2 dead Ceylons – perhaps salinity too low
5/19/07
Stats: Ph-7.5 Ammonia-0 Nitrite-0 Nitrate-20
Hi, I recently hooked up a three stage coral life RO filter and a 42
gallon metal storage tank for drinking water. All of the fittings are
plastic and drinkable water friendly PVC lines. I used this water after
flushing 15 gals through the filters and membrane and tank.
<15 gallons of water to flush a 42 gallons tank is not much. I had a
comparable little metal storage container made for drinking water (army
related product). The water didn’t loose a certain metal taste even
after months. Although they may be fine for humans, they possibly are
not safe for sensitive fish, at least the water from my container was
never used for the fish tanks.>
I changed about 10 gal in my 55 gallon freshwater tank with a 1/8 tsp
(if that much) of reef buffer (because my previous tap water had a pH of
8.0) and two of my fat and healthy puffers (Ceylon, aka Tetraodon
fluviatilis) died the next day. The other one that's still alive has
patches of his skin that are coming off! Please see attached picture.
All other puffers - 5 of them, different species and cichlids are fine.
<8 puffers (3 Ceylons and 5 others) and cichlids in a 55 gallons sounds
a little overcrowded.>
I am figuring that it is either the metal storage tank, not flushing the
RO system enough or the reef buffer.
<I’d carefully exclude the reef buffer. Most likely the storage tank or
possibly another reason not related to your new installations.>
I did about a 30 gallon water change in desperation with my tried and
true tap water (with conditioner of course) that has never caused me
problems (not like this anyway). I typically keep my ph anywhere from
7.3-7.5. I tested the pH last night and it was 7.5.
<Carry on doing water changes to remove any possible toxic
compounds/ions.>
I really hope I didn't kill my puffers with the reef buffer (please
don't yell at me) <never would.>, but I had no other means to raise the
pH and feared that I would shock the fish by adding water with a ph
of 7.0. I also added two tbsp of salt (like I always do).
<Ceylon puffers will only be hardy in water with a SG of at least 1.005.
2 tbsp of salt per 30 gallons will hardly give the water a salty taste.
I’d suppose your puffers died, because they were in fresh water too long
and could not deal with maybe minimal changes in water chemistry they’d
have no problem with in brackish water. Separate your last survivor to
another tank with a SG of about 1.005. If you need to cycle it fast, you
may want to use BioSpira or old filter material from a brackish tank
with similar SG. See
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/cav1i1/green_spotted_puppies.htm. Care
for your puffers is the same.>
I have two other fish tanks and now I am afraid to use the RO.
<The RO should be safe. I’d flush the metal canister again. If the water
in the storage canister has a metal taste or if any other fish die, when
you use this water, exchange it.>
Any advice would be appreciated. Thank you for your site, it has helped
me a great deal in the past, I have always been able to find the info I
was looking for, this is the first time I ever needed to write you. I am
so sad. Please help me. –Kimberly.
<Glad you like the site. Good luck. Marco.> |
|
An Mbuna African Cichlid in upper left... RMF |
Swollen Puffer 4/16/07
Hi,
<Hello, Pufferpunk here>
I have a leopard puffer named Pettie (that might need to be changed) who's
stomach is very "puffed". I have had him for about 2 weeks & now all of a
sudden, Pettie's belly has grown! How can I find out if he is & what to do next?
Thanks so much!
<It could be a couple of things. An overfed puffer's stomach can stretch quite
large. Or it could be puffed with air. Can it swim normally? See this article
about air-filled puffers:
http://www.thepufferforum.com/forum/library/hospital/help-my-puffer-is-air-filled/
There are many good articles on caring for your puffer at that site. ~PP>
Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer
Thu, 17 Mar
Hi all, I know I'm Pufferpunk & should have all the puffer answers, but my own green spotted puffer (T nigriviridis) has stumped me. I keep his water
pristine (50% weekly water changes) & none of his puffer/non-puffer tank mates are sick. I can't imagine what has compromised his immune system like
this. His eyes are so cloudy, he's practically blind & his fins are fraying. He looks as if he's interested in food, but can't find it, cause
he's blind. The other 2 puffers have rallied around him & the damsels keep going over as if to say, "Are you ok?" Any advice here? I'm treating with
Melafix & water changes right now. I do not have a extra tank large enough to quarantine him--he's 6".
~Jeni
<Does sound like a deficiency syndrome... have you tried force-feeding this fish? I would... Is the lighting very bright over this tank? Bob F>
Re: Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer
Bob, It's only been a few days & he is already quite plump, so I don't think
force feeding is necessary as of yet. I found an old response in my puffer forum about cloudy eye in a porcpuff, from Leslie:
"It could be a bacterial or fungal infection. It's hard to say. I have a friend who has been using 7cc of 3% Hydrogen Peroxide
(H202) in 1 liter of clean tank water for an 11 minute dip. He swears by it and has been using it for
25 years."
Are you familiar with this? I still can't account for the frayed fins. This is very strange. What would cause a fish's immune system to crash like
that? ~Jeni
<Is it both eyes affected? And only one fish... Is strange... the dip idea is a good one... relatively safe and effective... I would super-dose the
system with a HUFA/Vitamin mix as well. Bob F>
Re: Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer
Ok, he's in the peroxide dip right now, since I already have that in the house. Does peroxide have a shelf life?
<It does... particularly if it's been opened...>
It's pretty old. How often should I be doing this? Should I leave him in there longer than 11 minutes?
~Jeni
<No more than this time. BobF>
Anthony's Take on Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer and MelaFix
I really think Melafix and many other such homeopathic treatments are at best "stimulating", but really
touted way too much as "cures" for a wide range of ailments. I suspect a search of the archives will
reveal far more queries in frustration that the tea oil did not cure Ich, balding, jock itch and
everything else they claim this product treats. I do believe it has some efficacy... but claiming (as they
did at least at first) that it treats bacteria AND parasites AND X other things... is... well... hard to
believe. And apparently hard to quantify. Requests for data to back it up have been ignored. Ahh... the pet
industry.
Hmmm... point of this rant: I would not use such tea oils as a first course of action with expressed
pathogenic symptoms. Rather... save your Melafix for QT on arrival as a "preventative". It worries me to so
many people opt this way first instead of using proven medications :( The time lost is often at the cost of
fishes lives.
Lest there be any doubt of my perspective, I'm friends with an Aqua Pharm rep... and got gallons of the
product to try when it first came out. Used them when I was wholesaling a few hundred to one thousand+ fish
each week. I used it weekly for the better part of a year before giving up. It seemed to
mildly help some maladies... but really did not live up to the claims at the time. FWIW
My advice... get this fish into bare-bottomed isolation. Use the standard Nitrofurazone/Furazolidone
cocktail for at least 5 days (follow mfg dosage). Add B12 to the food if the fish is
eating... or to the water if not (appetitive stimulant, proven ;)). If you want to continue Melafix. No worries... all good. For other
homeopathic meds: garlic and beta glucan (for parasites and immunity boosting respectively).
If parasites are indicated at any point... formalin and malachite watched closely (short baths or in the
QT tank).
Best of luck! Anthony <Marina's note: It didn't help my dandruff,
either!>
Re: Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer - Don't Use Ten Year Old H2O2
Since that peroxide solution is probably 10 years old (or older) & has been opened for
that long, I think I should do it again. How often should I do this--several times/day, daily? ~J
<Once should do it. B>
Michael Maddox's Opinion on the Puffer
From personal experience, I will have to agree regarding the anti-biotic treatment. As much as I am against
indiscriminate use of these medications, cloudy eyes\frayed fins usually indicated a bacterial infection, as well as
the possibility of abuse by tankmates. We like to attribute human characteristics to animals, but puffers are NOT each others' friends, and I
know from first hand accounts they will kick each other while they're down, every single time. Please isolate him ASAP, before another puffer decides
to make him into a chew toy! (learned this the hard way, 9 years ago ^ ^). Good luck! Let us know how he\she fares.
M. Maddox
Quick Update on Pufferpunk's Puffer
Conveyed this morning: after the H202
dip (with fresh H202) the puffer's eyes are noticeably clearer.
Justin's Suggestions for Pufferpunk's Sick Puffer
Well if you cannot get this guy into another tank, do you have access to any large Rubbermaid
containers? That will do for a q/t as well. But get him out of the main tank.
