FAQs about Mussid Coral Social Disease
FAQs on Mussid
Mussid Disease 1, Mussid Health 2, Mussid Disease 3, Mussid Disease 4,
Mussid Disease 5,
FAQs on Mussid Disease by Category:
Environmental (Pollution/Poisoning, Lighting...),
Pathogenic (Infectious, Parasitic, Viral)
Related Articles: Coral Pests and Disease; pests, predators,
diseases and conditions by Sara Mavinkurve, Mussid Corals,
FAQs on Stony Coral Disease: Stony Coral Disease 1, Stony Coral Disease 2, Stony Coral Disease 3, Stony Coral Disease 4, Stony Coral Disease 5, Stony Coral Disease 6, Stony Coral Disease 7, Stony Coral Disease 8, Stony Coral Disease 9, Stony Coral Disease 10, Stony Coral Disease 11, Stony Coral Disease
12, Stony Coral Disease 13,
Stony Coral Disease 14,
Stony Coral Disease 15, Stony Coral
FAQs on Stony Coral Disease by Category: Diagnosing:
Environmental (Pollution/Poisoning, Lighting...),
Nutritional, Social (Allelopathy),
Pathogenic (Infectious, Parasitic, Viral)
FAQs on Stony Coral Disease by Family: Acroporid Disease, Acroporid Disease 2, Acroporid Disease 3, Acroporid Disease 4..., Caryophyllid Disease, Caryophyllid Disease 2..., Elegance Coral Disease/Pests, Dendrophylliid Disease, Faviid Disease, Faviid Disease 2, Fungiid Disease,
Mussid Health 2, Poritid Health, Trachyphylliid Disease, Trachyphyllia Disease 2,
FAQs on Stony Coral Disease by Type: Brown Jelly Disease, RTN,
Re: re: Frag Blastomussa Wellsi... allelo
Update. After a few days the frag split and it looked like a pie with a
wedge removed. It took a few weeks for it to heal. I did try a second
frag but that one did not cut clean and you can't even tell what it is.
<Give it time>
But it is alive so will just wait and see.
A couple other things happened in my tank. My candy cane had one head
that was bent a bit down and then started to look as if the flesh was
pouring down. It was tear drop shaped and stayed like that for a couple
weeks. I snipped it off and it looks like I now have a candy cane frag.
I have a Platygyra for about 2 years. Never saw it eat so I don't feed
it. And I never saw any tentacles. It started to recede and about half
of it died away. I moved it to a new spot and it has come back nicely
and has recovered around half the loss.
One evening about a half hour after lights went out I looked in my tank
with a light and the Platy had long tentacles flying around. Never saw
this before but it explains why my open brain has been deflated at
times. Just sharing, am
<Thanks for this follow-up. Bob Fenner>
Couple questions; Pterapogon fdg., Scler. stings
Hi Crew and a happy New Year, I haven't asked anything in a while so
here are two issues. I bought 2 pair of Banggai Cardinals over the past
six months and all starved. The would spit out the food. I guess they
wanted only what they were used to. I tried pellets, flakes,
decapsulated brine shrimp eggs (which most fish go crazy for), my own
home made minced fish.
They were all in good shape but they lasted 2 weeks and that was it. And
they were from different stores. You would think they would take
anything if really hungry.
<... I'd have tried live and frozen/defrosted foods of appropriate size>
Anyway, I decided to try once more and after a week of watching them
spit out everything I went back to the LFS and asked them what they
think will work. And they suggested Hikari frozen brine shrimp. Well, it
really worked. They are now much livelier and run for all the foods but
they still spit out all except the bs. It does contain supplements so do
you think they can survive on it.
<I'd expand on the menu... Read here:
and for Apogonids in general>
I had a really nice Lobophyllia. It was oval about 3 inches long and 2
wide. Red outside and bright blue center. Had it about 3 years. Any time
an Acan or Candycane fell on it they melted away
<?! why are other Scleractinians falling?>
and you could hardly see any mark on the lobo. Recently an Acan fell on
it with the same results. About a week later I rearranged my rock so
that my Trachyphyllia would have room to spread so I removed all my
coral, rearranged everything and put the coral back. The next
day I felt a bad sting on a finger and it took a week till it felt
normal. And then the Lobo just disintegrated in about 2 days.
