30/05 Mr. Fenner & Crew  <Brian/Karissa> Howdy from the North Pole (Alaska that is), I need help in treating an A. clarkii. I purchased two of them from my LFS in which I trust and am good friends with the owner and staff. In the LFS they were very active, beautiful, and eating like a happy clown does; however, that is the end of that story, at least for one of them.  Day 1 in the Q tank, just fine, mostly hiding, but did come out and eat.  Day 2: no activity and little eating.  Day 3: smallest guy out and about, and eating fine, but the bigger one, had developed over night what to me looks like a fungus or bacteria. Off I went into The Conscientious Marine Aquarist, reading and rereading Chapter 9 'Disease', and searching WWM as well, and I am still not sure what this can be.  To best describe it would be a whitish, pink, hairy, cottony looking matter than has covered the tips of the Caudal, Pectoral, Pelvic, and forward edge of the Anal fin. In additional to the fins, it has also covered the area around the vent, as well as the mouth and with tiny blood streaks on the lips. Behavior has declined, mostly just treads water in one place; however, on occasions will swim the length of the tank a few times. Breathing is not really labored; no gasping at the top or lying on the bottom, and of course eating has slow to almost a stop (1 or 2 flakes/shrimp a day).  Day 4: The matter on the caudal fin was gone, along with that part of the fin, the rest remains the same. The other clown is showing no signs of infection and is doing great. RO Water parameters are fine. Salinity is 1.023, temp 80°F, with 10% water changes on all my tanks (3) biweekly. Can you help me identify this illness and a possible treatment? Here are a few pictures.  <Bryan, for some reason I cannot view the pictures, possibly not in jpeg format? As for the clowns, do purchase a fungus treatment of some kind and do not use chemical filtration during the treatment. The clown should recover nicely. James (Salty Dog)> Thank you  <You're welcome> 

Brooklynella 11-29-05 Hi guys, <Hello> I am really desperate for an answer regarding disease. I have had 2 Percula Clowns in the tank for about 2 months now and they seem to have suddenly erupted in a fungus/parasitic infection. The white stripes are flaking and turning grey, and there are a combination of white bumps and white spots descending over the gill area. I have read many FAQs on Clownfish disease/disease but have a dilemma; I am going to place the two clowns into QT for treatment, however there is no way that I can include the other fish, due to territoriality and restriction of volume.  These are: 2 X Green Chromis, 1 X Andaman Damselfish and 1 X Royal Gramma. Could I please add that these fish are showing no signs or symptoms and are as full of vigor as ever. My question is, would it be too risky to QT the clowns but simply observe the others for a change in condition?  <Yes, the other fish will be carriers if they don't die and will infect the clowns when they come back. Use plenty of hiding spots in the QT and you can even use buckets to QT if necessary.> Secondly, tiny (about half a millimeter) clear sacs containing what look like eggs are sporadically stuck to the inside glass. I believed these to be Nerite eggs but am now wishing to know if they are perhaps parasites or spores etc. <Most likely snail eggs. Nothing to worry about.> Many, many thanks in anticipation of any help offered. Steve Morse. <Glad to help, Travis> 

Peculiar Perculas! 11-28-05 A quick question if anyone would be so kind to assist....  <Travis here with you.> I have consulted WWM FAQs btw, but cannot find the relevant answer. I have two Percula Clowns and had a little trouble with one (seemed to be some kind of parasitic infection which cleared up after QT and treatment).  Unfortunately, the condition seems to have returned - though I'm doubting if it's a problem with parasites after all. Around the first white band (about the gills) are what look like scales flaking off/small scars and the final band, around the tail, has gone a dark grey. The second fish now seems to be developing a grey band yet both fish are very lively and are showing no signs of distress (scratching, laboured breathing, listing etc). Please could you enlighten me as to possible causes of said discoloration and markings? <Some clowns will darken with age or in response to your lighting. As long as you are not seeing open wounds or signs/symptoms of disease I would not be alarmed.> Many thanks, Steve Morse. <Travis> 