Anyway please q/t this guy for several reasons, one I don’t think its tank mates are saying hello, as other
puffers and damsels are notorious for picking on the weak and sickly, especially at night. Also you need
to get an antibiotic in the water ASAP not tea oil anymore. I use Fungus
Eliminator by Jungle Products since it has two antibiotics, Nitrofurazone and Furazolidone. Which should help its general well
being. If you truly cannot treat outside its tank this can be added into the display without staining or
killing off the bacteria cycle...
Also that tea oil is probably doing more harm than good right now, as it irritates the fish to force them
to heal, and that might be creating more of a problem then the puffer can handle. If you must use
MelaFix in the q/t you can but do be very watchful.
Also go buy a marine predator pack of frozen food cubes. These have shrimp, clams and other foods in it
as well as having a very appetizing smell for the GSP (mine finds it seconds after it hits the water, even
if its hidden behind power heads etc as it floats) if it wont eat this should help it to and it will keep
the teeth down as well.
Hope it does ok, and gets back to normal. I am sending you another email with other info enclosed
solely for you as well on this. <Justin (Jager)>
Ill Puffer 2/13/04
Dear WWM-crew,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
We have a green spotted puffer, about two inches long; he's now been with us for about three months. Today, we noticed that he has brownish-red string-like
things coming out of his gills on both sides (on his left side you can barely see them, but on the right side, one string is protruding about 2mm.) He also isn't his
old self--he swims slowly, seems to be breathing quickly, and has done strange things like get himself stuck on the filter pump. He also seems bonier and
skinnier than usual. His coloration has also darkened considerably to gray on the sides and around his mouth. Read everything we could online, but there's
nothing on these strange gill strings.
<It sounds like your puffer is suffering from internal parasites. Try to find some Discomed, by Aquatronics. Although that company has gone out of business,
there is plenty to be found on the internet. You will need to treat it's food with the med. Since it is also in it's gills, I'd try Parasite Clear, by Jungle. You can also
add a garlic remedy, like Garlic Guard, or Garlic Extreme.>
Water quality, ammonia is fine. Specific gravity is 1.005. Please help!
--Kyle & Hannah
<Here's a great article on your puffer: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm I'd start raising the SG .002 weekly, until the tank is
around 1.010-1.012. I hope he makes it! ~PP>
Figure eight puffer fish question
Hello,
<How goes it? 70F outside today, bright and sunny...sometimes Texas does have it's moments...>
I recently purchased a figure eight puffer, he seems quite happy in his tank and has eaten some water snails. Most of the time he seems happy swimming up and down but every now and then he lies flat in the water (he's tricked me into thinking he was dead once) and morning I found him in his tank with his tail bent round his side. Is this a sign of him being unhappy or ill?
<Not usually, puffers often wrap their tail around themselves, especially when sleepy. Remember, puffers require brackish water (SG of ~1.012 or so is the SG I kept my puffer tanks> lots of variety in their diet (anything meaty works for them, snails are definitely the best staple) tankmates they won't kill, and frequent water changes
because they're messy. Here's a link for some further reading: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/cav1i1/green_spotted_puppies.htm Enjoy your puffer - they're cute and fun!>
Thanks in advance for your reply, Sabine
<You're welcome>
<M. Maddox>
Sick GSP? 1/26/04
HI,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
My green spotted puffer has recently gotten sick. I have no idea what is wrong with him. His eyes are black like when he is sleeping, but before they were it looked as if he had hemorrhages above them. He is hardly eating, his stomach has 2 stress lines from his eyes to his tail, he is hiding, and it seems as if he only uses one gill at a time. He has no visible parasites, the water is fine (ammonia=0 nitrite=0 nitrate=0 and PH= 7.5), and he is the only fish in my tank, in which the salinity is at about 1.000.
<How was the tank cycled? 0 ammonia & nitrItes are great, but 0 nitrAtes makes me believe that the tank hasn't been cycled. Salinity (SG, or specific gravity, measured with a hydrometer) measuring at 1.000 is freshwater. There is not enough salt to register. Please read:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm
>
I have had him for about two weeks and he just ate three neon tetras that I added to see if they would get along.
<GSPs are not good with tankmates.>
The spots on his back are sometimes faded, but it doesn't look like he has mucus anywhere on his body. I also recently (4 days ago) added some algae remover to the tank, but nowhere on the box did it say that this medicine couldn’t be used for fish with no scales.
<Algae remover is a waste of $$$ & can be toxic to fish. I'd do a 50% water change & add fresh carbon to your filter. Get some marine salt & start raising the SG .002/week. If the tank hasn't been cycled, then all of this doesn't matter, because a puffer cannot live in an uncycled tank. Get your water tested again at your local fish store.>
Please help me WHAT IS WRONG WITH MY FISH (I am extremely frustrated). Thanks
<Make sure you read the article I linked you to. After reading that, you may find that keeping this exotic fish is more than you
bargained for... ~PP>
Lonely puffer 2/27/04
<Pufferpunk here again>
I have bad news. My little puffer has now passed. I am very upset. I took him out of the tank and dissected for the heck of it. It seemed as if he had some kind of blockage right before his anus. It looked like he had some small pieces of coral lodged in
there? I am not 100% sure though.
<That definitely is possible. Sorry for your loss.>
My other guy seems to be doing better, I am staying on top of my water changes and my SG is at 1.006. Since my little GSP died, the bigger guy seems lost w/o him. Is it possible that he is lonely? The figure 8's don't really interact with
him the way the Spotted puffer used to. Should I get another GSP?
<I'd still like to know the tank size & tankmates.>
By the way I just want to say THANK YOU for helping me, this site is awesome and I read all the postings every time I get a minute (which turns into hours..). I am learning
so much from this site. THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!
<You're very welcome, that's what were here for! ~PP>
Puffer Questions 1/22/04
Hi Crew,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I have a 120 gallon tank with two green spotted puffers and two figure eight's.
<Nice sized tank for just 4 puffers!>
My question is - One of my green spotted puffers ( 2.5 inches long) has a black ring on his belly. It is about the same size as one of his spots. It seems like the top part of the ring is a little thicker than the bottom part. It also becomes darker at certain times.
<It could possibly be a puffer bite, or just a stray spot. Some GSPs have belly spots.>
His waste is sometimes chunky brown pieces, I am not sure if this is normal or not?
<Normal puffer poo.>
Also one of my figure eights stays to himself, and doesn't interact as much with the rest of the three puffers. It seems like he ignores me most of the time when I go to the tank. While the others are begging for food constantly. I don't see anything attached to his skin or anything.
<Puffers can be moody creatures. Is he eating ok? Skinny? Is he bullied by the others?>
I keep the ph at 7.9-8.1. The nitrites and nitrates are good.
<PH is fine, ammonia & nitrItes should be 0 at all times, nitrAtes should be under 20. Is there marine salt in there? What's the SG (specific gravity, measured by a hydrometer)? I see a couple of problems with your fish combo. F8s prefer a low-end brackish water environment of a SG at around 1.005-1.008. GSPs prefer high-end BW & even marine levels as adults. Also, F8s are mild mannered puffers that grow to 3", while GSPs are extremely aggressive puffers that will grow to twice that size.>
I have an emperor 400 Bio wheel and a Magnum 350 canister for filters. He darts around a lot. It seems like something isn't right but maybe I am overreacting. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!!
<Answer my questions & we'll see if we can get to the bottom of this. ~PP>
Death of 2 puffers
hi there...
<Hello>
will be grateful if u could help enlighten me... I bought 2 green spotted
puffers... let's call em A and B... I put them in a fairly large aquarium round
4 to 5 feet wide kinds...A was pretty active when I brought it back, eating all
the bloodworms am feeding them... but B is kinda sluggish... and when tries to
eat something, A chases after it, so B gave up and I haven't seen it eating at
all for few days... and soon B develops this horrid brown black colour all over
it's body and start getting real skinny... after a few more days it died... I
tot it was some rivalry stuff with the 2 of em so I ignored A...is still eating
fine and pretty active until one day it refuses to eat and at the end of the day
it turn brown like B and died... I don't know what's the problem cuz at first I
thought it was the water ... I just use freshwater without adding salt) cuz some
sites says that puffers can survive in freshwater... so I tot B was weaker...
but then the active A sudden death just puzzles me... before they died they
don't seem to have any growth whatsoever on em and the color on their body
always fluctuates from yellow to brown patches... is it really hard to keep
puffers?... I heard they are hardy fish and the thing is my dad rear his other
tropical fishes in his tanks till the water turns green and they still seem to
be all right... thanks
<Yikes... very likely these "freshwater" Puffers were not so
"fresh"... Please take a read over the "Freshwater Puffers"
materials stored on our site: www.WetWebMedia.com and try to identify what type
you had... I suspect these two perished mainly for lack of the salts found in
their natural waters. Very common, and unfortunate. Bob Fenner>
Juvenile Green Puffer
I have two green spotted puffer, and two figure eight puffer's in a 30
gallon brackish aquarium. All have been living peacefully together (more or less
:) for a couple weeks now. My question; one of the green spotted puffers
developed a cloudy "film" over one eye last night while I slept. Do
you have any idea what this could be?