What could have triggered this event. Thanks, Sam
<The contact with both. Bob Fenner>
Need help with sick Australomussa 6/17/12
I have a problem with my Australomussa that I have never seen before in
one of my corals. I have had this Australomussa for about a month.
It is in a 50 gallon breeder with 4 39 watt t5 bulbs, and I placed this
coral on some rubble at the bottom of the tank lower flow area.
<Mmm, likely better "a little up" nearer the light, placed on rock; away
from other Cnidarians>
It was healthy when I
received it, and it was eating. I think that I went wrong by
placing it near the mushroom corals that my clowns host.
>Ah yes... needs to be away>
They kept flicking sand on it and this apparently aggravated the coral
quite a bit.
<And allelopathy... chemical...>
I think that this was the issue rather than water quality. The
other corals in the tank are doing fine. The mouth on this coral
is showing the skeleton and has receded to the point that it no longer
appears to have a mouth. It also has a very sunken appearance.
I have since moved it to a calmer area and have been feeding it oyster
eggs every day. I have been doing this for a few days but have not
seen any change yet. Is there anything else I can do to save this
<Perhaps a bit (more) iodide/ate, slightly lowered spg, a bit of simple
(hexose) sugar... Search re stony coral, Mussid Health on WWM>
Is it possible for this coral to regenerate a new mouth?
I have never seen this happen to coral before. Thank you very much
for your time. Tyler
<Welcome. Bob Fenner>
Re: Need help with sick Australomussa
Thank you so much for taking the time to help me. You saved the
<Happy to assist your efforts. BobF>
Unknown LPS disease! 5/28/12
Having some major issues and would be very grateful if you could offer
some information or solutions.. details below...
all of my LPS in my nano are melting away in a particularly weird way.
They start out with displaying their stinger tentacles in mass all at
once then a few days later progress to mush... It appears to be a lot
different the brown jelly though.
<The given name for this condition...>
This happened right after i setup the nano, so i took it down and
started over thinking i had some kind of pathogen. I cycled tank, cooked
rock, added new sand..etc. . put in some tester corals and all seemed
well. Ordered some Acans.. and a few days later two colonies are doing
the same exact thing. Other colonies are completely unaffected. However
the last time they were hit one by one and all eventually died.
All param.s are spot on. 78 Deg, dKH 8 sg 1.026 ca 420 mg 1350. p04 is
undetectable. No ammonia, or nitrate either. Any soft coral varieties
seem to be unaffected. Fish/inverts are also fine. ORP, ph, temp, photo
period all stable/consistent as well.
Pictures are below.. they show how it starts out and what is progresses
too. Also dipping just finishes them off completely - so that's not an
option. I tried Lugol's, revive and others all to the same effect. Any
ideas what is going on here? I was thinking some kind of contaminate but
have done my best to rule that out by tearing down the tank and starting
over. I switched salt, changed ro/di, food, cooked rock, new sand, not
dosing anything, new carbon and gac.. basically new everything except a
new tank (which was cleaned very well)!
Thank you for your advice and happy Memorial Day!
<Likely a simple example of allelopathy (see WWM re)... a bane of
too-small volumes w/ too many disparate Cnidarians present... I'd keep
changing water, add an over dose of iodide-ate, a teaspoon of a hexose
of your choice and reduce the spg. by a thousandth... In the longer
haul, you need more volume at least. Bob Fenner>
| Re: Unknown LPS disease!
Thank you for the quick reply. The tank is primarily Acan lords. There are a
few stalks of Duncans, Zoas,
<Most likely candidate for toxicity>
and palm tree corals. Will Acans lords compete with other Acans?
<Not much, no>
Always though the same species would live happily in close proximity. I
planned it to be an Acan tank. Also not familiar with hexose?
<Six ringed sugars... use the Net>
Any suggestions on what to purchase?