Please help - clownfish is not doing well.... 11-27-05 First, I would like to thank you and your colleagues for putting together such a comprehensive and useful tool. I have recently entered the hobby and have spent countless hours on your site. I have an emergency and will try to give you all of the relevant info as concisely as possible. I am posting this in the emergency post board as well as sending it. MY EMERGENCY: my wild perc. (in QT) is gasping at the top of the tank and neither he nor his mate will eat anything! (please read below for details) Main Tank Set: I set up a marine tank 3 months ago.  Equipment: 30 gal display tank (3ft, 1.5ft, .75ft) with 15 gal sump, 40lbs+ live rock, RO water, auto RO top-up, Deltec MHE600 skimmer (rated to 700ltrs), two Hagen 802 powerheads (1500lph each), Eheim 1262 return pump (2,000gph but turned down) and two small heaters (one as a back-up).  Lighting: 4x39w VHO T5 14k and 1 Blue T8 about 2 inches above the water surface (very close fitting hood).  Water has always been tested for Ammonia, Nitrite, Phosphate, PH, calcium, and specific gravity. For the last 1 and half months, testing occurs every few days (temp several times and spec. g once daily) and Ammonia, Nitrate and phosphate have never been detectable, ph steady at 7.9-8.0, specific gravity .0021-.0022. Temp is a steady 76-78. I change 15 - 25% of the water every week and a half or so. Inhabitants: All relatively new. One and a half months ago, an urchin, some blue legs and some snails.  Five weeks ago, two wild percula clowns (read the problems below).  In the last four weeks, three Banggai cardinals, a flame hawkfish (great fish, star of the tank, very healthy, but never again will I impulse buy. I should have waited), skunk, shrimp, blood shrimp. Everything looks great and eats well, except my clownfish. I have a (presently) controlled hair algae problem, it think because of the extreme lighting and no consumers (I am trying to get hold of some 'super grazer' snails that apparently eat it. Any other advice on this not urgent topic would be appreciated.) My problem (emergency!): the original two wild percula clowns were the first residents of my tank (wild because of a perceived greater likelihood they take to an anemone. The anemone is what I am really after, hence lighting and water flow above.) The larger was about 1.5 in., the smaller less than an inch. Both were somewhat tentative in the new tank and after a few days were eating (though not voraciously, like the cardinals or the hawkfish, initially a lot of suck in, spit out). They stayed in their own small turf, bobbing up and down.  After about 10 days, the smaller of the two was dead in the morning. He appeared very thin, though he was eating. I called several LFS and they said he was small, it happens. Fair enough. I got a replacement wild perc., again smaller than the survivor (just over an inch). These two immediately got on well and were more interactive and adventuresome than the pair had been before. Again, eating no problem.   This Tuesday the trouble continued. In the morning, the larger clown (survivor of the first pair) was laying on the live rock/substrate, gasping and not really upright. With some prompting, she started swimming for a while, but then went back down. I immediately (yes I have a job, but pushed some meetings back) went the LFS and bought a QT (I know, I know I should have had one already) and went home and set it up. 5gal tank (Note: I live in London in a small apartment and my girlfriend would kill me if it was bigger) with 70% water from the main tank, 30% 'new' but aged water, a piece of live rock from the sump, a small heater and a air pump-driven sponge filter .  I scoured your website and determined that they must have an intestinal parasite. No visible symptoms except long, stringy feces that seem to stay attached for a few days. I though this was normal for clowns because every one of mine had it. Armed with this info I called a knowledgeable LFS who had seen the problem before and recommended an emergency ph/temp adjusted freshwater dip in Acriflavine for the sick one and QT with a course of Sterazin for both. The sicker clown was dipped for 5 minutes and survived only a short while longer in QT. I was determined not to lose the only remaining clown that had, to date, exhibited the same stringy feces but otherwise looked happy and healthy.  Once he was on his own in the QT, he looked very stressed and seemed to be searching for something. I (probably incorrectly) decided to get him a mate, pair them up in QT and re-introduce them into the main tank together after he recovered. I ph/temp adjusted freshwater/Meth. blue dipped the new clown for three minutes. She paired right off with my incumbent clown and he seemed much less stressed. They then proceeded to eat a little bit of frozen Mysis. Since then I have been treating them with Sterazin, changing 50% of the water with water from the main tank every other day and trying to get them to feed. He passed some long (2.5 in.) translucent, stringy stuff from his anus (worms?). <<Holy cow!  But, stringy feces can be a sign only of internal parasitic infection, also a sign of infection by other microbes.  MH>> All the water parameters are good (same as main tank, including temp). He is now gasping at the top of the tank and she is lethargically resting on the bottom (but upright) and neither will eat. She has exhibited none of the 'stringy stool', yet. I am tempted to abandon the QT and medication and reintroduce the clowns to the main tank, but I know this can't be good. Please help me save my clowns!!  <Alan, it sounds to me that your clowns are suffering from Brook. DO a search on our site for Brook aka. Clownfish disease. You will find a wealth of information on that disease and its treatment. Until the brook is cleared don't worry about the internal parasites. Travis> Many thanks in advance. Sincerely,  Alan 