<A "sort of secondary" infection, likely bacterial,
stress-related... likely from the system being so new... crowded puffer-wise...
and likely will solve itself>
None of the other fish have any evidence of this, and the one fish with the
cloudy eye still seems to be swimming around healthy, and eating. Did he maybe
get in a fight? Or do you think he is sick? Thanks for your AWESOME site, and
priceless advice. Good-day!
<Maybe a fight, and not really so "sick" as in treatable for a
condition, agent. I'd just keep the system on an even keel and wait this out.
And you're welcome. Bob Fenner>
Pufferfish (brackish...)
Hi Bob,
Thank you so much for all the information on this website. We recently (3 weeks
ago) added a spotted green puffer fish to our established freshwater plant and
fish tank (30 gallons). He seems to be doing very well. We feed him living and
frozen brine shrimp. Just today, I noticed that he has two small white spots on
his one side. I'm very worried about this.
<Are they "symmetrical", as in evenly placed on both sides of the
body? If so, these may be nothing more than "tubercles"... natural
structural parts of the puffers body... Otherwise, you may have cause for
concern... as this isn't really a freshwater fish, as you likely know, but a
brackish animal... that likely has too different water quality requirements than
your plants, likely your fishes as well... As in a need for hard, alkaline water
with ionic/salt content: http://wetwebmedia.com/fwpuffers.htm
>
From looking over your site, I think I should feed him a more well rounded diet
(addition of blood worms?
<A good idea... a favorite food of this group, as are tubificid/black
worms>
I've tried dried plankton, he hates that), and maybe add some salt to our tank.
But we do have some plants and other fish, including Corydoras julii, Siamensis,
and albino shrimp, so I am worried about adding salt into the system.
<You should be... the Corydoras can take some salt, the shrimp, not
much...>
The fish store supposedly has acclimated their puffer fish to freshwater.
<Though they cannot live permanently in "very" freshwater... this
species migrates in/out of the sea...>
I really love this Pufferfish, so I am willing to do what it takes to keep him
healthy. Your help is greatly appreciated.
<In any length of time (months) this animal will need different water
conditions. I know this is hard to come to grips with... but I'd either trade it
back in, or place it in a different type of system... There are other brackish
livestock, including fishes, invertebrates and plants... but what you have
cannot practically be kept together. We can/should chat this over if it's not
clear. Your friend in fish, Bob Fenner>
Sincerely,
Carina Howell
Sick dwarf puffer
Hi, I have had a tank with 6 freshwater dwarf puffers (most about 1/2 inch)
in an eclipse system 6 (6 gallon w/ charcoal/BioWheel) for about half a year
now... everything has been great with no problems until the largest one (almost
1 inch long male) developed a white spot in the middle of his back about a week
ago. Since then, about 8-10 of these spots have slowly developed over his back
and head. These spots look larger than any ich spots that I have seen, these are
about 1mm in diameter and some have turned black. There isn't any noticeable
bump or depression in the skin, however.
<Good descriptions, not likely ich... perhaps not even infectious or
parasitic>
He has no other symptoms except that he has recently developed a very small
white spot on his fin and brown dot on his underside, he has also started to act
a bit disoriented and seems to be having a bit of trouble eating, though he
tries. I removed the filter and have tried a 5 day, full strength cycle of Quick
Cure (malachite green) as well as adding a little over a tablespoon of aquarium
salt.
<Good choices in therapy... about what I would have tried... in addition to
vitamin administration to the food, water>
I also raised the temperature from the normal 82 up to 85 and begun daily 20
percent water changes but to no avail. A couple of spots have recently begun
developing on a second puffer in the same progression (from the middle of the
back to the head).
Do you know what this could be and how I could treat it? Also, can I raise the
temperature and salinity any more?
<Could be a Microsporidium, sporozoan infestation... Worth taking a look at
scrapings of the area (even histological sections if you can secure help, do
this maybe through a local college...) to determine origins... I would stick to
what you're doing and add a complete aqueous vitamin and iodide mix to these
fish's foods daily and to the tank water weekly. Such preparations are made and
labeled for ornamental aquatics use by retailers, e-tailers. You might even try
(yes, this is a semi-endorsement) a "garlic" prep. in their food. Good
luck, life my friend. Bob Fenner>
Thanks,
Jeremy
Sick puffer
Hi,
I recently purchased a figure 8 puffer that's about an inch and a half long.
He's currently in a 10 gallon freshwater tank with 4 painted tetras and a ghost
shrimp. He occasionally chases the shrimp, but other than that he's left
everyone alone.
<So far... Please read: http://wetwebmedia.com/fwpuffers.htm>
The tank has an Aquaclear 150 filter filled with the sponge and Ammocarb in a
bag. The heater keeps the tank at about 78 - 79 degrees and the pH is about 7.3
. I leave the light on during the day (there's a Brazilian sword plant in the
tank). The tank has cycled and I've added 2 tablespoons of Aquarium Salt.
<This is one of the freshwater puffers...>
He was eating fine for about a week (fed freeze dried brine shrimp and live
blackworms twice a day) but today he refused all foods at both feedings (morning
and night). He looks thinner and seems weaker (hanging out on the bottom a lot).
Is he sick? Is there anything I can do? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks for your help,
Eric
<Your Puffer may well be sick... perhaps just not acclimated... I would try
offering it other foods, perhaps a bit of cut shrimp, squid or crab meat. Bob
Fenner>
Re: sick puffer
Thanks for the quick reply ... unfortunately I just flushed the little fella.
No idea what happened unless he wasn't well cared for at the pet store or maybe
couldn't acclimate to the new tank. Thanks anyway.
Eric
<I am hopeful that your apparently cavalier action and message here are
simply my (mis)interpretation. What did Pliny the elder write, "If a man
would be unkind to his parrot (and you with a psittacine e-nomen), then why not
his country...". Be chatting. Bob Fenner>
Lymph on FW Puffer
Great site. My figure eight puffer has Lymphocystis I believe.
<Very common>
They are large clear bumps on his underbelly. I've asked several aquatics stores
what to do, but they've offered little advice. Is there something you would
recommend to treat this ailment?
<If large enough, discrete... can be carefully pried off twixt thumb and a
finger nail... Salt of appropriate strength/use helps, as does lacing/soaking
foods with a vitamin preparation. Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/lymphfaqs.htm
and the links beyond. Bob Fenner>
Joe
Puffer with problem
Hi,
My figure-8 puffer has a large growth on his tail just before his back fin. It
looks like a blister. There is no discoloration. His appetite is fine.
Antibiotics have been ineffective. What is it? How can I treat it?
<Likely some sort of subcutaneous tumor... best to ignore it... chemicals
won't "treat it", surgery is more dangerous, stressful than it's
worth. Good water quality, feeding... will see this animal to its best health.
Bob Fenner>
Thank you,
Paul
Re: sent from Puffernet
Jason,
<Hello,>
Thanks for the suggestions and I will check out the FAQ's on the puffers. But I
am not familiar with copper. Is that copper like the metal? <Same element as
the metal, but in liquid form.> Any way is it something that is normally
carried at the pet store? <Yes.>
Again thank you for your time and help. I'm sure my puffer thanks you as well.
Ed
<Ed, also check out Bob's answers to various FAQs on Copper in Marine
systems. Obviously your puffer isn't a marine fish, but I think some of the
information in these links will be of some use as well:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marparasitcurefaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/copperfa.htm
Hope that's helpful. Cheers, J -- >
Problems with a Figure-Eight Puffer
<JasonC here, helping out while Bob is away diving.>
Bob Fenner Hello I recently sent this message to the folks at Puffernet and they
said to send my message to you. <really.> I just copied what I sent them
put it on the bottom of this letter. The only thing new with my puffer is the
worm looking thing in his eye was there one morning and when I got back from my
run it looks like it popped out. <hmm...> My puffers eye is almost back to
normal <glad to hear this.> but I worry that if it was a parasite he may
have eaten again because I saw it nowhere in the tank. <may have gone into
the substrate.> and he is always on lookout for food. <sounds good.> He
also still has a bump on his back it doesn't look like it has moved to much.