Scolymia, Hlth., reading
<... where is your grammar Dan?>
i received a Scolymia about 2 months ago. when i got it , it was about
12inch in diameter when full expanded.
a couple of days ago it started to retract . it now only covers its
hard skeleton. i did a water change once i noticed it retracting, and
I'm in the process of doing another one. all my other corals
<These are likely at play.... Allelopathy>
and Clam are doing fine, fish as well. here are my parameters,
Alk 177 ppm
NO3 - 0
any thought on whats going on or how to fix the problem? is it normal
for a Scolymia to through cycles of expanding and retracting during the
thanks in advance
<Read here: http://wetwebmedia.com/MussidDisF4.htm
and the linked files above, and: http://wetwebmedia.com/cnidcompppt.htm
and... Bob Fenner>
Re: Scolymia- 2/16/11
Thank you for the information. If it is chemical warfare that is
causing the Scolymia to retract which one of these corals is a possible
Favia, Xenia, Ricordea, pink BTA, green BTA, frog spawn, various
Other then running carbon filtration, doing water changes and removing
the suspect coral is there anything else I can do?
<... read where you were referred to. The best would be to remove
the Mussid to another system, "condition" it to the presence
of the other Cnidarians through partial water changes for weeks>
I don't think it could be the Zoanthids as most of them came from
the same tank as the Scolymia.
Any help would greatly be appreciated,
<Keep reading. BobF>
Re: Scolymia- 2/16/11
oh yeah I also have some green star polyps
<... also high on the "noxious" list. B>
Re: Scolymia Australis tissue receding
Is the proximity of the leather to the Scolymia the potential
issue or are the two not able to co-exist period despite my tank
being 210 gallons?
<Is a concern>
I run GFO for pro-active algae control, would you recommend
discontinuing that practice?
<See WWM re... I am not a fan of hobbyists continuous use of
I will also place the Scolymia directly on the substrate as
Do you have any other suggestions?
<Not w/o further data>
Could my cleaner shrimp be irritating the Scolymia?
<Possible... but if so, much more likely "after the
fact"... That is shrimps might feed on a dead, dying
Thanks for your help Bob!
<Welcome Doug. BobF>
Re: Scolymia Australis tissue receding
In reading more on the topic of chemical warfare, I'm
thinking that at the very least allelopathy is a contributing
factor to my Scolymia issues,
<We are in agreement>
so I'm going to remove the small Sarcophyton and large Finger
leather from my system, I also have 4 Ricordeas and 2 Yumas in my
tank that are a considerable distance from the Scolymia, are they
potentially contributing to the chemical warfare issues?
<To a lesser extent; yes>
The 3 cleaner shrimp in the system are constantly picking at my
<Cover them! With a plastic "berry" basket,
inverted... KEEP the shrimps off them>
after they have been target fed, do you think this is stressing
the Scolymia and contributing to the tissue recession?
<Yes, yes, YES>
Thanks again Bob, you are literally a lifesaver!
<Mmm, more like an enabler. You can be the lifesaver.
Re: Scolymia Australis tissue receding
Do you think if I added additional GAC to my reactor that I would
still be able to keep the Ricordeas and Yumas or should I plan on
potentially having to get rid of them?
<... see WWM re allelopathy... My archived .ppt vers. of the
MACNA pitch last year>
Also any suggestions for trapping the cleaner shrimp?
<Also posted.... learn to/use the search tool, indices...
Invertebrate ID and Bleaching
Hey, I have another favor to ask of you,
I bought another coral over the past week and I have a concern
with it. It was told to me it was a Large polyp stony, called a
pineapple or Favia species of coral,
<Hmm, it is a Brain or Pineapple coral, family Mussidae. More
a search of a few websites seems to confirm this, but the LFS
told me that it likes pretty intense lighting from metal
<Depends on the species.>
so I placed it on top of my display tank near the light I have, a
Solaris 14inch LED fixture, which again to me seems as bright as
at least a 250 watt metal halide, and the concern I have is that
it seems to be bleaching, especially the reddish brown raised
portion of the coral,
the green "eyes" don't seem to be affected as much
yet, but the coral in general doesn't seem to be as colorful
and full of life as it was in the store tank, and they had it in
a large metal halide lit tank.