Blackening ocellaris, the pH Kit is Acting Strange!  11/22/05 Dear Crew, <Peter> First, thanks for maintaining WWM. It's a wonderful resource. <Welcome> Background: On October 25 of this year, my girlfriend purchased a 20-gallon marine system. We both have had success in freshwater, but are new to salt. The seller said the tank had been running for a year or so. He hadn't been doing water changes and the tank's light had burned out and gone unreplaced.  The tank was running a hang-on Whisper power filter. The tank contained a ton of various algae, a two-inch layer of white sand, around 20 lbs. of live rock, a blue damsel, and an ocellaris clown (both looking healthy in spite of awful conditions). November 7, girlfriend added 2 more pounds of live sand, 4 more pounds cured live rock, and a 1/4" blue-legged hermit crab, which died/disappeared within a week. <Likely "used to" very dissimilar water quality...> Situation: My girlfriend has since replaced the light fixture with a two-bulb Coralife fixture, running one 10k bulb and one actinic, with little blue nightlights. She has added a BakPak CPR skimmer (with a pre-skimmer and without the Bio-bale media) which yields a cup of thin, dark skimmate every two days. <A lot of gunk for such a small system, eh?> She has also added a 125 gph powerhead for circulation. Test results: ammonia undetectable; between 0 and 0.1 nitrite ; 2.5 phosphate; between 75-110 mg/L nitrate (!). <!!!> The pH kit is acting strange, girl suspects it has been climbing, 8.5 - 8.7. Alkalinity 190-20 mg/L. Salinity had been at 1.018 and girlfriend has been slowly raising it over this month because she'd like to keep inverts eventually -- it now stands steady at 1.022.  Added 0.5 L Kalkwasser over 12 hours, couple tablespoons at a time, five days ago. Regimen of 20 percent water changes every 5-7 days since acquisition. Live rock is displaying Aiptasia and some little animals. Algae is still an issue (due to phosphates I think girlfriend said). Water change using distilled, treated with Prime water conditioner.  Problem: The clown is changing color on the top 1/3 of his body, from head to tail. It's as if he has a suntan -- it's an even darkening of his color, except for the white stripes, which remain white. He is turning black. The fish breathes, eats, and swims normally. He is sufficiently aware to dart for cover when I attempt to photograph his odd condition. This first appeared a week ago and his darkening is intensifying slowly but gradually.  I have read elsewhere on WWM that many clowns change color as they age, but I have never read about a blackening ocellaris. Any thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks. -- Peter <Is "stress coloration"... too much change going on too quickly to suit this fish. I would hold off, not use Kalk in this size, type system... rely on water changes, vacuuming to improve water quality for a few months... Bob Fenner> 

Clown with cracked fins  11/17/05 I have a saltwater tank that is established with healthy fish for over a year. Since the fish are reef friendly, I decided to slowly introduce some invertebrates. I placed a long tip anemone in the tank a little over a week ago. My maroon clown hosted immediately. He appeared to be a little rough with the anemone but QUITE happy. In any event, the anemone declined quickly and is dead or at least very close. <Not uncommon> My question has to do with the maroon clown who appeared to have developed some white fuzz at the tips of his bottom fins. He also began to swish his body in the sand upon occasion. Now, the white fuzz appears to be gone from the fins but his lower and rear fins are split / cracked.  What should I do? <Mmm, not much... if anything... out of the ordinary. Should heal in time> Could this have been from the anemone? <Yes, likely related> Is there anything I can treat the water with? The only other things in the tank are a couple of gobies, a Pseudochromis, a Kole tang and some xenia.  Thanks in advance, Frank <Optimized, stable water conditions, decent nutrition... Bob Fenner> 