Again thank you for your time and any suggestions on what to do would be a great
help. thank you
ed Purdy
<Ed, it sounds like you should probably take actions with copper or other
similar mechanism that would kill those evil-nasties. I would suggest you read
through the following FAQ on WWM: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/fwpufferfaqs.htm
- from what I can gather your puffer will respond well to copper and so now
might be the time to use some. Cheers, J -- >
Figure Eight Puffer Concerns
>Hello I own a figure 8 Pufferfish, shortly after I
>brought him home I noticed that he had a bump on his
>back. It has continued to grow and since move. I think
>he has a parasite of some sort growing under his skin
>and don't know what to do? The parasite has since
>split into two or multiplied at times it looks like
>there is a worm in his skin. I never see it move I
>just wake up and it is in a different spot. It is
>currently in his eye and I can see what looks like a
>little worm wrapped up in his eye. Please let me know
>what you think this might be and what to do to help
>the little guy out. Other wise he has a great appetite
>swims fine and acts normal. Thanks for your time.
>Ed Purdy
Spotted puffer
Hi I have a question about Pufferfish. I bought a spotted puffer about 2
months ago and he acts and looks really healthy. The other day I noticed
something strange , he turned a different shade. He was laying near an ornament
I have and was really dark. When I looked in the tank he came swimming over to
me like always and his color went back to his normal shade. A friend of mine has
a spotted and a figure 8 and he said he noticed the same thing only one of his
turns lighter. Is this normal?
<Yes, normal>
Do they do this for camouflage? Or is it a mood thing?
<Both as far as I'm concerned. Bob Fenner>
Picked a Peck of Pimpled Puffers (marine, but applicable to FW puffers as
well)
Mr. Fenner,
<Geri...Anthony Calfo here answering Bob's mail while he is away studying to
become a Tibetan Sherpa>
I have 3 small green spotted puffers in a 30 gal brackish tank.
<adorable fish... you are keeping them brackish, right? what's your
salinity?>
They are all eating well and are very lively. I have had them about two weeks
and two of them have developed small bumps (no discoloration-just raised areas)
under their skin. The bumps were first noticed on their bellies and now one fish
has a couple on his side. I need help in determining what these bumps are and if
I need to treat them. Please reply-Thanks for the advice.
<tough to diagnose from a general description of the symptom, but here goes:
if the bumps/dots are symmetrical and identical in size... and not larger than a
common grain of salt (as opposed to an uncommon 5lb grain...in which case you
can forget the quarantine tank and just find a small deer to lick it off, hehehe)
you may very well be dealing with an external parasite. Not at all uncommon with
this species and not as obvious to you compared to pictures of large-scaled
fishes in books. You must be very careful using medication with these fish and
follow manufacturer's recommendations for scaleless fishes (or halve the dose
for twice the time). Otherwise, large or asymmetrical bumps will rule out most
if not all common parasites and you'll look for other pathogenic symptoms. I
would highly recommend Dieter Untergasser's Handbook of Fish Diseases. A great
and easy to understand book with pictures and fool-proof flow charts. We need to
narrow the puffers condition down before we medicate. In the meantime... look
for medicated fish food at the LFS and maintain consistent water quality. I'm
(educated) guessing that your fish have common white spot and will need a
parasite medication. Keep us posted, Anthony>
Jaws the Mbu Puffer?
<Ananda here today, fielding the puffer questions...>
is this a silly question? if you were to be accidentally nipped by a Mbu puffer
would you get sick?
<Not a silly question at all. There might not be any of the puffer toxin in
the bite, but there could be other nasties in the tank that might make a cut
unpleasant, to say the least.>
I know if you value your life you shouldn't try to eat them in the sushi bars
and such.. I don't know who could eat a puffer anyway....
<Me neither! And I love sushi, but puffers are just too cute to consider
eating. Even if it wasn't dangerous.>
I know they could kill you if you ingest them, what about just sticking your
hands in the aquarium and such?
<At the least, do wash your hands -- and arms! -- with hot water and soap
before and after putting them in the tank. If you have any cuts or scrapes on
your hands, use aquatic gloves. Otherwise, you risk getting infections from the
stuff in your tank, and risk contaminating the tank, especially if you use hand
creams/lotions, perfumes, etc. --Ananda>
Unwell Leopard Puffer Fish
>Hi,
>>Hello, Marina here, but am also sending this to the resident brackish
expert, Ananda.
>About three weeks ago, I purchased two Leopard Puffer Fish (about 1"
long). They're currently in a 90 Gallon Brackish Water aquarium that
I've had for about two years. Partial water changes are made
religiously once a week. The one puffer fish is doing fine, looks
healthy/eats/moves around a lot. The other puffer started off fine,
but after a few days, I noticed his belly
had a few thin dark lines. It almost looked as if food had leaked out
of his stomach, but not through the surface of his skin. Since then
(about three weeks), his belly has gradually gone from white, to a dark black
color (from his tail, moving up towards his head). He spends a lot of
time laying at the bottom of the tank, still get's excited during feeding time,
but seems to have problems eating (choking).
As of today, I also noticed ick in the tank (two visible ick cysts on our
Australian Finger Fish, and upon closer inspection, both puffers are speckled
with ick as well). I returned to the pet store to learn that the
puffers we purchased were from a tank that was placed under quarantine shortly
afterwards due to ick.
>>Great. At least you know, yeah?
>I'm now treating my tank with ick medication, but my concern is still with
the one 'black bellied' puffer. Could this have been caused by the
ick? The other puffer does not seem affected in the same way, and
aside from the ick, all other fish are doing fine. Should I be
considering some sort of internal parasite or infection? I asked some
of the employees at the Pet store and got
strange looks as a result. Searching the internet has not provided me
with much information on any Puffer Fish related illnesses. Any
suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
>>I'm giving you this link on f/w puffer FAQ's..
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/fwbracpuffaqs.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwpufffaqs2.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/bracpuffaq2.htm
Please follow the links within links, sorry I can't be of better help at this
time.
Copper and puffers (07/26/03)
<Hi! Ananda here tonight...>
1. Had beautiful gold spotted puffer in tank with serious ich
outbreak. LFS said treat with copper power in show tank. NOW
know that was a bad idea.
<I would never treat anything in a show tank...>
Conscientious Marine Aquarist suggested puffer fish OK with copper Ananda said
get out of copper and do daily water changes in QT tank Which is right?????
<To some degree, both. I always try to steer people away from using copper
with puffers and other scaleless fish because they are *so* touchy with copper.
While it is *possible* to treat puffers with copper, it is also *difficult* to
maintain the copper at a level which is sufficient to kill the parasites without
endangering the puffer. (As an example, a couple of days ago, one reader lost a
puffer moments after putting it into a coppered tank. The tank had been used to
treat an angel, which survived the same level of copper that was lethal for the
puffer.) Add to that the fact that copper will also kill all beneficial bacteria
in a setup, and that means the hospital tank is likely to have some ammonia --
which is deadly to any fish. The combination could easily prove too much for a
puffer to take. Freshwater dips are significantly less dangerous to the puffers
(as long as you keep their heads submerged so they can't gulp air!). And the
daily water changes are designed to do accomplish two things: keeping the
ammonia levels down and removing any ich from the bottom of the tank.>
2.Also, tank had constant bubbles from Iwaki 55rlt pump with wrong sump ( too
small) and couldn't keep up with water flow and was sucking air
too. Is this a source of stress for fish?
<It could be. --Ananda>
Thanks, Russ
Puffer Ails 7/10/03
Our Mbu Puffer about (12 inches in length) has decided he does not want to
eat shrimp anymore. We were always supplementing snails, crawfish. He just will
not eat the shrimp. He has been doing something funny with his mouth, after he
has bit into something, He opens up his mouth very wide like he is trying to
push something out but nothing comes out, its gives us the impression that
something is stuck in his gums??? Does that make sense??
<have you checked for overgrowth on the teeth?>
He has been eating the snails even though he goes through this ritual. He is not
as eager to eat as he once was. We have ordered him Ghost Shrimp, Brown Snails
and crab. What else do you suggest?
<some Selcon to supplement the diet... also gut-loading the prey with
nutritious dry foods and frozen fare that the puffer would not eat alone>
My husband pet him yesterday, when he was cleaning the tank. The Mbu
"Andy" started to color up and move his fins like this made him happy.
I thought he would puff up and act mad but he seemed to like the contact.