<May have been under metal halides, but still a lot of
variables, hold old were the bulbs, water clarity, etc.>
I acclimated the coral very slowly and the parameters of my tank
are what I think pretty pristine, so I ask of you your expertise
on if I should re-locate this new coral to a lower more shaded
area, or let it recover from whatever it is that it doesn't
seem to like about my tank?
<Definitely get it lower in the tank, near the bottom, and
start working it up over the course of a couple of weeks until
you find a spot it seems to be
happiest. You can do some supplemental feeding to help overcome
Thanks in advance for your help....
Re: pH problems - Favia bleaching
Hey, I have another favor to ask of you, I bought another coral
over the past week and I have a concern with it. It was told to
me it was a Large polyp stony, called a pineapple or Favia
species of coral, a search of a few websites seems to confirm
this, but the LFS told me that it likes pretty intense lighting
from metal halide, so I placed it on top of my display tank near
the light I have, a Solaris 14inch LED fixture, which again to me
seems as bright as at least a 250 watt metal halide, and the
concern I have is that it seems to be bleaching, especially the
reddish brown raised portion of the coral, the green
"eyes" don't seem to be affected as much yet, but
the coral in general doesn't seem to be as colorful and full
of life as it was in the store tank, and they had it in a large
metal halide lit tank. I acclimated the coral very slowly and the
parameters of my tank are what I think pretty pristine, so I ask
of you your expertise on if I should re-locate this new coral to
a lower more shaded area, or let it recover from whatever it is
that it doesn't seem to like about my tank? Thanks in advance
for your help....Darren
I'm attaching 2 pics of the coral.
<Hi Darren, not to step into what Mike has already done with
you. I noticed that you have another coral in close proximity to
this one. Two things immediately come to mind. First, you say you
think your lights are equal to a metal halide but is easy to get
the exact specs on them and compare to be sure. Second, did they
have them under 100's or 250's or what kind of halide
because that makes a difference as well. And finally, Okay yeah I
have three points not two, I think that you may have issues with
the other coral stinging this Favia. I would suggest moving it or
other a bit farther apart.>
Maintenance and Water Quality Issues in a 14g
BioCube -- 05/01/09
Just got back in town the other day and Holy Sick Aquarium Batman!!
I really do have to join a local aquarium club for some support when I
have to leave town.
<<Doing so 'and gaining the 'local' support
and advice of others sharing your passion can be a real
Believe it or not, the Sea Pen is the only thing that has done well in
my absence. The tank has a horrible red algae bloom, my Xenia was torn
in half, my hermit crab decided that he liked the shell that the Xenia
was partially attached to and made it his new home. The Xenia does not
look like it's going to make it. My frogspawn, candy coral,
Ricordea and doughnut coral all look deflated and stressed. I lost one
of my feather dusters and all of my mushroom anemones.
<<Does sound like things have taken a serious
The feather dusters are connected together and I haven't seen one
of them emerge from his tube. Another one decided that he didn't
like his tube and is now sharing a tube with another one. Do I just
leave the empty tubes alone?
<<I would'¦ Trying to remove it will likely just cause
more undue stress 'possible physical harm>>
The protein skimmer and the well it sits in smelled horrible. I removed
the skimmer and thoroughly cleaned it with hot water and toothbrush. I
also siphoned the debris at the bottom of the well that contains the
<<A good move>>
I did a 25% water change the first day and I siphoned out all of the
red algae that I could reach.
<<Another good strategy 'and the siphoning will
probably need to be repeated periodically>>
I added Kent Marine Nano Reef supplements A and B.
<<I would not add 'anything' until you get the tank back
in 'balance''¦ And this will best be done through
frequent partial water changes 'say 25% twice a week for two
weeks 'and then reevaluate at that time>>
I also turned on my extra powerhead to boost circulation and prevent
the red algae from coming back.