Clown Fish Problem  11/15/05 My Clownfish is struggling for air, seems bloated and his eyes are bulging - he won't eat and this is entirely unusual for him. I tested the water and everything is well within limits and the other 3 fish are fine, fine, fine. I have read about the Epsom salts thing, but I am not sure if this is the answer for my Charlie Brown (aka Clownfish). I cannot QT him because I really don't have the resources. What else can I do to help him? <I would try treating the fish in situ, with Epsom Salt. Please read here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/clndisfaqs.htm and the linked (further) Clownfish Disease FAQs files. Bob Fenner> 

Got Man/Woman Trouble?  Nope, Clownfish Trouble  11/10/05 Dear Mr. Fenner, <Yes?> Two days ago I noticed a super small white something or other around the right gill area of my ocellaris. It is still there. However, yesterday I noticed a small baby pea size area of barely white (like bruised scales) on the ocellaris' body between the first white bar and the tail bar. I've also noticed both ocellaris swimming in and out of two caves and thought maybe the white patch? on its body could be scraped scales (actually hard to see unless you really concentrate). <Possibly... or the origin thereof> These ocellaris' are tank raised. Funny thing is, this ocellaris was not very active, sometimes hardly getting "enough" food in my opinion. Now, he (smaller of the two ocellaris) is very active, swimming around the tank more, and really going for its share of food! I've read through the FAQs and can't decide on my ocellaris' problem, hence not knowing what action to take. No velvety look, no white/ick spots, no Popeye.  The other ocellaris is doing fine, swimming and eating. I've had these two ocellaris now for 2 years with no problems. Other inhabitants of the tank are: l half-dollar size Regal Tang, 2 Chromis, 1 diamond goby, 1 small long nose hawkfish, 1 cleaner shrimp and 2 RBTA (originally l and then a split :) ). All the other inhabitants seem to be doing well.  <Yes...> Tank readings: 77.5 deg., dKH 10.2, Alk. 3.66, CA 410, SG 1.026, pH 8.0/8.1. Water change every week to week-and-a-half 12 to 15 gals. for a 55 gal. tank. CPR Bak Pak Reef ready skimming tank along with EHEIM 2215 filtering the tank. Am worried about my ocellaris and would like to take whatever action necessary to head off anything serious. Thank you for your time and looking forward to your help/advice.  Marilyn <Gauging from your stated conditions, types of livestock, the history... I would just try bolstering the immune system of the fish (and all else), by administering vitamins to the water and food... the former once a week, the latter daily. Bob Fenner> 