Cute. He has tank mates that he has had from the very beginning. A
Bala Shark "Cedric" and 30 small Tetras. When he is
finished with his food they all come over and he lets them eat what ever he was
having. I don't know how long this will last but it is really cool. I'll take a
picture for you guys... We were rinsing the shrimp in filtered water, we should
use a little water out of his tank I guess in a cup that belongs to him do you
think he may not like his food rinsed in the filtered water?? Could there be too
much Chlorine??
<no worries here>
We research and read and talk to people we just want to do the right things for
our Mbu Puffer Friend. He has become quite the family member. We are getting him
that 300 gallon tank so that he can grow very old in it. Thanks,
Vivian
<many FAQs in our archives on puffers... do browse as well http://www.wetwebmedia.com
Anthony>
Re: sick puffer (07/27/03)
Hey Ananda - thanks for the quick reply.
<You're welcome...it so happened that I was online when your email came
in.>
The puffer's belly is still white.
<Oh, good. Puffer bellies are good stress-barometers.>
The slug came from my garden (was on a leaf).
<Are you using any fertilizers or pesticides? If so, I would avoid using the
garden slugs.>
I went back & checked on him after turning off light & adding water and
he seems much better! He attempted to eat a couple of antibacterial
sticks. I put in a couple of mosquito larvae and he did eat one of them - still
seems to be having some trouble seeing them.
<Ah. If he's having trouble seeing, do a water change. That can be a symptom
of a water quality problem.>
Are they ok to feed?
<That depends on where you're getting the mosquito larvae from. If they're
from a pond or something near your house, you need to be *certain* that the
local government does not spray for mosquitoes. If you're certain that they're
"organic" mosquitoes (pardon the pun), they should be okay.>
Thanks again, Donna
<You're welcome. --Ananda>
Puffer injury/illness
Hi Bob, Sorry to keep bugging you,
<no worries.... but it is still me, Anthony Calfo, here at your service. Bob
is/has been away in the Caribbean. Also, please not our new addy is/will be
changed to crew@wetwebmedia.com for inquiries if you'd like to note it in your
address book>
but thought I would let you know what's happening with my puffer. I had him in
the 40 gallon and treated him with Maracyn two for 5 days.
<Maracyn is a brand name Erythromycin... which is a gram positive medication.
As such, it is almost completely useless for most all marine fish (and FW too)
illnesses. It is not only an outdated med, but most bacterial infections are
gram-positive in nature. Always buy/use broad-spectrum antibiotics to play the
odds in your favor. Furthermore, in the case of this fish, as I mentioned
before, this is not a pathogenic disease. It is almost certainly a physical
imposition (injury or defect). It needs to be treated differently.>
He never showed any symptoms during that time. He was very active and had a
great appetite. I returned him to the 7' tank and he was fine for two days. He
is now showing those same symptoms...clamped mouth, pinched belly, lethargic,
but nothing has come out of his mouth yet. ?? Is there anyone else that you know
that could help me with this? Kelly still hasn't replied. I just don't know what
to do anymore. Thank you so much. Lynn
<my strong advice at this point would be to find a local or regional vet that
will look at some better pictures of the fish for a prelim opinion (don't move
the fish unless you have to). I regret that we cannot help more, but through
e-mail, we cannot fairly assist you on a text description and vague photo (no
worries here.... I do understand the challenge of getting a good clear photo).
Best regards, Anthony>
More Puffer problems
Yes, we have a green spotted puffer who has been very healthy until a few
days ago. He has stopped eating (blood worms, plankton etc), hides a
great deal, is losing weight and now appears to have a slight bulge on the right
side of his mouth. I have checked into the diseases that I could find
online and nothing matches this description. There is nothing
protruding to indicate internal parasites. What could this be and
what can we do about it. Thanks, Lori. P.S. His teeth are not
overgrown at this point either.
<Hi Lori, You don't mention any facts about your tank, water, etc. so I can
only give you a very general answer. The best place to start is matching the
conditions required by your fish.
Check this link for the information you need. http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwpuffers.htm
Any variations from the conditions provided for your puffer should be corrected.
Read down to the bottom of the page to cover disease and parasites. These guys
are subject to several of these, but treatable. The FAQ's and links at the top
of the page will provide you with a bunch of needed info. Good
luck! Craig>
Re: More Puffer problems
Hi again, well we lost our puffer last night. My six year old was
very upset. We have had him about 5 months.
<very sorry to hear it. Have you read through our archives (Craig mentioned
in last e-mail) for the species survey(s) and all the many FAQ pages? This is
one of the most commonly mishandled fish and we get a lot of mail about puffers.
Common problem include incorrect or inconsistent salinity (have you been using a
hydrometer with your salt additions?), feeding small hard shelled crabs and
shrimp (live ghost shrimp, tiny crayfish, hermit crabs and their shells) to wear
their teeth down. Else they get overgrown in months and the fish can suffer/die
from it, etc. There are many issues to know with puffers. If you haven't had a
chance yet, please do navigate the archives from the homepage for more
information>>
Anyway, I am guessing that our water quality has never been consistent and that
is what finally took his life.
<yes, my friend... a common problem. The lack of a consistent salinity is
very stressful. We simply must use a hydrometer to coordinate salt levels and
top off for evaporation daily to prevent swings. Hydrometers are inexpensive
($5-15) and easy to use>
In a last resort to keep this aquarium for my kids let me give you the
rundown. We have a 20h with a spotted cat, 2 clown loaches, a blood
parrot fish and a Gourami.
<a huge problem here... the loaches need soft acidic water, the others are
somewhat similar and the puffer needs hard, alkaline and salted water (full
brackish). It is inevitable that one or the other groups of fishes would die.
Its like mixing polar penguins and Amazon parrots in the same cage because they
are both birds... one is going to die under the standardized husbandry (if not
both)>
They all get along great even when the puffer was with them.
<not exactly, my friend... it was only ever going to last short term. As the
puffer matured it would have become increasingly aggressive and literally picked
the eyes out of the other fishes. The clown loaches mature at more than 12"
long and will outgrow their tank mates, possibly eat them or simply stunt and
die prematurely if kept in a small aquarium. If the spotted cat is a Pimelodella
(pictus), it is a fish predator and can eat live goldfish at about 2 years old.
Sorry, bub... but somebody had to mention it if the LFS didn't>
Anyway, we have a whisper box filter, underground filter with powerhead, do not
overfeed and change the water partially at least once a week
<all excellent!>
and I can never keep the ammonia down in our tank for more than a
day. Each of our fish is no more than two inches long!!!!
<very simple then... 1) you really might be overfeeding (which I doubt and
take your word for) or 2) (my guess) Your under gravel filter has large pebbles
(lousy for filtration) and/or less than 3" of gravel (too shallow for
adequate bio-filtration)>
In the last couple of weeks, I took out the UG filter because not only was the
ammonia high but the nitrite as well.
<Doh! A properly installed UG can be an excellent filter. I would return
it>
Now, my ph is perfect at neutral, nitrites are zero but the ammonia is still too
high.
<you need a primary bio-filter, buddette. If not the UG, then a canister
filter or like unit. Again... return the UG or shell out $100 for a canister
filter>
Also, I cannot seem to get rid of green algae in our tank. I know
that the puffers diet was a bit messy but we were careful to feed only what he
would eat. In fact, all of our fish enjoyed "his diet" of
blood worms, plankton etc. The only thing I can figure is that the
size of our tank is the issue.
<agreed... the smaller vessel is a lot more difficult/less stable>
When I was a kid we had a 55 gal tank and hardly ever had to do water
changes. We changed the filter once of week and at best once a month
did water changes.
<agreed>
Once a year we tore down the tank.
<not necessary...ever with a properly maintained tank. Too stressful (for you
and the fishes <wink>)>
What am I doing wrong that is making this tank such a chore and heartbreaking to
my family?
<water quality as you suspected my friend>
Please help. Thanks, Lori.
<best regards, Anthony>
Puffer Problems
Hi Bob,
As always, thanks for the great site. Here's a good one for ya...
I see Puffers develop a graying area in the skin, which eventually spreads. We
call it "Puffer Cancer", for lack of better terms. Once it starts,
there is no repair, and the fish eventually dies. Any idea what we are dealing
with here?
<I have seen it in other stores and always thought it was because of use of
meds.>
We love our Puffs, and any input you have would be most appreciated!
I only see this malady in Tetraodons, not Tobies. Is it a reaction to copper?
<Could be or a reaction to formalin, malachite green, Methylene blue, either
in your store tanks or your wholesalers. -Steven Pro>
I await your response.
Puffer Problems Follow-up
Do you have any suggestions to prevent this occurrence?
