FAQs about Live Rock
Related Articles: Live Rock, Reef
Related FAQs: Live Rock, Answering
Some LR FAQs by James Fatherree, LR
Hitchhiker ID 1, LR Hitchhiker ID
2, LR Hitchhiker ID 3, LR Hitchhiker ID 4, LR Hitchhiker ID
LR ID 6, LR ID
7, LR ID 8, LR ID 9, LR ID 10,
LR ID 11, LR ID
12, LR ID 13, LR ID 14, LR ID 15,
LR ID 16, LR
ID17, LRID 18, LRID 19, LRID 20,
LRID 21, LRID
22, LRID 23, LRID 24, LRID 25,
LRID 26, LRID
27, LRID 28,
LRID 30, LRID 31,
LRID 32, LRID 33,
LRID 34, LRID 35,
LRID 36, LRID 37,
LRID 38,& Non-Vert IDs 1, Tubeworm ID, Polychaete Identification, Live Rock 1, LR 2,
LR 3, LR 4,
LR 5, Curing
Live Rock, Live Rock Selection,
Shipping/Moving, Placement, Lighting, Water Quality, Live Rock Studies in Fiji Collaboration
& Charts, Copper Use, Marine
Landscaping, Marine Biotope,
Sumps, Refugiums, Faux Rock,
Sharing 1 photo with Fish Bowl Photo.
Spg. id 4/18/14
This started "growing" on the back of the rock that my mushroom coral
are on. It stated a coyote of weeks ago with
just a few "tentacles". It now covers an area
about the size of a quarter. Any ideas? Thanks for any
help you can provide!
<Is almost certainly a Sponge/Poriferan... not problematical. Actually
indicative of good conditions here. Bob Fenner>
Photos shared with Fish Bowl Photo.
|Re: Sharing 1 photo with Fish Bowl Photo.
That is awesome news! We are fairly new to reef tanks/live rock. Loving
every minute of it. I really appreciate your help in solving this mystery!
<Certainly welcome. BobF>
White clear pod growing in the reef of our salt water tank
Not sure what this is...any ideas? Its about the size of a
<Likely either an Ascidian (Sea Squirt)... or a sponge. Not harmful in
either case... indeed, indicative of good conditions in your system. Bob
|Re: White clear pod growing in the reef of our
salt water tank 4/14/14
thank you so much for the reply....and so quickly! Used to any answer at
all being at least 2 days away, if at all. You are amazing!
I have read so much on your site...just couldn't find that answer...this is
so new to me that I am not even wet behind the ears. LOL It's a lot
of fun, I have a Banggai Cardinal that is holding eggs and am
hoping to raise them up to be great swimmers.
ID ? 3/6/14
Hi Wet Web Crew
Please can you help ID this? I have three of them suddenly appear on my
live rock, and let me know if its something I should be concerned about.
<... are these things motile? Any chance for a better (more resolved)
image? Am leaning toward a mollusk of some sort... I would not be
concerned unless you saw them eating something valuable. Bob Fenner>
full size crops
Identifying Brown Tube Worms 3/3/14
My reef tank is being taken over by what looks like tiny brown tube
worms and I'm at a loss for what they might be. They are becoming
quite the nuisance. Here are some characteristics:
· Feather "heads"
retract when touched.
· Tubes are flexible but
don't easily bend.
· Length is about 1/4
I don't know if these are tube worms or something different,
<The latter; they're Cnidarians...>
but I'd like to ID them to determine if they are could be stinging or
irritating my corals. I've attached some pictures to help ID these
little critters. I've scoured the web, including your site, but
haven't found anything to concretely ID them. I did find one
picture that looks like these on another site, but no conclusion was
drawn on what they are.
Please let me know if you need any other information.
<Either Aiptasiids, or possibly Zoanthids... NEED to be confined,
cropped back, isolated on single rocks. See/read on WWM re. Bob Fenner>
Odd flower like object on live rock, green and very tiny
I found the attached object on my live rock recently and cant figure out
what it is, even after hours of Google searching, including your site!