WHY IS THIS HAPPENING!!!!!!???? Clownfish disease  11/9/05 I DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS!!!!!!  My BRAND SPANKIN NEW Clowns have once again, stupid white specs on their dorsal fins (along clear part).  I don't get why this keeps happening. I am treating the entire tank with Kordon's Ick Attack because I have heard many success stories with it.  <<Cannot find what is in this stuff, but they sell as a "cure-all", am incredulous with all such products whose  manufacturers make such claims.  MH>> Plus, the Clowns are still active and eating and I don't want to further stress them with catching, copper etc.... Any input is greatly appreciated Thanks! Jon <Mmm, these spots could be "nothing"... if other fishes appear unaffected, infested, I wouldn't panic, treat with anything. Bob Fenner> 
Re: WHY IS THIS HAPPENING!!!!!!????  11/9/05 Thanks Bob! So do you think that I should just do a water change and put my carbon back in? Leave it alone. <Yes. This is what I would do> The Royal Gramma appears to be fine, but then again I can't always get a good look at it.  My last clowns got the same issue and they are dead. The Ich attack says it will not affect animals unaffected and that it can clear, fungus, flagellates (sp), and other infections as well.  <Mmm, I don't know how such a thing is possible...> I just don't want to have to deal with another two clown deaths here. That would mean 6 clowns. Yea, its sick. Thanks for any help. Jonathan <Are these clownfish tank-bred? You might want to look around for another source. Cheers, Bob Fenner> 
Re: WHY IS THIS HAPPENING!!!!!!????  11/9/05 Yes sir. Tank bred. I have bought each pair at a different, reputable dealer. Obviously its something I am doing wrong. <Mmm, not necessarily Jon. Many difficulties "show up later" that are of little cause of purchasers... for instance "chilled" livestock... that has been subjected to cold may look fine for a several days to weeks, but can be doomed no matter what you do.> Thanks for your help! Jon <Welcome. Bob Fenner> 
Re: WHY IS THIS HAPPENING!!!!!!????  11/9/05 I suppose. By the way, I just picked up your book. Great read. Best one I have read yet!  -Jon <Glad you are enjoying, gaining by it. BobF> 
Big Oops! Reading time!  11/9/05 Ok, Its Ich. My Gramma has it now, so what course of action do you think I should take. I just put carbon back in the filter and did a water change. This just keeps happening so I really don't know what to do. I only have a 10 gallon tank which could be used as a QT and I don't know how suitable that it. I would have to get a sponge filter too. <... Uhhhhh> This is getting so stressful. I cannot believe that I did not QT the Gramma. AHHHHH Never again will I do that. What if I treat all the fish with Clout. I'm just terrified to use copper. <<I'd be more inclined to use copper rather than Clout, that is strong stuff.  How about hyposalinity here?  Marina>> <Take a few deep breaths... a few more...> Thanks so much for your help in my mistakes. I am a stubborn SW novice. -Jon <Well... be an informed stubborn SW novice. Read on WWM re ich/Cryptocaryon, its treatment... Bob Fenner> 
What Do You Recommend?  11/9/05 Would you recommend the Medication, Clout?? Thanks! -Jon <I recommend reading> 
Hello!  Read, Read, Read, Because It's all Here!  11/9/05 Hey, Earlier I inquired about using Clout to treat Ich because I really prefer not to use copper.  The Ingredients in Clout are Phenylbenzylindene, dimethyl, phosphonate, methylnitro and inert ingredients as non-toxic binders. What do you think??? Now, I know this is a stupid question but I should not just remove my crabs and starfish and treat the whole tank because It will kill my Live rock and Sand, Right? Or pose other problems in the long run? Thanks!
Jon
<Read> 

Bloated Clown 11/6/05 Hi, <Hello there> Am a new convert to marine aquariums and find your site a great help and a terrific resource. <Ah, good> I have a problem with one of two Percula clowns that I have had for 3-4 months now.  The clowns were purchased as a same size pair and have grown at different rates until one is now twice the size of the other (as they do).  <Yes> All has been well in the tank until about 4 6 weeks ago when I noticed the belly of the smaller clown started to become bloated in appearance. I initially thought it was a pregnant female until I researched some and found that the smaller fish is usually the male! <Yes> Since the discovery the clowns belly has got more extended on both sides of its body, to such an extent that he looks very, very pregnant or about to burst!  The clown appears perfectly normal (apart from the pot belly), eats, swims and behaves as normally as one would expect. Have some concerns for his future tho.  Any thoughts? <Perhaps some type of gut blockage... I would try feeding foods with laxative effect, most esp. Brine Shrimp/Artemia, and add a level teaspoon of Epsom Salt per five gallons of system water... to "loosen things up". If this doesn't do it, there may be an internal parasitic problem... calling for successive treatments with an anti-protozoal (my choice Metronidazole) and a vermifuge... Praziquantel, or? These are covered on WWM. Bob Fenner> 

Clown fish with red bulging eye 11/6/05 I've searched the site and can't seem to find a similar case. I have a pair of true perculas that have been in my 90 gallon reef tank for over a year. The female's left eye has all of a sudden turned red and begun to bulge She doesn't seem to be eating either. Any ideas as to what it could be from or if I need to quarantine her? Any ideas greatly appreciated. Thanks. <Is likely "unilateral exophthalmia" as a description... and likely due (originally) to a physical trauma (bumping into something)> P.S. Now it seems that my other fish (presumably my tangs) have started picking on her. She has some bites out of her tail and fin. <Please read here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/popeyefaqs.htm and #2 linked file above. Bob Fenner>