<Only, not to use any meds that scaleless fish are sensitive to, but not much
you can do about your wholesalers treatments. -Steven Pro>
Green Spotted Puffer Problem
Good morning guys!
One of my green spotted puffers is having a problem, and I'm not sure if it's
constipation or something worse. He is producing VERY large feces, and seems to
be a bit sluggish. When I fed flakes yesterday, the other spotted puffer and the
large Cory that shares the tank both fed, but the affected fish just mouthed the
flakes and spit them back. Later in the day, I fed a ration of frozen bloodworms
- which all three fish completely devoured.
<Puffers should not be fed flakes, they should eat pellets and hard shelled
crustacea to wear their teeth down. ghost shrimp, tiny crayfish, krill, etc>
What really has me concerned about this particular puffer, though, is the
presence of small red dots on his left flank, somewhat near the anus. I don't
know if he has bled internally, or if these are just marks from lying on the
slab of shale that he enjoys resting upon. I am really concerned, though - I
love these little guys, and hate seeing one of them in less than optimum health.
Any thoughts?
<Sounds like a bacterial infection. Improved diet and possibly quarantine
with medication. Medicated pelleted food is available from Tetra. Best Regards,
Gage>
Thanks, Chris
Green Spotted Puffer
Hi Gang,
My Green Spotted Puffer has developed what looks like a whitehead on it's nose -
Any ideas as to what this could be? Jason
<Hi Jason, This is likely Lymphocystis, a viral disease related to
environmental/water quality. Please test your water for wastes and
make any changes necessary to improve your water. Likely
nitrates... We get more mail on puffers than about any fish....many
misconceptions and problems with water conditions.
Please go to: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwpuffers.htm and
read about the conditions your puffer requires. There is much more on
Lymphocystis on WetWebMedia.com...scroll to the bottom of the page and type
Lymphocystis in the google search engine. No worries, this is
curable, Craig>
Palembang puffer
Hi Crew,
I've a question.. (but don't we all) I just got a Palembang puffer, and the tank
I got him from had probably 2 dozen of them all swimming happily... but I put
this little chappy in a tank on his own, and he seems rather distressed,
swimming up against the glass, even trying to jump.. and he looks like he's
trying to escape.. is this just due to him being in a new environment? or is
there something wrong with the water? I checked the ph and it seems ok... the
only other fish is a tiny Pleco. Thanks for your help
<Hey Marcus, it is very possible that this is just a reaction from the stress
of being moved into a new environment. I would also test my water for
ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate, just to be sure. Best Regards,
Gage.>
Marcus Tan
Sick puffer maybe
I have 2 figure 8 puffers and 2 spotted puffers in a 5 gallon freshwater tank.
One of the spotted puffers just recently started sitting on the bottom or close
to it in the corner. It looks like it has a discoloration line between the white
part of the belly and the spots. It is kind of a dark area, all the way around.
If you know what this could be please write me back.
Annie
<Sounds like what folks term a "stress syndrome" of these fishes
(they're brackish to marine)... with nervous involvement, parts of the body do
discolor... I would read and heed the materials stored on our site re these
tetraodonts: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/puffers.htm
You need to add some non-iodized salt to the system, maybe some live rock (yes,
as if this were a marine system) to speed (re)cycling in the different ionic
environment...
Bob Fenner
Re: sick puffer.........
I am sorry to bother you again but today when I woke up my puffer whom
I
wrote to you about yesterday had puffy cotton like stuff on his body
around
his fin. Could this be something different? The per store says that its
ick and I got him some "Furacyn" medicine but he looks worse today. :(
Also, do I need to add salt to my tank? I mean, I have Neons, swordtails,
shrimp, and baby swords. It is just a 10 gallon tank. Will the salt hurt
them at all? Sorry to bother! Thanks a bunch! >
<Not ich... did they ask if the appearance was white, discrete spots? Likely
a secondary infection of some sort of fungus... and once again, nutrition and
environmentally related.
If you can understand the following, do add the salt and amend the foods as
previously recommended. No amount of medicine otherwise will stop this
problem... No to adding much salt with the Neon Tetras... Please either trade
the puffer in (it will eventually eat the Neons) or the Neons... otherwise, the
Swords will be fine with the salt...
The Puffer is a brackish to marine species and quite nippy/aggressive... with
easygoing freshwater species... I would have encouraged you to leave such a fish
out of your system.
Bob Fenner
Hurt puffer.........
Hello! I have a spotted green puffer. He is in a freshwater tank with
female swordtails and guppies. I feed the other fish tetra color and I
feed
him brine shrimp pellets. His tail is curled up and his left fin is
starting to rot it looks like. Not like Ich but just deteriorating. I have
only had this tank set up for a week and the day after I got the tank set
up
I had baby swordtails. My fish went through a lot of stress separating the
babies from the tank so that is probably the cause of this. What could be
wrong with him? Ich? Fin rot? Maybe just a fight with another fish? :(
I love my fish so much and I don't want to loose any! :) PLEASE help
me?!?! Thanks so much! >
<Likely the tail curling is nothing (this is what these puffers do) but
pectoral fin is trouble... and likely due to being in a strictly freshwater
environment (this species is actually more marine) and a too-limited diet... I
would add "some" salt (a teaspoon per gallon ultimately... a teaspoon
per day until you reach this amount... if you have no plants... or other
livestock... the swords are fine... that are salt intolerant. And do look into
other frozen, freeze-dried foods like Tubifex, mysids, krill, bloodworms... for
your puffer. These two changes will reverse the current trend.
Bob Fenner>
Green Puffer
Hi Bob!
My husband and I have 4 Green Puffers. Two adults, and 2 babies. One of the
adult puffers fades really bad in color. Going from his beautiful bright
green, to a pale green to where you can barely see his black spots,
and then back to his beautiful green again. Is this a sign of stress? He isn't
acting any different and is eating like the fat boy he is. I am
hoping that you have the answer!
Thanks!
Stephanie and Doug
<Thanks for writing. Likely there is nothing wrong with the
"flashing" adult puffer. These fish do shift brightness and markings
with their moods... this one is likely just communicating with its kin. Do take
a read over the freshwater puffer section and FAQs on the www.wetwebmedia.com
site for more input on their care. Bob Fenner>
Puffer with Bent spine
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
Hey I was just wondering I've had my 2 dwarf puffers for about 3 months now
everything has seemed to be fine eating and interacting normally they have a
steady diet of small snail and ghost shrimps. My question is, I noticed
yesterday one of the puffers was swimming around in circles. I know this
question has been asked before but the odd thing is his body seems to be
permanently curved. His body is arched in a weird way, and once in awhile he
tries to bury himself. I'm not sure what to do. I checked the water and
everything is fine. The other puffer is acting normal, and the fish I have them
paired with are fine. I have a non-aggressive cichlid and a Gourami from my
previous tank and they have all gotten along fine.
<There are 3 things I can think of. Going from best to worse: it could be
starving due to internal parasites. The stomach would be caved in, causing the
spine to bend. This is treatable, if the fish is still eating. I have had
great success with Discomed, by Aquatronics. Unfortunately that company has
been out of business for a while, so you may be hard pressed to find any. Here
is info on alternatives:
http://puffer2.proboards37.com/index.cgi?board=hospital&action=display&num=1116217071. The
other thing it could be is a defect in the spine & lastly, tuberculosis, which
is contagious to humans. Either way, it doesn't look good for the fish if it is
the last 2 & the fish should be euthanized with an overdose of clove oil & then
frozen.
Sorry for the bad news, lets hope it's just IPs. ~PP>
Puffer Scar? 5/17/05
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I ran across your site some time ago and it has been most helpful and informative in maintaining my aquariums. I've got a particular question that I haven't been able to find the answer to so far.
I've got a common, "avocado" puffer. I've had the puffer for several months and it's been doing great. In fact, it's still doing great except for one thing. I noticed a white mark on the side of my puffer. It certainly isn't ich (there was an outbreak of ich a month or so ago; I simply added aquarium salt as directed and raised the temperature accordingly, and along with water changes the ich went away), and it doesn't appear to have the raised,
cauliflower look of a bacterial/fungal infection.
The white spot is located right above the main black spot these puffers have near their tail fins. I've included a picture,
<<Photo not found.>> with the puffer being as still as it's going to get for the camera.
The tank has lots of plants, some driftwood, and two big flowerpot "caves" for hiding. This setup has been working nicely and still is as far as I can tell.