<<It will come back for now 'but the extra circulation
is another good move>>
I normally do not run the extra powerhead because I only have a 14g
BioCube and my frogspawn and doughnut do not seem to like the extra
<<I see'¦ Keeping a noxious mix of corals is often
more complicated in such small volumes 'but does make water
changes easy, and is the single best way to keep up with water
I tested the parameters of water and readings are good except for
nitrates. So I performed a 10% water change on the second day. Nitrate
came down from 50ppm to 35ppm.
<<This is likely a large part of your issues here. I would strive
to get this reading below 5ppm (you should step up the water
The corals have dramatically improved in appearance.
<<And should continue to do so 'just keep bringing
down that Nitrate reading>>
However the doughnuts mouth is wide open and my pipe coral is not
<<May be a delayed recovery 'or maybe these have been
more seriously damaged>>
My Firefish is acting kind of weird, he is normally very shy, but as I
type, he is swimming in place at the center of the tank. Kind of like
riding the current. I think those are all the problems that I have
encountered so far. I look forward to any helpful suggestions.
<<Water changes, water changes, water changes'¦ Be
Re: Maintenance and Water Quality Issues in a 14g
BioCube -- 05/01/09
So sorry to bother you again.
<<No bother my friend>>
I had to ask another question about my doughnut coral.
He seemed to be doing alright. He was my newest addition to the tank,
about 3 weeks ago, and never seemed to be fully expanded or
symmetrical. Today he was symmetrical as well as expanded. His mouth
finally closed somewhat but a few minutes ago he let go of his
<<Lost footing? As in became 'detached' from its
skeleton? Not good'¦>>
I currently have placed him in the sand with a shell weighing him down
so he does not float behind the rocks. Doughnut know what to do.
<<In my experience, large polyped corals such as this never
recover/reattach to the skeleton 'is but a matter of time
I'm afraid. EricR>>
R2: Maintenance and Water Quality Issues in a 14g
BioCube -- 05/01/09
Sorry, should revise previous email. The doughnut has separated from
<<Ah yes 'did surmise such, but thank you for
R4: Maintenance and Water Quality Issues in a 14g
BioCube -- 05/03/09
Good Morning Eric,
Thanks for confirmation on actions taken in response to Operation Death
I will hold off on additional supplements until the tank is healthy
<<Excellent 'is best>>
A question about more aggressive action.
I have another salt water tank that was set up at the same time as my
BioCube. I only stock live rock in this aquarium with no base
substrate. Some people collect spoons or marbles, I collect live rock.
Okay..... I collect spoons, marbles and live rock.
Should I transfer corals over to my live rock tank with the exception
of my chili, Featherduster and sea pen in order to clean the wells of
<<Might not hurt to do so with the stonies>>
I know that the wells are very slimy from the dead mushrooms and a good
cleaning could possibly improve my nitrate levels more quickly than
water changes alone.
<<Yes 'no doubt>>
Also, until the nitrate level has been reduced, what volume of water do
you recommend for water changes and how often should it be done.
<<A couple 50% changes a day apart should show some significant
improvement 'done in conjunction with the
'cleanings' you mention>>
Could you describe to me how the doughnut forms his skeleton?
<<I'm guessing by 'doughnut' you have Cynarina
lacrymalis'¦ This coral forms/grows its skeleton as any
other hard or 'stony' coral does 'through the
extraction of bio-minerals from the surrounding water. If you're
interested in the science of it, you may find more info with a good
search of the web 'or you can visit a local college
and the relationship between the skeleton and coral?
<<Mmm, I would describe this as 'necessary for
How does the skeleton keep him alive?
<<By providing an anchor, support, and protection for the
polyp 'and possibly an avenue for nutrient
Is it like the relationship between fetus and mother?
<<More like flower petal and receptacle (the attachment point of
the petal), I think>>
An umbilical cord where there is a transfer of nutrients?
<<Not to the same extent 'if at all>>
Or does the skeleton act only as a support for the doughnut?
<<Not so simplistic 'but does provide
If it acts as a support only and nutrients will not be lost due to the
separation, could the doughnut be reattached to the skeleton
<<I have never seen this work>>
Would puncturing the doughnut with a needle kill it and could he heal
around a suture?