Ailing percula, Paying Attention to the FAQs - 11/4/05 Our male percula is not doing well. We noticed a developing problem about four weeks ago when it looked as if there was a small pebble under the skin on his forehead. The size of it would vary a bit over the coarse of the day. We wrote you about it then and followed your advice to just watch and wait and see what happened with this 'head bump'. He also seems to have a rapid breathing rate--mouth open, gills pumping away. <Evidence of something amiss in the environment... is your water quality near sea water? E.g. spg?> Until three days ago he would eagerly approach food but would actually eat only one or two minute pieces of plankton or Mysis. Swallowing seems difficult or something. Now he isn't eating at all or showing interest in the food. The area behind where the bump was, just near his dorsal fin, has now opened up and he seems really weak, too.  He seems to use his anemone to support him most of the day and yesterday began hosting in a different anemone on the sand bed and actually laying on his side for a few moments every now and then before returning to his regular home.  We gave him one freshwater/Methylene blue dip a week ago, but didn't notice any marked improvement. Perhaps we should have repeated the dip? <For what reason/s?> Tonight we did a saltwater and antibiotic dip for 10 minutes and I gather from WWM sites that we should repeat that at least daily. Is that correct? <... Why?> Can you suggest any ways to get nutrients into this ailing fish while we try to help him heal? <Perhaps vitamin supplementation, addition to the food, water> Our water parameters are good, SG 1.025, and the rest of our tank stock seems healthy. We have a skimmer and sump set-up. We are fighting Cyano with frequent water changes, increased circulation and careful feeding.  <An indication of varying, poor water quality...> It's a 75 gallon tank with about 70 pounds of live rock; button polyps; <Can be toxic> 3 various mushroom rocks; 2 Ricordea; a frog spawn coral; a Condylactis and a Macrodactyla. (We now understand it was not wise to get these different anemones. <Correct... their chemical interaction (war) is also a factor here> Fortunately, they have chosen homes far from each other and seem very happy/healthy.) <They still "reach" each other through the water...> We also have a clean up crew: 10 hermit crabs, a couple of snails; a cleaner shrimp. Perhaps this is more than you needed to know. I so appreciate any advice you can offer for helping our percula. He really seems to be suffering...... Thanks in advance. What a blessing your knowledge and dedication is to us trying to establish our own little piece of ocean in the middle of Iowa! Kathy PS I checked out the 'format' button on my email and switched this from 'html' to 'plain text' just for you. That ought to show you I'm reading my daily FAQs! <<OH, THANK YOU!!! (I could kiss you, Kathy.)  Marina>> <Appreciated. A bunch to related, most of which I've barely hinted at above... you might try chemical filtrants (e.g. Polyfilter, activated carbon) in your filter flow path to remove nutrient, some of the reactant products of your cnidarian mis-mix... Bob Fenner> 

Re: ailing percula 2 11/6/05 Dear FAQ Crew, Thanks for your prompt response to my question.  I see I left out some really important details from my first query: We did the Methylene blue & freshwater dip because the bump on the percula's head got 'fuzzy' and we decided from WWM reading that this treatment was appropriate. <I see> He did begin to eat a bit after the dip, but because we saw no improvement in the bump we didn't repeat the dip thinking the stress of being netted and dipped maybe did more harm than good. <You are wise here> In hindsight perhaps we should have repeated the dip---that he started eating again was a big improvement.  When the wound broke open into a 1/8" round pit a few weeks later the edges of it were 'fuzzy' and by this week his eyes were beginning to bulge and one was a bit cloudy. We thought this was a clear indication of bacterial issues and so did the antibiotic & saltwater dip. <... hard to state/reason what the origin of this "bump" might be... but not likely pathogenic... that is, induced by an infectious or parasitic organism directly> I am sad to report the percula died this morning, but so thankful for your input on water quality and the chemical warfare (cw) likely going on in our tank. I read an article on WWM about cw but foolishly thought that as long as things looked good/healthy that it wasn't an issue in our tank. <Would like to (re) make a statement here re... Most all life in the wild "looks good" till about the "last moment"... masking illness, susceptibility to predation... lest it become a meal or displaced.> We will look for a good home for one of our anemones as well as the button polyps, and pursue the other courses of action to improve our water quality. <Ah, good> Just so you know, thanks to WWM, we are now practicing a basic marine husbandry tenet that so many of us newbies seem to miss: research before you buy AND have a long term plan for stocking--not piecemeal.  <Excellent!> We, and numerous creatures in LFS's everywhere, thank you for being so good at what you do! Kathy <Thank you. Bob Fenner> 