My puffer has its usual voracious appetite; I feed a diet of frozen shrimp (in the shell), home grown snails, the occasional crayfish, and frozen peas (when I can trick the puffer into eating them; just like children - won't eat their vegetables!). The puffer still swims to the front of the aquarium when I come in the room, and waits in the front corner for my attention before performing its "I'm-overly-excited-give-me-more-food" dance, as always. Even after eating, my puffer will retire midway back in the tank and eye me for any signs that I'm going to get more food.
One thought I had was that perhaps a crayfish had managed to get a scratch on the puffer (most of them don't have a chance, and my puffer likes to chase them around the tank to get the best angle of attack) and the white mark may be a scab healing over. Also, I have a fluorescent light on the tank, set on a timer, for the plants. Although the light comes on after daybreak (to provide a more natural transition from darkness to broad daylight) my puffer is occasionally startled by the light and will dart off out of sight on rare occasions when the light turns on. Perhaps the puffer scraped against something, again causing a wound to heal.
As a side note, I have never seen my puffer actually "puff" up; I take this as a good sign that it's rather content and stress-free in its home.
Anyway, water parameters test ok and I'm doing daily water changes just in case, along with the addition of a little salt. Still, I know ya'll are prone to proactivity when dealing with possible illnesses and I wanted to balance overdoing things with due caution.
Whenever I search the site, I always end up with information about ich (using search terms like "white spot, white mark, etc.") which isn't the case here.
Any info you can provide would be appreciated; I'd like to head off any potential problems ASAP! Thanks for the great and informative website (from myself & puffer).
Brian
<Not to worry Brian, looks like scaring to me. If you want it to heal faster, you can add Melafix. Sounds like you really care about the fella! Good work. ~PP>
Sick Puffer? 1/05/05
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I have had my puffer for about 1 month and I keep him in a 10 gallon tank that I
have added aquarium salt in.
<what kind of puffer is it?>
For the past 3 days he has lost weight and it looks like someone has squeezed
the back of it. (Which I know no one has).
<Internal parasites?>
I feed him flakes and he used to eat it just fine. But the puffer does not eat
anymore. Could the puffer's diet be a problem?
<Definitely could be part of the problem. Read about puffer's diet here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm This diet is
good for all puffers.>
The puffer is by itself and has caves to go in and out of. It can hardly swim
anymore. Please help me ASAP?
<It would be of great help to know what kind of puffer you have. Also, please
post your ammonia, nitrItes, nitrAtes & pH. ~PP>
Gray Spots/Patches on F8 Puffer 12/31/04
Hi.
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I just noticed that one of my Fig8's (I have 2) has some gray discoloration on
its belly, while the other one is still a bright pearly white. Can you please
advise what it might be and what remedy to use?
<A little more info would be helpful. How long have you had them? What are the
water parameters--ammonia, nitrItes, nitrAtes, pH? Are they in brackish water?
What SG? Are you using marine salt? What are you feeding them? Does it eat
well, but remain thin? Water changes--how much, how often? I ask all this,
because a darkened belly can be either a sign of sickness or stress, which can
be caused by poor/incorrect water conditions. If it changes back to white
pretty often though, it could just be moodiness. Here's a great article on
them:
http://www.aaquaria.com/aquasource/8puffer.shtml>
Thanks much for your time - appreciate all the useful info on your website.
Pat
<You're very welcome & Happy New Year! ~PP>
Black dots on Puffers 11/29/04
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
Hello I just visited your site for the first time and found it very informative!
<Thank you! We aim to please.>
I believe I read every post in regards to sick puffers - but I still did not
find an answer to my question -- I hope you can help.. The LFS was of no help -
3 said they are community fish and are able to be in freshwater and live a long
time..
<They can live into their teens, but not in FW.>
I have 2 puffers, 1 figure eight and 1 spotted, they have plenty of hiding areas
and are in a brackish 10 gallon tank - they are the only fish in the tank.
<That tank is too small for 2 puffers. I highly recommend not keeping those 2
species together. The GSP is a high-end BW fish, that will prefer SW as an
adult & grow 2x the size of the F8, which prefers low-end BW & isn't nearly as
aggressive as an adult GSP. They may seem fine now, but I can't tell you how
many stories I hear about maturing puffers being killed by the more aggressive
one. You can keep a single F8 to maturity in a 10g tank. An adult 6" GSP will
need at least 20-30g.>
My concern is the larger of the 2 puffers (spotted) started to develop small
black specks on its belly, almost like it picked up some remnants form somewhere
- now the smaller puffer has developed the same thing - my larger puffer goes
through the color change at least 2 times a week - my smaller puffer stays the
same. I thought I was going to lose my large puffer, it started breathing hard
and its fins were laying close to his boy not moving - so I added salt and did a
partial water change.
<How much salt do you have in there? What kind? You must use marine salt &
measure it with a hydrometer. Juvenile GSPs prefer a SG (specific gravity--a
measurement of salt with a hydrometer) of 1.008-1.010. Juve F8s prefer a SG of
1.005-1.008.
He perked up a bit -but I'm really worried about the black specks. Do you know
what this might be?
<All puffers have spines. It could just be dirt sticking to them.>
The LFS gave me ick meds and I put that in today - but I know puffers are very
sensitive to meds and I don't want to hurt them.
<Get that med out of there now, especially if it has copper in it! Do a 50%
water change (should be doing that weekly too) & add fresh carbon to your filter
& remove after 2 days, so the meds don't leach back into your tank. There
should be no reason to use meds for ich. Heat, salt & heavy water changes
should get rid of ich. Anyway, why would you treat for a disease it doesn't
have symptoms for? Ich would cause the fish to have WHITE spots, not the black
spots you are seeing. Stupid LFS!>
Please advise if you can - and I hope someone asked this and I missed it - What
is your advise?
<Read these articles on the 2 puffers you have:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm
http://www.aaquaria.com/aquasource/8puffer.shtml>
P.S I think you handled that persons question the way it should have been - if
you don't want an answer then don't ask!!
<Very true! ~PP>
Marriage is like a Garden; it dies quickly unless you lovingly tend to it....
<So agreed! I have been married for over 13 years. It is paying attention &
compromise.>
Bumpy Puffer 11/29/04
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I've had a green spotted puffer since July. In the last two days I noticed a
bump developing on his upper back just behind his head. It's as if a few scales
are out of line, except it's a visible bump.
<Puffers are scaleless fish. It could be a few things. The best scenario would
be just a cyst, that the puffer will absorb back into to it's body. The worst
is a tumor, or a parasitic nematode (see:
http://nematode.unl.edu/), that will eventually kill the fish. If it has
any tank mates in there, I would quarantine the fish, until it is resolved. Can
you get a close-up of the bump?>
His appetite is the same and there isn't any color changes. Also, the salt
levels in the water are as they should be.
<What are the salt levels? Are you using marine salt? Here is a good article
on them:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm>
What is your advice?
<Just do what you are doing & follow the article on it's care &
feeding. There's really nothing you can do.>
Thank you for your time,
Alina
<Here's hoping it's just a cyst. ~PP>
Green Spotted Puffers with Ich 10/24/04
Hi
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I have four green spotted puffers and it looks they now have a small case of
Ich. I have some medicine that works great on the other freshwater fish but I
was wondering if would be safe to use on them. The medication is called Rid Ich
and contains that malachite green stuff. They are in their own 10 gal tank and
only have a Pleco in there with them. Do you advise that I get some of the salt
to put in or just use a dose of the med?
<I'm not surprised at all that your puffers are sick. A 10 tank is way to small
for 4 of these puffers. I suggest 10g/small puffer (<2") & 20-30g/adult fish
(they grow to 6"). Also, these puffers prefer high-end brackish water & marine
water as adults. Keeping them in conditions not suitable for them, will cause
them to stress, lowering their immune system, making them susceptible to
diseases, as you can see. My suggestion to you is, get a much larger tank for
these puffers & keep alone. Get them in brackish water & raise their
temperature to around 86-87. Here is a good article on treating puffers with
Ich:
http://puffer.proboards2.com/index.cgi?board=hospital&action=display&num=1086103674
I have had great results with this method. It is not a good idea to use Ich
meds on puffers, as they are very sensitive to them. Also, please read this
article on the care & feeding of your puffers:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm
Until you can get them into a larger tank, I would do large daily water changes
(with dechlorinator), add 1tbsp aquarium salt/5gal
for now (your Pleco won't appreciate marine salt, or any sort of brackish water
levels) & raise the temp. Make sure you cycle the larger tank, before adding
those fish. If you aren't prepared to keep all 4 as adults (needing at least an
80-120g tank), then please find homes for some of them.>
Thanks a lot.