<Mmm, looks Polypoid... My guess is on some sort of Hydrozoan... Does it
"sting", stick to a sensitive part of your wrist? Yowch!>
The live rock I bought only stated that it is usually from the South
Pacific but could be from anywhere.
The object is ridiculously small, maybe 1/4" high and a few mm wide. It
doesn't come off the rock with a baster like algae (I do have diatoms
and GHA). I originally thought it was a new strand of algae.
I have asked over at Nano-reef forums but the only idea I got was that
it could be some sort of macroalgae. This tank has only been up for
about 6 weeks and currently only has live rock in it.
I have only noticed this one in the tank and it's stationary, I haven't
noticed if it looks any differently at night than during the day. My
apologies that the pictures aren't better.
<Welcome! Thanks for sharing. Bob Fenner>
|Re: Odd flower like object on live rock, green
and very tiny 2/1/14
Thanks Bob, I've never touched it so not sure if it stings! I'll see if I
can trick my boyfriend into finding out...
<Heeee! Good idea... the wrist, not callused hands or fingers. BobF>
What is this?! 11/2/13
I haven't been able to get any answers from my local marine aquarium
My tank was set up by them 3 weeks ago.
There is a tiny brittle star "hitchhiker" who seems to like living in it
Is this white stuff good or bad?!
<More of the former... it's a sponge>
I'm new at reefing. (I've been reading & dreaming of having a salt
water tank for years. I don't want to advance to anything bigger
before I understand the science and how to care for everything first.
So, I have a "training" tank. It's only a 9 gallon Eheim.
Please help with my question about the white web!
THANK YOU FOR YOUR EXPERTISE!
<See WWM re; including compatibility. Bob Fenner>
10 gallon saltwater fish tank wildlife
My daughter was looking though your website and it is great. We have
some questions to ask though we just got a 10 gallon tank just 3
weeks ago and we have 2 live rock pieces in one of our live rocks we
have a brittle star fish and what appears to be a bristle worm
and now we have just fed them and it looks to be that we have very many
of these worms and we are thinking about trading the rock. Should we are
do you think this is ok?On the other rock we have little hair like thing
sticking out and we have no clue what they are either.
<Leave all as is for now; and read here:
Live rock hitch hikers
I'm hoping you can help me out.
<I'll see what I can do.>
I have a 55 gal FOWLR setup. It has been running
about 2 months. I have live rock, live sand and live gravel in it.
Last week I purchased a new live rock from my local store because it was so
beautiful. After I got it home and in my tank I noticed a few creatures that
began growing out of it( see pic1).
At first I thought they were some sort of feather duster. Now I'm beginning
to suspect that they are Aiptasia.
If so, are they as dangerous as I have read?
<Quite dangerous, if you are a tiny invertebrate. Really more of an
annoyance as they can spread quickly and irritate coral.>
My wife thinks they are pretty and wants to keep them.
<Hmmm. May change her tune when there are hundreds.>
Is that even practical? If not, what is the best way to get rid of
I've read about several methods and would like to get your opinion.
<Plenty of commercial products available. I prefer Peppermint Shrimp.>
A couple of days ago, my wife saw another item in there that looks like a
snail without a shell ( see pic2).
<Don't see a second pic but it sounds like a Stomatella.>
One person said it looks like a sponge. I'm not sure about that because it
moves around the tank and even hides in or behind the rock. Do you
have any idea what it is?
<Not without a picture.>
I've kept freshwater fish my whole life and have always wanted to do
saltwater. This is my first effort and want to do it right. I now have 2
damsels, a snowflake eel, a turbo snail and a chocolate chip starfish. I
have added them little by little over the past few weeks. Any advise that
you could provide would be greatly appreciated.
<Take it slow and keep reading.>
Apparently I'll have to send the other photo separately. Hopefully that will
work out ok.
Thank you in advance,
|Live rock hitch hiker
I sent another email with the information about my tank but could only
attach one photo because I'm doing so from my phone. Can you help me ID this
<It is a Stomatella sp. A beneficial grazer.>