<<I have seen this done with some of the so-called
'leather' corals (Toadstool, etc.), but I wouldn't
recommend this procedure for a large-polyped coral such as this. Your
water quality issues were the cause of the polyp bail-out'¦
Addressing these will certainly benefit the remaining corals/any future
additions. You could try a few spots of superglue in an attempt to hold
the polyp in place in hopes that it will reattach to its skeleton on
its own 'but I do fear/expect that the Cynarina is
<<Happy to share. Eric Russell>>
Cynarina lacrymalis question -02/07/08 Greetings!
I was hoping that you could help me with what is, I believe, a donut
coral, as I have not been successful in locating much information on
the Internet. I acquired this fellow, a relatively large donut about
4-5" across and green in colour, from a fellow hobbyist about
three weeks ago. He told me that he did not feed the coral,
<<Needs to be fed. RMF>> but that it had once eaten a
(dead) fish. It seemed to be doing well in his tank, also. It looked
great in my tank for many days - reacting to proffered foods (Mysis,
brine shrimp, as well as Cyclop-Eeze and various other foods), swelling
at certain times of the day, etc. Today, however, he sort of shriveled
up, and his mouth is gaping, and I am not sure what the problem is. I
have an established 28 gallon tank, over 30lbs live rock. 4 x 24W T5HO
lighting, good flow, but no direct flow to his area. I do not have a
skimmer, but have ordered a Prizm Pro. I have a modified AquaClear HOB
filter/refugium. The tank has many Zoas, candy canes, clove polyps,
Palys, brown star polyp, and a leather coral or two. I have a watchman
goby, a Randall's goby, and a pair of false percula clowns. I feed
roughly every other day, and do a 15% water change every 5 to 7 days. I
had a temperature drop from 80F to 75F over the course of the day today
(from about 1 am to 6 pm), which is the only thing I can think of, that
could be the cause of his ill health. <I wouldn't worry about it
unless the condition persists. It might just be expelling waste.>
Any guidance would be much appreciated. Thank you very much, Zoe
Stevens <De nada, Sara M.>
|Re: Brains in a Nano cont.
3/28/06 Dear Mr. Fenner,
In my last
email I sent to the WWM email. I told you about how I
never received a reply when I had sent pictures with the
email. You directed me to send it to your
personal email. <Yes, thank you for this>
In a previous email I told you about
my Lobophyllia and some odd behavior. As I said before
it I am not sure if this is just natural or a problem.
Other than the odd behavior and some recession it
is doing well. <I see this here> As I mentioned
before with the recession it was there either when
I bought it 4 months ago or shortly afterwards. The
recession does not appear to have gotten much worse, but
not better. Below are pictures of the
lobo in it's 3 forms (not really the right word).
When it is in it's extra expanded state, it's
"normal" state (meaning what it looks like
most of the time.) and when it will pull in most of
it's tissue. The behavior has no pattern and varies from day to
day. On most days it will look normal all day, on other
days it will go into the pulling in it's tissue
form. It does usually do it in the afternoon and
will stay like that for a few hours. It is rarely in
it's extra expanded state, usually once or twice a
week. ( it only stays like that for a few hours
then will usually go into the normal state) The
fluctuations seems entirely unrelated to feeding or
water changes or anything else. Bye the way how often should
I feed it? <A few times a week with meaty foods...
Please see here: http://wetwebmedia.com/mussidfdgfaqs.htm>
I was thinking 3 times a week. (Or is that too often.) Order of
picture is as follows: 1. Extra Expanded 2. Recession Extra
Expanded (have moved the rock with red algae on it since picture)
3. Recession Normal 4. Normal 5. Recession Closed Up 6. Closed Up
7. Full View of Tank. (Daisy Polyps are closed up because I took
the picture in after 8 P.M. just when they like to close up
for the night, not a great picture of the tank either.
The flash washed everything out, but it gives an accurate
representation of the tank.) Thank you for your help and time,
(sorry if the pictures took a long time to load) MDM
<Likely this tank is doing about as well as it can under your
good care. The keeping of multiple species, families, orders of
cnidarians in small volumes is problematical. Put another way, your
"margin of error" increases with increasing system size
all else being equal. Bob Fenner>