Constipated Clown? or bigger Issue 10/29/05 Hello All, <Amy> I'm fully prepared to ensure that she's protected when/if she returns to the main display and I'll buy another setup for my puffer.  I'm wondering if you might be able to help. Please bare with me, it's a long story. I've used the site as a reference for years, and most recently when my beloved clown started to get ill.  I have a 4 year old clown who about 2 weeks ago that came down with what looked like Brooklynella. <Out of the proverbial blue? Odd> I noticed she was acting strangely and promptly removed her from my main display tank. I knew she'd need to go into  Quarantine and decided to give her a fresh water dip according to the specifications on your site. When moving her from the main tank to the dip I noticed there were some bubbles on her right side near her tail and her breathing laboured. One of her tank mates (puffer) had bitten her tail a bit when she fell ill. So I was also trying to have that wound heal at the same time. I'm fully prepared to ensure that she's protected when/if she returns to the main display and I'll buy  another setup for my puffer. I combed through the site (and Bob's book) and I felt that it was either Brooklynella or marine velvet. After a few days of dips with no improvement and her breathing growing more laboured I decided to add formalin to the dip but not to the quarantine tank. <Good> I followed the instructions and within about 3-4 days she was looking a bit brighter but now wasn't swimming normally. She was swimming almost vertically (I felt something was off with her swim bladder but as long as she was looking comfortable and eating that we'd get through it) I was/am fine with having her that way as long as she appears bright and comfortable. Of course after all this time (4 days at this point) I was most concerned that with her not eating she'd starve to death before I could cure the Brooklynella or whatever was causing the issues.  I soaked some shrimp in Kent vitamin mix and fed her with an eyedropper. She ate! and she would eat every day since.  I stopped using the formalin as soon as there was improvement as I'm not crazy about using it in the first place. <Very toxic> There have been some very dark days with this clown during the past 2 weeks and she's been through a lot in her life and she actually has survived my ex's tank splitting at the seams. So I am fighting like crazy for her, and so is she. She still makes eye contact with me, and tries to visit with me and with the eating I know she's got some type of appetite. After about 5 days in quarantine I noticed that it looked like she had some bruising under the skin. She still wasn't swimming normally and now that I was finished with the formalin and her breathing was back to normal I wanted to treat her with antibiotics to fight any infection with the tail and also in case the bruising was hemorrhagic septicemia.  I decided to use Furan-2 in quarantine and followed the directions for a full course of treatment another 4-5 days. She  started to look brighter and I felt that we'd turned a corner. Her breathing had improved, she was eating, her tail was healing, the bruised areas seemed to improve -but still not swimming properly. I saw some excrement early on, it was whitish and I know that's not good and can be a sign of internal parasite but that was 5 days ago. I haven't seen any excrement since (but if could be caught in the filter, etc. I have been looking but haven't found anything). Now that all medication was being removed from the water I added some Epsom to see if I could try to have her to have a bowel movement.  She's still not swimming normally (she is in a u shape with head and tail pointed down) she has been very bright up until the past 24-36 hours. She is no longer eating regularly (she had a bit to eat tonight, still the vitamin soaked shrimp) and now has a swollen/bulge area on her side (the side that's pointing up) around that bulge there's a bit of bruising that's appeared (again in the past 24 hours) I don't know what to do.  Do you have any recommendations, do you think it's constipation? <Very likely just the side-effect of exposure to medicines> or should I continue medicating with Furan for another course? <I would not> I don't want to drag out her life if she's not comfortable and I have been prepared throughout the past two weeks to euthanizing her (with clove oil) but every time she seems to pull through. I'm prepared to do whatever it takes, even it if means we hit the end of the line and I have to euthanize her. I just want for her to be comfortable. <Mmm, I would just "leave this animal alone" at this point... and hope that it recovers of its own accord> The levels in her quarantine are zeroed out across the board. I've obviously made every attempt possible to make the water quality as pristine as possible to assist in her recovery. I just don't know what to do. Should I massage her with a gentle gloved hand? <No> is there any other recommendation you may have? <None> Have you heard of this before? is there another course of treatment you'd recommend? <Don't know what the root cause/s were here, don't favor guessing even with photographs> I don't want to give up on her, and want to ensure I've tried everything. Any help would be amazing. You guys are always so wonderful and always seem to manage to make me feel that I'm at least trying to do the right things. Thanks in advance, Amy <At this juncture, the fish will either recover or not. I believe you have done your best. Bob Fenner