Sarah
Black Line on Green Spotted Puffer 10/26/04
Hi,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I just got a GSP a few days ago. I noticed that he often turns black on his
sides, kind of where his belly meets the green and black. I was wondering if
this is something to be concerned about. I've watched him quite a bit and the
black does go away sometimes and he'll be purely white on his sides and belly.
<This is generally a sign of the puffer being stressed somehow.>
I was also wondering, what things I need to test for in the water. So far I've
been checking the salinity but that's pretty much it. I know I should check the
pH but I wasn't real sure how to go about doing that so any suggestions would be
great.
<The tests I use come from The Master Test Kit, by Aquarium
Pharmaceuticals. You need to test for ammonia, nitrites, nitrates & PH.>
Is it better for the water to be too salty rather than less salty?
<"Saltiness" should not be a guessing game. SG (specific gravity, a way of
measuring salinity) is measured by a hydrometer, which is what you will need to
keep brackish fish. Also, you MUST use marine salt. You can start out low &
raise it a little every week. There is a great description of this process &
all the info you'll need on your green spotted puffer here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm>
Right now he has a 3 gallon tank (I know way too small but I'm looking for a
bigger tank, hopefully I'll get him one this weekend). He has some plants,
which I just put in today and he seems a lot happier with it. There's also a
log, which he often sleeps in.
<As you have figured out, that tank is way too small for this fish. A smaller
GSP is ok in a 10g tank for a while, but a 30g is recommended for an adult (6")
fish. Did you cycle that tank before adding the puffer? Were there fish in
there before him? If not, this could be the cause of the stress. See:
http://faq.thekrib.com/begin-cycling.html If that tank isn't cycled, I
highly suggest giving the fish back to where you got him, until you can properly
house him in a larger cycled tank, or he will die from toxic ammonia &
nitrites. You will not be able to keep plants in brackish water, the salt will
destroy them, causing to foul the water.>
His current diet is just fresh water shrimp and mollies. Would sand crabs from
the beach be ok to feed him (just the little ones that don't really pinch)? If
I feed him those things is it still necessary to get him snails? I'm not sure
that there were any snails on the plants I put in. It didn't look like it
though.
<It is not a good idea to feed fish to this puffer. Fish are too fatty & can
cause liver problems in these fish. There is a great list of foods in that GSP
article I linked you to above. I don't suggest feeding them those crabs, unless
they are quarantined & treated for parasites 1st.>
Anyways, that's plenty questions for now.
<This is not a fish for a novice fish keeper. If you are prepared to give your
puffer the proper care, it can live over 10 years. ~PP> Thanks! -Tersha
Green spotted Puffer Problem Date: Mon, 2 Aug 2004
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
We have 2 spotted puffers. one is fine the other has a pink and red end of its
tail. It is inflamed and he is keeping his tail curled close to his
body. Please help, I don't want to loose this puffer!!!!!
<1st of all read this:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm. This article
should tell you the best way to care for your puffers. Get some PimaFix
and/or Melafix, as it sounds like your puffer has a bacterial infection on it's
tail. Next, have your water tested for ammonia, nitrItes, nitrAtes & pH. Get
back to me with the results. ~PP>
Sudden death in my puffers 6/24/04
Hi,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
I was just wondering why I have been experiencing sudden death with my puffer
fish. I had a couple Green Spotted puffers for a few months and then I wake up
and they are dying at the bottom of the tank. My last one was in its own tank by
itself. It looked perfectly fine when I went to bed, but when I woke up in the
morning I find it lying at the bottom of the aquarium, it lost all of its color.
Thanks.
<Sorry for the loss of your puffers. Here's an excellent article on GSPs:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/BrackishSubWebIndex/gspsart.htm. It should
answer all your questions on them. Please let me know if you have any more
questions after reading it. ~PP>
Listless Congo Puffer 3/16/04
Hi
<Hi Dan, Pufferpunk here>
I bought a Congo puffer from my local fish shop and put him in a fully cycled tank ph 7.3 with a sand bottom.
<Sounds great so far!>
He wasn't too lively and would often just sit for a while without moving. A couple of times I thought he was dead.
His eyes also seem like they have cataracts is the best way I can describe it. The guy in the shop said this is totally normal for this species as they sit and wait for passing fish, being "lurkers".
Just wondering if you could shed some light on this for me as you seem to have the most knowledge of puffer fish from any site I have visited on the net.
Any reply would be gratefully received.
<If the Congo puffer you are referring to is the Tetraodon miurus, then your LFS is correct. These fish are ambush predators. They lay in wait under the sand up to their eyeballs, for food to swim by. In the case of a puffer in captivity though, fish is a poor diet. They are fatty & can cause liver disease. Try to get your puffer on other food (crustaceans) as soon as possible, throwing in an occasional worm. You can find more info on your fish here:
http://home.messiah.edu/~dw1178/pufferlist.htm Share experiences with your puffer here:
http://puffer.proboards2.com/index.cgi
>
Thanks, Dan
<Although not very active, a very interesting species to own! ~PP>
Puffer Burned 2/26/04
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
Please can you help I have a T palembangensis puffer with what looked like might have been a burn. It went a bit
red (it is on top of the fish) ring like. It's skin seem to come off like a blister, so I dabbed a bit of
Meth blue on it
just to stop infection, but now it has fungused up (cotton wool like). Please can you help me cure this?
<It sounds like your puffer could have been burned by the heater, buy the round, blistering appearance. You can also try
mercurochrome on the spot. Keep the tank pristine (water changes, water changes, water changes!). You can add 1tbsp salt/5-10g. Add Melafix & Pimafix. If it gets worse, you'll have to use something stronger, like Maracyn. I'd get a heater guard, so this doesn't
happen again. Come visit us at http://puffer.proboards2.com/index.cgi
>
Thanks, Eak
<I hope your puffer gets better soon! ~PP>
Sick Palembangensis Puffer 2/26/05
Hi there Eak here.
<Pufferpunk again>
Thanks for your quick response.
<I'd like to make a small request of you. You may have noticed that I corrected
all your capitalization. That's because we need to do that, since all these
inquires go into our FAQs & we want them to look nice. Pleas try to use capital
letters in your inquires, when necessary. Thanks>
I do have a heater guard on the (sleeve type) but I have noticed the puffer
hiding under the heater he stays there till feeding time.
<Are you saying the end of the heater is exposed, where he lays? Does he have
enough plant cover so that under the heater isn't the only place he has to hide
out?>
He likes his live food red crabs and anything else that moves like shrimp. I
have read this is typical behavior for this kind of puff. My water parameters
are: pH 7.5, ammonia <0.3, nitrites 0, nitrates under 50ppm.
<Try using water changes to get your ammonia to 0 & your nitrAtes <20. I do 50%
weekly water changes on all my tanks. I wouldn't keep this puffer in a tank less
than 30g.>
I love my puffer fish he is brill his character is ace at feeding time.
Thank for all your help I will try those treatments on my puff. Thanks again
<Good luck with your puffer! ~PP>
Sick Palembangensis Puffer - II
Hi there Eak again.
<Pufferpunk again too>
Sorry to keep bugging you. My heater guard covers the whole heater. I use tetra
test kits my ammonia is 0, on the tetra test kit its lowest 2 readings are <0.3
My readings are <0.3. I have purchased some Nitrazorb to combat the nitrate
problem. I have been doing a 25% water change every week quite religiously.
<The best way to combat nitrAtes is doing water changes. I suggest raising your
to 50% weekly. I'd still like to know what other tank mates are in there.>
My tank is 147 gallon 6x2x2 there are plenty of hiding places for it but it
still chooses to sit in the open. But today there as been a new development my
puff as got the same mark on his under carriage.
<Maybe someone is biting your puffer? Where else could it be getting burned?>
I have moved the puff to a quarantine tank with the same parameters but the
nitrates are <20 mg/l. I have added some Tropic Marin salt to it, as I have
brackish puffers as well, which are brill.
<Brill? Aquarium salt is better than marine salt for medicinal purposes on FW
fish.>
I am now treating with MelaFix and PimaFix because I cant find the other things
you suggested to use. Also I have to hand Myxazin, Protozin, Sterazin, Octozin,
all Interpet treatments.
<You could try dosing an antibacterial med at 1/2 dose, as long as it says ok
for scale less fish.>
It doesn't seem to be the heater but it definitely looks like a burn like you
suggested. Thanks again sorry about my grammar and spelling I had to get my girl
friend to help me with this one.
<I hope everything gets straightened out with your poor puffer. ~PP>